Added: 3 years ago
From: scarabaeidae
Views: 58,777
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (189)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fantastic, Jeronimo!

  • I like.

  • Heh, cute.

  • i really hate the battlestar intro music with the girls singing in the background.

  • @johnTRAN93 The lyrics actually give you a clue into the finale of the series. Look them up at your own peril...

  • As a fan of both series i have to say this is a brilliant mash up!

  • Was anyone else immagining the 10th doctor being the one who planted the idea to start over in Apollo's head? I just prefer that theory to as Caval would say "god"

  • I got chills!

  • Very good. I love both shows, and this is a really good remix.

  • VERY nice job

  • I thought it was awesome mashing up two great shows like that! Good job

  • After it said "They have a plan" I reeeeeeeeeeeeally wanted to hear "EXTERMINATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!"

  • Battlestar OWNS The New Dr Who but the CLASSICS Own the New Battlestar!

  • Holy frak. 

  • idiotic...

  • From someone who loves both of them series: Frakkin' brillant, indeed. :-)

  • :-)))

  • That video was fracking hilarious!

  • fooking brilliant.

  • well done

  • Brilliant, I wish I'd thought of it.

  • Excellent - BBC Producers take note!

  • Brilliant!

  • Good job at combining the two shows.

  • I don't think there's much else to say besides: Win!

  • that was brilliant

  • This seriously rocks. Fantastic as the 9th doctor would say. The 10th would probably go for: brilliant.

  • I would watch this!!!

  • Doctor Who will never be second to BSG. When the fad of BSG runs out, Doctor Who will still be around.

  • WOO THAT WAS AWESOME

    I do prefer BSG to DW of course, but DW comes second...

  • Dr. Who doesn't have a patch on BSG I'm afraid, too many silly and dire episodes (talking of the new Who not the old which was far better and a far better format)

  • yeah, i like DW but its still a kids program.

  • This makes dr who look interesting.Its like putting a mini engine into a Ferrari BSG being the Ferrari of course.....so say we all

  • Love it!

  • Cringed for the first, maybe two, seconds but it is actually brilliant! Would never have believed that would work.

    Thanks!

  • That.  Was. Cool.

  • LOVE IT.

  • this owns!!

  • HOLY SHIT! AWESOME!

  • Why didn't you use the rebellion scene fromt the Genesis of the Daleks?

  • That has to be one of the coolest things I've ever seen!

    Bravo!

    5 stars

  • Surely the line should be "They Have A Master Plan"

  • @Concreteowl no, cause barrowman would be unable to contain his springtime for hitler routine.

  • Nice.

  • First off, great video. Very great editing.

    Secondly, I don't understand why fans of either show feel so compel to go insult each other. As a fan of BOTH shows, I clearly understand that both are written with different themes and ideas. If you can't appreciate each individually, than too bad. There's no need to go and insult one show with the idiotic idea that the other is somehow superior.

    Other than a SciFi background, both are very different. Apples and Oranges.

  • The former German President Johannes Rau once quoted: "A patriot is someone who loves his fatherland - a nationalist is someone who despises the fatherlands of the others."

    You can use that on Sci-Fi-Fans as well.

  • I agree, I happen to love both shows are very well put together and I really think this fan work is simply amazing. Just out of curiosity what did you think of Caprica? I actually have not watched it yet, I was not too happy with the last episode of BSG.

  • I will say that I like both programmes, but I only love DOCTOR WHO. They both have lapses in their story-telling - from time to time - but I forgive DW while I'm less forgiving with BG. But I agree that there's no reason to dump on one series just because one happens to be a fan of another series.

  • I agree, I love both shows too. I don't get the hostility between some fans of the two shows. Can't we all just get along?

  • This really proves that the BSG intro is the best one ever made.

  • Brilliant!

  • wow, that was real awesome!

  • That was one of the best custonm intros I've ever seen.

  • Genius.

  • This is simply one of the greatest things I have ever seen on youtube..... so very rad.... thanks!!!!

  • tennent is to star in a new dr who movie, they are still writing the script at tho mo.

  • I love, love, love this! As a huge DW and BG fan, this is a match made in heaven. I love the BG music, always have, and seeing it paired with my favorite Time Lord does wonders.

  • wow that was incredible. It worked so well, i was really impressed.

  • awesome vid mate, very nice

  • total awesome

  • Still, a well put together vid it has to be said.

  • great

  • this is genius!

  • to me this kinda fits...

  • You don't think the writers considered other costumes ? It was a conscious decision. It all relates to the human psyche and possibly the idea that aspects of the human / cylon memories are stored over generations. It's all pretty much Joseph Campell territory.

    Nothing is identical by the way. Just very familiar.

  • Dude, unless you're going to comment with something along the lines of 'lol that is kewl' "DEATH TO AMERIKKKA!" or "frakfrakfrakfrakfrak", take that shit to a BSG forum, yo.

  • P.S. I didn't call you a retard, pay attention.

    You may want to check with someone for ADHD though.

  • At the end of the day, the new Galactica is thinking mans Sci Fi.

    The old Galactica and Dr Who is sci fi for the lowest common denominator. Kids.

    Apart from the writing being much better, the production value blows it away on every level, photography, editing, acting, music, beats it hands down.

  • There's a lot good about the new BSG, but there's some bad, too, and some good to be said about the old. The original BSG recognised that a whole separate society would NOT wear the same clothes, have the same names etc as one to develop 10000 years later on another planet. Even if somehow the inherent Cylon racial memory stored aspects of colonial civilisation and passed it to us there'd be deviation, not everything is identical except one booze and whether we chop the corners off of books.

  • Of course, the main thing I think that is the difference between Doctor Who and Battlestar Galactica, is that Doctor Who isn't up-its-own-arse conceited and pretentious. Doctor Who does that thing of... oh, what's it called? Entertainment. The whole family can watch, and it's still full of those great adventuresome moments and good quality writing, direction and performance, without being miserable. I was also kind of hoping this would be the original Galactica music, which was excellent!

  • Elitist Faggot much?

    I can watch both DW and BSG. Sucks to be you.

  • Not sure what sexuality has to do with it, but yeah, that was a pretty snotty comment I left wasn't it?

    I think I'd just got fed up with Battlestar Galactica fans running my favourite show down. I don't necessarily take back what I said, but I could have put it across in a bit more of a diplomatic way.

    The "faggot" comment, however, is pretty inexcusable.

    Enjoy your day.

  • thank you from a fellow DW, BSG fan

  • @stevenpw Don't know about old Galactica, but old Doctor Who was definitely *not* sci-fi just for kids. If it's hard sci-fi you're looking for, come back here after seeing Warriors Gate and The Invasion, to just mention two.

  • Religioun was a main theme in the old series, the new series expands on it, it's more a study of Theology. The Cylon faith is based on monotheism, thats intellectual writing the old show didn't have in one single episode.

  • Amazing female characters ? Lol ! They where wooden and one dimensional, conveniantly put in there as love interestests for the male characters. They served no purpose other than to look pretty. The female characters are far deeper in the new show.

    Adama and Roslins relationship is called character development, something the old show didn't have. Baltar is a complex character, much more so than the stereotype bad guy in the old show. He is much more real (human).

  • BTW; Barrowman was just fabulous in, "Shark Attack 3". If ya really want laughs...

  • BSG = Perfection

    Dr Who = Total Shit

  • I'd rather watch Doctor Who than the crap that they've turned Battlestar into

    The only thing I DO wanna do when I watch it is root for the Cylons - sorry folks but when all you want out of a series is for the Bad Guys to hurry up and beat the crap out of the good guys its time to put it away :P

    I mean no offense or disrespect but a show NEEDS more than a woman in a red dress boinking in some guys imagination every twenty minutes

  • I always wondered == if it was so hard to make a cylon detector-- why didn't they just look for the red LEDs in their backs that light up when they fuck?

  • You obviously havn't watched more than two minutes of BSG, which is by far a more intelligent and thought provoking show than the original series and Dr Who put together. Theres a hell of a lot more to it than the said woman in a red dress.

    Theres no good guys and bad guys in BSG, to beat the crap out of anyone, they all shades of grey.

    I mean no offense, but I reckon your probably a 12 year old with ADHD so I'll forgive you for your uneducated comment.

  • Dude, when someone says, "hey, I liked Jar Jar!" do you bother arguing with them. I figure fans of the drwho that's on right now to be either shills (if I were gay, I wouldn't consider drwho to be doing me any favors), or Vicky Pollard types, since it's that chav sort of market that modern day drwho works hard to resonate with, or they're just undiscerning tv nerds. It's pretty retarded, in a word, and when someone sings its praises I know that it's a contrivance, shilling, not a real opinion.

  • Comment removed

  • i was going to tear you a new asshole and leap to dr. who's defense, but then I remembered they cast that emo fucktard as the new doctor. So nevermind.

    (you really are unnecessarily hard on the show though. acting, music, effects, all top-notch)

  • I'm twenty years old

    Grew up on the original battlestar

    Have been watching this series since it came out

    Rooted for them to make something good of it... and got shafted

    My first complaint was that they took AMAZING female characters - threw them away. Taped breasts onto two of the leading male characters and called it a good idea... Athena, Casiopia... NONE of the women in that show were weak - removing them was unneeded.

  • My second complaint was that the cylons are religious morons. Adama is switching opinions (in the first series he was about as close to Roslins worst enemy as possible and then SUDDENLY - after a rather... unique near-death adventure - he's falling in line behind her and turned into the good fairy!

    Baltar is a puss, Six is a bitch, Apollo is mamma's boy... I mean. There is not ONE good character IN the show! Is the point of this series to make you hate EVERYONE?

  • kinda makes you wish the original version was back, right?

  • I do never got in to this new one watch the first 2 esipideos of season 1 that was it

  • And if you meant no offense then calling me a twelve year old with ADHD, a retard and uneducated was completely and totally uncalled for - I was simply expressing my opinion. Doctor Who is something EVERYONE can enjoy - Battlestar is geared to people who want to take lessons on how to rape cylon spies

  • OMG I can't stop laughing.

  • Phph, uh, uhm... what was funny about that? All it did was make me wonder what it would be like if drwho were really that cool. Instead of just a rinky dink gay soft porn weird pop culture worshiping lame arse mutant.

  • What's funny right now, in the "sad sort of funny" way, is that you might reproduce, or might have already done so, you knuckle-dragging australopithecus.

  • ohh! yer such a bITch!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • you can add the BG music to anything and it'll always be awesome

  • liked it :D

  • Marvelous! I totally love it!

  • 2 survivors...

    Lol.

  • Excellent!

    ( OMG! Daleks are Cylons!)

  • Dude. FANTASTIC. You NAILED this! :D

  • I loved it! Wicked brilliant!

  • At least the ending of Dr Who might be a bit more promising than the shamble finale of BSG... Still wonderfully put together. SO SAY WE ALL!

  • I pefer that BSG shambles finale, to any modern Docter Who episode.

  • can someone please send me these songs???

  • A-Frakking-Mazing!!!!! hahahahahahaha

  • Awesome!!!

  • Awesome! Just frakking awesome!

  • made me smile, well done!

  • re: luke9828, ditto! Well done!

  • whats the font?

  • The beginning with the Daleks was SPOT ON! :)

    I have a question- when it said there were two survivors looks for Gallifrey, where did you get the clip of the old man in the Orange Gallifrey clothing and orange domed tower behind him?

  • That clip was from Series 4 Episode 12 where the Doctor is telling Martha and Jack about Gallifrey.

  • You mean Series 3 :-P

  • Yeah, that.

  • haha FANTASTIC! (ha! relation to content!)

  • omg that was kool

  • Freaking Awesome!!!!

  • GREAT!

  • Fantastic! 2 of my favorite shows.

  • That was amazing. Be cool if you could do the same with the BSG season 4 intro.

    Something like 13 Doctors. 10 Are Known. One lives in Secret. Two will be Revealed.

  • That was briliant! I have to admit when it first started, I was a fraid you wouldent give the show, either show for that matter justice, but I was wrong. Well played. That was awsome

  • Dude, you really pulled that off in style, well done :)

  • Oh, that is just brilliant! Absolutely brilliant!

  • BRILLIANT

  • Oh, fantastic!

  • Excellent! Very nicely executed.

  • Love it! Very well done.

  • Loved it, thank you.

  • Excellent work done.

  • LOL, oh I love it. totally awesome!

  • Those two shows could hardly be more different, but that video is pretty frakkin' cool.

  • Okay, you win. This is just too good for words.

  • That's a really nice video, great work ! Thank you for sharing.

  • Oh man, I want to see THAT kind of Doctor Who!!! Serious, strong, fast paced, with Tennant and Simms as main characters. Wouldn't it be wonderful? Thanks! Faved it and gave it five stars.

  • wow. made doctor who look exciting

  • I love it!

  • WOW! that was great! Fantastic job!

  • really really really good

  • that was really awesome! especially the end section.

  • this is great

  • That was fantastic, thanks!

  • Brilliant. There are no other words.

  • That was stunning... as a media teacher I can honestly say A+!

  • *GRINZ* Perfect. Wonderful. I need to get back into watching BSG again ...

  • AMAZING!!!

  • WOW. Just wow. amazing 5 stars.

  • Best two shows on Earth in ONE!?

    Bloody fantasmical : D

  • Oh my god my two favourite shows combined this is frakking awesome! Really beautiful editing job.

  • That was pretty good! Liked it!

  • Love it, love bost shows, awesome.

  • *Both even.

  • Wow I wasn't expecting that!!!!! Nice 6/5

  • out standing...

  • nicely done 5 stars

  • WOW! That was amazing. As a HUGE fan of both shows, WOW!

    You win.

  • That was terrific. Lot of work went into that.

  • Dude! That's great!

    Er, no I mean:

    Mate! That's FANTASTIC!

  • Fabulous! A++

  • Perfect.

  • So Well done...very cool

  • That was really well done, at the start I was wondering if it would just be a meshing of clips, but you've really captured the whole feel of the BSG opening.

  • That was really neat! Well done.

  • That was well done, mate. These two series run back to back on Sci Fi in the US now, and it's sometimes jarring to go from the dead-serious drama of BSG to the zany Britishness of DW. I think you did a good job combining the two.

  • Yeah, I can't really wrap my head around why they put those two shows back-to-back outside of trying to boost ratings. They're so wildly different.

  • That is just awesome! I like both shows, and that just fits despite it being two separate mythologies and shows.

  • That? Was *awesome*.

  • frakin amazing!

    so well done!

  • OMG! Who would have thought that would work? Well...obviously you did, and it totally did! Nicely done :)

  • Fantastic Vid :)

  • EXCELLENT!!!!!!!

  • Awesometastic.

  • fantastic

  • That is brilliant! Gave me goosebumps!

  • amazing

  • Wow better than I anticipated!

  • This is frakkin awesome!

  • wow! very cool

  • I loved that. Battlestar Galactica and Doctor Who are my favorite shows.

  • This is the coolest thing I have ever seen on Youtube!