...after all the Pogorelich-Scarlatti around here, one wonders what he can do with the OTHER Baroque guy?...with Bach he is not quite as effective...one needs a slightly different kind of "tone-attack" setup for Bach than what Pogorelich is used to doing...still, this is Ivo, I am not going to bitch, particularly...
So often at this speed a performer loses the soul of the piece and it become machine gun like. Not so here. Not at all. This is the most musical, most lyrical, and expressive performance of this I have ever heard, and I bought my first recording of it 50 years ago. Compare his use of speed to build structure with his performance of the Mozart Piano Sonata (Turkish) that is breathtakingly slow. He uses tempo to build structure and lyricism. Both are magnificent. Bravo
One have to remember that during Bach's time they couldn't perform this piece in this fast tempo, because of the instruments. By going quicker the piece adapts itself to a modern piano and the music becomes more current. As long as the figures and details in the piece doesn't get lost it's fine in my oppinion.
@ytfarmer90 A very balanced and polite way to say it:D. I agree. " i go a step back, so do you"(for now). You can be a negotiater with those skillz:D.
Que magnífica interpretación, fluida y furiosa. Esta pieza me recuerda al desalojo del gueto de Cracovia que aparece en la película "La lista de Schindler" en donde un soldado alemán se sienta al piano e interpreta esta pieza en medio del horror y las ráfagas de las ametralladoras nazis...!!!
I was merely expressing MY opinion of his playing, and if you think I'm not entitled to have an opinion then you shouldn't even have bothered to read my comment. I stand by what I said, this performance is pure over-exertion and empty exhibitionism.
Too fast, not enough expression, over-dramatic accents, etc. Yeah, I don't like him very much, even though I'm Croatian too :P Just listen to the Gould version for comparison...
The first time I heard this I thought he played it too fast also, but the more I listen, the more I love it. This music makes me feel so lifted and clear in thought.
You are right ! today´s pianists and many conductors have an obssession for fast "tempi". They both neglect that music is a language... a sick and primary error. People around the world are living life "in a hurry" and all they can hear is the another "virtuoso" hammering... Welcome to the world of deaf !
jejej
marianomanto 1 hour ago
it would be better if video was synchronised
KUNGFUTOMATO 1 month ago
I love the tremendous energy coming from this flood of sound. Brilliant!
qqjefferson77 2 months ago
The hands and manner are the most well-practiced and well-controlled I've ever seen.
ivanoschen 4 months ago
So he can keep a tempo... one of the few Pogorelich recordings I can listen to without getting annoyed. It was enjoyable, but not a revelation.
ReturnOfTheStienway 4 months ago
Wonderful performance!
MadameAmelieSon 4 months ago
I think Pogorelich is not of this earth
IWMYB 5 months ago
prekrasno...
nemam potrebu za hranom...
xBlackDoll1 5 months ago
Comment removed
TheKoteche 5 months ago
Ivo, you inspire me. You get me high on music.
iluvmarriageoffigaro 6 months ago
radical, the best.
KarloFeder 6 months ago
...after all the Pogorelich-Scarlatti around here, one wonders what he can do with the OTHER Baroque guy?...with Bach he is not quite as effective...one needs a slightly different kind of "tone-attack" setup for Bach than what Pogorelich is used to doing...still, this is Ivo, I am not going to bitch, particularly...
fredericfranc 8 months ago
Maybe a bit fast, but what a lively music ! It's positively enthusiastic and irresistible.
rigel48 8 months ago
Incredible! It is beyond me that anyone would "Dislike" this.
veganman22 8 months ago
Pogorelich: one of the few pianists capable of giving justice to this masterpiece.
greppi93 9 months ago
please check out my interpretation! i think it is very similar, although mr pogorelich is still unreachable ;-)
just insert this in the url as video code: watch?v=jbSgxAwu6CQ
enecee13 10 months ago
So often at this speed a performer loses the soul of the piece and it become machine gun like. Not so here. Not at all. This is the most musical, most lyrical, and expressive performance of this I have ever heard, and I bought my first recording of it 50 years ago. Compare his use of speed to build structure with his performance of the Mozart Piano Sonata (Turkish) that is breathtakingly slow. He uses tempo to build structure and lyricism. Both are magnificent. Bravo
GeorgeM1949 10 months ago 3
EXQUISITE
model23girl23 10 months ago
One have to remember that during Bach's time they couldn't perform this piece in this fast tempo, because of the instruments. By going quicker the piece adapts itself to a modern piano and the music becomes more current. As long as the figures and details in the piece doesn't get lost it's fine in my oppinion.
Ianthe22 1 year ago 2
A true genius. One of the greatest interpreters of Bach, sitting with Argerich, Perahia and Richter [Still do think that Gould is the best....]
pila406 1 year ago
played a little too quick, if you ask me
Blackadder512 1 year ago
@Blackadder512 Quick? You think it would sound better slower?
Ianthe22 1 year ago
@Ianthe22 Yes, perhaps not better, but certainly not worse.
ytfarmer90 1 year ago
@ytfarmer90 A very balanced and polite way to say it:D. I agree. " i go a step back, so do you"(for now). You can be a negotiater with those skillz:D.
Ianthe22 1 year ago
what the hell! beautiful accents! I never heard those ones! very... uniques! :D
newFranzFerencLiszt 1 year ago
mindblowing. I usually enjoy this prelude a little slower, but I take my hats off...
crapscular 1 year ago
This has to be the best I've heard by quite a long way
chrish12345 1 year ago
a bit too fast for my liking but brilliant in executions nevertheless
ahamayoisac 1 year ago
i just transcribed another performance of his on my channel. really exciting, and musically valid in my opinion.
Sorcerer88 1 year ago
wow, amazing hand movements, dexterity, beautiful...
rabbintigger 1 year ago
Que magnífica interpretación, fluida y furiosa. Esta pieza me recuerda al desalojo del gueto de Cracovia que aparece en la película "La lista de Schindler" en donde un soldado alemán se sienta al piano e interpreta esta pieza en medio del horror y las ráfagas de las ametralladoras nazis...!!!
morgulddt 1 year ago
POGORELICH IVO,YOU ARE THE BEST !
Sanjaviolina 1 year ago
perfect
universmusica 2 years ago 2
As for me, Gould is sterile and dull, he never impressed me, sorry
Pogorelich is - on the other hand - an unique piano genius, and I don't even want to think to argue that fact
I own a CD of Bach's English Suite played by him, and "it smells...like victory"
Ivo Pogorelich is Salvador Dali of classical music
BRAVISSIMO!
rokizifredi 2 years ago
I was merely expressing MY opinion of his playing, and if you think I'm not entitled to have an opinion then you shouldn't even have bothered to read my comment. I stand by what I said, this performance is pure over-exertion and empty exhibitionism.
Tomislav4499 2 years ago
fuck yeah Christopher Walken!
gassyjeff 2 years ago
Just AMAZING
jennieforte 2 years ago 10
@jennieforte I totally agree with you
mynabi01 8 months ago
tomislav, you are so small,to talk to him,POGORELICH IS THE BEST, no one not play like him......... BRAVO POGORELICH
planetmusica 2 years ago 6
Not too fast I suppose, no faster than Glenn Gould anyway
freddymerckx1 2 years ago
Tomislav you are so boring.......
xmiroslav 2 years ago
Too fast, not enough expression, over-dramatic accents, etc. Yeah, I don't like him very much, even though I'm Croatian too :P Just listen to the Gould version for comparison...
Tomislav4499 2 years ago
The first time I heard this I thought he played it too fast also, but the more I listen, the more I love it. This music makes me feel so lifted and clear in thought.
pianofan2010 2 years ago 3
You are right ! today´s pianists and many conductors have an obssession for fast "tempi". They both neglect that music is a language... a sick and primary error. People around the world are living life "in a hurry" and all they can hear is the another "virtuoso" hammering... Welcome to the world of deaf !
harpsinth 2 years ago
Sheer genius.
billyguns2 2 years ago