Hana kimi- Taiwan version vs Japan Version (abs-cbn vs gma)

[LadyPurpugia]

Everyone are better in Japanese version :D

[21setsuna]

ella chen

wu chun *¬*

Jiro wang arrrr

tang yu she grrrrr

tang zhi ping *//////* ñam

[detay08purple]

Omg Jiro is so hot in the picture

[Shikkyta]

Horikita Maki

Wu Chun

Jiro Wang

Hiro Mizushima

Thang Zhi Ping

[chrisnelify]

ilove japanese version coz the story focus in all actors en actress not only in lead character..and j-version is way funny and have a lots of cute boys..

[reya93]

even though the japanese version is the original i just can't get myself to watch it.. i tried but i just don't like it.. my favourite character is the doctor/ teacher but i don't like the japanese one.. i will try to continue watching the japanese version and come back here to say what i think.. ;) ♥Jiro Wang♥Wu Chun♥ (i probably just like the taiwanese version cos i know the actors though.. but i am willing to learn more bout the japanese cos i am not really very familiar with japanese dramas)

[abrantesgay]

gusto ko po Taiwan..okay? nakakakilig..

[moonrooh]

story line better in J version whereas character best played in T version. :)

[wynanubies95]

heroes: i love taiwan version

heroin: i love japan version.

but taiwan better than japan ;)

because taiwan version so sweet n cute...

[TheNesli91]

nice mv...well done :DDD for me the japanese version was the best :DDD

and the japanese actor who plays the role of nanba minami is called mizushima hiro and not Moriguchi yoko :DDD

[MegaCrystal77]

i watched hana kimi japan till ep 4 on youtube.but there are no more episodes of it uploaded with eng sub.someone plz plz plz tell me where to watch episode 5,6,and so on.

[melz1906]

Taiwan version for me!

[FruitLoopFan]

I love Mei Tian and Kamikawa Takaya as the doctors!

They are both sexy :)

[sunshweta]

I like both versions. But ending is Very Appealing for Hana Kimi Japan!

[dalipay]

Taiwan version is good but i like the Japaneses version more. I find Oguri Shun more manly, not the pretty boy type. I also find him hilarious and adorable on the drunken scene,so natural, hindi sya papogi. Para lang syang mga friends kong lasing, kaya parang totoo yung dating sakin ng scenes..hehe!

[avatarkatara101]

I both think they did a great job like if you want something light hearted watch the Japanese version want something less hearted watch this version . I guess it just depended on your taste . I just don't get people that are flaming this version or the Japanese version . Can't we get along I mean were pretty much watching the same show but different version . You can never go wrong with both versions . There some things I like better in the Japanese version but it goes the same way

[angel08ella618]

haha..mga bulag nga ung may gusto sa japan ver. NO offence!!

hana kimi taiwan is way much cooler and better than japan ver.

ung mga nagsasabing di maganda c ella,mga bulag b kayo??

try nio kaya mag research para makita nio ung 22o...

parang ang gaganda nio aa,,try nio mag-salamin para makita nio itsura nio kumpara kay ella...FYI ella is more beautiful than her...NO OFFENCE ..it's just my opinion..

[chrisnelify]

bulag pla ah,sa tngin q kw ang bulag ngpa2tawa kba c ella ms mganda ky maki?? hahah skit ng tyan q gnda ng joke mo gurl hahahahaha

[angel08ella618]

@chrisnelify bkt 'te? maganda kaba??? bka wla ka pa yata sa kalingkingan ni ella ehh...try mo kaya magsalamin ng malamn mo ang ktotohanan...d mo nmn kilala c ella db? so don't judge her..may sira tlga ung mata mo te.pa-doktor mo nyan bka 2luyan ka ng mabulag....^_^ ..hahaha!!!

[chrisnelify]

@angel08ella618 tlgang hnd aq mganda dhl la2ki aq hahaha..my goodness tnggpin nio nlng kxe ang kato2hanan,nga pla bt kba xado depensive,well gnyan tlga truth hurts hahaha

[apeape231]

taiwanese version all the way! jia you!

[gluber10]

eew ! khet d n mag dmet lalaki c ella mukha ng lalaki ..

mas mganda p dn c maki ! haha mas original ang japan

title p lhn japanese na ee ,, tsaka mas nkktwa eun..

mxeadong annoying mga expression ni ella ..

[jasfer996699]

japanese version-hilarious and fun to watch,gorgeous artists,poor acting

taiwanese version-not so cool but still fun to watch,cute artists(but still japanese artist was DDG),excellent acting

its not about looks, its about acting but since it is entertainment, japanese version won because it is crowds favorite.

[Woesszz]

Japanese version is better,,

The taiwan Ashiya is.. ew

[BloomSpring0709]

I thnk taiwan is better than japan.

[isrhiosbe10]

para sa'kin hana kimi taiwan is the best ang pangit kya ng hana kimi japan mga bulag ata may gusto sa hana kimi japan.

[helloherra]

i only liked wu chun in this version cos he is so cute.

[helloherra]

i hav watch both but liked jap version more. i luv all of the casts...ike ike go go ore go gooo!!! homo janaiiii!!!

[pinkcherry71]

and by the way NO OFFENCE for people who loves the taiwanese version

[pongpongcasili]

i second d motion... japanese version is the best.. i've seen it many times .... and its more fun, no boring moments at all.. and the ost is great..PEACH love the soundtrack

[pinkcherry71]

im not a japanese or taiwanese but the truth is the japanese version is THE BEST.... there are( mizushima hiro, ikuta toma) , who r my fav, oguri shun, and alot of hot guyz

[ArashiYagami]

japanise verision its the bestttt

[MizushimaNemi]

...Nanba Minami in japanese is MIZUSHIMA HIRO..you morooooons!...¬¬....Moriguchi Yoko?! WTF???!

[reinejsume]

taiwanese is the best....i love taiwanese version coz the lead stars had so much chemistry.,..chunella...is soooooooo cute...chunella forever.

[AshleybeeClubPenguin]

ELLA LOOKS LIKE AN ACTUAL GUY! WHOEVER THUMBS DOWN AND THINKS SHES PRETTY U GUYS ARE BLIND. Except for some parts she looks cute.

[Jlo151825]

there both okay..but i like the taiwan version better...

[LauraxGirrrrl]

Take the Nakatsu from the Japanese version and put it in the Taiwanese would make me happy. I really like both versions, except I like how the Taiwan one follows the manga. BUT I love the Japanese one too. And of course, Ikuta Toma. :) lol

[geue23]

japan vrsion is so nice i like it

bt most i like is taiwan vrsion

coz of ella chen

wo ai ni ella my jie

S.H.E 4 ever nd CHUNELLA JERRELLA lol

bt thankz to ur vd so nice

[JSjujubee]

the taiwanese actors are so much more cuter <3 xD

[prettytime]

cool =D

well - I must say that I were a bit dissapointed by the japanese version =/

I mean - it's not at all like the manga .. well - I just feel it lost a bit charm .. but hey - it's good anyway =)

but seriously - I fell in love with the taiwan version xD <3<3

it's so sweet and it got a lot of charming moments =D

in my opinion that is ~

cool video =)

[kimbathekingda]

Japan version for me. I'll never get bored to watch it. japan ver. is really fun to watch. plus tons of hot guys in there. it's alot of fun to watch too.

[danizzaTan]

Hey Let me warn you!

I have no fear kung cno man ang may sabi na panget c Ella Well.

GO TO HELL!

MA2TAY NA KYO!

[danizzaTan]

4 me Taiwan coz I can feel the connection of CE.

the love and romance between them while Japan Ok you might tell that Ashiya is more beautiful than Ella But we are comparing the story not their looks:D Japan version I don't feel any connection at all no love.. I say...... NO OFFENSE!

[tengvangxiong]

i think both is the best yeah!!! :)

[pinkholy97]

Taiwan version..

bcuz..

wu chun iz in it<3 himm ..

and the guys in japanese version are not so handsome..

budd i lyk the girl in japanese btr thn taiwan..

itz all bcuz she loveeessss to act cute..

she iz so nt cutee and preettyy

[crockrocks111]

taiwanese version is the best i like the cast better...the other...hmmm...so so so lang...the story...mas cute ang taiwanse version nakakakilig...japanese...paran­g i find the story like...its all over the place...parang ganun...to be frank di ko cya feel...

[Akimnio]

everyone has their opinions on which version they like best because someone's hotter or cuter or sexier. Personally I think they both have their own uniqueness. I'm not going to sit and choose because no two movies are going to be the same.

[jaleela1991]

To me, honestly? They are both equal! The Taiwanese Version is more true to the Manga and the Japanese Version has a really good story line. So to me, they are equal! =D

[wafuclub999]

gago ang nag post ng video na to..halatang mas gus2 taiwan e..!

maki is prettier than ella..but ella is cute as a guy..

wu chun is more handsome than oguri..

ikuta is cuter than jiro but jiro is cool..

but 4 me i like taiwan not b'coz der are many cute guyz...its bcoz when i watch this i fell the story and im gonna laughing out loud..

the japanese ver...is have a lot of comedy so im not fell a story but fun and cute..;)

thats the true!!!haha hirap mag english wew..

[emelyn28video]

JAPAN VER.

JAPANESE VER. has a good story in JAPANESE VER. the girl ASHIYA study on a ALL BOYS school to consider SANO to get back on high jump because her feeling was she is the reason why SANO quit high jump...SANO's bone was break because of saving ASHIYA....

BUT ON TAIWANESE VER. she study on a ALL BOYS school just because she have a crush on that boy...

(sorry for wrong english its so hard [sakit sa ulo])

[Akimnio]

yeah taiwanese version she has a crush on him, but she still gets him to return back to high jumping......

[sekkitojangepecoh]

japan version.......

[jassminify]

Taiwan's version choice actor is beter than Japan's actor wu chun ,jiro,tang yu zhe more handsome than Japan

[angeltheya12]

othere's r really airhead person huh...

anyways

i like japan more i saw how thw girl of taiwan flirt at the the "bidang guy"

after all original namn n gumawa ay ang japan dahil sila ang nag publish ng book (manga)

[KairiX16]

taiwan CUZ JIRO AND WU CHUN are in itttt <3 fahrenheit..... the japanese got ugly guys.. xcept the girl shes ok.. but ella is so much cuterrrrrr

[LilGirl134]

I love Japanese version. If you kinda look at the Taiwanese version of Nakatsu he kinda looks a bit serious, unlike Japanese vers.

[JaNTriSha08]

The Japanese version is the original version..

But for me the taiwanese version is more cool and awesome ..

But other's like the Japanese one..

[wetpaxz]

i totally agree! :) Ella played the role better than Maki && W Chun is FAR HANSOME than Oguri. CHUNELLA are the best! :D

[KawaiiAsians]

I like the Taiwanese version because you can feel the connection throughout. In the Japanese version there was NO chemistry. Thats all Im saying...

Oh and

WU CHUN AND JIRO WANG ARE THE BEST!

kthxbai~

[ahmshereiam16]

JAPANESE version is way cooler, funnier and above all the guys are HOT!...nakatsu and sano are HOT!..tennoujo and kana love team is so cute and very funny!

[kuhlet24]

yeah!

oguri as sano really hot!

[sunshweta]

@ahmshereiam16 , I Totally agreed with YOU. I Loved both versions.... But ending for Hana kimi Japan was Very Appealing.

[araferma]

mas maganda ang sa japan! lahat ng series na gawa sa japan e magaganda talaga! as in!

hana kimi,hana yori dango, diba!

[manhidnatao]

i knew it already.. nuh,.ang cnsbi lng d2 eh kng nu ms gust0 ng ta0, ska bkt kng kelan gnya n kc ng iba ska ggwa dn ung japan.. and besides all of it opinion ng tao ang hiningi d2 sa video (sa VIDEO)hndi opinion mo kylangan q0..ngshashare lng ako ng opinion oki^^ thats my point of view,.eh d kng anu gsto mo d un nah i d0nt care?^^.. gbu n,.hav a nc day wushuu....

[kuhlet24]

i agree to that!

Jver of hanakimi is the original one.

the story and the cast r hilarious!

and my all time fav japan actor is the lead guy! yey!

no plan 2watch the Tver

[7jessik7]

Taiwan!!!!! is the excelent and very very good!!!

[2793lulu]

my point of view i love the taiwan version is hilarious!!!especially ella her actin was so alike with the manga...she had the spirit....is like if the mahga came out alive so i go for HANA KIMI(Taiwanese VERSIOn) n i love u ♥U♥ jiro n wu chun ..........

[kimbathekingda]

Japanese ver all the way!!! guys are way hotter.

Shun Oguri is hot♥

Toma Ikuta is cute♥.

Hiro Mizushima is sexy♥

yuu Shirota is also hot♥

etc etc so many.i died of happiness.

[djloverjhin]

Japanese Version for me!

[loveranimegurl94]

LOL personally i think the taiwanese version is wayy hilarious than the japanese one xD

the actors are hotter too o-o||

[TearsForLosers]

Taiwan version. The actors are way hotter, especially Wu Chun!

[jicks]

shun was amazing but i loved how wu zun would always rub ella's head <3

nakatsu + jiro were both freaking hilarious.

as much as i love hiro, danson as senior nan is the cutest dorm leader ever xD

tang zhi ping was awesome as the gay doctor <3

neither series were perfect but both were equally fun to watch. i personally love both!

[angelolz0612]

i vote japanese version!XD

[2977watersugar]

Japan is 60 minutes one broadcasting time and one period broadcasting is three month,so it is necessary to shorten the story.

And japan-version Nanba Minami 's cast name is not Moriguchi Yoko.

His name is Mizushima Hiro.

[2977watersugar]

My opinion

Cast of the version of Japan is better-looking than the version of Taiwan.

Maki Horikita is lovelier than Ella.

Toma Ikuta is good-looking than Jiro.

But!

Wu-Chun is good-looking than Shun Oguri.

Taiwan-version story is nearer the original book than Japanese-version.

Because Taiwan is 90 minutes one broadcasting time and one period broadcasting is also longer than japan .

[christinajonas1]

screw the JAPAN version! the the TAIWAN ONE IS SOOOOOOOO MUCH BETTER!!! WITH SOOO MUCH HOTTER GUYS!!! SANO! I LOVE THAT ACTOR. and the japan actress looks like a dude!

[BlankSpot410]

HANA KIMI TAIWAN ALL THE WAY!!!!!!~

[lhudell]

Ive watched both versions, and i could say that no ones better bcoz their both great and fun to watch! Only that Hana kimi-japan is original, and taiwan version has a lot of romantic scenes and more good looking actors than japan version!

[mistakenidentity09]

Sa Nodame Cantabile Anime Ending yang kanta??

DIBA??

HEHEHE!!

[jamPrinny11]

the Japanese one is better, trust me

[bhezbhie01]

what I know is SENIOR NAN in the taiwanese version that is DANSON TANG YU ZHE looked a lot and WAYYYY hotter and cuter than in japanese version =] another thing, halos nmn ng tao sa taiwanese version looked like a lot cuter than in the other version. :) and npka obvious na girl ung sa japan version. nu ba un. :) FREEDOM OF SPEECH PEOPLE! xDD

[rox19972008]

i just can't choose!!!!

[ayoki23]

HANA KIMI TAIWANESE IS THE BEST.

I love jiro wang and ella chen.XD

[TatsukiUkitake]

I like the Japanese version better.

[demicute12]

i like hana kimi taiwan version

[Yanarazmy]

My opinion...

I like hana kimi taiwan better than

japan...

Altough I never watch hana kimi

japan version...:D

So don't be angry with me coz that is my opinion right...???

[singlelady0310]

bkit nman po nsali ang histOry ng pilipinas?!..

hahaha!!!

[singlelady0310]

i like hana kimi TAIWAN !!! go CHUNELLA's !!!

[kakoiibampaia]

yep... i dont think i would ever watch the japanese version anyway

[manhidnatao]

kung ano namn ang mas hot version

xmpre panalo na taiwan version..^^!!

ska kng sa papogian lng nmn..nkow..

wla ung sa japan..ung gumnap na Dorm suprvsor sa japan wla sa kalingkingan ni senior nan!!wuuuuu ang gwapo niu...at pgdating nmn sa act mas gsto ko c ella kc si ashiya parng ang lungkot ng muka.(prng lging puyat ba??)at hgit sa lahat mas gwapo c wu chun sa iniong lahaatt!!!heheheh..comment lng

[manhidnatao]

I THINK mas mdming ngaya ang japan sa taiwan...kgya dn ng Metor garden..gnya dn nila sa taiwan un..pro all n all..mgnda namn ung gngwang panggagaya ng japan sa ibng show....

just my opinion^^

but..sa lahat...LOVE KO HANA KIMI TAIWAN>>wuuhhhh..Rui xi(ella) and Quan(wu zun)..love u guys^^

[miewolfram]

hana kimi taiwan for all the chunella fans noh!!! go wu chun. 'di nyo ba alam na c wu chun ay sa fahrenheit at c ella naman ay nasa s.h.e.

sa mga nagsabi na hangang hana kimi lang si ella, nagkakamali kayo.

FYI si ella ay ang leader sa sikat na bandang S.H.E.

GO GO GO TAIWAN.

eh sino rin ba ang kaaway ng mga pilipino,diba Japan.

mga hot ang cast ng taiwan lalo na ang mga loveteams...nakakakilig

[animeauthority]

ginagaya nila ang mga mala-anime na galaw ng japanese,eh d nmn cla ganon kaastig...mas astig prn ang mga japanese lalo n s acting,kilos at salita...puro lng nmn chong kwayla buchikik ang slita ng taiwanese...dbest ang japanese pgdting s larangan ng paastigan...hana kimi japan astig...;)

[raihamid03]

haha..i agree with you..JAPAN version are way way more better than the TAIWANESE..

[animeauthority]

strawberry,nkaraan p un!!!ano nmn kinlaman nun s ngyn at s plabas...haaay...pano naging orig ang taiwanes?eh original nga ang japan eh, qng d nmn nla un nkta s manga d nmn nla magagawan ng storya un...at ska mas gaya2x ang taiwanese...

[raihamid03]

oo ngaa..kunh wlaa iunh manga wlaa dinn ianh version nanh taiwan na ianh ee....as gaya gaya tlaga iunh taiwanese..

[emilyismykitticat]

i new it only chinese and japanese versions ahahaha

[strawberry0425]

helllleeerrr guys!!! we hate japanese!! sino ang sumAkop sa mga filipino at pumatay ng maraming pilipino dahil sa pagpalakad ng sobrang malayo DEATH MARCH ang tawag dun.. at ang mga babae noon ay ginagawang katulong at pinagsasamantalahan... OHHH... taiwanese ..... grabe astig sila.. orig pa!! yung mga taga japanese ver. ay mga copycat!.. bakay sumikat an taiwan.. bleehh

[manhidnatao]

hahaha..pti ba namn un history noon sinama??

wat conek//..haha...

[araferma]

ang masasabi ko lang, magresearch ka para malaman mu kung cnu talaga ang original sa dalawa!,dahil japan ang orig at ginaya lang yun ng taiwan!ok..magresearch ka hah.

[raihamid03]

weitt lnh!!..at panuu nmn nxalee di2 anh HISTORII nanh PINAS!!..oii di 2uh bawt d historii aah..bout to xa Hana Kimi..bkaa nag kamalii ka!!..ahha..mas orig po kaya iunh JAPAN version..mas realistic pa.. ptii nkuha pu kaya iunh storii nanh hana kimi sa manga!!..

[11gearhead13]

no one noes the name of the song? wow....checked couple of hundred comments for this video and not a single song name.....

[manhidnatao]

bcoz its not about the song its about the 2 versionz,.,,^^

(nakss pwd nah..)

LOL

[Mudsville1]

Nang nalaman ng mga Japanese comic writers na nag-hit sa taiwan ang live action version ng ginawa nilang hana kimi, pinayagan na rin ang japanese TV Station na nagpalabas ng anime ng Hana Kimi na gumawa na rin ng Live Action series. Kung galing pala sa Japan ang kuwento ng Hana Kimi, mas feel mo ang kuwento kapag Japan din ang gumawa ng live action series, kaya mas gusto ko ang japanese Version

[araferma]

ako din! i luv japan!

hana kimi and hana yori dango japan is the BEST!

[Mudsville1]

mas gusto kp pa ang Japanese version, kasi ang kuwento talaga ng Hana Kimi ay galing talaga sa Japan, dahil meron itong Japanese comic books na sinulat ng mga japanese Comic writters at may japanese anime pa na ginawa, ang taiwan tv stations, nahiligan silang gawan ng live action series ang hana kimi matapos mapanood nila ang Anime at mabasa ang comic books.

[animel0ver89]

hanakimi taiwan versi0n per0 guz2 k0h lng sa hana kimi japan c ikuta toma kc big fan nya k0h ehhh

[11gearhead13]

wats the song name?

[polirlol]

ABS-CBN no.1 !!!!!

Go Go GO!!!!!

[jhenny001]

Cguro ok nga preho ung version nila pero i prefer japanese version still.... dami talagang episodes na napaiyak ako, napatawa, i like ashiya, nakatsu and sano.. grabe... lalo na ung final episode... nde ko napigilang umiyak.. i miss hana kimi japan T_T

[spongiemhaye]

kung story saka character ang pag uuspan,, taiwanese version ako... npaka realistic saka yung kilig tlaga it realy shows. maganda din yung bida sa japanese version,, pero nd convincing kc gurl na gurl tlga yung looks nya kaya nd ko mxado makarelate sa knya.. pero parehas mganda,, kanya kanya lang talagang hilig at taste....

[suzainnevhie24]

everyone MUST watch both versions...

so,u can be the better JUDGE...!

i watch both...

so,ill choose T A I W A N

[gandarynako]

shun oguri and horikitty both rock! ;-) love the japanese version the best. although the taiwanese one stayed true to the original opening scene in the japanese manga by hisaya nakajo. hell, horikitty even looks like the mizuki in the manga ;-) nice vid!

[unika542]

how funny, to tell you all honestly both jap and tai are good but what makes the tai more cute and good is because of how the phil daubed it, it was obvious that abs workers daubed the tai version which most of us adores and to tell you all honestly BINABOY LANG NG GMA ang hana kimi jap dahill sa pangit na pagka daubed dito nawawalan ng interest ang mga viewers na manood.how pity that the jap really was the movie chosen by the gma baboys and am honestly boring ang gma shows(^_^)

[suzainnevhie24]

gling mo mgcomment ah...sapul ang GMA...

:)

[raihamid03]

pangett nmn tlgaa ang pgkaka dubbed nanh both ABS nd GMA ee..soo mas mgndaa prenn pg SUBBED.

[peggyzoewong]

the japanese nakatsu is more lovable ... but the taiwanese nakatsu is very funny

[Eunicebaldovino]

for me, both is ok.... but I'll prefer Taiwanese version, 'cause when I watch the Japanese version, It's um, quite weird and really boring.... Ella may be so OA (over-acting) sometimes, but isn't that the huge deal of Asian Teleseryes? to be really cute and unique? If that's not true, why do so many people like Princess Hours with it's OA humors???

[empressmiaka15]

taiwanese vesion is so cute,,ella suits the role,,i think jap is good too but i like taiwan better,,

[grace080506]

pro japanese talaga

mas mganda kxe yng storya

[grace080506]

maganda ung ganwa moh ahh

kxo boto koh xa japan

pro pde nman pareho dba

tnx....

[mandarinfishorcagirl]

japan version all the way. maki ya shun ya toma no hou ga suki! also...the song was partially in nihongo, so...

[anabelen4900]

I prefer Japan Version :D

[takai06]

HANA KIMI TAIWAN RULES Jia you

[spoliarium98]

Starmometer(dot)com online poll results last Jan. 10 '09 (Phils)

2008 Peoples Choice - TV Shows Poll

Favorite Asianovela (Asian Drama) of the Year

* Hana Kimi (ABS-CBN) (59.0%, 640 Votes)

* Coffee Prince (GMA) (22.0%, 239 Votes)

* Marrying a Millionaire (ABS-CBN) (16.0%, 173 Votes)

* The Legend (GMA) (2.0%, 25 Votes)

Congrats to Hana Kimi & all the fans!!!

[fabpink17]

para sa akin parehas lang na maganda yung dalawang version peromas typeko yung taiwanese version kasi ang cute at maganda yung acting ng mga taiwanese kesa sa japanese. yun lang po....

[whiteangel616]

sa iyo, ewan lng kung ano mas iprefer mo, pero sa akin ung sa japanese talaga... so, mag respect tau sa isa't isa ok? wala akong ginawa sa iyo, and wala ka din ginawa, so walang personalan, pero gusto ko parin ung japan... aside sa maganda ung story, mas maraming gwapo... tingnan mo nalang ung pictures nila sa google... hehehe... :) well then, i still love hana kimi japan... take it or leave it...

[whiteangel616]

nagiging kissing monster, eh di pinakita, sa japan nakita talaga... and then, ung brother ni sano, di minention na ang haba haba nung taiwanese na version... mabuti pa japanese na version... and then, sa taiwanese, di pa bleached ung hair ng nag nakatsu! eh sa manga bleached hair niya... kitang kita sa background mo di bah... and then, walang masyadong role ung mga classmates ni mizuki na may mga malalaking bagay din silang nagawa ah...

[Candy684]

i love the jap one it's more funny more hot guys cute girl maki on the other side ella who looks like a man who doesn't know how to act wu chun i know he is hot but he doesn't know how to act as well also the taiwanese one is so boring not funny

[xoxoidEEkaYxoxo]

horikita maki is prettier of the girls

buuttt..

wu chun is WAY HOT! :)

[RyomasGF]

Japan's version is the BEST! It's SO funny that everyone who watch it will have cramps after! XD

Horikita Maki is really cute. And if she was a guy, I'd say he's going to be really hott!

Ikuta Toma is the BOMB! He's so funny and he's hott! Plus, he's Yamapi's best friend and he's freaking smart. How cool is that? Never mind. XD

Oguri Shun may not be as hott as Wu Chun but he acted Sano so damn perfectly! XD

And no, Japanese guys don't look like monkeys.

Jiro Wang does. KIDDING. XD

[lashemaxej]

nagustuhan ko nang husto ung japanese dahil un talaga ung una kong napanood.

ung taiwanese naman, di ko pa natatapos pero parang ang pangit kac magsalita ni ella eh, ewan ko. di lang ako sanay sa kanya.

pero pareho naman maganda, nasa preference na lang ng tao yan, magkakaiba naman tau.

walang mangyayari kung patuloy na magcocompare nang magcocompare dahil sa huli, magkaiba pa rin talaga ang choice ng bawat tao.

so ang masasabi ko, parehong may good and BAD points, no matter what.

[SweetySpy]

HK Taiwanese Ver is much100x better becoz Ella was there.

I believe that she suits the role perfectly well and acted on it far more convincing than anyone.

I can no longer count how many times I watched this series, and still laugh on the funny scenes there over and over again.

To think that I never thought to be hooked like this before on a drama, all becoz I wanted to watched Ella Chen's acting.

I really believed that HK Tai was much100x popular than the Jap Ver anyway.

[SweetCandyTube]

My Votes:

*Ella for Mizuki Asihiya role

*Wu Chun for Sano Izumi role

*Ikuta Toma for Nakutsu Shuichi role

*Tang Yu Ze for the Nanba Minami role

*Tang Zhi Ping for Umeda Hokuto

*Japanese Version -Funnier, good ending AND EXCITING

*Taiwanese Version -Cute boys, cute storyline AND GOOD ON CHOOSING CHARACTERS!

[whiteangel616]

mas original ang japan kaysa taiwan...

naku, napakapangit ng girl tsaka noong boy,

mas maganda si mizuki tsaka si sano...

napakahot ni sano...

oguri shun forever, maki forever!!!

x noong taiwan!

X!!!

hindi nila finollow ung original na storyline tsaka kung ano talaga ung real name nila, tulad nang meteor garden tsaka hana yori dango!!! X nang meteor garden!!!

mas maganda nga ung hana yori dango!!!

PERO HANA KIMI JAPAN is the best... walang kokontra!

[spoliarium98]

Kung pareho mong napanood ang TW at Jap drama version, magaling. Pero advise ko sa iyo, basahin mo rin yung Hana Kimi manga. (^_^)

type mo: SPECTRUM NEXUS, hana kimi manga scan

[whiteangel616]

don't worry... nabasa ko po lahat as in... ung manga... noon pa... di pa pinapalabas ung hana kimi... well, as what I have observed mas based sa manga yung nangyari sa japan... kasi nga aside sa pangalan, there were also some scenes nah wala sa manga...

[whiteangel616]

tapos, ung sa manga, di bah noong pumunta si julia, eh parang enemies talaga sila ni nakatsu, eh sa taiwan, pinakita doon sila nag end up, kahit enemies pa rin sila sa manga... and then ung part nah si sano

[borntopaz]

i mean the one playing rei xie (ella's role) for the japanese role one, she's so ugly yuck i can't stand her. and the show was very boring zZZzz

only thing that kept me awake was iukta toma, i love you ikuta toma!

but the taiwanese was waaay funnier, cuter, emotional, and i love all the characters, they played it very well.

i watched the orginal verson tho, so no tagalog subb :)

and hana kimi taiwan is the best!

[borntopaz]

japan sucks! the one playing rei xie is ugly bahaha!

go ella and wu zun wo ai ni!! ahhhh so ke aiiii.

[borntopaz]

hana kimi taiwan!

wu zun! so ke aiiii :)

[KairiX16]

taiwanese has so MANY CUTE GUYS!!! and japanese guys cant be compared... but mizuki in japanese one is better looking but she's too girly looking... on the other hand ella looks more of a guy xD

[Ursoz]

JAPANESE IS BETTER

[dizzyventuralover]

kung papanuorin nyo yung 2 palabas na walng dubbing at boses nila makikita nyo na pareho clang maganda at nagampanan ng maayos

[RabiaDroit]

the japanese versionn is better

[tinjoy0421]

hana kimi taiwan talaga..

mas maganda kazeh bagay yung mga roles e..

sa GMA d bagay yung mga characters na ibinibgay..

ang guwaguwapo pa nila at mgaganda..

hahaha..

opinion ko lang po..

sowi..

[JustDaRealMe]

In my opinion (nose bleed) may sarili silang ideas para mapaganda ang movie........nirerespect ko naman kung japanese version ang pipiliin niyo kasi sariling opinion niyo yun, e.....So in short, hana kimi taiwan ang pipiliin ko.....

[noobxeet03ilabeet]

ay grabee!! hana kimi taiwan!! kse nman ang panget ng characters sa japan! di hamak nmang mgnda c ella at mas mgaLing gumanap! pti c wu chun! lhat sa hana kimi taiwan maganda. ugh^^ ang ewan ewan nung sa japan!! LOLx. rawr!!~ bulag nlng ang mkpgssbing mas mgnda ung japan version! hahaha chunella is lab!! hana kimi fever! [woot!]

[gel0o08]

nku ung s abs ang mganda!! ms mukhang lalaki ung ngpanggap eh ung gma hlatang hlata!! ang panget p ng pagka dub!! wu chun!! asaness kau gma fans!!

[katexgg]

Japanese is the best. Funnier and their people are a lot better looking. Though I will give Ella the role of Mizuki because she looks like a guy.

[WaterPrincess45]

Well said. ^^ But, even though her character is supposed to look more like a guy, I ended up not liking Ella so much because to me she looked /too/ much like a boy. =/

[nikka0567]

taiwan nuh!!kc mas maiitsura kesa sa japanese ver!haha! no offense sa ibang natatamaan!!sensya na cnsbi ko lng ung gus2 ko sabhin!haha

[aewqwe]

taiwaneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­s

poooooooooooooooooooooooooe~!

[linda1120]

taiwanese is the best!

wu chun is soo much hotter than the other izumi (or however u spell it, my opinion i think he's hotter)

[63ina21]

taiwan version is the best!!!!!!

walang makakatalo....

copycat talaga ang gma, no originality...

[spoliarium98]

Hana Kimi TW, no doubt.

[7od5]

HANA KIMI JAPAN IS THE BEST!

[ampaulinday]

....gO tAiwAnEsE vErSIOn!!!!!!....

...mga ella chen h8rzz,,mga FEELER kmU!!!!! MA2TAI UNTA KMU NGATANAN!!!!!!! pinagmamalaki nyo ang hana kimi japan na CHAKA!!! hindi naman nangalahati ang hana kimi japan sa hana kimi taiwan!!!! at FYI!maraming gwapo sa hana kimi taiwanese ver. kesa sa hana kimi japan!!!! hana kimi japan LOOZERZZZZZZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

masyadong EMO...hahaiyzzzz...sori nlng sa mga hana kimi japan fans....

[unika542]

sus ................la paring sinabi ang japanese version...mga walang originality...wag nyong siraan si ELLA noh....MGA PANGET KAYO!!!!!

ANG LAKAS NG LOOB NYONG SIRAAN SYA....

di nga kayo nagkalahati sa PWET NYA......HAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAH (NO OFFENSE LANG HA)

PINAG LALABAN LANG ANG HANA KIMI ORIGINAL VERSION (TAIWANESE) IN BEHLF NAMAN SA ABS-CBN WU ZUN & ELLA CHEN RULEZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ.........

[janikka27]

noh offense meant ha! in my opinion na gandahan talaga ako sa hana kimi japanese version...kinikilig ako pag nagkasama c toma and maki...hays!!!!!!

[yennix]

syempre............

kapamilya ang d best!! hehehe

gaya2 lang naman ang kapuso eh@!

wlang originality

[numberonefanniella]

the owner of this vid is definitely right!! go taiwanese version!!!! hthey are the BEST!!! mas gwapo mas maganda at xempre mas nkakatwa at nkkkilig!!!!!

[GoodiTwoShuz]

its extremely choppy. u should fix it.

[GoodiTwoShuz]

this has some technical problems, no offense

[sammy091785]

hindi panget si ella ah!!!! mga sira kayo!!!hindi nyo ba alam maraming nasasaktan sa mga sinasabi nyo!!!lalo na kung naka embedd sa puso nila si ella!!! ang sasama nyo naman!!!!!sakali nga di nyo pa masyadong kilala si ella tapos ganyan na kayo tignan nyo mga pics at vids nya baka mabigla kayo dahil baka matalo niya si maki!!!!! gumising nga kayo!!!

[artsylife]

Japanese version is a million times better than the Taiwanese version! Its really funny, the actors are amazing. I dont care which ever network have aired which version. Pero sobra talaga nakakatawa yung japenese version. Also it has enough romance/kilig d nasobrahan. I thought sobra naiba yung taiwan version. Japan version really captures the manga.Nakatsu is amazing character

[nativencheyenne]

taiwan version rocks but never seen japan's version