this is the crappiest recording of her. whoever took it needs to tune their camera cuz anette sings ever dream really well. its even better than tarja's & thats hard for me to say cuz i like tarja to. ever dream was her audition song. this recording makes teh whole band look at of tune lol
somebody learn this woman to sing...scream is not sing...she don´t sing with the soul....My God....nightwish is over....how could a band that was so perfect to fall like this?it´s very sad...
Yes Tarja had a more operatic voice bla bla bla and yes it was very good, but in my opinion, Annette brings much more power to this song, she expresses the emotions of it more with the power in her voice rather than just singing it in a way to show off her voice. I like her version.
Obviously, this video doesn't show to the full extent what Annette's voice brings to the song because the quality of the recording is not very good, so people who are judging her on this video are being rather unfair.
Man, she's doing good this time! Last few vids with her singing Ever Dream, it wasn't so good. But... this is awesome!! I'm going to see them soon and I CAN'T FUCKIN' WAIT!!
I think you mean different. Tarja had opera training and Anette did not. However Anette can sing in more styles then Tarja ever could. So I guess its an even trade off.
la chica esta canta bien y tien un estilo más abierto. Me gusta musicalmente. Esta chica anterior, tarja era muy buena...pero no era más que cualquier cantante de opera que podés encontrar en cualquier lado. Esta le va a dar otro vuelo.
Can't help but get the feeling that making her sing "Sleeping Sun" that way was Tuomas's idea. Her solo album is extremely operatic-sounding compared to her singing on "Once" and on the 2005 version of "Sleeping Sun".
would think you're trying to make a point panterela lol, but a good one nonetheless. I've been an anette fan since day 1 so she has my full support. If you ask me anette's the 3rd best thing to happen to nightwish. 2nd being marco joining and the best is tuomas just being tuomas. anyway, love her or not she's still fuckin excellent at ever dream and for all the snipes that dont like her just because shes not tarja, go worship tarja's album, which is just poor, you have to admit
Yes Discipleofbabylon, i agree Anette is a good singer, we have to give her that, but i think u are going too far saying that tarja's album were poor, I am a Nightwish fan, i understand NW is not one person, but I still love tarja's style better if u ask me, but thats a matter of taste, and doesnt make Anette bad at all. The good thing here is that NW keeps doing great music.
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Well the old songs are hard for a non-classical singer to sing. Actually, if you dont even have a large range, it'll be hard for ANYONE! ESPECIALLY the old ballads.
woah, sweeet... =) Some kind of a pity that Anette's already in a relationship ^^ I love the song, and she sings wonderful. I adore Tarja, too but still Anette seems to move more on stage... like that. also this way of singing must be very exhausting for her... *.*
how can you say she sings beautifully when she is obviously constantly falling off key... i don't hate the poor girl, it's not her fault. but if you notice, even the new songs, which we can't compare to tarja's, she can't sing live. there isn't one song where she doens't give me the creeps. she might be a great girl, but the little one has no metal vibe in her body whatsoever. she might be a great person but music isn't about that whatsoever.. stop denying the obvious.. sad but true.
This is an awsome song and i adore it about as much as i adore BOTH Annette AND Tarja.
can people please stop ruining it with pointless bickering...
Annette is different to tarja and its only your own opinion thats making her either better or worse. I personnelly prefer her to tarja mainly because her voice is easier to listen to.
The band says they have moved on - and tbh if you cant move on then go and do some knitting dont complain about it cos its not goin to get you anywhere.
yes you are right, people should stop comparing, they are different people. different voices. and besides yes nightwish has decided to do different music, but, and this but is crucial, they could have picked someone who can sing right trough a whole song. not even the new ones, suposedely appropriate to her voice can she sing right live. is you don't notice it than it's obvious you haven't spent that many times listening... and hey i have nothing against the girl.
Tarja is the one with the most boring, unoriginal album of all time. Face it: Without Nightwish, TARJA is finished. A good voice AND good songs are needed to succeed in music. Tarja only has the voice. Tarja didnt make SHIT. The only piece of CRAP she made is My Winter Storm!
ehhhh mira, entendi algo de lo q pusiste y no me gusto, el album de Tarja Turunen no es tan bueno como los anteriores de NW, pero no esta tan mal. Es cierto q Tarja no era NW (la esencia), pero era un miembro muy importante de la banda. No me gusta el nuevo NW, no me gusta el cambio q le hicieron, no me gusta annette, pero se ve q a thuomas y los demas (FANS)si les gusta , asi q hagan la musica q quieran yo nunca voy a comprar un disco suyo, NUNCA!!!
yes, tarja lost a lot without nightwish, but honestly do you see nightwish gainning something without her? 'cause all i've been seeing around me is they fan base shiffting into one of evanescence's nature. perhaps that's what they're looking for, making more popular music and gaining more money, which is honest, just not too honest to say tarja was a whore just into money when at least with her they could've preserved nightwish's own sound. either will be the same. lets make peace with that.
hell no? hell yes. :P i hope the examples i know won't generalize. hopefully they'll never become so popular, and the "goth" "emo" fashion will become less atractive to all this kids.
lolol no, i'm saying it's weird this fashion that has become rockish goth metallish clothes and sounds that the "fans" change their taste from 6 to 6 months. i'm a nightwish fan and i know many and i don't consider us one of those people. i'm sorry if you thought the message was for you or something
Oh not it's fine. And fans DO change their taste. Not just Nightwish fans. X`D. I love this band and Anette is amazing. I'm not obsessive or anything but I have three pics of Anette glued/attached to the front cover of my school assignment book. XD
I think Annette is perfect for this band! Tarja was just an average opera singer, people who say her voice is unique, haven't heard opera before!She was average.. Anette gives Nightwish the rock edge!!!
anette doenst fit this band. the band with anette is the same it would be with brintey spears or christina aguilera :)) and yes maybe tarja was an average opera singer but she fitted far better in this band. And the quallity of theyr songs were a lot higher.
Yes, yes I forgot if you can't sing Opera you are a pop singer. Ever heard of the queen of metal Doro?! FFS. Annete is a ROCK singer, it's not the voice that makes her great, it's her persona as well! She's a hell of a nicer person then Tarja. Therefore she wins!
gunna have to agree with 300worms on this one, Fribbe. I honestly like Anette's voice better than Tarja's, and was disapointed when I heard how much of a drama queen she was.
You say that because she was the original and although Tarja's voice is the archetype for all of Nightwish's vocal catalogue. I believe that Annette's voice suits Nightwish perfectly and brings a new fresh sound.
To tell you the truth, I thought it would be MUCH worse.
This song in particular doesn't sound bad at all (so doesn't Nemo)... the one I don't like very much is Wishmaster... the words in elfic language doesn't sound very good with her voice . . . **
wow increible ke n la parte final le baja totalmente la escala de la canción, la musika esta en una escala y la voaz en otra y eso no suena bien, umm le falto mas esfuerzo a esa cancion
You can say Anette is too mediocre or moderate, but you know that if she tried to imitate Tarja you would just say "omg she is just trying to be like tarja and she cant". She's doing her thing, she's doing it her way, if you can't respect that then you don't have to listen.
actually, she may scream a bit, but shes still a damn sight more in tune than tarja was half the time, and i dont care if you rate me soo low that my comment gets removed or something, i know im right! and im gonna stick up for annette even though i did love tarja. :)
Estas equivocado, Tuomas es uno mas de la banda, si hubiera otro en su lugar daria lo mismo, Tarja le dio identidad a la banda, Annete canta bien pero no es para Nightwish es mas para una banda pop, no tiene el carisma ni la voz para interpretar los temas como lo hace Tarja.
Se nota que no sabes mucho de Nightwish. Tuomas es el que hace casi toda la musica, y es el único que escribe las liricas. Sin Tuomas, Nightwish no existe. Y que es mas importante en una banda, la imagen o la musica en si? Y no, la vos de Anette no es pop solo porque no canta opera. Muchas bandas de heavy metal y rock en general tienen cantantes asi como Annette (que tiene una vos aguda y no alterada), y eso no los hace pop.
Se mas de Nightwish de lo que puedas imaginar, por mas que Tuomas escriba parte de las letras (aunque en su mayoria lo son, presta atencion que no todas son de el)Nightwish podria existir sin problema, de la musica ni hablar toda tampoco es de el, es cueston de informarse, No te parece? cuantos cantantes como Annete hay en bandas metaleras y que hayan triunfado? nombrame una, para Annete todas las canciones son iguales!!! cero interpretacion y cero carisma.
Mira, Tuomas hace todas las letras, todas. Eso se ha mencionado en varias entrevistas. Y como ya dije, casi toda la musica la compuso él. Como el 90%. Y eso lo puedes ver en los creditos de cada una de las canciones de los cds. Sale quien escribió la letra y quien compuso la música. No cuesta nada buscar esa información en internet, deberias hacerlo.
Y eso de interpretación y carisma es algo demasiado subjetivo como para ser considerado más que una simple opinion. No es bueno hacer que tu opinion suene como una verdad indiscutible.
Lo de las letras y la musica es cierto y como te decia no es toda de el (en internet no toda la informacion es creible), no solo para mi sino para muchos la interpretacion es mediocre no esta acorde con la musica, no es que yo tenga la verdad es lo que me parece, no quiero discutir ni niciar una pelea, es solo mi opinion, saludos.
Annette has no presence, shes so..medium. wheres the evilness? the spice? she has good voice, thats for sure, but this is one of the songs she shouldnt sing. first of all at the high points she seems to be in suffering...
i really dont think tuomas would dick over the entire nightwish fanbase just to dick a chick in his band. i have more respect for nightwish than to think that. good or bad, they saw something in annette, thats why shes the new vocalist
Tarja's version is good, but wow this is really good, this is the first time i have heard annette sing this song...i am impressed, I will find out in person when they come to san deigo!
I hate to say it even though it was expected that she would do a bad job, I know she has a diffrent voice i like her voice on the CD's better but LIVE (not her voice in compparesing to Tarja's) she is not so good LIVE.
i don't...that was nightwish, singing them live and actually releasing an official album is almost going backwards, they don't want to go back they want to move forward. As much as i wold like that i don't think they should.
Mainly to patteriz, but also to all people gramblig about Anettes versions of old songs:
Anette didn't raped this song. She sang it in different way (personally I like it - I also like Tarjas versions). But it doesn't mean, that all CD's with Tarjas version of Ever Dream are now gone! We have now TWO VERSION of this song - you can listen to the one you choose!
Kill me, but I understand why Tuomas chose her with this song, she adds some personality to the song, almost like a sweet melody, and I liked her change of tone in some notes...
Anette singing ever dream...it's like apocalyptica trying to play farewell on turntables (it may be different, but not necessarily good)
The only thing making nightwish different from other bands was tarja's voice.
Anyway, all tokyo hotel fans will be delighted by the new nightwish sound...so why would the quality of the music matter as long as the income are the same?
I hope not to offend anybody, Anette may be a good singer but there are many just like her.
Oh I am a Tokio Hotel fan now? XD Quality of music??? DPP is musically their best album so far -.-' You want poor quality of music, go listen Tarja's solo album - that I would believe Tokio Hotel would enjoy very much...
Poor Tuomas, he has always written everything for the band, but some fans, who must live in a dream, think it was Tarja the talented one the band - stupid morons...
In that case, let Tuomas do all the singing. I'm sure it will be a wild success.
By the way, i am sure it was Tuomases writing that made "phantom of the opera" so popular.
Let's face it, it wasn't the incredible music that Tuomas was writing that made the band so famous. It was the mix between that and tarja's voice. I found them good back then. Now i can't listen to any of them.
Why do you even exist? It wasn't Tarja that was Nightwish's key to success, BUT, she was a part of it. And Anette has got that part now, and they are still as famous and good as before. And Nightwish manage just fine without you supporting them. I don't even think that they care if you would listen or not because you are just a Tarja-fan.
I couldn't have put it better ^^ Finally someone that sees is my way, I don't know why everyone has to hate Anette. She's Anette and she does rock in my opinion ^^'
You said it... IN YOUR OPINION... In my opinion she cannot sing those songs in the same tune... They could change the tune, even the melody, and Anette has to create her own melody... not Tarja's melodies... like a cover... got it?
I was talking about the songs before the newest album... anyhow... I don't like her... and I don't like the two songs I've heard from the new album... the music... it's ok, but I don't like Anette's voice.
You call yourself a Nightwish fan and you have an opion like that? Come on, NIGHTWISH IS NIGHTWISH, not Tarja or Anette. And I don't know what do you mean by tokio hotel fan lol it's so not true. Anette can sing some songs so much better than Tarja, they're different persons so stop compering them. And I don't know what the fuck is your problem just listen to her singing you'll see that she rocks, as an example listen to "Eva"
Ohhh, how disappointing...Annette can't hit the high notes Tarja did with this song, especially in the chorus. She still does sound pretty good, though. She doesn't have Tarja's range or grace, but she brings her own attitude to the band, and to me it works. Say what you want, but I find appeal with both Tarja and Annette.
Completely agree every word. In fact, I have both the songs with Tarja and with Annette in my playlist, and I listen them enjoying equally. Nightwish is not one person, by the way, and Tarja's solo songs are nowhere close to those which she made with Nightwish
Everybody has their own taste.But i prefered Tarja couse when im listening Anette singing live it reminds me on Britney Spears or other pop singers...And she gets a bit lost while singing, her voice goes up down and she doesnt sounds good live at 1 point. And also i cant neither look at her. She doesnt knows to stand str8, and she s dancing terrible, at least she doesnt fits with this kind of music. And from some old songs whitch were fast ones, she made very slow songs and I dont like it
Uh your a douche this is Nightwish now so evidentally it does fit! Toumas chose her so saying you don't like her is like saying you don't like him so fuck off and go listen to someone else!
Annette's voice doesn't carry as much power and force as Tarja's did in the old songs (including this one), it's true, but she is a very talented singer in her own right. Plus, people fail to remember the fact that the guys are still playing like fucking Gods! Besides, Annette does such a good job in the new songs, I can't even imagine Tarja attempting those songs now, so I like both singers for different reasons.
Besides, does anyone here honestly think the band would chose a singer who isn't good enough for the band? NO WAY! Tuomas and the guys know what they are doing and the new album reflects that. It's one of their best to this date!!!
Listen to new Tarja's songs. They are lifeless and cold. All energy was from Nightwish, but not Tarja herself. Anette's brought a second wind to the old NW songs.
I'm new to nightwish and she sounds and looks great. I am sure tarja was/is great but this girl is awesome too. Just another chapter in the evolution of a great band. It happens all the time.
That was to YulieAna. . .not Blknight, btw. People need to learn that Tarja is gone and Annette is the voice of the new nightwish. . .that is all there is to it. Thumas chose annette, so trust the band. . .stop critisizing them.
i wont say tarja didnt fit nightwish 100% because she did and cant argue she got talent,but for me it doesnt matter who sings,since toumas is the real talent behind the show(and the rest ofcourse) and besides,olzon sings really well and she seems like a really nice and and warm person,props o/
i do not deny the fact that annette allso has a great voice but whatever she does she should stop singing the classic nightwish songs the ones that everyones remebers with Tarja singing them. Because she simply can not match Tarja's voice. As i allready said in an other comment Annette singing Tarja's songs sounds worse than Tarja would if someone strangled her while singing. :((((((((((
Damn! it's sad the way Tuomas destroyed a power metal band like this!!! She sings like Madonna!!!, I can believe the horrible way she sings a so amazing song. Get TARJA Back!!!!!!!!!!!!!! or finish this project to save the honor of one of the best FINISH POWER METAL BANDS!!
sound doesn ´t works :-(
at least for me
matotuHELL 1 month ago in playlist Další videa uživatele benjnin
que buena que es mi anette ,mamita te adorooooooooooo
bachitarica 1 year ago 4
She was good even in 2007 =)
MrArmoris 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Her own style = out of the tune
lanebrazil21 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great band without singer
gabrielgrigore 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaajjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjt!!!!!
come one...this girl has no voice....bad bad bad
khonanesta 3 years ago
That was her very first gig, last year. Why don't you listen to more recent videos...
Maxcaster 3 years ago 10
lol:D :D :D
Nikochkaa 3 years ago
Anette seems to include the rest of the band more!
Makes them Nightwish.
-Not just "girl singing with some backup"
That's what I like the most!
Magneaa 3 years ago 19
this is the crappiest recording of her. whoever took it needs to tune their camera cuz anette sings ever dream really well. its even better than tarja's & thats hard for me to say cuz i like tarja to. ever dream was her audition song. this recording makes teh whole band look at of tune lol
mystiquesword 3 years ago
I do not know how Nightwish is sustained without Tarja, really ridiculous.
mancha110 3 years ago
i hate the way she moves... i can't stand her
vnom0301 3 years ago
somebody learn this woman to sing...scream is not sing...she don´t sing with the soul....My God....nightwish is over....how could a band that was so perfect to fall like this?it´s very sad...
Isanan 3 years ago
Isanan
How do you know that? Did you know her?
I am so tired of persons like you who think what they know who can sing and not. Anette have her own style in singing. Don't blame her for that.
MetalWillStandTall 3 years ago 17
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Her own style of singing is not for this band...
dreamracer7 2 years ago
Good performance, except in the last chorus. I prefer Tarja, BTW
Nectas 3 years ago 2
Yes Tarja had a more operatic voice bla bla bla and yes it was very good, but in my opinion, Annette brings much more power to this song, she expresses the emotions of it more with the power in her voice rather than just singing it in a way to show off her voice. I like her version.
chainsawxcharlie 3 years ago
Obviously, this video doesn't show to the full extent what Annette's voice brings to the song because the quality of the recording is not very good, so people who are judging her on this video are being rather unfair.
chainsawxcharlie 3 years ago 3
Not even close comparing a Tarja performance of this song. Its obvious Nightwish loose its esence and unique style with this type of common voice.
ARJONA06 3 years ago 3
"Its obvious Nightwish loose its esence and unique style with this type of common voice."
What "essence" and what "style" are you talking about? Their music is still the same and the new album is a lot more original than the previous one.
Tarja's classical voice is not uncommon at all, there are other bands who are fronting classical singers.
YulieAna 3 years ago 3
well annette can sing good to but i still think tarja is better but it's a kikcing ass song ^^
gohanchan60 3 years ago
i just love Anette! And this was her first gig in the world tour so it's normal that she was nervous. Just give her a chance!
antza90 3 years ago
horrible
MetalNeyth 3 years ago
lol yeah
silkroad37 3 years ago
Man, she's doing good this time! Last few vids with her singing Ever Dream, it wasn't so good. But... this is awesome!! I'm going to see them soon and I CAN'T FUCKIN' WAIT!!
Nightowljrm 3 years ago
shes way better now then when they played at this gig (i was there)
ronfo 3 years ago
we all know that Tarja's voice is better than anette's voice but anette has a great metal voice that we can't find it in Tarja's voice !!
balamokh 3 years ago
I think you mean different. Tarja had opera training and Anette did not. However Anette can sing in more styles then Tarja ever could. So I guess its an even trade off.
blackren101 3 years ago
I loved it she sings very well!!!I like her style too!
chocolovebsb 3 years ago
la chica esta canta bien y tien un estilo más abierto. Me gusta musicalmente. Esta chica anterior, tarja era muy buena...pero no era más que cualquier cantante de opera que podés encontrar en cualquier lado. Esta le va a dar otro vuelo.
pabliyo750 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIT
WOW!!!I can't belivie!!!
she is soooo bad,sooooooo bad!!
Thuomas is crazy!!!
new nightwish is NOT old nightwish!!
OOOOOH GOD!!!!
SHIIIIIIIIIIIIT
littlehadbanguer 3 years ago
your a fuckhead.
"new nightwish is not old nightwish!!"
no fuckin shit.
Jackk765 3 years ago 4
"new nightwish is NOT old nightwish!!"
ROFLMAO, that's all I can say :D
otacon1024 3 years ago
I liked it.. better than I thought it would be, but I disliked her yells in the first chorus.
PhoenixFanatic 3 years ago
Have you heard Tarja's second version of Sleeping Sun? She was planning on dropping the whole mystic opera voice thing anyway.
moose11235 3 years ago 2
Can't help but get the feeling that making her sing "Sleeping Sun" that way was Tuomas's idea. Her solo album is extremely operatic-sounding compared to her singing on "Once" and on the 2005 version of "Sleeping Sun".
BlackFiresong 3 years ago
and sorry for posting the same thing so many times, my pc bugged and i accidentally did it :S
Panterela 3 years ago
would think you're trying to make a point panterela lol, but a good one nonetheless. I've been an anette fan since day 1 so she has my full support. If you ask me anette's the 3rd best thing to happen to nightwish. 2nd being marco joining and the best is tuomas just being tuomas. anyway, love her or not she's still fuckin excellent at ever dream and for all the snipes that dont like her just because shes not tarja, go worship tarja's album, which is just poor, you have to admit
Discipleofbabylon 3 years ago
Yes Discipleofbabylon, i agree Anette is a good singer, we have to give her that, but i think u are going too far saying that tarja's album were poor, I am a Nightwish fan, i understand NW is not one person, but I still love tarja's style better if u ask me, but thats a matter of taste, and doesnt make Anette bad at all. The good thing here is that NW keeps doing great music.
Panterela 3 years ago
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Panterela 3 years ago 2
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Panterela 3 years ago
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Panterela 3 years ago
Anette is not a bad singer, actually she is pretty good, but she is not a soprano like tarja, its natural that she wont never perform this old songs made for tarja as tarja, its true that they changed their style to fit with anette better, but if they would want to replace tarja with another soprano anette wouldnt be here, tarja isnt the only soprano in this world, that was just their decision, so respect it and if u dont like it, then stop listening to NW, they are just trying to move on!!
Panterela 3 years ago
chateautring 77 tienes toda la razon nada k ver annette
drum125 3 years ago
es una banda de pop :D
poxiplus 3 years ago
hay que aceptarlo
anette no es ni la cuarta parte de tarja
nightwish sin tarja, dejó de ser nightwish, ahora, no se que es
chateaustrings77 3 years ago 3
Tuomas, Anette and Jukka are my idols.
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
anette sucks on this one worst than in the others... tarja owns those songs
Danielkalabrax 4 years ago
Tarja owns nothing. :)
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
anette really does need some air to sing. hahahahahahaha, is she dying or something performing that song
Danielkalabrax 4 years ago 3
Well the old songs are hard for a non-classical singer to sing. Actually, if you dont even have a large range, it'll be hard for ANYONE! ESPECIALLY the old ballads.
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
I don't like it. `_´
sahara0587 4 years ago 2
jamás llegará a ser ni un cuarto de lo que era (y es) TARJA TURUNEN
Que alguien la asesine! Que nos devuelvan a Tarja!!!
riky20dark 4 years ago
No me gusta como canta, no me cabe, NO.
olnerraga 4 years ago
woah, sweeet... =) Some kind of a pity that Anette's already in a relationship ^^ I love the song, and she sings wonderful. I adore Tarja, too but still Anette seems to move more on stage... like that. also this way of singing must be very exhausting for her... *.*
SleetasSoul 4 years ago
how can you say she sings beautifully when she is obviously constantly falling off key... i don't hate the poor girl, it's not her fault. but if you notice, even the new songs, which we can't compare to tarja's, she can't sing live. there isn't one song where she doens't give me the creeps. she might be a great girl, but the little one has no metal vibe in her body whatsoever. she might be a great person but music isn't about that whatsoever.. stop denying the obvious.. sad but true.
veracarvalho 4 years ago
This is an awsome song and i adore it about as much as i adore BOTH Annette AND Tarja.
can people please stop ruining it with pointless bickering...
Annette is different to tarja and its only your own opinion thats making her either better or worse. I personnelly prefer her to tarja mainly because her voice is easier to listen to.
The band says they have moved on - and tbh if you cant move on then go and do some knitting dont complain about it cos its not goin to get you anywhere.
gorgerak 4 years ago
yes you are right, people should stop comparing, they are different people. different voices. and besides yes nightwish has decided to do different music, but, and this but is crucial, they could have picked someone who can sing right trough a whole song. not even the new ones, suposedely appropriate to her voice can she sing right live. is you don't notice it than it's obvious you haven't spent that many times listening... and hey i have nothing against the girl.
veracarvalho 4 years ago
WTF?
elfpeter 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
KILL THAT WOMAN!!!
melisa877 4 years ago
kill the vindictive and stupid bitches instead so they stop making retarded comments.
YulieAna 4 years ago
¬¬
SHE SUCKS!!!
AND YOU TOO
olnerraga 4 years ago
Oh gee, i'm really hurt by the same redundant hysterical outbursts. Go pop a pimple.
YulieAna 4 years ago
annetta sux not tarja
tarja is the one who mad the song and her voice is amazing so if u liek annetta then fuck off
EMANUrNIGHTMARE666 4 years ago
Tarja is the one with the most boring, unoriginal album of all time. Face it: Without Nightwish, TARJA is finished. A good voice AND good songs are needed to succeed in music. Tarja only has the voice. Tarja didnt make SHIT. The only piece of CRAP she made is My Winter Storm!
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
ehhhh mira, entendi algo de lo q pusiste y no me gusto, el album de Tarja Turunen no es tan bueno como los anteriores de NW, pero no esta tan mal. Es cierto q Tarja no era NW (la esencia), pero era un miembro muy importante de la banda. No me gusta el nuevo NW, no me gusta el cambio q le hicieron, no me gusta annette, pero se ve q a thuomas y los demas (FANS)si les gusta , asi q hagan la musica q quieran yo nunca voy a comprar un disco suyo, NUNCA!!!
melisa877 4 years ago
yes, tarja lost a lot without nightwish, but honestly do you see nightwish gainning something without her? 'cause all i've been seeing around me is they fan base shiffting into one of evanescence's nature. perhaps that's what they're looking for, making more popular music and gaining more money, which is honest, just not too honest to say tarja was a whore just into money when at least with her they could've preserved nightwish's own sound. either will be the same. lets make peace with that.
veracarvalho 4 years ago
HELL NO! Nightwish fans EVANESCENCE nature!?! XD
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
hell no? hell yes. :P i hope the examples i know won't generalize. hopefully they'll never become so popular, and the "goth" "emo" fashion will become less atractive to all this kids.
veracarvalho 4 years ago
Are you insulting Nightwish fans or something? I dont understand what's so terrible about them.
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
lolol no, i'm saying it's weird this fashion that has become rockish goth metallish clothes and sounds that the "fans" change their taste from 6 to 6 months. i'm a nightwish fan and i know many and i don't consider us one of those people. i'm sorry if you thought the message was for you or something
veracarvalho 4 years ago
Oh not it's fine. And fans DO change their taste. Not just Nightwish fans. X`D. I love this band and Anette is amazing. I'm not obsessive or anything but I have three pics of Anette glued/attached to the front cover of my school assignment book. XD
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
annete is more rock,tarja was more like an opera this rockS!!!
DrzSpectre 4 years ago 2
i like the way she sings!!!
poutsarasgt 4 years ago
I think Annette is perfect for this band! Tarja was just an average opera singer, people who say her voice is unique, haven't heard opera before!She was average.. Anette gives Nightwish the rock edge!!!
midwintertears 4 years ago 4
anette doenst fit this band. the band with anette is the same it would be with brintey spears or christina aguilera :)) and yes maybe tarja was an average opera singer but she fitted far better in this band. And the quallity of theyr songs were a lot higher.
BurningIceGod 4 years ago 2
Yes, yes I forgot if you can't sing Opera you are a pop singer. Ever heard of the queen of metal Doro?! FFS. Annete is a ROCK singer, it's not the voice that makes her great, it's her persona as well! She's a hell of a nicer person then Tarja. Therefore she wins!
midwintertears 4 years ago
"the band with anette is the same it would be with brintey spears or christina aguilera"
Christina Aguillera is an excellent singer, you can't even insult properly.
If you think that Britney Spears and Anette sing the same you are either:
1. A retard
2. A tone deaf retard
3. A poser.
I bet you copy and paste from other similarly idiotic comments, you Tarja fans can't even think for yourselves.
YulieAna 3 years ago 6
anette gives me chills xD love her.
liveaaaa 4 years ago 2
ı think annette is singing much better than tharja.anette suits nightwish
300worms 4 years ago
LOL no
serasvictoriax 4 years ago
Actually... Tarjas deeper voice suits Nightwish PERFECTLY!
Fribbe 4 years ago
gunna have to agree with 300worms on this one, Fribbe. I honestly like Anette's voice better than Tarja's, and was disapointed when I heard how much of a drama queen she was.
TheSnapDogAvenger 4 years ago
You say that because she was the original and although Tarja's voice is the archetype for all of Nightwish's vocal catalogue. I believe that Annette's voice suits Nightwish perfectly and brings a new fresh sound.
Alucard328 4 years ago
To tell you the truth, I thought it would be MUCH worse.
This song in particular doesn't sound bad at all (so doesn't Nemo)... the one I don't like very much is Wishmaster... the words in elfic language doesn't sound very good with her voice . . . **
celticgirl08 4 years ago
wow increible ke n la parte final le baja totalmente la escala de la canción, la musika esta en una escala y la voaz en otra y eso no suena bien, umm le falto mas esfuerzo a esa cancion
spektro999 4 years ago
You can say Anette is too mediocre or moderate, but you know that if she tried to imitate Tarja you would just say "omg she is just trying to be like tarja and she cant". She's doing her thing, she's doing it her way, if you can't respect that then you don't have to listen.
moose11235 4 years ago 5
also i might add she made it her own and changed the tune a bit, better than them just getting a copy,
kumbayad 4 years ago
actually, she may scream a bit, but shes still a damn sight more in tune than tarja was half the time, and i dont care if you rate me soo low that my comment gets removed or something, i know im right! and im gonna stick up for annette even though i did love tarja. :)
kumbayad 4 years ago
sakenla por favor...!!!
Cathrala 4 years ago
this is not cover u idiot
Owner94 4 years ago
MUY MAL, QUE LE HAN HECHO A ESTA CANCION!!! Tarja volve!!! Tarja es el alma de Nightwish, sin ella se aproxima un gran fracaso.
jorfer71 4 years ago
Tarja nunca fue el alma de Nightwish. Ese siempre ha sido el puesto de Tuomas. Y Anette no canta mal.
HunterLovell 4 years ago
Estas equivocado, Tuomas es uno mas de la banda, si hubiera otro en su lugar daria lo mismo, Tarja le dio identidad a la banda, Annete canta bien pero no es para Nightwish es mas para una banda pop, no tiene el carisma ni la voz para interpretar los temas como lo hace Tarja.
jorfer71 4 years ago
Se nota que no sabes mucho de Nightwish. Tuomas es el que hace casi toda la musica, y es el único que escribe las liricas. Sin Tuomas, Nightwish no existe. Y que es mas importante en una banda, la imagen o la musica en si? Y no, la vos de Anette no es pop solo porque no canta opera. Muchas bandas de heavy metal y rock en general tienen cantantes asi como Annette (que tiene una vos aguda y no alterada), y eso no los hace pop.
HunterLovell 4 years ago
Se mas de Nightwish de lo que puedas imaginar, por mas que Tuomas escriba parte de las letras (aunque en su mayoria lo son, presta atencion que no todas son de el)Nightwish podria existir sin problema, de la musica ni hablar toda tampoco es de el, es cueston de informarse, No te parece? cuantos cantantes como Annete hay en bandas metaleras y que hayan triunfado? nombrame una, para Annete todas las canciones son iguales!!! cero interpretacion y cero carisma.
jorfer71 4 years ago
Mira, Tuomas hace todas las letras, todas. Eso se ha mencionado en varias entrevistas. Y como ya dije, casi toda la musica la compuso él. Como el 90%. Y eso lo puedes ver en los creditos de cada una de las canciones de los cds. Sale quien escribió la letra y quien compuso la música. No cuesta nada buscar esa información en internet, deberias hacerlo.
HunterLovell 4 years ago
Y eso de interpretación y carisma es algo demasiado subjetivo como para ser considerado más que una simple opinion. No es bueno hacer que tu opinion suene como una verdad indiscutible.
HunterLovell 4 years ago
Lo de las letras y la musica es cierto y como te decia no es toda de el (en internet no toda la informacion es creible), no solo para mi sino para muchos la interpretacion es mediocre no esta acorde con la musica, no es que yo tenga la verdad es lo que me parece, no quiero discutir ni niciar una pelea, es solo mi opinion, saludos.
jorfer71 4 years ago
not its the same !!!!!
not its nightwish
i really think ...wtf!!
IAFM 4 years ago 2
Tarja it's veeeeeery good than Anette, sure. Ever Dream with Tarja it's very good song, with Anette its... Sucks :{
sergewarren 4 years ago
Good cover guys !
armcab 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
eww sounds like cheap pop! AND WTF IS MINISKIRT DOING HERE? HER PLACE Is in pussy caT DOLLS
Zanthia11 4 years ago
Annette has no presence, shes so..medium. wheres the evilness? the spice? she has good voice, thats for sure, but this is one of the songs she shouldnt sing. first of all at the high points she seems to be in suffering...
Valkyrjor 4 years ago
unfortunately you`re absolutely right :(. Nightwish used to have their own distinctive style when Tarja was a part of them. Now they are...medium :(
gogata1987 4 years ago
anette and tuomass have sex toghether...i'm sure...in this song anette is good...(tarja's version is better!!!!)
catnekylibi 4 years ago
so what??
Pepekno1 4 years ago
is for that that she is the singer of nightwish
catnekylibi 4 years ago
i really dont think tuomas would dick over the entire nightwish fanbase just to dick a chick in his band. i have more respect for nightwish than to think that. good or bad, they saw something in annette, thats why shes the new vocalist
vilbobaggins666 4 years ago
i don't understand what they saw...
catnekylibi 4 years ago
fair enough . . .
vilbobaggins666 4 years ago
Tarja's version is good, but wow this is really good, this is the first time i have heard annette sing this song...i am impressed, I will find out in person when they come to san deigo!
charmed4sure16 4 years ago 3
I hate to say it even though it was expected that she would do a bad job, I know she has a diffrent voice i like her voice on the CD's better but LIVE (not her voice in compparesing to Tarja's) she is not so good LIVE.
boeliejoelie 4 years ago
Tuomas and Nettis always smiles to eachother <33
Ebonybitch91 4 years ago
Creo que esta chica no encaja con Nightwish... al menos en esta cancion se nota... hay una larga distancia para que llegue al nivel de Tarja
ceternyum 4 years ago
Can't wait to hear Ever Dream live with Anette ^^ 4-3-2008 <33333 I pray that they'll release an album with Anette singing the old songs =]
xxUltraFreakxx 4 years ago
i don't...that was nightwish, singing them live and actually releasing an official album is almost going backwards, they don't want to go back they want to move forward. As much as i wold like that i don't think they should.
charmed4sure16 4 years ago
Mainly to patteriz, but also to all people gramblig about Anettes versions of old songs:
Anette didn't raped this song. She sang it in different way (personally I like it - I also like Tarjas versions). But it doesn't mean, that all CD's with Tarjas version of Ever Dream are now gone! We have now TWO VERSION of this song - you can listen to the one you choose!
NoFearDaveIsHere 4 years ago
marco kicks ass!!
purplmoon 4 years ago
ya fregó a la canción...U_U...valiendo madre!
I don't think she should sing that kind of songs, the chours is to much for her...
sadrek 4 years ago
Kill me, but I understand why Tuomas chose her with this song, she adds some personality to the song, almost like a sweet melody, and I liked her change of tone in some notes...
ImaginaryVoncroy 4 years ago 2
I dont think she really "raped" it. After all this was the song that got her accepted
scott2008 4 years ago
Oh no. oh my god.. she raped this song.. it is so good, when tarja is singin it! but not with anette, Ja missä on lavakarisma :O
patteriz 4 years ago
Nightwish had to be called Daywish after Annete came in. :P
Meowyn 4 years ago
Anette singing ever dream...it's like apocalyptica trying to play farewell on turntables (it may be different, but not necessarily good)
The only thing making nightwish different from other bands was tarja's voice.
Anyway, all tokyo hotel fans will be delighted by the new nightwish sound...so why would the quality of the music matter as long as the income are the same?
I hope not to offend anybody, Anette may be a good singer but there are many just like her.
peeweemrmn 4 years ago
Oh I am a Tokio Hotel fan now? XD Quality of music??? DPP is musically their best album so far -.-' You want poor quality of music, go listen Tarja's solo album - that I would believe Tokio Hotel would enjoy very much...
Poor Tuomas, he has always written everything for the band, but some fans, who must live in a dream, think it was Tarja the talented one the band - stupid morons...
ImaginaryVoncroy 4 years ago
In that case, let Tuomas do all the singing. I'm sure it will be a wild success.
By the way, i am sure it was Tuomases writing that made "phantom of the opera" so popular.
Let's face it, it wasn't the incredible music that Tuomas was writing that made the band so famous. It was the mix between that and tarja's voice. I found them good back then. Now i can't listen to any of them.
peeweemrmn 4 years ago
Why do you even exist? It wasn't Tarja that was Nightwish's key to success, BUT, she was a part of it. And Anette has got that part now, and they are still as famous and good as before. And Nightwish manage just fine without you supporting them. I don't even think that they care if you would listen or not because you are just a Tarja-fan.
DavidPix92 4 years ago
I couldn't have put it better ^^ Finally someone that sees is my way, I don't know why everyone has to hate Anette. She's Anette and she does rock in my opinion ^^'
xxUltraFreakxx 4 years ago
You said it... IN YOUR OPINION... In my opinion she cannot sing those songs in the same tune... They could change the tune, even the melody, and Anette has to create her own melody... not Tarja's melodies... like a cover... got it?
Juan2611 4 years ago
Lol. They're not the same person, of course they cannot sing the same.
xxUltraFreakxx 4 years ago
yeah... but they are playing them with the same tune...
Juan2611 4 years ago
Buy the newest album and if you can't hear the change that's your problem XD
xxUltraFreakxx 4 years ago
I was talking about the songs before the newest album... anyhow... I don't like her... and I don't like the two songs I've heard from the new album... the music... it's ok, but I don't like Anette's voice.
Juan2611 4 years ago
You call yourself a Nightwish fan and you have an opion like that? Come on, NIGHTWISH IS NIGHTWISH, not Tarja or Anette. And I don't know what do you mean by tokio hotel fan lol it's so not true. Anette can sing some songs so much better than Tarja, they're different persons so stop compering them. And I don't know what the fuck is your problem just listen to her singing you'll see that she rocks, as an example listen to "Eva"
xxUltraFreakxx 4 years ago
For the 100000000000000000000000000000000th time: YOU MISS TARJA, GO BUY "MY WINTER STORM" and leave Anette and Nightwish alone -.-'
ImaginaryVoncroy 4 years ago 4
AHAHAHAHAHA That's the best comment EVER hahahaha..
juckadings 4 years ago
Surprisingly good!
Rotux911 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The old singer was better for this song.
vahnx1337 4 years ago
Damn the Tarja Freaksssssss
Go after her and problem solved!!!!!!!!!
ellusionism 4 years ago 4
Damn the Tarja Freaks!!!!!!!!!
Go after her and problem solved!!!!!!!!
ellusionism 4 years ago 2
Ohhh, how disappointing...Annette can't hit the high notes Tarja did with this song, especially in the chorus. She still does sound pretty good, though. She doesn't have Tarja's range or grace, but she brings her own attitude to the band, and to me it works. Say what you want, but I find appeal with both Tarja and Annette.
fireproof30 4 years ago
Completely agree every word. In fact, I have both the songs with Tarja and with Annette in my playlist, and I listen them enjoying equally. Nightwish is not one person, by the way, and Tarja's solo songs are nowhere close to those which she made with Nightwish
sarumanwhiteone 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sounds like Britney Speras singing whit Nightwish. LOL!
Bring back Tarja!!! I'm disappointed! :((((
NiramZD 4 years ago
No one cares if your dissapointed cause Annete is the best!
Amaranth1707 4 years ago 2
some ppl might argue that shes not the best...but one thing is for sure: Anette is amazing!
ValerioMean1990 4 years ago 3
Everybody has their own taste.But i prefered Tarja couse when im listening Anette singing live it reminds me on Britney Spears or other pop singers...And she gets a bit lost while singing, her voice goes up down and she doesnt sounds good live at 1 point. And also i cant neither look at her. She doesnt knows to stand str8, and she s dancing terrible, at least she doesnt fits with this kind of music. And from some old songs whitch were fast ones, she made very slow songs and I dont like it
TANYAnILIAS 4 years ago
You mean best because it was sold in so many copies? Because it's more commercial.
StarOfGhost 4 years ago
if annette sucks then why is her first album with them one of the best by the band so far?
Discipleofbabylon 4 years ago
anette you suck !!!!! bad , youre voice does not fit with Nightwish.
alexsb2006 4 years ago
Uh your a douche this is Nightwish now so evidentally it does fit! Toumas chose her so saying you don't like her is like saying you don't like him so fuck off and go listen to someone else!
Amaranth1707 4 years ago 3
I DO like Anette!
lastofthewilds 4 years ago 3
Annette's voice doesn't carry as much power and force as Tarja's did in the old songs (including this one), it's true, but she is a very talented singer in her own right. Plus, people fail to remember the fact that the guys are still playing like fucking Gods! Besides, Annette does such a good job in the new songs, I can't even imagine Tarja attempting those songs now, so I like both singers for different reasons.
BleedTheWineUnholy 4 years ago 12
finally, someone logical.
ZephyrYHK 4 years ago
Thanx :)
Besides, does anyone here honestly think the band would chose a singer who isn't good enough for the band? NO WAY! Tuomas and the guys know what they are doing and the new album reflects that. It's one of their best to this date!!!
BleedTheWineUnholy 4 years ago
She doesn't sound bad but sometimes she sings a bit out of tune.
lissanoora 4 years ago 5
Anette is amazing!
ValerioMean1990 4 years ago 3
True, Juka is amazing
d0z3r69 4 years ago 5
Jukka rocks :)
(well comments are all about Anette and Tarja (even if she isn't there anymore, accept it))
Don't forget the other members :)
Tuomas plays like a god, Jukka bangs on his drums with talent, Marco still sings pretty well and Emppu's fingers are on fire :)
Marypeter18 4 years ago 13
true, they´re all awesome :))
NightwishMuffin 4 years ago 3
tarja's solo album is good, but anette cant sing the old nightwish stuff, to lame voice!
eirnil1 4 years ago
To be honest, Anette has just proved that it's the band as a whole that is good, and not the singer.
Anette's old stuff with Alyson Avenue wasn't very good tbh, and neither is Tarja's solo stuff (minus a couple of songs)
I really like Anette, AND Tarja though.
MobileFish 4 years ago 6
its not so bad...
GAVALEE 4 years ago 4
thats right ,tarja with nightwish is awesome but tarja solo sucks !!!
FCBrugge111 4 years ago 3
coz theres no tuomas composing awesome music for her :P
Metov257 4 years ago
Listen to new Tarja's songs. They are lifeless and cold. All energy was from Nightwish, but not Tarja herself. Anette's brought a second wind to the old NW songs.
Beaverlogist 4 years ago 4
I'm new to nightwish and she sounds and looks great. I am sure tarja was/is great but this girl is awesome too. Just another chapter in the evolution of a great band. It happens all the time.
chillichomper 4 years ago 4
Please make it stop !! i can`t stand anette .. leave the band !! We All Want Tarja Back !! And DOn`t Sing Old Songs ... You`re voice s***s ...
blcknight16 4 years ago
and that is it!
osrocker 4 years ago
Fans of Nightwish do not want Tarja back, fans of Tarja want Tarja back.
YulieAna 4 years ago 8
You nailed it on the head with that statement!!!! You rock!
humanslushi 4 years ago 3
That was to YulieAna. . .not Blknight, btw. People need to learn that Tarja is gone and Annette is the voice of the new nightwish. . .that is all there is to it. Thumas chose annette, so trust the band. . .stop critisizing them.
humanslushi 4 years ago
i wont say tarja didnt fit nightwish 100% because she did and cant argue she got talent,but for me it doesnt matter who sings,since toumas is the real talent behind the show(and the rest ofcourse) and besides,olzon sings really well and she seems like a really nice and and warm person,props o/
leron83 4 years ago
man this sux big time
i do not deny the fact that annette allso has a great voice but whatever she does she should stop singing the classic nightwish songs the ones that everyones remebers with Tarja singing them. Because she simply can not match Tarja's voice. As i allready said in an other comment Annette singing Tarja's songs sounds worse than Tarja would if someone strangled her while singing. :((((((((((
BurningIceGod 4 years ago 2
Damn! it's sad the way Tuomas destroyed a power metal band like this!!! She sings like Madonna!!!, I can believe the horrible way she sings a so amazing song. Get TARJA Back!!!!!!!!!!!!!! or finish this project to save the honor of one of the best FINISH POWER METAL BANDS!!
frunorock 4 years ago 2