I am a Falun Gong practitioner. Falun Dafa is a cultivation system in the Buddha School based on the principles of the Universe: 真 Truthfulness 善 Compassion 忍 Forbearance.
Since 1999 it has been brutally persecuted by the CCP in China. People are being killed, tortured, put into concentration camps and have organs harvested from live people, simply because of their belief. More than 3400 Falun Gong practitioners have died at the hands of CCP in the past 12 years.
With all the respect to American culture but can we leave the 'everything is coppied from America' for a minute please. 'The Sun Also Rises' is an old Chinese saying. It's been around for a long long time and it reflects the Chinese values and an possitive attitudes towards life even when time is rough. So don't drag this completely oriental movie into the American culture.
It's completely symbolism. The plot is not supposed to make sense, and its purpose is to provide scattered memory of a generation. I personally found the film is very beautiful and haunting, but could not explain why.
The tile For American may mean Hemingway, but for Chinese means a philosophy metaphor" no matter what your plight was worst today, the sun also rise tomorrow". How an optimistic life attitude. I really appreciate it.
Undoubtedly i was a really ambiguous movie, even Chinese also difficult to understand what the movie want to say。For me, i think the movie would like to tell us the story our parent generation's love story (The era was China's culture revolution period, still had many romantic story here and there).
@Scottcreek942 you are SOOOO ignorant. The movie has nothing to do with "the novel", and should you have seen the movie, you would know it. ...there's more than just Ernest Hemingway out there, you know?
The movie was not related to Hemingway's novel, but another Chinese novel " Velvet"(天鹅绒)by Yemi(叶弥)。The story occured in last century 60s-70s in China and the movie composed by 4 parts-crazy mother, love, gun and dream. The director is Jiangwen(姜文), a strong romantic style Chinese movie maker.1995,his first movie "In the heart of the sun" won the Cannes Golden. Actually a gifted director.
You may not believe this, but the world does NOT revolve around American culture- which has only been around since 1776. Chinese culture has been around for THOUSANDS of years. Why should they care if there's an American book with a similar title?
There's NO copyright even in the US for titles, & there have been several American films with IDENTICAL names. Besides, this is a CHINESE film!
Artists can call their books, films or plays anything they want.
You keep your sociological bullshit to yourself. Tseuc was merely asking why the named the movie after one of the finest and most well known pieces of work of any generation. He was in no way, shape, or form demonstrating ethnocentrism.
too right! and why is it that just cos someone writes in BLOCK CAPITALS they think theyre making a strong and valid point, excuse us for likeing a book and not being aware of the intrcasies of millenia old chinese art
@spookytom I know you wrote that 2 years ago, but i feel compelled: it doesn't matter how long Chinese culture has been around, but rather how long the Bible has been around since it is the source for the title. Also, saying that American culture began in 1776 is extremely problematic. Are you implying that the label "American" is all that makes the culture of the colonies American? Whatever culture America has, since you imply it is different, is not tied directly to the date of its founding.
This has been flagged as spam show
I am a Falun Gong practitioner. Falun Dafa is a cultivation system in the Buddha School based on the principles of the Universe: 真 Truthfulness 善 Compassion 忍 Forbearance.
Since 1999 it has been brutally persecuted by the CCP in China. People are being killed, tortured, put into concentration camps and have organs harvested from live people, simply because of their belief. More than 3400 Falun Gong practitioners have died at the hands of CCP in the past 12 years.
faluninfo(.)net
Xiaolian7 6 days ago
Hey, What do you expect from a country that excludes every other country from a "World Series"?
Nobby2001 2 months ago
It means there's nothing new under the sun, it's from the Bible.
yiweijin 1 year ago
Watched it like 5 times
love it
but always confused what's it's all about
KubernetePirata 1 year ago
hands touching butts? definitely not faithful to the novel.
spokmage 2 years ago
With all the respect to American culture but can we leave the 'everything is coppied from America' for a minute please. 'The Sun Also Rises' is an old Chinese saying. It's been around for a long long time and it reflects the Chinese values and an possitive attitudes towards life even when time is rough. So don't drag this completely oriental movie into the American culture.
fishishyo 2 years ago 7
It's completely symbolism. The plot is not supposed to make sense, and its purpose is to provide scattered memory of a generation. I personally found the film is very beautiful and haunting, but could not explain why.
sweeper1977 2 years ago
The tile For American may mean Hemingway, but for Chinese means a philosophy metaphor" no matter what your plight was worst today, the sun also rise tomorrow". How an optimistic life attitude. I really appreciate it.
Tanlovepeace 2 years ago 4
Undoubtedly i was a really ambiguous movie, even Chinese also difficult to understand what the movie want to say。For me, i think the movie would like to tell us the story our parent generation's love story (The era was China's culture revolution period, still had many romantic story here and there).
Tanlovepeace 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mad chinese movie makers, they copied the title from the novel, and ruined it
Scottcreek942 2 years ago
@Scottcreek942 you are SOOOO ignorant. The movie has nothing to do with "the novel", and should you have seen the movie, you would know it. ...there's more than just Ernest Hemingway out there, you know?
marco70go 1 year ago
the sun also rises is a reference to the biblical passage from Ecclesiastes. It doesn't relate to the hemingway novel.
Vomitorator 2 years ago 11
lol this ain't no american movie, I dun think.
lolwriter 2 years ago
obviously not!!!
gambtn 2 years ago
What the fuck is this? Is it supposed to be related at all to the book?
I'll be at Wikipedia if someone has the answer.
nietzschex6x 3 years ago
The movie was not related to Hemingway's novel, but another Chinese novel " Velvet"(天鹅绒)by Yemi(叶弥)。The story occured in last century 60s-70s in China and the movie composed by 4 parts-crazy mother, love, gun and dream. The director is Jiangwen(姜文), a strong romantic style Chinese movie maker.1995,his first movie "In the heart of the sun" won the Cannes Golden. Actually a gifted director.
Tanlovepeace 2 years ago
Hemingway, author of this novel, lived most of his life in Paris.
Therefore it isn't even American culture.
RatchelR 3 years ago
He lived in Paris for only about 10 years.
sltleovyed820 3 years ago
why don't they call it velvet
its almost like false advertising
tseuc 3 years ago
tseuc
You are incredibly ethnocentric
You may not believe this, but the world does NOT revolve around American culture- which has only been around since 1776. Chinese culture has been around for THOUSANDS of years. Why should they care if there's an American book with a similar title?
There's NO copyright even in the US for titles, & there have been several American films with IDENTICAL names. Besides, this is a CHINESE film!
Artists can call their books, films or plays anything they want.
spookytom 3 years ago 24
You keep your sociological bullshit to yourself. Tseuc was merely asking why the named the movie after one of the finest and most well known pieces of work of any generation. He was in no way, shape, or form demonstrating ethnocentrism.
Mrun985 3 years ago
too right! and why is it that just cos someone writes in BLOCK CAPITALS they think theyre making a strong and valid point, excuse us for likeing a book and not being aware of the intrcasies of millenia old chinese art
myloverisbillmurray 3 years ago
@spookytom I know you wrote that 2 years ago, but i feel compelled: it doesn't matter how long Chinese culture has been around, but rather how long the Bible has been around since it is the source for the title. Also, saying that American culture began in 1776 is extremely problematic. Are you implying that the label "American" is all that makes the culture of the colonies American? Whatever culture America has, since you imply it is different, is not tied directly to the date of its founding.
musicfan747 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Japs
BRman1 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no idiot chinese...-_-'
triniboitnt 3 years ago
What does this have to do with the book?
branquela82 4 years ago 4