American Idol Top Twelve Selection Season 4 part 1

[Bearbear714]

Constanstine and Bo :)

[starshollowresident]

"lassoo" hahahaha i love simon. i totally miss him this season!

[yumakookie]

Lmao its so funny how ryan makes the contestants scared

[SteelAVic18]

I love Vonzell!!!!

[katherineoa]

..thanks

[harrisonegg]

Why did you video tape this it's sooooooooooooo bad

[sexyshy3000]

ryan was such a basterd back den lol

[thenamesgreg101]

hmmmm hated anwar sooo much hated natia hated mikayla hated scott and hateeeddd jessica just cuzs shes such a SLUT!

[onesmartlady]

anwar probably would be the most underrated idol contestant ever..

[littlelotte689]

carrie and bo..never will be another two this perfect...in AI

[me101me]

haha. 7:47 to 8:05.:)) Carrie is awesome.:))

[wissphoto]

Man, Ryan was really messing with this group this year! LOL He made them squirm.  Were the girls really that forgettable? I only remember Carrie. I remember most of the guys, like Bo and Constatine.

[DoubleDBlogXX]

the finale should of been carrie and vonzell!

[me101me]

at least Carrie was the finale.:))

[DoubleDBlogXX]

what?

[me101me]

I ment to say at least Carrie got in the tops.:))

[avabiancawoot]

i love Carrie

[heatherblu19]

hahaha! mario bf faaaar the best. i love him!

[Dominozone]

This was when I first started watching AI.. Ohh I just loved Vonzell but Carrie was good to.

[mardgreen88]

well i mean they were all behind her. but they patted her on the back and stuff so it's not like they snubbed her.

[jacydc]

haha jessica sierra reminds me of bette midler.

i think it's the lack of neck.

[jaymejean28]

hahahaha. she does have no neck. just like melinda.

[jacydc]

oh yeah, her too!

geez, they should form some sort of club.

neckless anonymous, perhaps.

[blueblutterfly01]

i luv carrie !!!

[Softballchiccc3]

I hate ryan hes sooo mean when i saw it in{05} i was thinkin why is Carrie goin home-sooooo scary!!!

[Zoso9090]

I believe they do that on purpose to build unnecassary tension for the viewer, like Montell when he says... "You ARE................NOT the father!"

Well you know what I mean.

[ProjectRevolution]

Oh my...Ryan was so mean!!! ....Sorry....pause... I'm gonna have to ask you to stand up and take a seat. =P wow...suspense!

[mcforeva]

Vonzell and Carrie are the best!! <333333

[pepyang]

i agree. they are da best...

[hugsandkisses2011]

ya... but its carrie that is the better one

[tameshawilkinson]

the 1st,3rd and 4th were the best all the rest were crap.

[jackfender24]

i want to have bloody hto sex with carrie underwood

[ChicagoAirJordan23]

season 4 and 5 are the best season.season 4 my bet is bo bice,while in season 5 my bet is chris daughtry

[nooriskandar]

season 3 and 4 are the best

[tysonroxzmyworld]

i'm in luv with constantine is so hott

[CarrieUnderwood1983]

constantine is my friends mom's cousin's dad's son. It's so cool. My friend got to meet him

[num1meekfan]

i love mikalah

[GGLore]

I think that season 4 and 5 were the best seasons :D

[licha1r]

me too!

[cyrusvail]

Aaaww...it was adorbale how Bo was disappointed for Constantine when he thought he's not with the top 12.

[honeybun13]

i think the first one 4th and 6th were the best seasons!!!

[aidean88]

After this Season, American Idol went downhill, I think This and Season 3 were THE Best Seasons!!!!!!