Added: 6 months ago
From: DontFearTheReaper1
Views: 43,611
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (602)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you r right i saw it but i didn't want to say anything cuz people might think i'm a freak but way to go man i subscribed !!!

  • Altair, Ezio and Connor

  • You mentioned that you spent TWO friggin hours trying to clear that up!! You sir are a dedicated fan and i therefore salute you!! The gaming world needs more people like you in it!! :D

  • Dude, you just talk way too much for getting across this simple message.

  • oh wow dude you really did a good job on finding this thanks man for the info :)

  • I think it's like this

    The greeting = Minerva (AC II)

    The warning = Juno (AC Brotherhood)

    The revelation = Jupiter (AC Revelation)

    because think about it, Minerva comes and it's the first time so The greeting

    Juno comes and she warns us - it's the warning :D

    and then comes Jupiter and that's the revelation

  • Three lives toiled: Altair, Ezio, and the guy during the American Revolution in the next one.

    Three lives lost: Lucy, Maria, and a loved one from AC3

    Three Messages -

    The Greeting:Altair (Starting the story)

    The Warning: Ezio (The Prophet)

    The Revelation: The guy from AC3

    Just my theory! :D

  • okey everything is fine but I Can't Understand one thing please read my comment and answer if you can... If In AC Brotherhood when you are finding at the end of the game the apple of aden (by Desmond) In a misterious Location but we know from AC Revelations that Altair is leaving apple in masyaf and when Ezio is finding that he leavs that apple in that place too... so can enybody explane me how the fuck did Desmond find it in that Location if it was in Masyaf... I Hope you understand what I mean

  • @TheDownfan in ac1 listen closely to the doc. he says that abstergo only has ONE apple. but there is more than one. there are 72 thats why lucy shan and bec were obsessed with 72

  • @uranuslolman

    There are only 3 apples... And to explain the reason - Ezio retreieved the apple from Altair in revelations, then he put it back in Rome where Desmond would find it.

    Make sense now? Think more in a timeline.

  • @mastersamuss ive read on acwiki that theres 72

  • @uranuslolman Thanks For Explain and Happy New Assassin'S CreeD III

  • its true I wrote Three lives toiled. Three lives lost.

    Three messages delivered : The greeting,The warning, the revelation, I pressed ENCODE and this came out 54 68 72 65 65 20 6c 69 76 65 73 20 74 6f 69 6c 65 64 2e 20 54 68 72 65 65 20 6c 69 76 65 73 20 6c 6f 73 74 2e 0d 0a 54 68 72 65 65 20 6d 65 73 73 61 67 65 73 20 64 65 6c 69 76 65 72 65 64 20 3a 20 54 68 65 20 67 72 65 65 74 69 6e 67 2c 54 68 65 20 77 61 72 6e 69 6e 67 2c 20 74 68 65 20 72 65 76 61 6c 61 74 69 6f 6e

  • 63 6f 6f 6c 20

  • holy shit

  • Maby the girl desmond killed in ACB is the other life

  • I thought ezio had a daughter

  • @gematriagrim666 He did you idiot!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    (watch ac embers)

  • @UnkownTV01 Thats what i said retard

  • Three lives-Ezio, Alatar, and Desmond

    The Greeting-Alatar

    The Warning-Ezio

    The Revelation-Demond

  • and lol three lives toilet f*cking sh*t

  • hey come on i wanna see the video b

  • and in assassins creed 3 thers a new protagist so mabye the three lives toiled is the new protagist who nows

  • At the end of asassins creed revelations it tells how the people of died from the fires and their making a new game in 2012 and its going to be called assassins creed 3 if you dont believe me go to google and look it up

  • In my opinion, this is just a nice reference to the 3 gods/goddesses that we meet in the games. Think about it...3 lives toiled to save civilization (they were all researchers), 3 lives lost (they all died when the sun went nuclear, and 3 messages delivered (they all 3 speak to you in the games with greetings, warnings, and revelations. It seems to suggest the gods speaking to Desmond. I don't think it's as deep as everyone thinks it is. But, that's just my 2 cents on the subject.

  • @Rovue1 That's an excellent point, as in regards to the Ezio trilogy,Minerva speaks to you in ACII, followed by Juno in Brotherhood, then in Revelations Jupiter I believe( i could be mistaken) all reveal the messages.

  • great find!

  • decode this! - 43 68 65 63 6b 20 6f 75 74 20 6d 79 20 63 68 61 6e 6e 65 6c 21 21 20 54 68 61 6e 6b 73

  • Thumbs up if you typed in the search bar:"How to decode Hex Messages"

  • hahahahahahahaha i know already the ending to asassins creed revelations

  • Comment removed

  • i think ubisoft is showing the date release for AC3????

  • it could mean ezios dad every one forgets about him being an assassin who died

  • my thought about lucys death is this. if none of those wemon died than Altair/Ezio/Desmond would have all been held back becase if lucy lived then the templars could have held her hostage and then desmond would have failed and no AC3 9/16/12 ( always November why?

  • @kidwolf1996 not always November as its just been released that AC3 will be released in October this year

  • i agree with SangosEvilTwin.

  • Three Lives Toiled: Desmond, Ezio, Altaïr

    Three Lives Lost: Lucy, Cristina, Maria

    Three Messages -

    The Greeting: Altaïr

    The Warning: Ezio

    The Revelation: Desmond

    Desmond's role as the Revelation was pointed out all too clearly in Brotherhood.

  • @SangosEvilTwin I believe that the one in brotherhood was actually a warning, the revelation is what you see at the end of "revelations" the fact that the world is coming to an end just as the previous civilization. And you copied the beginning of this post from me :P just sayin'

  • @nooMeulB0612 re: your last line . . . Really? There's absolutely no way that anyone but you could have thought of this, and everyone else is just following you. Right. You keep on thinking that.

    And as for the other part . . . BH is centered around Ezio, and the very end of Revelations shows Desmond, so . . . what's the ish here?

  • @SangosEvilTwin i completly agree

  • @SangosEvilTwin Yup!

  • @SangosEvilTwin i noticed you left the three messages blank maby its referring to the three of the messages that you can get in the in boxes on ac1 2 or 3 at the computers at least 3 of them were important if you read them all the way through.

  • @SangosEvilTwin actually i believe that the Three Lives Toiled: is Desmond, Ezio & Connor

  • Ok here is my theory Three lives toiled that means the lives of Altair,Ezio and Subject 16.

    Three lives lost thats again Altair,Ezio and Subject 16 they all lost there lives.

    Three messages delivered thats the things that we learnd abaut them three trough the games.

    The greeting thats when we play as Altair there we learn for the first time abaut that all.

    The warning thats when we learn trough Ezio that the world is in danger.

    The revelation thats when we learn what must be done to save the wor

  • it means the message minerva gave to desmond in assasins creed II

  • the 3 toiled...3 lifes spent in the order

    3 lifes lost...3 lifes of a normal lifed changed by the order

    the others are veg but i will do what i can

    3 messages

    the greeting...welcomed into the order

    the warning...the warning of al life spend helping others

    the revelations...that all of there lifes has added up to that moment

  • Comment removed

  • Three lives toiled: Desmond, Altair and Ezio.

    Three lives lost: Lucy, Maria and Cristina.

    The greeting: Ezio is born in AC 2.

    The warning: Ezio knows about it can be the end of the world at Desmond's time.

    The revelation, well.. for that one i must finish revelations first. =(

  • @nooMeulB0612 Three lives lost:Altair,Ezio and Subject 16 becose they all lost there lives.The greeting could be when we for the first time play as Altair and when we lern abaut that all but it could be as you say.The revelation is when Desmond lern how to stop the end of the world.Thats what i think i mean i played revelations and i know how it will end

  • it means the three lives that are focued on Desmond Ezio and Altair now the greeting would be Altair it introduces the first assassins creed the warning would be Ezio because he knows the world will end and the revelation would be Desmond because he is related to Altair and to Ezio and to Subject 16

  • you bleeped it because you didn't want to cuss LOL

  • @SamFraser101 That is one AMASING observation. Well done!

  • Maybe the entire riddle revolves around Ezio, with the Greeting representing his encounter with Minerva in AC2, the Warning representing his interactions with Juno in Brotherhood, and the Revelation representing his encounter with Jupiter in Revelations.

    Plus, there's a chance that the 'three lives lost' are in fact his family, Giovanni, Federico and Pettrucio, who were hanged in AC2.

  • 3RD assassin my guese= DESMOND! I hope that helped uncover the truth

  • The greeting= Assassin's Creed II

    The warning= Assassin's Creed Brotherhood

    The revelation= Assassin's Creed Revelations (duh)

    That's my theory, but i might be wrong.

  • be cool if they had desmond in the city as a assassin

  • good job

  • the Greeting is the first game and the first life. the warning is the second game and the second life. the revelations is the fourth game and the starting of the last life.

  • The Greeting is when he met Minerva in AC2, the Warning was the incident with Juno in Brotherhood and the Relevation was was shown in Relevations by Jupiter. That's my speculation.

  • Ezio isn't a decendent from Altiar guys. The reason desmond is so special is because his mother and father have relations with assasins and what not. That's why he can acess all the memories.

  • @Yourskateteam

    he is a decendent from altair

    how do you think desmond relives altairs life in the animus

  • @mattyzigzag there are not relalted ezio on desmonds dad's side aitair is on his moms side or some thing like that

  • OMG ANOTHER ASSASSIN OMG

  • It's The greeting being Desmond. The warning is Altair and the Revelation Ezio. God it's not hard people.

  • @xXNovaPrinzZXx No. In Assassin's Creed Embers it shows that he only has a daughter and in the novel of Revelations by Oliver Bowden Ezio as 2 daughters. I have beat AC Revelations so I know who Sofia Sartor is. She is a 30 year old woman who marries 52 year old Ezio Auditore da Firenze.

  • @Catssassins12 1 son Marcello and 1 daughter Flavia. Sofia is 35 to Ezio being 52 :)

  • Ezio does not have a son!

    

  • @Catssassins12 He will in AC Revelation he will fall in love in a woman names sofia. Some years later he married sofia and maked two or three kids. I dont now what they are but one of them is boy.

  • @Catssassins12 wikia it he dose

  • @Catssassins12 Read the book he does. He's called Marcello. For some reason he was left out the short film Embers but Sofia and Flavia (his daugher) were in it.

  • i personally think the tree lives are:altair altairs wife and lucy in that order i really have no idea but im a big a.c fan so...

  • oh man i thought ur da vinci's ancestor til i heard that u used a hex program, DARN IT!

  • without (the only way i can put this) nerds this code would never have been revealed. i dont think theres anyone else who has done this congrats man. desmond will be the last part to this story then... shame AC is so good

  • The third life is Desmond.

  • Desmo its been already toiled cuz he has the message, now he has to pass it through his son... desmond and eve's adn. Lucy died cuz he cold get involved with another woman than Eve and in brotherhood subject 16 said:"the sun... YOUR SON..." i think eves adnits the key combined with desmond's

  • three lives toiled = lives that meet the desired  three lives lost = its just the cost of deliver the message three messages delivered = fruit of eden message ( end of the world)

    Desmond its almost finishing his quest, he needs Eve's ADN to do w/e has to be done. He need to have a son (subject 16 ACBro: "the sun...your son"). Eve its the woman in ACR ending.. *i think the sould make a movie*

  • I'm not BEEPing with you. :)

  • i think i figured this out and reply as well

    three lives toiled-altair-ezio-desmond

    three lives lost-minerva-juno-jupiter

    three messages delivered:

    the greeting-minerva

    the warning-juno

    the revelation-jupiter at the end of this game

  • @cedwolf03 why is this not the top comment?

  • The Third Person is... Desmond!

  • So this guy can decode a message that I didnt even see in AC:Revelations, but he cant work out all that its Ezio, Altair and Desmond in "Three lives tolied"? LOLOLOL

  • @RegensDominor

    Its a vague message. The trailer came out before the game.

    Upon playing & finishing the game, the message is still vague. The message could be addressing Altairs wife (who was killed by Altairs old friend), Altairs surviving son, Lucy, or even Subject 16.

    And the big revelation isn't really as big as earth-shattering as "The Truth" from AC:II. It seems more like a re-hash of what we already know from our interactions with Minerva & Juno.

  • @DontFearTheReaper1 Ok fair enough, my apologies. Subject 16 isn't dead though, his mind is trapped in the animus. Yeah the ending of AC:Revelations was basically summing up AC:II, Desmond must find the temples each containing knowledge on a different way to save the earth, the temples need keys to open them - Pieces of Eden, e.g. Ezio opened the vatican vault using the staff and apple.

  • @DontFearTheReaper1 41 77 65 73 6f 6d 65 20 76 69 64 65 6f 20 6d 61 74 65 2e 20 57 65 6c 6c 20 73 70 6f 74 74 65 64

    Decript that :)

  • @MegaSkaro

    Thank you for the compliment!

  • @DontFearTheReaper1 its a riddle not a message

  • @RegensDominor three lives toiled = lives that meet the desired three lives lost = its just the cost of deliver the message  three messages delivered = fruit of eden message ( end of the world)

    Desmond its almost finishing his quest, he needs Eve's ADN to do w/e has to be done. He need to have a son (subject 16 ACBro: "the sun...your son"). Eve its the woman in ACR ending.. *i think the sould make a movie*

  • @RegensDominor You forgot your comma whats so funny about that?

  • Three lives toiled, three lives lost; that's gotta be Altair & Ezio, but it could be either Desmond or Subject 16, because they both toiled & lost, because in ACR (SPOILER) Desmond learns that his mind's fragmented, so that could be a loss, but also 16 died, so that could be it too. Three messages: The Greeting, The Warning, The Revelation; the greeting would obviously be about the first game in which he's introduced or "greeted" to Altair & a piece of eden, the warning would be the two messag

  • i can read it

  • How doyou guys know ezio dies??? I played revelations story and he didn't die just gave up being a assassin and he doesn't have a daughter wtf are u guys talking about

  • @TheTrickLife search for Assassins Creed Embers

    on youtube

  • @TheTrickLife Ezio dies in the short animated film called Assassin's Creed Embers

  • @TheTrickLife Watch Assassin's Creed Embers.

  • Omfg your voice is soooooo annoying!

  • i know this is way off topic but the games with ezio are done :'( he quit being a assassin once he figured out his lifes porpous (it was to deliver messages to desmond thru the animus but back on topic i dont think sub 16 counts as one of the lifes lost

  • I think for the 3 lives lost it might be Subject 16

  • @Sasuke69355 i agree cuz in revalations he says he will never be able to get out unless hes in a diffrent body wich means his life was dumped into animus island wich isint a real place so he basicly died

  • Ezio knows hue desman is and talks to him at the end of the game play it to find out what happens next

  • The Greeting=AC2 to BrotherHood

    The Warning=Brotherhood to Revelation

    The Revelation= Revelation to (Whatever game comes out next

    )

  • @keybladejunkey1 lol fail the greeting is obviously assassins creed 1 cuz thats the first game so

    the greeting - ac1 to ac2

    the warning - ac2 - brotherhood

    the revelation - brotherhood to revelations

    plus it said that 3 mesages delivered that means that they are delivered and it cant be revelations - (next game) cuz that game hasnt been released so the message couldnt be delivered

  • The third life is Desmond, the last Assassin's Creed will be about Desmond, thats the rumour ofc

  • @DontFearTheReaper1 Actually, if you look above your HEX codes, in the video, the ending of each string of text (in example: "source\S17.anima.09082012.QmF­kV2VhdGhlcg=="), got some more hidden treasures. We got a date, and we got a base64 hash (QmFkV2VhdGhlcg==). Example: This would translate to "BadWeather". Go have more fun. :>

  • i think the new assassins creed is going to talk about 21/12/2012

  • Three lives toiled desmond ezio and altair

    three lives lost desmond ezio and altair

    three messages

    the greeting the ones who came before

    the warning minerva at the end of ac2

    the revelation the end of acr

  • SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER

    EZIO IS DEAD KILLED BY A TEMPLAR

    HE HAS A DAUGHTER

    DESMOND IS GOING TO END IT

    OR SHOULD I SAY WILLIAM SON

    AT THE AC REVELATIONS ENDING HE HAS TWO APPLES AND HE IS IN FRONT OFF A CAVE THAT ZEUS SPOKE OFF AS THE END OF THE ROAD

    IT ALL ENDS

    ILL GET BACK

    LIVE BY THE CREED

    NOTHING IS TRUE EVERYTHING IS PERMITTED

  • @jash471 Ezio wasn't killed by a templer

  • im pretty late but ezio has a daughter and only a daugher thats like 10 maybe when ezio dies

  • Your a huge fucking nerd... just saying.

    I came here to see a Secret Message... You showed it to me, Thank you, it's pretty neat, but you also gave me 4 minutes of shit I could care less about. -_-

  • Im guessing its Altair, Ezio, and Desmond or Ezios father, brother, and little brother

  • JUST AMAZING :DDDDDDD !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I believe Desmond is just a Messenger. Someone living his memories just as he did with Altair's/ezio's.

  • The greeting- Altair, the one who first showed us the power of the apple.

    The warning--Ezio, the one that learned the warning. --------------------SPOILER ALERT-------------------------­--------

    The revelations- Desmond returning the apple of Eden the the cave.

  • Good man!

  • imagine if the message said "if you can reed this it means you need to get a life"

    lol xD

  • 54 68 72 65 65 20 6c 69 76 65 73 20 74 6f 69 6c 65 64 2e 20 54 68 72 65 65 20 6c 69 76 65 73 20 6c 6f 73 74 2e 20 54 68 72 65 65 20 6d 65 73 73 61 67 65 73 20 64 65 6c 69 76 65 72 65 64 3a 20 74 68 65 20 67 72 65 65 74 69 6e 67 2c 20 74 68 65 20 77 61 72 6e 69 6e 67 2c 20 74 68 65 20 72 65 76 65 6c 61 74 69 6f 6e 2e from:good guy greg.
  • @tylivalord thanks dude

  • Three lives toiled means the lives of those who came before (Minerva, Juno and Jupiter)

    Three lives lost means the same... they are dead we only see the messages the left...(The ones who came before)

    Three masseges delivered are the messages wich they explain the issue they have and it's solution...(The greeting,The warning,The revelation)

  • @MrPaliotomaro I buy that... that seems the most plausible I've read so far. The whole overarching plot centers on the first civilization characters communicating with the protagonists in an effort to prevent catastrophe and the end of the human race, yada yada. A greeting, a warning, and a revelation to desmond that is the key the salvation of the human race. It would fit with desmond's last words: I know what to do (or something to that effect)

  • dude, the first part of the message may go along with the three protagonists lives. Altair, introducing us to the Assassin's, Ezio who receives warnings of disaster, and then Desmond who receives revelations. However, the message could also be about the three, people who came before. Minerva gave the greeting of the first civilizations existence, Juno gave warnings for Desmond's task, and (spoiler) Jupiter gives revelations. All three are dead and probably have toiled to give the messages.

  • nobody factored in subject 16

  • @benignd01 have you? i don't see how he ties into this

  • @GostProductions it's not as obvious as the others but his life was also toiled and lost just the same. not to mention that because of that a lot more information came to light.

  • So Altair Is the Greating, Ezio Is the Warning & Desmond Is the Revelation Desmond has lived both lives till their end (Altair, & Ezio). So Its Up to desmond to gain lost knowledge From those who came before and so where does that leave the next AssAssin'S Creed With desmond (Possible) Or with another Assassin lock away in Desmond Memories. Well we won't Know till 2012. Merry Xmas To everyone And Have A HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!!!!

  • u r fucking amazing, like how the hell did you find that out! but i did some research and your theory makes so much sense, good job man. :)

  • This guy seriously needs to get a life

  • or the greeting-chuck norris, warning-macgyver, revelation-rambo, what else could it be

  • there a code within the code

  • Guess: Desmonds son is reliving his fathers memories also with an animus and in which, three lives that were toiled are desmond, ezio and altair, who also delivered the three messages in chronological order. altairs memory being the greeting (to this 'world'), ezio's memories being the warning about what is going to happen and desmond the revelation. Also i believe these three lives were also 'lost' since they dedicated there whole life to discovering the truth (Im assuming Desmond dies).

  • can you teach me how to read that code?

  • @turistamen2

    Its HEXIDECIMAL CODE. You can't read it. You'd require a translation program.

    Just google search it. Your bound to find an online translator.

  • Nice. Just wish you had a more epic voice. Then it'd be pure epic, just not kind of.

  • OH, and, um, the third life mentioned could be Lucy... Hmm?

  • This message may be relevant to some people who believe the Assassins and Templars are real. "The Greeting" To me, this may mean the beginning of us (humans), the war, and the Ones Who Came Before. "The Warning" Somehow, this makes me think of Rodrigo Borgia, and Abbas, how he betrays the Order/Brotherhood. "The Revelation" This may be when we all realize that what we've been brought up to believe is all some lie, and also when we fight back.

  • What the Fuck! anyone remember that line form an AC game?

  • the end for revalations is a let down cant talk about it cause i dont wanna spoil it fo others.

  • I wonder about these "god" peeps -were their secret centres to work in the relevant planets? They wud hence survive th sun explosion?

  • Absolutely brilliant! Although I think it relates to th 3 "gods" tryin 2save mankind-who did all 3

  • Which type of code it is the one of the message?

  • you are fucking amazing

  • @3799corey

    Well, I wouldn't go that far, but thank you for the compliment!

  • @DontFearTheReaper1 how about this ..... the greating : is minerva's message at the end of AC2,

    the Warning: is Juno's message at the temple of Juno at the end of ACB (before Desmond kills Lucy)

    the Revelation: is the "promised" revelation by the "third first generation guy" at the end of ACR.

  • @JakeIsProbablyANinja seriously hes just being interested in the game not just randomly playing everything

  • 3 lives toiled: Harry, Ron and Hermione

    3 lives lost: James, Sirius, Lupin

    Greeting: Hagrid at the very start of number 1

    Warning: Voldermort is back (number 4)

    revelation: Snape was actually a good bloke

  • @qwertstar101 you should leave seriously leave this world off assassins

  • @qwertstar101 Requiestcat in pace.

  • Comment removed

  • Three lives toiled - Altair, Ezio and Desmond

    Three lives lost - Altair, Ezio and Desmond (I'm guessing)

    Three messages delivered -

    Greeting - Minerva

    Warning - Juno

    Revelation - Jupiter

  • FOR CRYING OUT LOUD CAN PEOPLE STOP CALLING JUNO FROM BROTHERHOOD MINERVA. IT'S NOT MINERVA YOU FOOLS!! ARGHHHH

  • 3 lives toiled.

    altair, ezio, desmond

    3 lives lost.

    Maria, Christina, Lucy

    Three Mesages delivered: The Greeting, the Warning, the Revelation.

    AC 1- The Greeting (Minerva)

    AC 2/Brotherhood since it falls under AC 2) - The Warning: warning of the fate of our world and the key to stopping that fat. (Juno)

    AC Revelations - The revelation about how the sun flare destroyed the ancient civilization (Jupiter)

    AC 3 end it all.

  • @Arcilios what about CYPHER? that name was mentioned at the end did it mentioned that Desmond was cypher or what?

    

  • @Arcilios I knew the third life was Desmond

  • @Arcilios that's making sence

  • @Arcilios oh you got spot on mate

  • @Arcilios ok so you saying that AC3 will be the final installment? cuz from the looiks of the ending they are at the temple

  • @Arcilios nice one man!

  • @Arcilios your a fucking genius

  • @Arcilios i think the 3 lives toiled are:

    Altair Ezio and Subject 16

  • @Donferike97

    the only reason why i wouldnt include him is becuase 16 was just pretty much there, we never really played as him or saw his full story right? we just know what happened to him while abstergo kept him in the animus.

  • Theory:

    3 messages delivered:

    Greeting: Minerva from AC 2

    Warning: Minerva from Brotherhood

    Revelation: That old dude (was it pluto?) from...well revelation of course

  • Three lives toiled-altair,ezio,desmond

    three lives lost-maria,christana,lucy

    three messages devlivered-altair learning with the apple,ezio was learning about the life before,desmond learns about altair and ezio and the life before

    greeting-altair

    warning-ezio

    revalation-desmond

  • EZIO'S SON IS NOT A NEW CHARACTER!

    It will be Altair's son Darim, who goes to Alexandria. That will probably be the next game, Desmond's new ancestor Darim. That short film with Ezio wasn't even CANON!

  • @MrBlackwings12 The next game will be with Desmond and only Desmond

  • the greeting is ac2 when he was born the warning is when you find the heart of the story between ac2 and ac3 the revalation is ac4 all will be revealed altir and stuff all about ac1 and ac4

  • assassins creed 2, brotherhood, and revelations each had a vault (of sorts) containing a MESSAGE for Desmond through Ezio so there is your 3 messages. 3 lives are Ezio, Desmond, and Altair.....the game is supposed to be about finding a key memory between all three (which it does). The three lost are Maria, Lucy, and Christina.....all women loved by the 3 main characters all lost....(a common trend?) So there is your decoding enjoy

  • Three Lives toiled: It's obviously the three protagonists of the series so far same goees for the three messages. Three lives lost: I think Al Mualim for Altair but for Ezio I can't think of one person since he lost too many people but I'll have to go with Mario, his uncle and for Desmond it's probably Lucy although it's not clear if she's dead or not.