I've been to carter valley & carter fold-beautiful land & beautiful people, they were just singing old songs that they knew from their area-they don't sing stuff like this anymore too much -love this
Superb. I knew country music was done for when CMT published their poll of industry people and performers in Nashville of the top 100 country songs of all time. Not one single Carter Family or Jimmy Rogers song on the list. Nothing from the people who basically invented the genre. But the Dixie Chicks were there...something not right about that...
Couldn't agree more, the ONLY days of country music -- later and contemporary stuff is 90% plastic, botox, collagen, and just plain mediocre. It got cut off from these wonderful, truly ancient roots...
Love this music. A.P., Sara and Maybelle's voices are what I have always called "true", nothing added to try to make it sound better. Wonderful talent, wish there was more of it around!! Most musicians you hear today sound good only in the studio, hear them in person and they just plain suck! Not the Carter's, they have a true, God given talent!!
A P Carter wrote many many what we called Southern Gospel songs today. No one has ever been able to play exactly like Maybelle. She picked with her thumb and strumbed with her other fingers. She had her own style. There is many guitar greats playing there own style. But none like Maybelle.
Sean he may not be a Great Singer but He has a nice Voice. I can Picture myself on board a Southern Passenger train heading through Virginia and this song in the Background.
@mikegilbo I have all nine volumes of "Their Complete Victor Recordings," and A.P. sang lead on quite a number of them—and on "Lonesome for You" (Volume 5: Sunshine in the Shadows, 1931-1932) he sang a duet with his wife. I think he sounded like a sheep.
A.P. is Alvin Pleasant Carter, founder of the original Carter Family, husband of Sara and brother-in-law of Maybelle, composer of and lead singer on "My Clinch Mountain Home." Listen to this song again to hear his baritone voice. He is mostly recognized as a composer and song arranger, not as a great singer.
doesn't come any better
renlewis 1 month ago
it just don`t get any better
junetune1944 3 months ago
Fantastic song I enjoyed listening!
MrDeCorey 10 months ago
I've been to carter valley & carter fold-beautiful land & beautiful people, they were just singing old songs that they knew from their area-they don't sing stuff like this anymore too much -love this
rainharper62 1 year ago
Superb. I knew country music was done for when CMT published their poll of industry people and performers in Nashville of the top 100 country songs of all time. Not one single Carter Family or Jimmy Rogers song on the list. Nothing from the people who basically invented the genre. But the Dixie Chicks were there...something not right about that...
bongojava21 1 year ago
I love these old songs, The best days of country music
mayor621 1 year ago
this is country music
bucaneromax1 2 years ago 2
@bucaneromax1
Couldn't agree more, the ONLY days of country music -- later and contemporary stuff is 90% plastic, botox, collagen, and just plain mediocre. It got cut off from these wonderful, truly ancient roots...
Ampelos69 1 year ago
Pure and unpretentious... the real thing.
camaysar222 2 years ago
Love this music. A.P., Sara and Maybelle's voices are what I have always called "true", nothing added to try to make it sound better. Wonderful talent, wish there was more of it around!! Most musicians you hear today sound good only in the studio, hear them in person and they just plain suck! Not the Carter's, they have a true, God given talent!!
adhelper1 2 years ago 2
Wow! That one gives me goosebumps.
I haven't heard it in years. This is some real down- to-earth country music.
Thank you bigjaw1.
phrakanong 2 years ago
LOL I find it funny that u post this video and u dunno who A.P , but this is a great song - I love it!
georgejonesfan93 2 years ago
A P Carter wrote many many what we called Southern Gospel songs today. No one has ever been able to play exactly like Maybelle. She picked with her thumb and strumbed with her other fingers. She had her own style. There is many guitar greats playing there own style. But none like Maybelle.
dyer47lam73 2 years ago 2
Sean he may not be a Great Singer but He has a nice Voice. I can Picture myself on board a Southern Passenger train heading through Virginia and this song in the Background.
Wehategod 2 years ago
Comment removed
PeterNGloor 2 years ago
Peter someone posted awhile back on here that AP wasn't such a great singer but I said he has a nice voice.
Wehategod 2 years ago
You misunderstand! I said A.P. is a great singer; he just isn't adequately credited as such.
seancoxen 2 years ago
Maybelle played the guitar in the fretted Hawaiian style that was popular at the time, not the dobro.
According to Sara Carter, A.P. wrote this song in 1911 returning from a failed trip for work in Indiana.
SettlersMuseum 3 years ago 2
I think Maybelle contribution to modern guitar and bluegrass technique is highly underrated - Maybelle rocks!
fassifernit 3 years ago 7
This is one of my favorite Carter Family songs. The story and lyrics are great, and Mother Maybelle on a Dorbo really sets this song off.
shinnytops 3 years ago 4
Love it when AP sings lead, usually you only hear him singing bass in the background.
mikegilbo 3 years ago 14
@mikegilbo I have all nine volumes of "Their Complete Victor Recordings," and A.P. sang lead on quite a number of them—and on "Lonesome for You" (Volume 5: Sunshine in the Shadows, 1931-1932) he sang a duet with his wife. I think he sounded like a sheep.
rambam1204 7 months ago
A.P. rocks! For some reason, he has been greatly undervalued as a singer.
seancoxen 3 years ago 16
Who is A.P.?
bigjaw1 3 years ago
A.P. is Alvin Pleasant Carter, founder of the original Carter Family, husband of Sara and brother-in-law of Maybelle, composer of and lead singer on "My Clinch Mountain Home." Listen to this song again to hear his baritone voice. He is mostly recognized as a composer and song arranger, not as a great singer.
seancoxen 3 years ago 5
@bigjaw1 Alvin Pleasant Carter (1891-1960)—known as "Doc"— was Sara's husband.
rambam1204 7 months ago