To me, the original was about how a person craves for eternity, love and beauty. It was arranged beautifully and made everybody feel like there's still an answer after all these years of thinking and despairing.
But unfortunately the truth is, if anybody is looking for something really hard now, it's for money, sex and violence. And Tori knows that only by exposing that dark part of life, we can't get to the bright part.
This version disgusts me, also the Pip version of "Me and A Gun", but we have to rip off the beautiful surfaces of things to truly realize and accept that it's still possible to change these situations.
I love Tori, and she is my absolute favorite, but I also love Neil Young immensely. This is a wretched cover, my least favorite of hers next to "Total Eclipse of the Heart". It's a gentle, contemplative song, and to quote a hater, she did indeed "rape" it. This is violent, angry, and wrong. The sincerity and sadness present in the original have been ripped away, as with any real meaning. I don't know how she interpreted the song lyrics, but it just doesn't work for me.
As Peter Murphy sang Tori "cuts you up and spits you out". I think she is some kind of genius but just not usually my taste and this is just a bad cover.
your wrong. I think anyway. I dont think your wrong by watching this video, this video is aweful. Any music lover should see her live, its completely different. If you felt the energy in the room that night, i dont think you would think the heart is gone. She is known for changing peoples songs completely. She covered EMIMENS "Stan" from the point of the women in the trunk!
Well if you knew anything about Tori Amos you'd know that it was from her cover album Strange Little Girls in which she took songs by men and interpreted them from a woman's perspective.
I think it ads a whole new dimension to the song and proves how good a song it is to transition into rock so well.
Also it's a song that no crumby youtube video will do justice to. Had to have been there.
Yeah but womens perspective? does that mean you have to take a touching song and make it sound like modern bullcrap? can't women see the meaning of songs or something? the song is about wanting to be a good person, this is just some.. i dunno what to call it.
Don't make me laugh.She does a good job here.The woman is a goddamn genius and better than most people in the world at what she doesIn this and in the different thing. Go Tori!
Does Tori Amos make it her life goal to ruin every song she covers. Jesus fuck. She's such a good singer but I haven't ever seen her do a cover that didn't blow cock.
How about you watch it as if you have never heard the song before. And let what her take of it is soak in. I love the 1996 covers. How much do you actually like her?
THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! This is a rarity by far, and this concert has my favorite set list on the tour so far. You rock for posting all these...PLEASE post any more you may have :)
horrible!!!
andrei1nikos 3 months ago
I love the madness she brings into this song. It's no longer a love song....it's so desperate and fed up and barely hopeful.
NietzscheOU 7 months ago
You mistake passion for anger.
FeverRai 1 year ago
To me, the original was about how a person craves for eternity, love and beauty. It was arranged beautifully and made everybody feel like there's still an answer after all these years of thinking and despairing.
But unfortunately the truth is, if anybody is looking for something really hard now, it's for money, sex and violence. And Tori knows that only by exposing that dark part of life, we can't get to the bright part.
MrMountainshore 1 year ago
@MrMountainshore
This version disgusts me, also the Pip version of "Me and A Gun", but we have to rip off the beautiful surfaces of things to truly realize and accept that it's still possible to change these situations.
MrMountainshore 1 year ago
I love Tori, and she is my absolute favorite, but I also love Neil Young immensely. This is a wretched cover, my least favorite of hers next to "Total Eclipse of the Heart". It's a gentle, contemplative song, and to quote a hater, she did indeed "rape" it. This is violent, angry, and wrong. The sincerity and sadness present in the original have been ripped away, as with any real meaning. I don't know how she interpreted the song lyrics, but it just doesn't work for me.
sickofwaitingtables 1 year ago
I love almost All of her songs and most of her covers, but THIS... I really cringed when I first heard it and every time after.
1Natasya 1 year ago
As Peter Murphy sang Tori "cuts you up and spits you out". I think she is some kind of genius but just not usually my taste and this is just a bad cover.
11xzxzxz 1 year ago
I love Tori, but this cover is horrible...
TomDemian 2 years ago
AMAZING cover by one of the best artists alive.
sheerdrop15 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rubbish. why cant she stick to fuckin up her own songs.
martinbaylor 3 years ago
alex do mean the heart of gold of the song?
your wrong. I think anyway. I dont think your wrong by watching this video, this video is aweful. Any music lover should see her live, its completely different. If you felt the energy in the room that night, i dont think you would think the heart is gone. She is known for changing peoples songs completely. She covered EMIMENS "Stan" from the point of the women in the trunk!
tetrachord 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OH MY GOD. Sacrilege!
strawberryletter22 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
terrible, totaly ruins the heart of the song
alex8039 4 years ago
Well if you knew anything about Tori Amos you'd know that it was from her cover album Strange Little Girls in which she took songs by men and interpreted them from a woman's perspective.
I think it ads a whole new dimension to the song and proves how good a song it is to transition into rock so well.
Also it's a song that no crumby youtube video will do justice to. Had to have been there.
sixthcrusifix 3 years ago 2
Yeah but womens perspective? does that mean you have to take a touching song and make it sound like modern bullcrap? can't women see the meaning of songs or something? the song is about wanting to be a good person, this is just some.. i dunno what to call it.
alex8039 3 years ago
Don't make me laugh.She does a good job here.The woman is a goddamn genius and better than most people in the world at what she doesIn this and in the different thing. Go Tori!
mobbyplay 4 years ago 16
This has been flagged as spam show
Does Tori Amos make it her life goal to ruin every song she covers. Jesus fuck. She's such a good singer but I haven't ever seen her do a cover that didn't blow cock.
hitsua 4 years ago
How about you watch it as if you have never heard the song before. And let what her take of it is soak in. I love the 1996 covers. How much do you actually like her?
PreciousEarthquakes2 4 years ago 6
Fantastic!
Now she just needs to do Happiness is a Warm Gun.
kristalr 4 years ago 3
Thank you, Pip. I really need this. Love the original , but love her take on it even more.
lulyb 4 years ago
oh my g-d finally she sang my favorite song heart of gold. amazing
nehdar 4 years ago 4
Glad to see Tori I mean, Pip.... is back !! YES!
playboyjudas 4 years ago 3
Oh, Shit she is so awesome!
123Ralf 4 years ago 2
that was fantastic!!! the end is awesome.
WendyKike 4 years ago 3
Stunning :) Cant wait until I see her on July 4th!
sitorimon 4 years ago 2
I was at this show to. This was my favorite. We filmed and uploaded almost the exact same video's haha
bethhartweblog 4 years ago
Wow.
robertschrader 4 years ago 2
Killer she is
bumbeez 4 years ago 2
I can't believe it! One of my favorite songs of SLG played live!! I hope she play it in San Diego :)
HernanEvan 4 years ago 2
THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! This is a rarity by far, and this concert has my favorite set list on the tour so far. You rock for posting all these...PLEASE post any more you may have :)
lipglossboost 4 years ago 3
oh my god. amazing. thank you!
safeinmyframe 4 years ago