People really made a big deal out of this story. First, the guy was fifteen and felt attracted to her and went looking for Hanna. So he was perfectly aware of what he was doing. Besides, he wasn`t a 10 yr old kid, come on, at that age he was more than ready to have sex, at least biologically. The point is, that this has happened since ancient times. Women used to get married when they teenagers with men much older than them. And teengers have sex you know? People STOP BEING SUCH PRUDES!
She's smart and very talented, perfect for old demanding roles. Silly vulgar actresses of our times should learn from her acting. I burst into laugh when I hear people calling "actresses" people like "Rose Mc Gowan".
Must there be talk about the age difference in a relationship here? We should be looking at the performances of the individuals in the movie, NOT about the age difference. That is not the focus of the movie.
We are just jealous coz we had not that kind of relationship in teenage, it's not every guy who can make love with mature woman like he did.. he's lucky! ;p
It's really only a crime if she is responsible for any damage done to him. Would he have become that introverted, anti-social person without having met Hannah? Would his relationships; marriage, siblings, daughter have failed without having met Hannah? Or is she the cause of his social detriments? If it is the latter then it is abuse. But if the former, then she carries no guilt for the way he turned out.
You are missing the whole story. There is a gap in a movie - we know nothing about him in period between sommer with hannah, and coledge. He looks very happy then, he seem to forgot. BUT - the fact, the knoledge that he was actually in love with nazi-camp guardian who commited murders - THAT's what made him thisway. It would be no difference if he was older or she was younger.
wait....before my people on the left send me obnoxious comments in retaliation for the one i just posted, just know i love Kate too and have ever since i was 15 and saw Titanic in the theatres. She deserves that Oscar....too bad Leo will never get one.
He was in love with her. She was alone, besides being kind of ignorant and very reserved and misterious. What can people from that time expected to know about psycologycal problems and or human rights, guardianship otr teenager issues, etc??? All of this problems werent even considered until ONu came out after WW!!!
actually, I'm atracted by much older men :p Pedophilia, in psycological sense, means atraction to undeveloped sexuality. "Undeveloped" means that it isn't developed bilogicly, AND, that there is no need for sex. Now, teens do have sex, I hope you are aware of that? So, technicly, this was not pedophilia. But, you are not stuped because you cannot undersand that - you are stupid because you don't understand main point of this movie - our morality is a lie. it's based on hipocricy.
i agree with you...let me end up being a 45 year old guy someday romanticizing a 17 year old girl, then tell me that's not pedophilia...lol But that's how the oscar's are, we give awards to people who play roles like that.......
Why do you know thats pedophilia? because it has been listed and recognized as a social and psycologycal issue since all social and mind sciences said so! What do u think pple before or during the war supposed to know or consider it a crime? Nowadays it is! we have mass media info, society, etc.
Of course is pedophilia, but what about the feelings of that 17 year old nowadays...will she be in love?? i think the oscar goes to is not for * the role*, is the good or bad interpretation of it.
On the other hand i agree Oscars are not quite pertinent in some lines... How is it possible that slumdog won best movie and besides like 78 awards more...that was such a predictable film!
She only won Best Actress for this role at the Oscars and BAFTA. She won Best Supporting Actress at the Golden Globes and SAG for this role. She did however also win Best Actress at the Globes for Revolutionary Road.
What a powerful performance. Just watch the detail in her voice, facial expression and action when she says ''we were responsible for them!!'' Truly one of the best performances i've seen in decades!!!
I totally agree with you...and also the part when she hears she has been convicted for the murder of 300 women, and whe she first listens to the tapes older michaels sends her...omg her facial expressions are amazing....definitely well deserved the oscar
really really happy that kate got the oscar finally........although i wanted meryl streep to win as well. but kate never won and im glad that she did. it was long overdue.
This is the clip that they should show at the Oscars. If she doesn't win this year then the Academy will lose all credibility in my book, and there isn't much left to lose!
This story is fascinating, wonderful acting, the "two Michaels" with Kate Winslet stunning...
henriette756 3 weeks ago
Exquisite acting!!
ephimer 1 month ago
I thought "Titanic" was so-so and still think Winslet is the world's greatest actor.
beowulven 1 year ago
for me, kate already nabbed the oscar with this academy award winning clip...
tashkenty 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
tashkenty 1 year ago
People really made a big deal out of this story. First, the guy was fifteen and felt attracted to her and went looking for Hanna. So he was perfectly aware of what he was doing. Besides, he wasn`t a 10 yr old kid, come on, at that age he was more than ready to have sex, at least biologically. The point is, that this has happened since ancient times. Women used to get married when they teenagers with men much older than them. And teengers have sex you know? People STOP BEING SUCH PRUDES!
alucinado1021 2 years ago
i am amazed i have never seen such an amazing actress
PuKemoBaHo00 2 years ago 5
@PuKemoBaHo00
She's smart and very talented, perfect for old demanding roles. Silly vulgar actresses of our times should learn from her acting. I burst into laugh when I hear people calling "actresses" people like "Rose Mc Gowan".
chandal09 2 years ago
@chandal09
Rose McGowan is a glorified porn star.
beowulven 1 year ago
She is mindblowing.
lethalenigma 2 years ago 2
Must there be talk about the age difference in a relationship here? We should be looking at the performances of the individuals in the movie, NOT about the age difference. That is not the focus of the movie.
youngfreak32 2 years ago 3
Kate é Fantástica, eu adoro ela!!!!
Lucassobreira1 2 years ago
We are just jealous coz we had not that kind of relationship in teenage, it's not every guy who can make love with mature woman like he did.. he's lucky! ;p
ModernFrench 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
TO ALL HOLOCAUST BELIEVERS!!!! Watch the playlist on my channel and then visit the website I link to!!!!
TheAntiSeMight 2 years ago
It's really only a crime if she is responsible for any damage done to him. Would he have become that introverted, anti-social person without having met Hannah? Would his relationships; marriage, siblings, daughter have failed without having met Hannah? Or is she the cause of his social detriments? If it is the latter then it is abuse. But if the former, then she carries no guilt for the way he turned out.
alexgomez83 2 years ago
You are missing the whole story. There is a gap in a movie - we know nothing about him in period between sommer with hannah, and coledge. He looks very happy then, he seem to forgot. BUT - the fact, the knoledge that he was actually in love with nazi-camp guardian who commited murders - THAT's what made him thisway. It would be no difference if he was older or she was younger.
jeboshifru 2 years ago
wait....before my people on the left send me obnoxious comments in retaliation for the one i just posted, just know i love Kate too and have ever since i was 15 and saw Titanic in the theatres. She deserves that Oscar....too bad Leo will never get one.
alexgomez83 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
alexgomez83 2 years ago
Comment removed
sagemanone 2 years ago
she's a genius
sammyb334 2 years ago
I was wondering if anyone realized the woman in this movie is a pedophile.
creative36 2 years ago
it seems u havent read the book ull realize it was LOVE
Tatasama 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No such thing as love when it involves an underage boy. It's called a sickness.
creative36 2 years ago
He was in love with her. She was alone, besides being kind of ignorant and very reserved and misterious. What can people from that time expected to know about psycologycal problems and or human rights, guardianship otr teenager issues, etc??? All of this problems werent even considered until ONu came out after WW!!!
Tatasama 2 years ago
can we consider brainwashing as sickness too? cause, that would make you sick.
jeboshifru 2 years ago
I won't excuse your facination with underage boys. You are sick.
creative36 2 years ago
actually, I'm atracted by much older men :p Pedophilia, in psycological sense, means atraction to undeveloped sexuality. "Undeveloped" means that it isn't developed bilogicly, AND, that there is no need for sex. Now, teens do have sex, I hope you are aware of that? So, technicly, this was not pedophilia. But, you are not stuped because you cannot undersand that - you are stupid because you don't understand main point of this movie - our morality is a lie. it's based on hipocricy.
jeboshifru 2 years ago 3
i agree with you...let me end up being a 45 year old guy someday romanticizing a 17 year old girl, then tell me that's not pedophilia...lol But that's how the oscar's are, we give awards to people who play roles like that.......
alexgomez83 2 years ago
Why do you know thats pedophilia? because it has been listed and recognized as a social and psycologycal issue since all social and mind sciences said so! What do u think pple before or during the war supposed to know or consider it a crime? Nowadays it is! we have mass media info, society, etc.
Tatasama 2 years ago
Of course is pedophilia, but what about the feelings of that 17 year old nowadays...will she be in love?? i think the oscar goes to is not for * the role*, is the good or bad interpretation of it.
On the other hand i agree Oscars are not quite pertinent in some lines... How is it possible that slumdog won best movie and besides like 78 awards more...that was such a predictable film!
Tatasama 2 years ago
Well, if someone is stupid enough, he would consider pitagora's theorem for slumdog too, just because he could not understand it.
jeboshifru 2 years ago
it's not pedophilia.
jeboshifru 2 years ago
that gave me chills ...
temospreamo 2 years ago 3
Great movie, magnificient performance, beautifully portrayed.... Kate kicked ass!!!!
Sagohoffman 2 years ago 5
its just agreat movie, but very sad
sarsora11 2 years ago
her denglisch ist awesome^^ no german were speaking like this :D
carolyli 2 years ago
Her german english is so great I think! ..wow
Fay101 2 years ago
She only won Best Actress for this role at the Oscars and BAFTA. She won Best Supporting Actress at the Golden Globes and SAG for this role. She did however also win Best Actress at the Globes for Revolutionary Road.
LennyDH 2 years ago
Moving... I like Kate Winslet's style of acting. She uses her eyes
erinpilla 2 years ago 13
This year's Oscars was like a wrestling PPV... the match between Winslet and Streep for Best Actress being one of the highlight matches of the card
erinpilla 2 years ago 2
What a powerful performance. Just watch the detail in her voice, facial expression and action when she says ''we were responsible for them!!'' Truly one of the best performances i've seen in decades!!!
zelderfordel 2 years ago 14
I totally agree with you...and also the part when she hears she has been convicted for the murder of 300 women, and whe she first listens to the tapes older michaels sends her...omg her facial expressions are amazing....definitely well deserved the oscar
alucinado1021 2 years ago 4
@zelderfordel The "we were responsible for them" moment always gives me chills.
stevedacool 5 months ago
really really happy that kate got the oscar finally........although i wanted meryl streep to win as well. but kate never won and im glad that she did. it was long overdue.
stefanmcr 2 years ago
She do deserve the oscar..but i wish it could come from her performance in revolutionary road. She's simply stunning in the movie.
exodus1307 2 years ago 3
totally agree with you, although this scene is absolutely mesmerizing. fantastic. no wonder she said she was in shreds after playing this role.
diuscorvus 2 years ago
finally she won the oscar......I luv u kate!!!!!!!
descarado1 2 years ago
KATE YOU'RE F A B U L O U S ! ! !
CharlotteNY 3 years ago 3
LOVE YOU KATE
Bitmate 3 years ago
the oscar goes to Kate Winslet!!!!
liujing81 3 years ago 3
she is one of the best actress in her generation
Wenchie04 3 years ago 3
Kate Winslet's German accent is very authentic
BrainySmurf1 3 years ago 4
This is the clip that they should show at the Oscars. If she doesn't win this year then the Academy will lose all credibility in my book, and there isn't much left to lose!
googledoodle101 3 years ago 4
go go Kate.
angelinoparedes 3 years ago 2
She ahs to win the OSCAR! In this rule is incredible fantastic!
AcordeAnita 3 years ago 2
she is simply stunning in this role!!
egoeime 3 years ago 2