Added: 4 years ago
From: ladycroft214
Views: 125,352
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (191)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i just remembered. i have every nin album on itunes. uh! silly me!

  • GREAT VIDEO; sad and super powerful song. Trent Reznor is a genius. I owe him a big part of my sanity

  • much beter fit. props.

  • muc beter fit. props.

  • If you asked me, this video is better suited for this song (And All That Could Have Been) than The Perfect Drug. Beautifully done.

  • @boardfu ewwh not at all :p

  • I will die to this song.

  • Beautiful re-edit ...Well done

  • Comment removed

  • Nice edit.

  • @allthatyouknow How come your comment doesn't have a million thumbs up? Jeez, even I felt it.

  • shhhhh.....silence........ the god is talking.

  • This music video seems like a Tim Burton movie. :D lol.

  • I love it

  • this just makes me wanna die

  • we dont follow you, your a moron just like us, fuck you. you never crossed us.

  • need some absinthe

  • This song got me through some bad times.

  • Amazing job, fits the song perfectly.

  • you did a fucking fantastic job. bravo

  • Mind blowingly well done sir!!!

  • Why, oh why can't I hear my NIN without you tube's incessant breaks and pauses? This honestly breaks my heart. You tube has truly dropped off in it's quality. You have no pride anymore you tube. Just excuses. Amen.

  • @fabianalicea Kinda like your religion. Ramen.

  • mostly a very good fit and very nice to compare different interpretations of the same song. Yours seems full of rage and disapointmet... so very differnt to the requim for a dream version!

  • Awesome upload man!

  • Nice edit. Fits the song, perfectly : P

  • this makes me cry! :(

  • eh....co-opting the perfect drug video for this and labeling it as a fan made video are really 2 different things......

  • @jloughry1976 My fucking point exactly, god these "it's so amazing", browning noising faggots on here make me sick.

  • the sync up at 4:55 is amazing :D

  • the emotion in this song and the lyrics and how its played is so amazing.

    its probably my favorite NIN song, just for the small details within it.

  • All of you have no clue, not a single clue. Not one. And you will never remember like we do.

  • FAIL! Just attach a sound byte to a completely different video and get 291 morons to "like" it....suppose that's why Bieber and Brittney are (were) so popular......sad!

  • @funkypost Well fucking said, my point exactly, this video and the user who created it, sucks major dick.

  • @misterphelps The videos perfectly fine.... it suits perfect drug though

  • Lara Croft is a NIN fan. I just came up with that because the channel name is ladycroft XD

  • -gets in emo mood to match song- wait, i was already there. I have been wanting to get "for all we could have done, and all that could have been" tat'd on me for a while, that and trents eyes on the back of my neck forsome strange reason.

  • wow really good job matching this up :D

  • @MissySlaughter Leave the perfect drug alone. It's perfect the way it is

  • Even though the song "Perfect Drug" has a comletely different feel, with your video patching I think the video fits this song better than the one it was created for. Great job!

  • I gotta confess something. And this you are going to have to just trust me on this. I love NIN, I've lived the albums. I think I have very near reznor potential maybe more. Everyone keeps calling him a genius... I agree, but do I walk this path?

  • .....

  • Shawn R.I.P this song tells the story of all my grief and regret and stupid misunderstandings we allowed get in the way of the two of us..Remember Me

  • I felt this in my clitoris. :D

  • @allthatyouknow omg.. your hot, lol. i know just what you mean! trent does that for me too.... fucking sexy man he is!

  • as a non-talented person this track is pivotal. lengthening of the instrumentation is the difference in 2 svc 12" sub woofers and a 15" dvc subwoofer...

  • This song to me is the very definition of melancholy bliss, marred in the confusing haze

  • rips my heart out EVERY Time!!!!

  • if i were a pussy i would cry and listen this song, but i wont, bcouse im not a pussy, best song

  • @LawBL94 your comment didnt make much sense lol

  • I've got "and all that could have been" tatooed on my cock

  • @BrandonTheRemix no way?!?! i have The Fragile tattoed on my cock!

  • i should shit my self daily if i lived there.

  • @misterphelps actually, if you knew anything about NIN, you would realize the footage has been completely re-edited and plays nothing like the original...

  • @ladycroft214 Trust me, I know far more than you about NIN and probably have been to more concerts as well. But this isn't a pissing contest. Check out other fan made videos, they make them from scratch, not pre-existing videos, dragging and dropping footage in a new order doesn't make it a fan video, it makes it a mockery.

  • @ladycroft214 Uh..jeez. I, for one, read it was fan made. (Maybe that douchebag full o' shit can't read?) Just wanted to chime in an say that YES-I noticed the excellent re-editing you did an you did 1Hell of a job. Reznor would be proud. Would like to see more from you. Oh, and...ignore morons like misterphelps. Really? misterphelps? even his ID exudes douchebaggery!! Sounds like a detention teachers name....

  • @YRARofUR Look another clit rubber decided to stick his nose into the discussion. You must have pretty low standards if you consider this trash "re-edit" excellent. With your warped and fucked standards you'd fuck anything that moves, the fish stop swimming when you come around. As for my ID, apparently you've never seen any of the Mission Impossible films or series. Your ID on the other hand sounds like the noise your mom makes when I fuck her in her ass while your bitch dad watches.

  • @ladycroft214 Ignore him, he is given to the shadows of the damned and the lost. Hatred will consume him until he is hardly a fleeting wind.

  • @ladycroft214 don't listen  to that poo poo head i feel as if this song more closely matches THAT particular music vid really... i recently started listening to nine inch nails and i was surprised this WASN'T the music vid for this song....

  • @ladycroft214 i like it :)

  • @ladycroft214 plus it's been slowed down... great creativeness using NIN material :)

    you should go pro if you like doing this ^^

  • @ladycroft214 I really love how you did this video.Simply amazing.

  • @misterphelps you cant be serious...

  • @KuivatDubit Yeah, people need to stop giving credit to these amateurs, these cocksuckers butchering amazing work. Anyone with a 20 dollar editing software is automatically an auteur whose vision is "amazing" and "groundbreaking". Shut the fuck up, check out other fan videos, all from scratch using real skill like stop motion animation and adobe FX, this user took someone else's work and butchered it and expects to get praised, fuck him and you for defending this trash.

  • @misterphelps well its your oppinion, but does it give you a good reason to call someone a dumb cunt? talking of amateurs. your way of presenting your oppinions on this site is far from professional. Don't wait that anyone here will take you seriously.

  • @misterphelps Who cares about the video? you dont have to watch it, Just be grateful he puts this on youtube for you and me to enjoy and discover.

  • @misterphelps yeah c'mon man, this guy is just trying to pay homage to something he loves (and I love, go trent!). No need to be a dick about it. This is an awesome song!

  • in my nothing you meant everything to me...wtf that is amazing, i couldnt think of something that poetic in a million years..

  • What "Song" Is This Video Actually To?

  • @7dullboy7 "The perfect drug"

  • this song is straight up musical genius it just flows with crazy awesomeness

  • This song is stunningly beautiful - I don't think I can ever get bored of this. The true beauty of NIN's music is that, whether it's harsh, provocative, soft, mellow or screamin' - the songs always have this wonderful, atmospheric vibe that evokes such a powerful response when you listen to it. It's like if a particular 'mood' could write a song!

    Trent's songs paint such a picture and set a scene in your mind just with the music and melody alone, I find it impossible not to get sucked in....

  • I love how trent always has the most fucked up videos. i have listened to countless nin songs and they always are awesome.

  • Trent COME BACK PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • great song

  • I love this song.

  • U did very well. Thanks.

  • its too bad this song comes to an end it should just keep goin on and on

  • Such a mysteriously beautiful song. Love it.

  • I never understood why this video was used for the perfect drug song, it doesn't fit it. But this song, it's fits real nice.

  • The Chorus gives me chills every time...

  • If you pause it at 1.45 it looks like the outline of ET, god im baked.

  • Fegule

  • your brilliant

  • man this song just FLow like a river stream

  • this is a great song and a really nice job putting this second fan made video together.i worked on this tour and have always felt this album ,tour,and song will hold a place with me so dear and personal.thank you for your choice of song and making a video for it.

  • MY DYSFUNCTIONAL WISDOM SYMPHONY

  • i got "and all that could have been" on my left collarbone. kind of on a whim, as i was walking out the door to the parlor i still had no idea what i wanted, and then i saw my nin dvd. i go back and forth on liking it. at this moment, i like it.

  • fukin excellent

  • Fuckin amazing!

  • Very nice video fits the song really well! Trent is an incredible composer

  • This video is absolute shit, but the song is beautiful.

  • rips at my soul

  • I can't find this song anywhere on itunes.

  • I own every single album from Nine Inch Nails, starting from Pretty Hate Machine, to The Slip. I do not recall this song being on any of them.

  • @youngdones The song is from "Still" ... He released it alongside And All That Could Have Been. It is beautiful. I definitely recommend it.

  • i don't think any NIN song compares to the raw emotion of this. absolutely amazing

  • Favorite NIN song, ever.

  • in my opinion this song, the hand that feeds, and the perfect drug best NIN songs ever

  • zaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaallliiiigggg­g !!

  • at first i was like how did this get 5 stars its just perfect drug with aatchb playing...but then i saw how well it goes ...wow ladycroft your a smart

  • This song gives me chills. Trent is such a fucking talented man.

  • it hurts too listen to this because of all the memoires that ive had of some of my exs. but damnit i love all of trents stuff

  • Out of everything i've ever heard from NIN this one will always hit me the hardest - so so sad and beautiful. The calm chaos in this track is just unlike anything else Trent has done imo - he dug really deep for this one.

  • Comment removed

  • lol, thanks man

  • Yeah, That's about right :)

  • Amazing video - Thanks for making this and sharing.

  • This is better than Awesome... I don't have a word to describe it...

  • @S4CK80Y  CARNAL ,SANGUINARY, HEDON, ABATTOIR, ABDICATE , ABJECTED, ABYSMAL, ILREPUTE, FORMIDABLEY EPITHET , fucking retard

  • @ByTwilightTheyStand HAHAHAHAHAH I honestly laughed aloud at reading this comment. Have you ever considered stand-up? Or joining the circus?

  • very depressing song..

  • man, awesome fucking job! almost all of the lyrics sync up - well done!

  • Beautiful Job!!!

  • Makes no fuckin sense Trent duznt have an official video to this song. Great job on the match.

  • this fit very good!

  • nice video and a great song/band

  • this song perfectly talks about how I'm feeling right this very moment

  • i've tattooed "and all that could have been" on my arm

  • Oh really? Cool! I was gonna get that but I went with Pretty Hate Machine instead...

  • this is pretty cool too :D where do you have your tattoo?

  • Inner forearm:)

  • me too. on the right side

  • lol yea me too :D

  • @astonishedeyes my cousin has a tatoo on his dick lol its a 100 dollar bill he said he got it cuz women love to blow money

  • @astonishedeyes WHO THE FUCK ARE VYOU PEOPLE

  • @ladycroft214 YOU FUCKING CHILD, ,,,DIGITEOUS MINIMEOUS, .....FUCK

  • I've got the A.I.R. flag...

  • @astonishedeyes my buddy got trent to sign his back and choose a saying to be tattooed, so Trent wrote "...and all that could have been" then signed his name, super fucking cool!!!

  • @astonishedeyes taT THAT ON YOUR BRAIN IDIOIT

  • @astonishedeyes and all that could have been is an awesome tattoo. I'm inkless but beside (not literally) my daughter's name i would like to have that ink.

  • god this song is too fucking awesome!

  • Great job!, it really fit with the clips from The Perfect Drug.

  • nice mix of the song and vid. This song is also one reason why you have to love the Still album. Great song

  • funny, my two favorite NIN songs are and all that could have been and the perfect drug.

  • Thx again everyone :)

  • Nice work. I haven;t seen the vids you cut it from, so I thought it was the vid for this song. Great song,,,

  • this song is so emotional

  • Romantic!

  • if you watch this video with an open mind it kind of looks like he's singing this song and not the perfect drug

    good job

  • Thx:D

  • amazing vid!

  • The only question is ... why was And All That Could have Been NOT on The Fragile? :(

  • Hmmm... who knows? Perhaps it hadn't been written yet... either way, at least he released it lol. It's unfortunate he didn't make a video for it though...

  • Thx everyone! I just thought it matched well... got the emotions across...

  • it written that its from this video ;)

    you're so clever ;p

  • Wow, awesome edit!! Just Perfect! :)

  • very well fitted

  • best nin song

  • I liked it good job.

  • @BrodyMan247 i just found it, i liked it too, very much, Trent is a GENIUS!

  • Lovely video, this is my favourite track off Still. More tormented than Hurt, cuts very deep and gets me everytime, but so so beautiful. Just like this video. Thanks for posting! ....."in my nothing you meant everything, everything to me". Fantastic lyrics! So beautiful!

  • Great video. Great song. Nice work.

  • Great video, very nice work, well done, for the most part of it it felt like it was the real thing....Thanks for sharing and keep up the good work..This song is very special for me

  • Thx! I just uploaded the HQ version. You can view it by going to my profile!

  • Thx everyone! Keep your eyes peeled! I am currently re-making this video as we speak into a high quality version. It has been a test to get it matching this one exactly... but I can't wait to share it with you all... it's so much better!! Sadly, it won't be 100% quality when you see it, cuz YouTube degrades it a bit, but it will be a huge difference!

    Is there a way to just replace this video with the new one?

  • This is such a beautiful song and it goes great with the video.

  • You did a superb job with the synching. Trent with a mustache is almost as unsetteling as that little girls face.

  • ...it's a boy, but thanks! lol

  • bs its not a boy:S

    great vid btw

  • i have no words for it i love the video and i really really love this song :O keep going on with your video`s they are awsome lolz

  • Thx everybody! This is prob. one of my favorites!

  • it's so............ hum i LOVE it ^^

  • One of the greatest songs of all time, haven't been able to get enough of it since high school 4 years ago!

  • This is a brilliant idea. The combination of the two work perfectly. You did an amazing job! I'm never taking this off of my profile. :]

    10/10

  • Thanks! At first I just started the two together and it seemed to be running together great so I really got into it and came up with this. Glad you like it!