Added: 4 years ago
From: iRonPaulcom
Views: 296,847
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,621)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • People are so fucking stupid.

  • Comment removed

  • I think Ron Paul is saying totally right. Everything has a reason and the reason of 9/11 is their strategies under the name of US defence policies. They have been attacking all over the world since 1950s.

  • Truth is Treason in an Empire of Lies.

    - Ron Paul

  • I like Sir Ron Paul, because he's the only hope, not just for America but for the whole world....

    US President = Deputy Officer of the WORLD Police Department ( WPD )

    Greetings from Pakistan

  • Why is it so hard for some people to empathize?

    

  • It PISSES me off how they twist his words and say that we invited the attack. NO, you fucking idiot Giuliani, THE US GOVERNMENT'S meddling was a large contributing factor. They aren't attacking us because we're free, they're attacking us because we're fucking killing them and occupying their land. Murder somebody's entire family, blow up their home, and then expect them not to get pissed of at whoever is responsible. THAT is absurd. Fuck Giuliani. Ron Paul 2012

  • ....... we have now lost so many more Americans since 9/11 because of undeclared war.....if politicians can be so bold as to denounce another mans thought on liberty on furthering military action with all its forfeits that carry away in the end trails...... following the founders stipulations as the constitution states going to congress and requesting a declaration of war is the only way......why is this so hard for politicians to understand.....

  • South Carolina is the worst

  • "I have never heard that before" Well that becouse you never listen to the rest of the world. Evyone else knows that is the case

  • I'm a New Yorker and in 2007 this was my epiphany moment. Ron Paul cured my ignorance.

  • Giuliani. He was a 9-11 hero. I wanted to see a man of his stature as the US President. Then the whole truth about him and 9-11 unfolded. The truth about this man and the US Govt involvement in 9-11 is too horrible to imagine. Like so much of the population, I bought the propaganda. Hook, line and sinker.

  • Wanna know how Guiliani was a survivor of 911? We'll in his own words he was told to stay clear of building 7 because they were going to "pull it."

    FUCK YOU GUILIANI.

  • FUCK YOU Giuliani!

  • Paul's words have been twisted on this issue. He is NOT blaming Americans for 9/11. Paul is saying that there are consequences to action. The US cannot continue to go around the world and do whatever it wants and not expect consequences of that action. Anger is a common human response to perceived injustice, and revenge is a real response to that anger. Just look at why Hitler started WWII--anger over WWI. The first thing he did was begin to dismantle the Versailles treaty.

  • It saddens me to watch all these idiots applaud Giuliani. I love this country so much and I don't want Ron Paul to lose because their are these retards that do not understand common sense voting. Ron Paul is correct 100% on his foreign policy! Dr. Ron Paul for President 2012!

  • Ron paul is the only normal rational thinking candidate, all other candidates are stupid idiotic dumb moron people

  • Giuliani "As someone who lived through the 9-11 attacks" . LOL.Ok Rudy what part of the WTC were you in? What part of past wars & going to war = more enemies is so hard to understand. I am appalled at how quoting non political intelligence analysis that they attacked because of our intervention is spun around into "are you saying we invited the attacks". I don't 100% agree with Ron. I have deployed and am for limited intelligent intervention not the mass goat rope of prior administrations.

  • Ron Paul is a Mental patient that has been on the loose since the 60's .

  • @TheDuckseason How so?

  • i think the applaud is edited and made louder by fox news

  • When I hear people applauding what that idiot said about 911 I go back to losing hope

    the majority of you Americans are restarted ( not the once supporting Ron paul ) I'm sorry to say that

  • Al-Qaeda wants to kill us for two main reasons. We are friends with Israel (Without us they wouldn't have a country) and we are infidels to their denomination of Islam, or whatever you want to call it.

  • @manxhedghog That's a start. But it isn't that simple. I'm an atheist ex-muslim. Trust me, Islamic culture and society is much more complicated and it cannot be simplified like that. I agree with Ron Paul. Go read history. Read about Guatemala, Jacob Arbenz, Che Guevara. Read about how the Shah of Iran was put in, etc.

  • I have less than 500 characters to put down any amount of knowledge I posses. Osama Bin Laden spit* lead Al-Qaeda and made it transparently clear on their intentions and motives.  Try reading him. I'm talking about Al-Qaeda, not the entire Muslim world.

  • Giuliani: "9/11... 9/11... don't forget about 9/11... terrorists... muslims... 9/11"

  • Giuliani is such a politician. That's the dirtiest word I know.

    Ron Paul's a statesman.

  • Comment removed

  • "Where going to chaaaange the subject, HA, HA, HA". Ignorance is funny. Cant be ignorant anymore when the countries gone to shit.

  • Hes like some kind of a maverick hero. <3

  • @Qyburnator what does maverick mean..?? thank you

  • @MultiJokesMan Maverick means being independant and outcast. A maverick hero would be like Batman.

  • “That there are men in all countries who get their living by war, and by keeping up the quarrels of nations, is as shocking as it is true; but when those who are concerned in the government of a country, make it their study to sow discord and cultivate predjudices between nations, it becomes the more unpardonable.”

    ― Thomas Paine, Rights of Man

  • @MrCrowemagnon beautiful quote. thank you

  • Giuliani is a neo-con, his followed neo-con policies caused American lives sinces after WW2.

  • We invited Pearl Harbor, 9/11, virtually everything...Face it, America is one big giant fuck up and Giuliani, burn in hell fur fag...

  • @XionComrade They knew pearl harbor was going to happen and let it happen just to boost war moral.

  • @XionComrade See thats where you are wrong we didn't invite Pearl harbor we didn't want anything to do with WWII The country was following the same policy then as the policy that Ron Paul supports the Japanese deliberitly attacked us to draw us into the war and what happened we declared war with a clear enemy and we kicked their ass 9/11 was blow back from 50 years of meddling in middle eastern politics we go to war and we don't even know who we're fighting and its been 10 years.

  • God, Giuliani's an idiot. I do hope and pray that Ron Paul is elected. He is, with no doubt in my mind, the man for the presidency.

  • The Iraq War was a travesty, so to hear at the beginning of the video, "Congressman Paul, you are the only one on the stage who opposed the war in iraq" is fantastic.

  • Americans never want to hear that we have done anything wrong.. Ron Paul appealed to logic and reason.. Giuliana appealed to fervent, blind nationalism.. I mean I love America and all, but we are definitely fallible.

  • Rudy's applauders... Baa baa baa!!

  • Why do we believe we can do no wrong? What is wrong with admitting our mistakes and correcting them? The whole "America is number one, everyone else is just jealous because we're awesome" mentality is ridiculous and childish, in my opinion.

  • Dr Paul is a hero

    hes brave to speak the truth against the people who first cheered for the war then against it then voted for obama now hate him

  • Rick Santorum = The New Giuliani.

  • I've read books on this topic and they all agreed with Ron Paul. I don't KNOW the truth, but the explination that Ron Paul gives seems much more plausible than that of Gulliani (who later said that Al-Qeada attacked us because we are free and wealthy or something like that.)

  • I've read books on this topic and they all agreed with Ron Paul. I don't KNOW the truth, but the explination that Ron Paul gives seems much more plausible than that of Gulliani (who later said that Al-Qeada attacked us because we are free and wealthy or something like that.) I mean, c'mon...does anybody really think that people would spend millions (maybe billions) of dollars and build an army to attack a country over jealousy? I'm suprised this wasn't a question post 9/11.

  • "Have you ever read the reasons they attacked us?"

    That audience doesn't like reading.

  • the crowd is even more stupid then Giuliani - and ye FUCK SANTORUM

  • Comment removed

  • Santorum tried this shit again last night. Fucking idiots...

  • FUCK SANTORUM

  • Good luck, Mr. Paul

  • When the fuck will america wake up ? i guess the propaganda being spewed in american media is working . MOST AMERICANS ARE FUCKING SHEEP. DUMB IDIOTIC PATHETIC SHEEP. I SAID MOST NOT ALL . i am ashamed to be an american .

  • that was such an ignorant comment by Giuliani

    wow.

  • Giuliani: "having survived september 11th..." HUH? Survived??? Firemen have said you ran away like a coward before thr plane even hit the building. No fireman has any respect for you. Youre responsible for thr deaths of a good hundred some firefighters you sick bastard.

  • what i loved about this debate was the fact that guiliani's mic was never turned off and you could hear his smug snickering throughout every one of paul's statements. i have never wanted to hit anyone with a hammer more.

  • "We need to look at things from the perspective of if someone did it to us."

    You talk about morality? That's morality! Ron Paul 2012!

  • Not to mention, abraham lincoln, our first republcan president, ended slavery and united the union and confederacy into a single nation.

  • republicans are so bat S*#t crazy now, they won't listen to their only voice of reason in their party

  • Ron Paul 2012

  • Wow, listen to all the retards applaud dipshit Giuliani. Rudy is a scumbag politican. Ron Paul is a true leader with real morals and he knows his stuff.

  • @VGMurders have you seen the ron paul amagin this ??

    lol ..well amagin Ron is the guy we elect on the perpose hell END WAR..

    lol then wen hes president he CHANGE HIS MIND...XP

  • @MultiJokesMan Well there is a significantly lower chance for that too happen than all the other politicians. He's argued the same views for almost 30 years and never voted against what his views unlike every other politician running.

  • Why the hell are we out declaring war on terrorists when we can use the Marques and Reprisal part of the constitution and treat them as criminals?

  • Giuliani is a fucking piece of shit

  • @94Cioppa I spit on his name.

  • @94Cioppa Agreed. If he runs for president in 2012, and gets the nomination, we're fucked.

  • @94Cioppa

    Giuliani is a good person, unlike you

  • @DrWrongPaul lol

  • Ron Paul was never suggesting that the 9/11 attacks were okay in any way, he is simply saying that they could have been prevented.

  • I'm disgusted by the fact that our country is so anti-intellectual that it drowns Giuliani's foolhardy sentiments in applaud, yet condemns Dr. Paul with silence. No wonder we are where we are.

  • @zagat44 Don't be too hard on them. I used to be the same way. People can change, and I believe they have. Before people got so involved online with social media and such, they only knew what they were TOLD about the wars. The CIA's report was not put out there for general consumption. If people realized what our leaders (both parties) have been doing overseas in OUR name, we would all be outraged and we would change the way we vote.

  • @miazagora I hope the rest of the country thinsk like you - congratulations in being awaken

  • Yes, Osama bin Laden and his supporters are (were) angry over our bases in Saudi Arabia, but why? It is because Saudi Arabia is the location of Mecca and Medina, cities bin Laden believed to be on holy land. Since no plot of land is holier than another plot of land, this shows that the root cause of Islamic terrorism is religion. Should we commit cultural suicide (giving up the 1st amendment by censoring satire of Muhammad, for example) to not offend these people? I would say no.

  • @myloxyloto Why should we have bases in Saudi Arabia? We shouldn't. We need to dismantle our bases and bring our troops home from around the world. We need to take care of us.

  • this view count is such bullshit!!!

  • israel guard hinding infomation attack risk of ambassador america /trrorist attack passage for 7 family [built yael german mayor of hertzlia israel ]972 52 3400161

  • Let's see how fast we can get the Likes to 1776!

  • Comment removed

  • No one applauded for Giuliani!!! FOX just played an applause clip. That's why you see no one clapping in the first place!!!!!

  • @elr456 said, "No one applauded for Giuliani!!! FOX just played an applause clip. That's why you see no one clapping in the first place!!!!!"

    That´s it right there. It´s all smoke and mirrors, each one playing the American public for the patsies they think you are. Fox, CNN, CBS, Hollywood, they are all the same buckets of shit.

    But you know what? They are playing into Dr Paul´s hands because his honesty shines through their veil of lies and exposes them for what they are.

  • The worst part of this video? The applause after Giuliani panders and presents that misinformed straw man attack.

  • Giualiani= consumnate liar, neocon, profiteer off of tragedy.

    The NY firefighters and nypd even hate his guts. He turned his back on rescue workers, gave them faulty equipment, and claimed to be a hero for showing up at press conferences. Shameful

  • Why wasn't Giuliani in his fortified command center on 911?

  • Giuliani and all the other sheep are closed-minded tools. We need Ron Paul as our president

  • what a pathetic response. im so offended that we might have to take responsibility for our actions. anyone notice how he looked at the audience after he said that. oldest strategy in the book. Rob is the only one on that stage with any balls, and the only one with any real solutions. he never bullshits around an answer either. he is straight and to the point. he may be our last hope to save this rotting country. if barack hussein obama gets reelected im jumping this sinking ship.

  • Oh yes, let's all make fun of Rudi for being offended by that idiot Paul.

    The man who held New York together when we still were reeling from a few thousand dead, you couldn't walk the streets in Manhattan without breathing in the dust of human remains... that he could deeply offended by the mindlessly stupid it's our own fault argument, is only showing your own ignorance.

    I'm a vet, and frankly Paul's line other than his take on the budget, is cowardly, and rooted in an ignorance of history.

  • @mark81150 but is his answer wrong? has our wars over there made it a safer and more peaceful place for Muslims? call it "collateral damage" if you must, but our policies murder innocent women and children every day. if i killed one of your family members, you would kill me. i hope anyway. ive been in the navy for 4 years so far, and im not so blind to believe that America is so peaceful and diplomatic as they would have us believe. we ARE the bullies of the world.

  • @siegemachine

    "we ARE the bullies of the world."... why are you in the Navy?.. if you truly think that.. you haven't paid attention to the reasons we're there.. we had almost no prescense there at all till Iraq invaded Kuwait, certainly no troops. The ME was a mess from decades of cold war interferrence from the USSR and our need to counter that. afterwards, we were drawing down... then Iraq decided to take advantage of our pulling back, the history is complex, and Paul get's it all wrong.

  • @siegemachine also,.. our goal wasn't to bring make the world a better place for muslims.. any more than the 40's Germany a better place for German's, the Japanese were happily butchering Chinese in mass, they like the current islamic fascists waged war on US... and make plain, they'll go after and kill American's no matter what.

    To say otherwise is ignoring what the muslims themselves say.

    Innocents always die in war, but that isn't our choice, as hard as we work to avoid that.

  • @siegemachine You tell me what we can do and NOT be called a bully just by virtue of the fact we are the only global power left after the USSR fell apart. Even when Clinton was in, and we actively waged an air campaign to save Bosnian muslims from being massacred.. we still we hated by a great many muslim nations and the petty tyrants and their propaganda machines..

    The cop or soldier who pulls a family out of a firefight to save them, will be hated by the murderers going after them.. a given.

  • @siegemachine We will never be loved by half the world, never have been.. even in the 1800's when we were without global reach, the europeans sneered at us as a rival power in the western hemisphere.

    But even when you call us bullies,.. a wrong headed and simplistic view..

    would you feel less a bully if we dumped our high tech so the third world could kill many more of us, could sink your ship at will? Loose the Air Force so more Marines die, more Army? Your guilt is yours,.. not mine.

  • @mark81150 "The third world could kill many more of us." What a repellant "us against the mongrels" world view. News for you, Iran can sink our ships, even our carrier groups. And nice false ultimatum there. The best way to prevent casualties is to never commit them to silly wars of religion and "national interest." Don't compare the imperialist era to now, although the same faults apply. The Spanish American war was waged on a fabrication, US-Mexican war illegal, and the Banana wars unjustified

  • @siegemachine lastly,.. I was a ground combat specialist assigned nuclear weapons security at a Minuteman missile base.

    If we were attacked by the Soviets in a first strike, we would have launched 200 missiles, 3 warheads each at the greater Soviet Union. 600 nukes.. and I sleep fine,. no guilt, not for protecting our own, as we do now. It's necessary, I hate the death, but have no guilt over it. I blame the aggressors here, the Bin Laden's, Iran, they share most of the blame.

    Don't you?

  • @mark81150 bin laden worked for us. he was an informant and middle man. when we killed Saddam over weapons of mass destruction that we "knew were there" that allowed bin ladden to take power. even they admitted after the fact that there were no weapons. we went to war on a lie. Saddam never would have allowed bin laden to surface. who better to make a fall guy than an Islamic extremist. so we are not the terrorist?

  • Respond to this video... we bombed two innocent cities. we occupy almost every country in the world. im sorry your offended that i think we hold some responsibility but i guaranty you that our government has lied to us. i mean the fact that we use depleted uranium shells is bad enough. im sure you think im ignorant but how much have you looked into 9/11? or why all our money is printed by the federal reserve.

  • @mark81150 I'm glad the military made you into a mindless killing apparatus, I feel so ...safe!

  • @mark81150 no it is courageous to take on the media, and gov't

  • Hey Giuliani, the most ridiculous explanation for 9/11 that I ever heard is that they attacked us because we are free! Now go sit in the corner.

  • Giuliani: "If I act indignant, people will rally around me!"

    ...didn't work...

  • Here's my question to the Paulists: By your definitions of non-interventionism, was the land invasion of Japan justified, or should have we allowed the Imperial Dynasty to either remain or communism to take over?

    Further, since Nazi Germany did not attack us directly anymore than Iraq, how do you justify our part in the Allied invasion?

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios Ughh.. Japan attacked the United States. Congress declared war. A land invasion was justified. There's a difference between invasion, overthrow and long-term occupation.

    The United States could have quite easily gone into afghanistan, overthrown the taliban and left within a matter of months. Of course, this wasn't the intent. The intent was a permanent occupation.

  • @roflcopter2006 Then why did we invade Germany? We were not directly attacked by Hitler as we were by the Japanese.

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios Germany, Japan and Italy signed the Tripartite Pact in 1940. As soon as the United States retaliated, the United States was also at war with Germany because under the pact, Germany and Italy were obligated to come the the aid of Japan. It was a less a case of the United States declaring war on Germany, but rather, Germany declaring war on the United States when it refuted to exit the pact following pearl harbour.

  • @roflcopter2006 Awesome reply.

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios Further, that shows exactly why the United States should NOT be involved in pacts such as Nato. That was Nazi Germanys MAJOR downfall. If some eastern block nato member got into a conflict with Russia, the United States would be forced to intervene (unconstitutionally I might add).

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios They declared war on America and were a powerufl of Japan.

  • @jurassicturd3 Yet we were never attacked directly. Paul says Vietnam was a mistake because now we trade with them, but could we not have done the same with the Nazis over time?

    Regardless, our unwillingness to enter the war sooner cost millions of lives due to non-interventionism.

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios They decalred war, a powerful nation declared war that had near free reign on the Atlantic.

  • @jurassicturd3 That's really not good enough. You could use the same argument for Iraq, as it was threatening our oil supply. I seriously doubt Ron Paul would have declared war on Nazi Germany had he been president.

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios Iraq wasn't threatening our oil supply, Germany was allied with a nation that attacked us, they were extremely powerful and a real threat, they were developing atomic weapons.

  • @jurassicturd3 Don't waste your time with this GeekyNinjaStudios guy. He asks the same questions over and over and when provided with facts doesn't have the courtesy to reply. Look below. I showed him the tripartite act as a valid justification for declaring war on Germany and he couldn't respond with anything.

  • @roflcopter2006 That's because you did not respond to the final point I made. Isolationism kept us from engaging the Germans sooner, costing Europe far more than it should have. Of course if you hate Jews or other Europeans that's not a problem, but I believe America's unwillingness to enter into WWII earlier was a critical mistake which we should not look back to with pride. We could have prevented more loss of life, but instead we hid behind Paulist foreign policy under Roosevelt.

  • "al Qaeda is a corrupt multi national financed by the Saudi oligarchy and Pakistani secret police, its a crime family, a fascist cult, not just that it purposedly destroys civilians, using civilian aviation to inflict further death of civilians, but its objective is a stone age society, without music, philosophy, ect" - Chrirstopher Hitchens. It is disgraceful that Paul rationalizes what these people do and who they are and what they want. It is disgraceful he does not want to fight them.

  • I know the Paulists will flame me for this, but 2:57 is the best moment of the video.

  • @TheGeekyNinjaStudios What, you don't think Ron Paul is right? Explain me why he is wrong and how he is wrong and I'll explain why you're wrong.

    ...Slowly

  • giuliani is a zombie, only he feeds off of applause.

  • R[ƎVO˩]UTION 2012

    Moneybomb at Ron Paul 2012 . com !

  • The truth about mr giuliani >>>you tube ..Giuliani Gets Exposed As Fraud by Firefighters

  • how convenient theres no Ron Paul supporters in the audience, just stupid sheeple who dont know what thinking for themselves means.

  • I'm sorry but Americans are at times too patriotic and just believe anything that they do is right. It's not. This is frustrating to watch and that fucking retard who's name I don't want to mention at 2:42 is a wanker. Ron is a good man and talks more sense that the rest of those twats.

  • on another note, who would dare mess with the USA?

    all the nations learned just before the end of WW II just what lengths the u.s. gov will go to after they dropped 2 atom bombs on Japan killing hundreds of thousands of people if not millions including the aftermath, then they have the nerve to use 9/11 in debates like this?

  • yeah the liars always fall back on 9/11 to make them look like there in the right.

    vote for Ron Paul in 2012

  • i cant stand watching this. That applause for Guliani is a prime example of how uniformed the US public is about CIA operations over seas. The covert operations take advantage of the innocent! DID you know we actually HELPED both Saddam and Osama obtain power? But as soon as Osama began to lose to the soviets we turned out backs on his regime and let them be bombarded by airstrikes. And as long as Saddam kept our oil reseves alive, we didnt care how many people he killed! NO WONDER THEY HATE US

  • Paul 2012

  • guliani you NWO tip rat....

    Dr Ron Paul is the truth....2012

  • Sure hope those 275,186 views represent Ron Paul 2012 voters!!!

  • RON PAUL IS RIGHT, FUCK GULIANI!

  • it was not us attacking you open your mind it was an insid job

  • I felt stupid everytime ron paul got on TV and i didn't comprehend anything he was saying about the federal reserve and the economy because he only has a minute or two to explain his position. Found a really good site that cleared it up for me. hmscoop.com. Quick overview of banking and the federal reserve.

  • Fox overlay of applause on top of Giuliani is literally disgusting..,..Completely false

  • @gingerlives It is because people are so patriotic in this country they can't see through the bullshit

  • Comment removed

  • Cont....we gave those weapons to sad dam and then he used them against his neighbors,. Oh and about ww2 the greedy people that own our country made money off both sides of the war..

  • @mysticsimplemind,.. Really do your research, ya ron Paul is for staying out of other countries affairs like, oh ya, we gave th

  • Ron Paul says the same stuff that the US was built upon. Its in the Constitution, its the same beliefs as the founding fathers.

    The US has turned for the worse over the past decades. The "patriotic" Americans believe that they are ALWAYS doing the right thing, that the US is a well respected nation around the world, but hate to burst your bubble, countries fear you, they don't respect you. The US has been using intimidation to bully the smaller countries.

    AMERICANS MUST WAKE UP, vote Ron Paul!

  • Giuliani is a donkey raping shit eater..

  • It all boils down to one thing. What does the CONSTITUTION say about foreign policy?

  • Ron Paul makes a few good points. I'm having trouble though understanding his point about staying out of other countries affairs, and his championing the quote about staying out of NATO, ect ect ......... Our ten years of bombing Iraq had something to do with Iraq invading a sovereign neighbors country (Kuwait) ..... I am guessing that this relates to his comment about us not understanding Middle Eastern affairs. Europe is most likely glad that we didn't understand Hitlers affairs I guess.

  • @MysticSimplicity Yeah, whatever, any good that the Americans did in WW2 has long been out-weighed by all the evil foreign policy decisions since then. How many people were killed in the Holocaust? Just under 6 million. Now look at the Cold War - at least 3 million Vietnamese in Vietnam, more than 3 million in Korea. So between the US and USSR you people are worse than Hitler.