Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (64)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • I like it. Recording was poor but... I'd like to have you do it again in a studio... :-)

  • bit too fast - but... awesome!

  • Wow....such passion, such love, such talent....it takes no genius to notice you ADORE what you are doing! So amazing! but, since the audio quality isn't the best in this video, i kind of find it a shame it's so fast that some notes and colors are hidden and hard to notice! Nonetheless, awesome job :)

  • theres just something about the sound of a very talented pianist sitting down at the big D!

  • ho chi minh like in vietnam?

  • :)) Did You Guy's knew that she's only

    16 year's old ?? :))

  • O.O Nice xD

  • Its a little too fast and keep to the tempo, it went a little too fast when you repeated the first phrase but other than that, GREAT PERFORMANCE!

  • el microfono esta muy pegado...por eso no se entiende mucha la melodia...

  • Tempo was wrong but otherwise perfect :D

  • I wish I could play as well as you but it does seem too fast - almost a whole 2 minutes shorter than every other rendition of this movement - let the audience enjoy it a little longer and you might be able to put some dynamics back into it.

  • it is played teh tinest bit faster tahn other buts still exactly the same fuckin awesome

  • Well, some people dont repeat the A section.

  • es un video un poco malo, ya que toca a destiempo, a desatono, se equivoca en una octava, bueno varias, casi no se entiende el piano, pero supongo que ella mejorara

  • i recommend u to watch this video

    Beethoven Moonlight Sonata 3rd mov.月光ソナタ3楽章

    just copy the title and search

  • i dont have any sound!

    what the hell!

  • i say(in my opinion) you're a BIT fast... and you need to put more feelings into it.. or is that how you interpret the music? I guess you're still young.. and yea.. but If i was to score you.. i say 90%of technique and 70%of presentation(interpretation)

  • ''65% of presentation''. imo

  • What TECHNIQUE!

  • I love the person falling asleep at 3:35. They are obviously tired of the lack of feeling from the play wondering when Mark Salman will show how its done.

    Grats can play it fast, but can you play it right.

    It took me no where.

  • splendid! but i want more feelings

  • 雑すぎる

  • On your 2:00 left hand octaves, your left hand is so damn loud!!!!

  • I think you did way better then your unsuccessful etude..

  • You're wonderful!

  • She is wonderful, isn't she? Watch the video where she plays the rachmaninoff etude-tableax in a minor. That even more confirm our statements!

  • Kind of like Glen Goulds version. Pretty nice! I would have enjoyed better sound quality though (recorder).

  • i'm fine with this tempo, it's just that she's not ready yet to play it at that speed. Can't you tell it's very blurry? I'm not criticizing.. but practicing slow makes a big difference, kudos

  • how did you make the camera scene swich?

  • There're 2 cameras

  • Why did you not take the repeat?

  • Damn Amazing

    Nice Job

  • u're amazing girl!

  • very good! I'm just starting on this piece....I was looking for a recording to listen too....slow down a little to keep the tempo even though.

  • Me voy a poner a llorar,Que talento que expresion sin duda la proxima Concertista mundial,Alguien sabe que edad tiene????Es increible elnivel de expresion que logra con tan poca edad

    Gracias por compartir

    Pallares Marcos

  • At 1:26 somebody is laughing:P

  • You play so great, I fully admire you, hope you get a great star on the sky.

  • its bad because its too perfect! i LOVE IT!

  • Rhythm in the opening was very sketchy.

  • how old is she on this age?

  • great playing, but your foot is down on the accelerator the whole way through, ease up a little. No racing driver drives in top gear all the time.

  • this was good, but i agree it's a little too fast for my taste. i know it's supposed to be fast but it sounds a little rushed at times. Fast does not always mean good, but this was still pretty outstanding. maybe it would've been better if you went a teeny tad slower and stayed on tempo (when you're supposed to).

  • I have three words for this young musician: far too fast!

  • lol, i totally agree, i can't even hear the double chords at the top of the piano

  • Thank you very much for posting!!!!!!

    love it!!

  • I bet u practice 24 hours a day....But this sounds awful because it s too fast and mechanical.Kempffs mistakes...u need them

  • great job!

  • what style but righthands sound a little less than the left EXCELLENT

  • excellent left hand sounds and dynamics, one of the better performances on youtube, good job!

  • Thanks dear beyond9001!!

  • You are really good at the piano. Here's an admirer.

    Large want to be like you, a teacher at the piano.

    Congratulations! !

  • Dear Iordarudess. Thanks for your gracious comments!!

  • I suggest you to watch Wilhelm Kempff plays Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata mvt. 3 here in Youtube. Take a look at the difference of your tempo to his tempo. He played it 7:33 mins. and you played it 5:07 mins. only!

    It means that you played it fast. And I know your speed is amazing.

  • Thanks Lester. OK. I'll take it into account!

  • It's nice!

    But I think you've done it too fast,

    Can you play it a little bit slower?

    Please don't be mad at me.

    I hope you understand,

    thamks!

    -lester-

  • HAHaHa, Never!! No Problem.

  • Absolutely breath taking speed and wonderful control, I expect we'll be seeing many more great things coming from your way in the future? If I wasn't in the Air Force and living in the UK I'd like to further my abilities in playin the piano... I taught myself the moonlight sonata first movement but that's not a hard piece to play. Good luck to you!

  • Thanks Dear Zach :D

  • nice... very nice... specially when it ocmes to me loving moonlight sonata...

    you go girl! you must be proud...

    keep it up...

  • Too mant thanks!

  • very good! great talent!

  • :D thanks!

  • Awesome! Five Stars and Favored!

    Do you recall how long it took you to complete this?  I'm working on this less than a month now and so far, it's terrible. lol

    Thanks!

    ;)

  • It took about 3weeks for me to complete it.Thanks . .

  • on 3 wks? omg!  most people say six months to a year. you must be a genius of some kind.

    ;)

    very nicely done. very professional.

  • Many thanks!

  • woohaa! great!! amazing speed and control

  • Thanks my friends loves2listen!

  • Congrats on your great performace. I enjoyed all of your videos.

  • Thanks for your kind comments!!

  • Very nice playing, you truly are amazing, and so beautiful in that white dress you look like an angel.

  • Thanks dear M3sslah!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more