Фраза "Они редко видят людей" просто убило!Сразу возникает вопрос,а кто же тогда они??Правильнее надо было сказать они редко видят туристов или заграничных гостей!В целом фильм хорошо снят, очень понравилось!И все таки статистика приведенная в фильме на счет того что 90 % населения кочевники и чабаны вызывает сомнение! Это видео скорее всего снималась в целях привлечения туристов,ведь чем дальше страна находится от цивилизации грубо говоря,от ж/д дорог, тем больше она привлекает туристов!
"inmiishka" хрень несёт! Общаюсь с тувинцами уже больше 20 лет и ничего плохого сказать о них не могу. Есть свои особенности, но так это и хорошо! Разве было бы интересно, если люди были бы все одинаковы?! И @TheDimas2005 абсолютно прав, в каждом народе есть как положительные, так и отрицательные личности.
И если одна какая-то овечка встретилась, нельзя судить о ней обо всём стаде!
@TheDimas2005 ты следи за словами! не обобщай всех! в каждом народе есть ублюдки,извиняюсь за выражение. Если так всех обобщать, то все народы получается ублюдки.
А насчет темного времени суток ты ошибаешься, я сам тувинец и очень хорошо с русскими дружу и общаюсь. Ночью когда по городу гуляли никто не приставал и не ничего такого не было.
People, stop arguing, Tuvans are Tuvans , not tuvan mongols, or tuvan turks or whatever: of course they are culturally and historically linked to those cultures;like everything and everybody else in this world; so just enjoy Tuvan throat-singing ;)
@casperado666 real turkic people is altaic asian looking nomadic people. tyvans they are ancient kyrgyz turks. and i'm not talking about arab-persian descent turkish.turkish and turkic is different meaning.
Очень смелое заявление в начале репортажа о том, что только жители этой страны умеют извлекать двойной звук при пении. Я сам и некоторые мои знакомые (русские люди) прекрасно владеем и хоомеем и сыгытом. Развить горловое пение возможно и им владеют не только жители Тувы!
People from Tuva and Kirgiz know themselves very well that they are the Mongols. If you are hesitating ask them. They will say it. we understend each other withoit translator. Because it is our language
They are Mongols. The General Subeedei (Subotai in Western sources) of Genghis khaan who devasted Europe including Russia was uriankhai (tuvan) as well. Uriankhais used to be very brave and heroic people. I really do not know situations in Tuva now. Because we lost to Soviets after WW2.
Tuva are very similiar to Mongolians and they are nothing like Russians. I would like Russians out of Tuva. Give it back to where it belongs which is of course MONGOLIA.
Tuva was a part of Mongolia for 700 years. Soviet Union stole Tuva from Mongolia. As a mongolian I do not recognize Tuva as a part of Russia. Tuva should be a part of Mongolia.
It is possible, but only after America give their territory back to apachi and cherokee or Turkey give their country back to Greece - )
Not correct speak that somethong was a part of Mongolia 700 years - there wasn t such country during this period. Or you have to say - Russia was part of Mongolia also!
Notice then up to 1949 Tuva was indipendent country - friendly to USSR - and formally join to USSR (not to Mongolia)by free will.
geografically - no. People in Mongolia and Tuva have a lot of common in culture and lifestyle, but ad fact Michalkov made his film about Inner Mongolia (also known as Manchzhuria) - it is modern Chaina. But it is close.
Actually Tuva was a part of Mongolia until Soviet Union stole it from Mongolia. So it is the Motherland of Mongolia. You might know that Mongolia controlled Tuva for 700 years. We do not recognize it as a part of Russia.
Ask those people if they want to "return back" to Mongolia, and they will tell you "NO". Mongolia wanted to become a part of Soviet Union but was rejected. The life level and personal opportunities in Russia and Mongolia are incomparable.
And one more, just statistics, naked numbers, no insult, nothing personal, GDP per capita 2008 (World Bank data) Russia - 42d in the World 11 339 USD, Mongolia is 111th in the World and 1998 USD per person. Ask Tuvinians where they want to live. In Russia they have all the opportunities, for example Russian Emergency Minister Mr. Shoigu is ethnic Tuvinian and had held his position for almost 20 years. Any comments?
Thank you for the video. I do understand some Russian - but more the written Russsian although there are some parts of the oral part that I also understand easily.
znznb зайдите из Тывы,пожалуйста!!!
888LICA 4 hours ago
Фраза "Они редко видят людей" просто убило!Сразу возникает вопрос,а кто же тогда они??Правильнее надо было сказать они редко видят туристов или заграничных гостей!В целом фильм хорошо снят, очень понравилось!И все таки статистика приведенная в фильме на счет того что 90 % населения кочевники и чабаны вызывает сомнение! Это видео скорее всего снималась в целях привлечения туристов,ведь чем дальше страна находится от цивилизации грубо говоря,от ж/д дорог, тем больше она привлекает туристов!
kuularsv 7 months ago
Эмили ФАКЕМБЕРГ-француженка кошерная какая то!)))
RedQueen100 10 months ago
"inmiishka" хрень несёт! Общаюсь с тувинцами уже больше 20 лет и ничего плохого сказать о них не могу. Есть свои особенности, но так это и хорошо! Разве было бы интересно, если люди были бы все одинаковы?! И @TheDimas2005 абсолютно прав, в каждом народе есть как положительные, так и отрицательные личности.
И если одна какая-то овечка встретилась, нельзя судить о ней обо всём стаде!
fenix2000taurus 11 months ago
Тувинцы черти и ублюдки. Русского зарежут прям на улице и имени не спросят.
В тёмное время суток даже в Кызыле прохожие редкость.
TheDimas2005 1 year ago
@TheDimas2005 ты следи за словами! не обобщай всех! в каждом народе есть ублюдки,извиняюсь за выражение. Если так всех обобщать, то все народы получается ублюдки.
А насчет темного времени суток ты ошибаешься, я сам тувинец и очень хорошо с русскими дружу и общаюсь. Ночью когда по городу гуляли никто не приставал и не ничего такого не было.
inmiishka 1 year ago
чашпан УГЖОК!!!!!!!!!Мен Тыва МЕН!!!!!!!!!
1gans2 1 year ago
Shu-de!!!
onesecbeforetheend 1 year ago
NE MUTLU TÜRKÜ DİYENE !
TÜRK TÜRKLEŞTİKÇE KUVVETLENİR !
trholy25 1 year ago
Мечтаю побывать в Туве и послушать эти чудесные горловые песни вживую ))
svetlana773 1 year ago
Greetings from Hungary!
Long live the turanian Brotherhood!
TheHunpower1 1 year ago
Өндрийн Хонгорсүх гэдэг хүн байна
byambaa27 1 year ago
fakemberg evrejka pokyda
casperado666 1 year ago
Comment removed
SHUDE888 1 year ago
Comment removed
SHUDE888 1 year ago
Comment removed
SHUDE888 1 year ago
People, stop arguing, Tuvans are Tuvans , not tuvan mongols, or tuvan turks or whatever: of course they are culturally and historically linked to those cultures;like everything and everybody else in this world; so just enjoy Tuvan throat-singing ;)
SHUDE888 1 year ago
very perfect video.this Tıva Turkic wonderful secret rich culture 1 number!!!!!really
koktengri87 1 year ago
@koktengri87 turks look nothing like tuvans. and their culture looks nothing like turkish culture. stoptrolling dude
casperado666 1 year ago
@casperado666 real turkic people is altaic asian looking nomadic people. tyvans they are ancient kyrgyz turks. and i'm not talking about arab-persian descent turkish.turkish and turkic is different meaning.
HanHentii 1 year ago
Когда-нибудь. Я приду к Туве.
Misterbonesaw 2 years ago
Скажите пожалуйсто,что за музыка звучит,или хотя-бы кто её исполнитель.1.39
Заранее благодарю.
HannaLoverika 2 years ago
Очень смелое заявление в начале репортажа о том, что только жители этой страны умеют извлекать двойной звук при пении. Я сам и некоторые мои знакомые (русские люди) прекрасно владеем и хоомеем и сыгытом. Развить горловое пение возможно и им владеют не только жители Тувы!
UzharaBear 3 years ago 4
People from Tuva and Kirgiz know themselves very well that they are the Mongols. If you are hesitating ask them. They will say it. we understend each other withoit translator. Because it is our language
munhkuktenger 3 years ago
They are Mongols. The General Subeedei (Subotai in Western sources) of Genghis khaan who devasted Europe including Russia was uriankhai (tuvan) as well. Uriankhais used to be very brave and heroic people. I really do not know situations in Tuva now. Because we lost to Soviets after WW2.
hitbukh 3 years ago
I believe Tuvans consider themselves as Mongols not Russians.
temur11 3 years ago
Tuva are very similiar to Mongolians and they are nothing like Russians. I would like Russians out of Tuva. Give it back to where it belongs which is of course MONGOLIA.
temur11 3 years ago
Tuva was a part of Mongolia for 700 years. Soviet Union stole Tuva from Mongolia. As a mongolian I do not recognize Tuva as a part of Russia. Tuva should be a part of Mongolia.
temur11 3 years ago
It is possible, but only after America give their territory back to apachi and cheerokee and Turkey left their country to Greece...-)
Notice then Tuva
fromyug 3 years ago
It is possible, but only after America give their territory back to apachi and cherokee or Turkey give their country back to Greece - )
Not correct speak that somethong was a part of Mongolia 700 years - there wasn t such country during this period. Or you have to say - Russia was part of Mongolia also!
Notice then up to 1949 Tuva was indipendent country - friendly to USSR - and formally join to USSR (not to Mongolia)by free will.
fromyug 3 years ago
hva?
shawnoshawn 3 years ago
very nice landscapes! it's mongolia?
letufi 3 years ago
it's Russia near Mongolia border
fromyug 3 years ago
many thanks for the answer-
I saw a very nice film from Andrei Mijalkov; "Urga, near the paradise", it's the same area , doesnt't it?
letufi 3 years ago
geografically - no. People in Mongolia and Tuva have a lot of common in culture and lifestyle, but ad fact Michalkov made his film about Inner Mongolia (also known as Manchzhuria) - it is modern Chaina. But it is close.
fromyug 3 years ago 2
thank you very much for the details-
letufi 3 years ago
Нет, это - Славная Родина Россий!
No, this is the Glorious Motherland of Russia!
maxrocks1 3 years ago
Actually Tuva was a part of Mongolia until Soviet Union stole it from Mongolia. So it is the Motherland of Mongolia. You might know that Mongolia controlled Tuva for 700 years. We do not recognize it as a part of Russia.
temur11 3 years ago
Ask those people if they want to "return back" to Mongolia, and they will tell you "NO". Mongolia wanted to become a part of Soviet Union but was rejected. The life level and personal opportunities in Russia and Mongolia are incomparable.
igor9rus 2 years ago
And one more, just statistics, naked numbers, no insult, nothing personal, GDP per capita 2008 (World Bank data) Russia - 42d in the World 11 339 USD, Mongolia is 111th in the World and 1998 USD per person. Ask Tuvinians where they want to live. In Russia they have all the opportunities, for example Russian Emergency Minister Mr. Shoigu is ethnic Tuvinian and had held his position for almost 20 years. Any comments?
igor9rus 2 years ago
Thank you for the video. I do understand some Russian - but more the written Russsian although there are some parts of the oral part that I also understand easily.
Lovely music and countryside.
Thank you again
Ruthenian0103 3 years ago
Замечательная длина в футах Тува. Пожалуйста загрузите больше длины в футах.
cortezawwris 3 years ago
Agnessa,thank you for sharing this.I miss very much the video from Mescovic!
tps607 3 years ago