Added: 8 months ago
From: IGNentertainment
Views: 132,351
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (952)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This game is so fucked up I could take five times the amount of characters that I am allowed just bitching about whats wrong. First of all DS2 was beast I loved that game, but this shit is gotta go. How The fuck and why the fuck is there fucking guns in a sword game and at that how the hell are there guns in a story line that is apperently past fucking tense I didn't see guns in 2 or 1. Also another thing is you cant design your characters and the choses are retarded they have no eyes aghhh.

  • nevermind then lol

  • This or marvel ultimate alliance?

  • and the first one was so great :(

  • That's a shame.... Dungeon Siege 1 and 2 were absolutly amazing! But this... this doesn't look that great.

  • @BigFreakingCacodemon Its not. Having played DS1&2 myself, 3 sucks majorly. Which is what happens when they take what was a PC only game and have to dumb it down for console gamers.

  • this looks kinda bad

    

  • here's hoping that Diablo 3 will not turn out like this

  • When I first heard about DS3 I was like : OMG OMG soooo cool. But then i cryied for days. They ruined the game of my life.

  • @MrEstador LMFAO! same with me :(

  • @MrEstador first world problems ROFL

  • I got this for christmas, An I haven't even taking it out of it's packiging yet.... :L

  • ruined yet another great game...

  • This game pretty much took a major dump on the entire Dungeon Siege Fanbase. "Hey let's take everything that was good about the original game...the squad-based team control and intensity and complexity of combat that made it unique...and completely destroy it to copy recently successful releases."

  • My brother bought this and the new Jurassic park game..... he has no taste in video-games

  • @killshotgamer he actually paid money for that Jurassic Park dribble? good lord, you really must educate your brother about video games dude.

  • @killshotgamer If he likes the games then why say anything about it. He does have taste, they are his own tastes. If he did like them or find them interesting to buy then why say he has not taste just because you don't share his interests.

  • Just throwing it out their I never played DS 2 but I loved the FUCK out of the first one, and the third one seems to be lacking in every way in comparison to the first. Also on a personal note villians that you "kill" in a cutscene, that's sort of how you say "Fuck your mother!" If this little shit has be trying to kill me for the whole fucking story, you can be damn sure by the end of it I want to run her through with a rusty flagpole and wave her around a little, just saying.

  • Seems like a Dragon Age clone to me.

  • i played this game windowed while watching movies on my computer lol so dont even know if i liked it or not :\

  • I dont understand why is this game shitted on so much. Honestly, I just got it, Played it for few hours and Honestly it is entertaining. Its definatelly NOT the best game, but Hell, Its hella fun. I'd say play it if you get a chance.

  • This "game" is a piece of shit. I installed then uninstalled in the same hour; the dialogue was boring, combat too repetitive, and the gameplay way too linear . I don't even know why they rate this M, i'd bet a 3-year-old could go through this junk easy. IGN review is 100% accurate for this one

  • @whatupmygoon You play the first two at all? I know this one is lame but the others are better.

  • just bought it for £15 at currys ( dont ask why i was there )

    i would recomend it if you like third person free roam killers! i just like free roam though

  • @browndog388 I hope you're not talking about dungeon siege 3.. because the pc version was on sale for 5 dollars a few days ago :\ ... since you said free roaming, I don't think you're talking about Dungeon siege 3 :)

  • IGN ripped this game a new one, ouch :S

    *cancels ds3 purchase*

  • got it for $5 on Amazon lol

  • @capucchan8 oh lol same .. got 5 hours in so it's worth it :D

  • This Game Sucks for PC Gamers

  • @TommyNockersx3 It's plain shit on whatever platform. I liked the original Dungeon Siege and even Space Siege, but this is a bland, generic borefest. I paid £4 for it, and still feel ripped off!

  • obsidian fucked this game up so bad!!

  • I saw a BF3 commerical that claimed BF3 had the BEST story... lol

  • Bought this game today only because it was £2.50! Nice cheap game to add to the collection. Lol

  • boring loot is definatley a killer

  • came here to learn about south park game :)

  • I played this game in 1080p and it looked the same as in standard definition, other than that great game. reminded me of baldurs gate

  • @CyclonicDeath something tells me you didn't play baldurs gate.. This game is about as far as you can get from baldurs gate for an rpg..

  • dull story?...DULL STORY?! i find it extremely intresting. And yes ive beat it.

  • Steam sale!

  • they gave this a 6.5 even though they did not like it!?

    WHAT THE HELL IGN!?

    PULL YOUR GOD DAMN ACT TOGETHER!

  • can u play multiplayer on same screen?

  • I just finished this game as fire form anjali. It isn't the best game, but the grahics are good, everything dialog is dubbed, the outcomes of the story depend on your choices in game. I loved it. I got addicted to it. So don't let this review stop you from getting this game because it's definitely worth a try.

  • Shame. I heard it was good. Maybe Dark Souls will be better.

  • the gameplay and graphics are ok, but any other things sucks.

  • this review was good

    sarcasm ftw

  • ok , i played Dungeon Hunter alliance in psn . I liked that game , but can someone tell me if this one like Dungeon hunter alliance or even better ?? , i really don't care about the graphics & stuff , I care about the gameplay & stuff , specially online

  • first one was fantastic. this game is nothing like the first

  • Game companies should stop letting Obsidian do their sequels.

  • @dyldragon1 Fallout: New vegas was 10 times better than Fallout 3

  • @Lius525 lol true i got addicted to fallout nv but not on fallout 3 for some reason

  • Dungeon Rainbow 3.

  • i absolutely loved ds2, but ds3 is shitty :(

  • @robdoubletrouble At least this is better than the Uwe Boll Dungeon Siege movies... UGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHH

  • this game was shallow and boring with hardly any resemblance to the first two, which in my opinion is a major flaw. Maybe I'm addicted to progression, but i liked the fact that you could spend hoouuurrss leveling all of your toon's skills, and the equipment was actually interesting and useful, I mean seriously you changed armor like 3 times in the whole game. There were what, like 4 or 5 skins for each character. Game seemed slapped together and they were just banking on the name selling it.

  • @Nebraska117 i couldn't agree with you more.

  • i thought this review was pretty accurate, i own the game and the combats fun but the story is boring, the camera sucks, and the loots also boring.

  • hey lets all hate the ign videos and watch their videos so they actually make revenue in this torrent of reviews and hate

  • accurate review. I deleted it after 3 hours cause it gets boring real fast, the bland bad guys is the most telling. boring dialogues.

  • leveling starts to lose its appeal at the end of the game....

    so its an rpg?

  • partty babyz 7.5, Dungeon Siege 3 6.5

    LMFAO IGN

  • this game is way to shallow

  • 50% off on Steam

  • At all the IGN reviews i see fanboys spamming that IGN give high score only to COD. Well I just watched 5 reviews of them and thats the one that got the lowest score. You enjoy the game, ok, but IGN give you real information, you may not have problem with the issues the reviewer said, but they are problems and some like me prefer to know about them before buying a game. In your opinion every game is fun, super cool, but we give money for them so we want to know all the good/bad sides!

  • @kartofawe

    You're the only person here who is actually logical. These stupid babies need to shut the fuck up and accept that bias exists and other people might not share their opinions.

  • @kartofawe what?? i cant even understand what youre saying. cod blows and ign loves cod

  • @kartofawe I know. Not to mention everyone said "They gave BF3 a 9, so COD with be a 10" I just laughed when I saw the review for MW3 "9.0" I just thought it was like a slap to the face to the IGN haters.

  • @kartofawe What the fuck did you just say?

  • I dont use IGN for reviews I watch the trailer...search for a IGN ''review'' and watch it so i get an idea what the game looks like... so... It just gives me basic info

  • Hmm, I've played this for a while now and I find it really enjoyable.

    Sure some things could have been better, but it's still a fun game if you like dungeon crawlers - and I do!

  • played for 30 min and uninstalled

  • worst RPG sequel of the history. why? Example: i played DS 2 for years.. never beat it in hardes diff yet, couse i play diferent builds, diferent chars, in party and alone.. the is so much game inside ds2..... then we got DS 3 i installed it , play it for 8 hours then uninstalled and start to play ds2 again. You can't compare 8 boring hours with 5 or 6 years of fun.

  • The best thing about Diablo 2 was the complex skill tree systems. Why do the recent "Siege" games all suffer from scaled back customization? That's SO crucial to making a Dungeon Crawler replayable.

  • @XinBiDe Because they are trying to go after a more general audience to make more money. As a result there are less and less worth while rpgs coming out.

  • Dungeon Siege 1 was the best out of the entire series for me, this game doesn't feel anything like the first game which is what I loved about the first game.

    But I guess that's just my opinion

  • @SamNukem i like your opinion

  • LOL somebody defending IGN? I've never even seen that before...But seriously IGN does suck.

  • Comment removed

  • can you play this 2 player offline? and if so, how?

  • torrented this game to see if it's worth "supporting the producers".

    Conclusion, producers can SUCK IT !

    I'm not paying those greedy fucks 60$ for this...REJECT. Whatever the fuck this thing is stop calling it a Dungeon Siege sequel, it's not, it just ISN'T !

  • I read Obsidian and that was enough for me screw those guys they can't make a bug free game if their lives depended on it.

  • This game is fun in 2 player local co op, me an my mate both really enjoyed it!

  • worst game i have ever played, glad it was free.

  • @BethesdaModder Coming from the fucking idiot who watched this review. You're just another "IGN sucks" bandwagoner. They don't give a game you like a good review, and so you hate them. God forbid their opinions conflict with yours, your majesty.

  • @SteelerEagleFan pwn'd

  • @BethesdaModder Yeah IGN can go to hell.

  • @BethesdaModder IKR? I just got DS3 and I'm enjoying it.

  • @BethesdaModder Lol,I just watch the gameplay. :P

  • @BethesdaModder so dont believe there facts?

  • @Darkfang2u2 nope, all ign is good for is release dates, previews and such. NOT for reviews.

  • @BethesdaModder dude if you even knew half of what your talking about than you would know that their not the ones full of shit but you are so sincerly fuck off

  • @BrainBucket78 i actually agree with this, people don't understand that reviews reflect the people who reviews them not the public.

  • @BethesdaModder damn well then which is the best review site

  • @billiam837 PCgamer.com

  • this game was so bad in so many ways lol...what were they thinking? Talk about dropping the ball..

  • I'll get this game for free if i buy my nvidia geforce. If it's free, would it be worth it..?

  • @thecadaver33 If you went for AMD HD cards, could have gotten Shogun Total war 2 for free. Too bad its ended. If worth it because is free, but AMD just has better free games to offer :P.

  • All I was expecting was some classic Gauntlet style gameplay, and that's pretty much what I got. Not getting to keep your XP and stuff during online matches sucks, though. Good thing the people I'll mostly being playing this with won't mind so much.

  • friendly advice ..

    DON'T buy it ... its very short game .. omg i can't believe that i spent that money on 15 hours game ..

    and D2 was WAY better

  • I have to say this game is pretty awesome but I can't really say otherwise only because i only play it when my friend is over and we offline co-op it.....ive never actually played it alone so....maybe ign is right on this one...i never even tried online xD.

  • @Hyperbladex7 i do have a friend who is playing i think i will try it thanks by the way

  • this game reminds me of wow a little bit

  • i very much enjoyed this game. the story was fine and i feel that not every game needs a branching dialogue tree to make me feel like what I said mattered. This game was fun for me since I enjoy games where you take on rediculous odds and travel to unique areas to fight more crazy enemies. Agreed that at the middle there was some fall off and i felt a bit bored but it picks up fairly quickly when you are hitting things with your biggest stick. :P

  • @rogoth1 Did you play Co-op? What would you rate it?

  • is this game worth it or not ???

  • @Lastat1011 if u got a friend to play it with hell yea other wise i dont think so ._. btw PUT IT ON HARDCORE other wise its pretty boring...

  • No wonder nVidia is giving this game away for free

  • im glad i got infamous 2 instead of this.

  • But I liked the Boring Story!

  • Dungeon Siege 1 = Innovative hack 'n' slash, on par with Diablo.

    Dungeon SIege 2 = An incredibly fun sequel worthy of the title.

    Dungeon Siege: TOA = A fun yet simplified Button-Mash DS.

    Dungeon Siege 3 = WTF IS THIS SHIT?!

  • You know a non shooter isn't that great when people agree with IGN....

  • I played the demo...and well not gonna buy it

  • crap review

    this loser knows nothing about Dungeon Siege

  • obsidian will probably crash and burn by the end of the year lol XD

  • I give it a 4.5/10. Character creation is extremely limited, and there is nothing you can do to make him stand out. It's just... Bland. Dungeon Siege II is one of the best games I ever played. This game is just horribad.

  • Meh I got it for free

  • I bought the game

    installed

    tried it

    watched this review

    uninstalled the game

    Sold it

  • I guess obsidian didn't feel like paying IGN for a good review.

  • This game is a fucking disgrace to the Dungeon Siege title

  • Basically, IGN weren't bribed for this review so they gave it a 6.5

  • this is an ok game, you'll either like it or hate it i think

  • i haven`t played any of the dungeon siege games i will like to play one but this one look like its bad which one you recomend me?????? =)

  • @rainbowNickk Dude i recomend dungeon siege 2 and the expansion for it...i was like addicted to fuck monsters up and slash the shit out of people...go get it! :D

  • @rainbowNickk If you like how this game plays check out the Diablo series.

    (Diable I & II are out already, check out the trailer & Beta for Diablo III)

    You wont be disappointed :) I loved both of them and so do millions of other people, both of them are very expansive and the third game will be even better (coming out next year)

  • no new game + ..? no new game + ??\\.. nooooooooooooooooo neeeeeeeeeeeeewwwwwwwwww gggggaammmmmmmmeeeeeeeeeeeee + ??%%!!? ............. wii that sucks

  • the next disappointment after this will be DMC fake.

  • I c an ensure all who are thinking about buying this game - DONT! please believe me, this is the worst and most dissapointing game ive ever played actually.. sorry but, trust me.

  • i didnt play the 1st or 2nd ones but i quite liked this i agree that it does get broing levelling up and all the items and stuff but apart from the start i quite liked the storyline the only thing that pissed me off is there isnt like a free roam to do side quests and things when you beat the game

  • i loved kotor 2 so im not gonna say obsidian got that wrong

  • I didn't like this game at all. and instead I bought Dungeon Hunter: Alliance for 12 £ and I gotta say, that game's awesome, so simple yet so fun to play and brutal. The best choice I've made

  • obsidian screws up every franchise, falllout franchise, star wars franchise, dungeon siege franchise.

  • I really wish dungeon siege 3 was more like 2. The main thing that brought me down is that you cant make your own character and have to pick between four premade characters. Also you cant choose what skill tree you want to go with like the last game.

  • FUCK YOU OBSIDIAN! you ruined my favorite franchise!!!!

    dungeon siege 1 simple yet realy fun played twice trough the game

    dungeon siege 2 was the best over 10 played to the end with various guys

    and every time i play with my friends in the online option it feels 10000 times more fun what i wanted from ds3 was a similar game bigger and more stuff more key things to the game to me this felt like a shitty version of dragon age cuz of the talking in ds2 the talking was more faster and fun

  • So Obsidian fucks up yet another franchise

  • @Noodells Are you saying that Obsidian fucked up Neverwinter Nights as well? Lmfao Fucking fan boys!

  • @killdude74 You do know that Fable 3 is a completely different type of game? So any Normal person wouldnt compare Dungeon siege to Fable, it'd need to be another hack'n slash.

  • compared with something like fable 3 dungeon siege stands no chance

  • @killdude74 u trollin' ?

  • Why am i not surprised? Obsidian does the worst job at making games, they ruined Fallout New Vegas, KOTOR 2 was pretty much garbage and now they fucked up Dungeon Siege.

  • @SinSophie Not to be mean in anyway at all :) but your spelling is crap through and through..... You spell bOught not bAught.

  • when i buy a new graphics card off new egg i get this game for free as a coupon...i might burn it though

  • DO NOT BUY THIS GAME IT"S GARBAGE..if you already baught it fn sell it lol or return it --crap through and through

  • This is A very FUN game...you just got to play it to understand it

    But please play it online....

    if you play it alone you are gonna feel like you are in a DEAD FANTASY WORLD with zombie characters

  • Just been reading some of the comments on here...Guys, relax.

  • Fuck YOU Ign, You Biased Pricks!Fuck you, AND NO Outland is NOT THE Best PSN Title! LMFAO! Fucking Fag/Fanboys! LMFAO!

  • If this game were called Call of Duty it would have gotten a 10.5! Fucking Fan Boys.!

  • @deeppurple28 Dude, I fucking hate Call of Duty. I play mostly rpgs and dungeon crawlers (Elder Scrolls, Diablo, Torchlight, the previous Dungeon Sieges, Fallout series, Mass Effect, etc.) and I thought this was a crappy game.

  • @BaneOfLannister Fuck these Ign Fag/Fanboys! Those cunts over at Ign can't stop sucking Black Ops' Cock! Why didn't they mention that Dungeon Siege 3 is an Incredibly simple game to pick up and play even for the most Hardcore RPG Veterans? Diablo 2 is The Master of its kind, Its on my top list of games, yet I still managed to enjoy Dungeon Siege 3! LMFAO, Fucking fanboys are a Joke!

  • @deeppurple28 Wow...that was mature. As an rpg veteran, Dungeon Siege is a crappy, dumbed down version of it's predecessors. Grow up kid and present valid complaints about the review. Fanboy moron.

  • @BaneOfLannister Valid complaints? You truly are the load that bitch you call mom should have swallowed! How bout these retarded faggot ass Ign Fanboys pull their head out of their ass and stop picking at only all the flaws of a game! Fuck those retards, what about the fact that the game is simple and Incredibly fucking Easy to pick up and play for even the most hardcore and Casual RPG Gamers? Stupid Fucks, LMFAO! Fuck you Ign, and NO Shatter is NOT The Best PSN Game! LMFAO Fucking Fanboys.!

  • @BaneOfLannister LMFAO! Fucking Fanboy Retards! Fuck you and Fuck these Ign TWATS! This Ign Fag/Fanboy claims that picking up loot in the game results in you feeling like you are collecting trash, yet those other rejects at Gamestop claim that the Loot is incredibly well Balanced and that it keeps you coming back for more! LMFAO! Fucking Retards! This game is getting Incredibly Mixed reviews. Who do I Believe? LMFAO! Fucking Fanboys!

  • @deeppurple28 Wow. Somebody needs a hug and his nap.

  • @BaneOfLannister Fuck these Ign Fag/Fanboys! Gameinformer gave this game a FAR Better Review than what these cunts gave it! LMFAO!

  • @deeppurple28 Dude, relax. I get it. No need to be an obnoxious, overaggressive child about it. You're starting to sound like a broken record and more than a little stupid. I hope to god not all the fans of the game come across like you.  That alone will give the game a bad rep.

  • Dungeon Siege 2 was better imo

  • fuck you ya lil ign wainstain, this game rocks

  • Does anybody have this glitch happen to them: when in the mines talking to the queen for the first time it press R1 (ps3) to talk and instead the screen goes black for a second and nothing happens, I've had it happen before as my 2nd playthrough as the fire girl and I just saved and re-loaded it and it was fine, but now for my 3rd time as the sword guy the glitch doesn't go away at all, I can't continue the game cause it

  • I think this is a very good game. So far I'm about half way through it and loving it. The story is good and the combat is really fun. It makes the Fable games look like crap.

  • why does IGN always talk only about the bad points in games, they glance over ALL the good part and only think about the bad one, and there for giving it a bad score, even if its a ok game!

  • @AURORAZ99 To objectively review anything, you have to see the good and the bad. If a game has too many things that gets in the way of you enjoying it, you don't say "But hey! the spells had really pretty lights!"... Some people pay less attention to flaws, but IGN doesn't. I think it makes them more objective, and that's what you should expect from a review. Not every game is good, but you may as well enjoy a bad game. That doesn't make you a bad gamer, nor makes them bad reviewers.

  • @AURORAZ99

    I want you to skip to 3:18 and tell me what it says under the 6.5.

    It says "ok".

    6.5 is not a bad score.

    I played the demo, and personally i think that a 6.5 is generous.

  • I'm a big DS fan and I am disappointed by this game. You're better off playing ds 2 on veteran or elite.

  • DS3 Sucks ass.

    DS2 is great.

    DS1 is the best. game. ever.

  • I'm getting it free. Thanks, nVidia!

  • I miss simple psx games...

  • Sorry but its not Dungeon Siege, play Dungeon Siege1&2 and you will understand why.

  • I think ign makes alot of good games that are god sound horrible most of their reviews suck.

  • @krazedblade Go to gametrailers. That's where you get the best reviews.

  • im sorry but im with ign on this one

  • @xXxValleyKidxXx Sorry but I'm with Gameinformer Magazine on this one!