Added: 3 years ago
From: jennyonbroadway
Views: 46,201
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (204)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • "Not gay? St...still gay." I love the fact that came from a gay female character. Rock on!

  • Comment removed

  • I'm 6'0 and 135 pounds recovering from bulimia and that is kind of triggering

  • GET A REAL HOUSE LOL i adore it too.. :D

  • that bitch is fat lol xD

  • 4:30 - one of the most awkward slapsticks ive ever seen.

  • that guy that went on the date is a total dick.

  • I'm 5'9" and 140lbs... and I have an ED...

    shit. /triggering

  • @vikiwozeya

    Aw, no, that's thin! They say ideal weight is 100 for 5 feet and then another 5lbs for every inch, so yours would be 145lbs. You're thin, I promise! They just picked a random number!

    I'm 138lbs and 5'5" :( (and I have an ED too. I used to be 220lbs)

  • @Sarahrosebello i know, i know, of course. i can even see why they chose this weight/height to just show how messed up their perception is. youre thin, too, lovely (:

  • @vikiwozeya

    Thank you.

    And good luck, I hope you stay safe and eventually find health and happiness.

    Are you from PT?

  • @Sarahrosebello thank you, same goes for you (: no, whats pt?

  • @vikiwozeya

    It's an online eating disorder forum. There was a link to this show posted on there the other day.

  • @Sarahrosebello ohh gotcha.

  • 5 foot 9 and 140lbs is like, slap-bang in the middle of healthy:/

    and their dicks totally touched by association.

  • "still gay" LMAO! loved this show. too bad they cancelled it :(

  • but what a weird way to purge geeze....

  • i have an ED and this is HILARIOUS! love it! i can take humor.

  • remember Anorexics(some) believe that healthy weights are fat.. sigh 5'9 140? THATS FLIPPIN SKINNY!

  • To me 5'9 140 is perfect. Depending on the woman shape. My ex was 5'9 145. And I like her body way better than my ex before her who was 5'9 130

  • she's really cute.... and he's very fuking annoying!!!!!!!!

  • all women would find that offending what he said about her shoes

  • "thats illegal get a real house" lol wowww

  • why they stopped that show!!!!!!!! :'(

    can't we just clame it back?!!

  • why they stopped that show!!!!!!!! :'(

  • geez people this is a show about a bunch of anorexics! u are really being stupid if you believe the 5-9 140 thing, that is a bmi of 20, for me, that means perfect. If you don't look half-dead cuz you're so skinny and malnourished, then anorexics think you're 'fat', and they'll think you're 'weak' for eating anything at all. Do you care what these mentally ill people think about you?

  • wow, at 5'6.5" and 112 saying that 140 5'9" makes me feel obese, lol

  • @gaeilgedreamer dw yr fine - i'm 5''4 and 145 :( feeling like crap!

  • that makes me sad...i'm 5'8" and 135. I know it's dumb to get upset about something a character said on a (short-lived) tv show but it still bothers me.

  • LMAO at 4:30!!

  • 140 is healthy curvy. I'm 5'9" and could never be anything below 140 without taking dangerous measures.

  • I'm 5'8 and 96 pounds so yes 5'9 and 140 IS fat.

  • @SuperModel969 if you're 5'8 and 96 pounds you're not a supermodel

  • @SuperModel969 I sure hope that the 1969 next to your name isn't the year you were born. That would be really scary. To be 41 years old and sounding like a 15-year-old pro ana girl, I'd say you have way more problems than maintaining your skeletal figure.

  • @lonelyheroine actually it's 969 and FYI I'm 14

  • @SuperModel969 5'8" and 96 pounds? LMAO You have no curves whatsoever. Who'd want to fuck that? Maybe a pedophile...

  • NOT TRUE!! I'm 5'6'' and 160...and I'm not fat at all. I'm toned but I'm not like super thin...but deffinitly NOT fat.

  • awesome show Love Laura Benanti

  • I seriously mourned when this show was canceled.

  • They should NOT have scraped this show. It would have helped a lot of people see just how ridiculous dieting really is - it could have actually helped people LOSE weight and not the other way round. Huge shame.

  • i was disappointed when they canceled this. watched it every week.

  • hahahahahahahahahahahahaha

    this show is fuckign amazing omg xDD

  • ahhh i gotta stop watching this.

    its really triggering.

  • i agree..

  • 5"9 140lbs fat??

    isnt that ....normal weight?

  • They have eating disorders. They have skewed body image perceptions.

  • @BeforeTheSilverChain It's fat

  • @BeforeTheSilverChain, Exactly! Not just that, it's lower end of normal (according to BMI). Considering a healthy BMI is anywhere between 18.5 and 25 (for an adult that is), mid-point healthy is therefore 21.75. If you were 5'9'' and 140 pounds your BMI would be less than 20.75. The fact that they call this fat is a representation of how society has a f**ked up idea of what's an acceptable body weight!

  • @SeeWithoutHavingtoGo Agreed. According to wikipedia, the best BMI for a woman (meaning BMI with lowest mortality rates) are between 21 and 23.

  • @BeforeTheSilverChain yes, but keep in mind that these people are anorexic. They think everyone is fat.

  • @BeforeTheSilverChain Very much a normal, healthy and slim weight. BMI 20.7, which is slim, healthy and normal  xxx

  • @BeforeTheSilverChain on the smaller side of normal in fact

  • @BeforeTheSilverChain even skinny!

  • this show is funny,

  • someone please tell me, is this a real show? What IS this! Im interested. I have food problems. Id like a show like this, I think?... Anyone?....

  • i love this show too and it used to be on the air but stupid non-eating disordered ppl thought it would be too offensive so they had it taken off...i was so pissed!!! out of all the shit that is wrong with me, i would come home and be able to laugh my ass off about how horrible it is! it made me happy for an hour.

  • yea, I agree. It is offensive... but good. It lets you laugh at what is painful. Humor makes it easier. I woulda been a follower of the show. too bad:( thanks though for filling me in

  • oh its no problem! glad i could help :)

  • They should have considered those of us that do have these issues.

    IMO, this show is sooo funny. They approached the topic in a very non offensive comical way.

  • i know! just cuz the ppl that ARENT having problems with this is bitching doesnt mean that WE all are too.

    just like if they made a movie about a different serious disease like cancer or something...it might actually be funny to those who have cancer. It could brighten their day because they can relate and laugh about it! which is exactly what i did with this show haha.

  • @casanasie The Big C...........

  • @casanasie 'non-eating disordered ppl' don't exist. I don't know anyone who has a healthy relationship to food. More like too many people didn't like the reminder of how much they relate to these characters. It scared them.

  • wow this first episode is insanely funny......I wonder if this show made it

  • why's this guy so weird about how women look? most of the guys i know aren't nearly that picky

  • lol, get a real house

  • this show is annoying what's the point of it?

  • word,

    the show was good initially but the main character is a real deuch bag.

  • @TRUKNOWLEDGE1 Same as any show on tv, to be entertaining. If you arnt entertained, dont watch it.

  • wow sam is the most annoying and neurotic a** hole ive ever had to suffer through. billie is hilarious tho.

  • okkk she is odd rele odd

  • On reflection, I think I see what may have scared off the execs. I'm trying to recall exactly how many times "Friends" or "The Office" featured onscreen vomiting and I'm thinking it wasn't very often.

  • ironically, I'm bulimic and binging right now.

    this show is great, its funny but unoffensive.

    loving it.

  • lol same here

  • 5'6"/109

  • im 5'10 1/2 and 148 damn after seeing this i feel fat :(

  • well u are not fat...trust me u aren't

  • thank you :) hugs

  • Comment removed

  • this is sick!

  • 5'6"/110 lbs

    GOAL-100lbs

  • we ve dey same goal bt am 5'7:).

  • Love hte part when he pulls over the Asian guy on the bike and steals his food to yak it on the bum! LOL

  • 5'3, 100lbs

    goal- 85lbs hurhur

  • I am 174cm (like 5'9" and a half) and weigh about 140. =( (am a recently recovered bulimic) bad times for me. lol --- I want to diet sooo badly atm!!!!

    does anyone else think 140 and 5'9" is fat? or is that slim? I really dont know what to think atm. -_-

  • 5'9'' and 140 lb.

    Is not fat, it's quite slim. It's on the very low end of healthy. Some ppl would consider it underwt for many body types.

  • That is a beautiful, if slight, figure, and you're in possession of those proportions!

    So be proud of your body :)

  • 140 and 5'9 is not fat, it's a bmi of about 20 - which is slim, healthy but slim. don't diet :)

  • 5'9" and 140 is a beautiful body and healthy too! I got nervous when I heard that statement too because I too, am a former bulimic and am 5'10 (almost 5'11") and at my lowest i was like 138 and EVERYONE was telling me i was WAAAYYY tooo skinny. Like SCARY skinny! Way to go on recovering! Stay strong!!!!!!!!

  • Thank-you very much for the comments. They helped =)

    Hope your all well xxxx

  • I'm 6'0 (i'm a girl) and i weigh like, 135 but my lowest was 115....

    O_o

  • youre fat

  • that sounds underweight, considering your height. and pink2ply was joking btw.

  • 5'7 and 126 lbs...goal was originally 110, but right now its115 - 120 range

  • *pulls out gun* "that's illegal! get a real house!"

    by far, the best scene of part 2=]

  • is 5'0" 110 fat?

    i think it is, what do you?

    my goal weight is 90

    and fyi i'm very cautious about my bulimia and throwing up in public

  • nah thats perfect.:)

  • ha when the bum comes out of the bags of trash, that would happen to me, I have NO PRIVACY when I am purging

  • 5'6" 110

    Goal- 100

  • 5'4, 78 lbs

  • Lol, this is stupid, 5'9 140 is not fat. I'm 5'5 145 and im not fat.

  • five foot one.

    ninety eight pounds (:

  • oh and also. i used to throw up on the canal bank when i'd go running so that it couldn't be heard in my house. yes bulimics do it privately but you also gotta do what you gotta do. even if that means shoving your police baton in your stomach. bulimia is that ugly.

  • 5'4 and 130 lbs. frick. i'm bulimic and just discovered this show. so far so good! altho its making me really wish i could be anorexic and that's not good either : /

  • laura is an amazing actress:) i love her face on "still gay"

  • LMAO I can't believe they did that !

  • of all the characters the cop seems most unbelievable. a real bulimic would never throw up in public like that. they're very shameful and secretive about the behavior.

  • i know right? but they are so just making fun of eating disorders in a way. i'm anorexic myself and i love this show. it gives me a chance to laugh about my problems,....kind of. this is a ridicolulous show but still really funny haha. if you know what i mean?

  • I'm bulimic and trust me, we do it in public and personally I have zero shame about my bulimia!!!

  • 5'3 and 130lbs. Oh shit...

  • me too and in 5 1

  • honestly...i cant stand this show at all.

  • I'm 5'9'' and weigh 140! Now I kinda feel fat...

  • Don't be. Your at a perfect weight.On the lower side of the bmi level. In fact your ideal weight would be 5 pounds more than your weight.

  • Thank you. : )

  • Comment removed

  • why is HE obsessing about HER weight doesn't he have enough problems of his own?!

  • How is the COE/Anorexic guy not gay? He acts gay IDK..

    But seriously when the cop puked on the homeless guy. What a shock!! LOL!

    I think this just became my new favorite show! haha :)

  • I like this programme, its got a strange sense of humour though.

  • omg homeless guy...

    priceless

  • I will be honest, the 5'9 140 comment made me a tad uneasy, Im sure this isnt good for my eating 'issues',but this is so damn hilarious, I cant stop watching :D

  • Ok, so I have had anorexia for 23 yrs now and I really enjoyed this show. Its absolutely horrible and not at all true, but it is so funny to watch! Ed's are not funny, but sometimes you just have to laugh at it!

  • lol...NOW i see why this show would be cancelled-not that it isn't great, I'm loving it- but the comment about 5'9 and 140lbs being 'fat' (which is obviously a farce) probably pissed quite a few people off, seeing as like 60% of americans are overweight. There goes the viewers... =/

  • im like 59 115 or so but i guess it really depends on how you hold it

  • so NOT gay???

    ...STILL gay.

  • 5"9 is a very TALL women so 140 is nothing

    she wud definitely look very thin

    this whole show is a joke in so many ways XD but thats why i like it!

  • ya i'm 5'9" and 135 or 140

    and have had an ED for 5 years

    it's... curvy. 120 is actually underweight

    for 5'9"... and it's my gw. lol

  • its tru but im 5'8 and 105 and still curvy, but it depends on the person as well

  • So ur bulimic?

  • omg a bulimic cop...

  • hahaha im bulimic, and i binged on chinese before i saw this, and that was so fucking funny

  • get help. its not funny.

  • chocolate cake is better

  • No, it sticks to your throat and is a cunt to get out. Chinese food is usually greasy enough to do the work for you.

  • Hey, that's illegal! Get a real house!

  • i couldnt stop laughing

  • this show is so screwed up...love it!!!!!

  • i wish this show was still on

  • this programme is making me watch to purge so badly hahaha

  • God, men are so STUPID. Would you rather have a 5'9" woman that weighs 140 pounds and is HEALTHY or would you rather have a 5'9" woman that is 3 points below their ideal BMI and so sick that they can't even walk right.

  • You have a point. Besides most men don't want a skinny girl. They want a woman whos's not fat or thin. So 5'9 and 140 would definetly be good. I'm a guy, 5'7 and around 115.

  • Bullshit, guys want thin girls and they hate anyone who's not thin. What are you? Gay? How the fuck do you stay at a BMI of 18 if you're bulimic? You're full of shit or you don't eat.

  • Not all guys want thin girls. My current boyfriend of almost 3 years told me he was first attracted to me because of my hips and that I don't look like a little boy, his parents have even told me that he never really did like skinny girls he didn't consider them attractive. I've also met and seen pictures of alot of his ex's and majority of them have big hips.

  • wow you dont know how untrue that is, my fiance is entirely normal works as a probation officer is vanilla in almost every respect in fact, and im overweight andfor some reason he likes it, and i dont, im far more judgemental than he could ever be, i KNOW im fat but for some reason he still loves me, and his ex girlfriends were diff sizes, so your wrong sorry to tell you

  • "Yea.. uh huh... homosexual!"

    Ahh haha, why isn't this show on anymore!?!?

  • "egh I hated her shoes.." lol

  • hahah the police guy crackks mee uppp :D

  • GET A REAL HOUSE

  • haha... this is hilarious... i love this! what is this?

  • hey im 5'7" 118, so ill take what he said about his assisstant a compliment. but i dont think 5'9" 140 is fat, like at all. thats crazy talk

  • Laura Benanti is HILARIOUS! "all of your dicks were basically touching eachother...homosexual..."

  • ugh.

    i'm 6'0" and 140/

    i would hate to see 5'9"

  • i'm five feet three and weigh in about 77 pounds god i still think that's too much:((

  • too little babe :( stay healthy

  • Quit fucking whining to youtube. It's not that cunting sad. If it's too much; lose more, you stupid cunt.

  • Nice purging technique LOL

  • do you have a purging technique?

  • all the bulimics do

  • lol get a real house!

  • hahaha he purged on a homeless person

  • i have wide hips, i guess im fat. but one question to the people with eating disorders; if you have wide hips and a nice ass, does that make you grossly fat in your eyes? lol just wondering.

  • well, keep in mind that many people with eating disorders also have body dysmorphic disorder- they don't see their bodies as they really are. So they could be skin and bones but still think they have wide hips and are fat and stuff, so really, your question can't definitively be answered.

  • You wouldn't have a "nice" ass you'd have a fat ass.

  • "Get a real house!" Hahaha...

  • Heya, my views, and believe me this is correct information, i have a qualification in food and nutrition:

    A woman who is 5''9 and 120 pounds would have a BMI of 17.5. A person's BMI should be between 18 and 25.

    Therefore this idealistic 5'9 120 pounder would be clinically underweight.

    She would most likely be American size 0.Size 2 max.

    I am not saying these men's views are bad or good. They are realistic. A lot of men dont realise how skinny they think the 'perfect woman' is

  • my cw is 120 but im 5'45 and def NOT FAT.

    140 lbs on 5'9 is pretty much the same BMI, about 19,5 and perfectly fine.

    120 lbs on 5'9 would in contrast be a BMI of 16,8 ---> ED!

  • 120 5"45 - 20.3 BMI

    140 5"9 - 20.7 BMI

    Both healthy weights

    120 5"9 - 17.7

    so underweight not anorexic.

    That starts at 17.5

  • yuy, yea .2 points...go you! ::sarcasm:: posting this SHIT about yourself only feeds your fucking disorder. Get some help.

  • what on earth are you on about.

    i didn't post anything about myself. what i was posting was medical fact. so fuck off.

  • who the FUCK are you? I was talkin to YUY...NOT you for posting personal medical info. Fuck off.

  • i'm the same person

  • a BMI of 17.7 is so NOT healthy, and .2 would make like 1lbs, maybe 2? i dont see a difference...

  • i'm not saying that a BMI of 17.7 is healthy. What i'm saying is that medically it is not classed as anorexic, it is classed as under weight.

  • anorexia has nothing to do with how much you weigh, it's about the actual symptoms.

  • Yes thank you i'm fully aware of that. I had an eating disorder for a long time.

    What i was saying was that medically thats when the term anorexia offically starts. I am NOT saying that you can't be anorexic if you're any higher than a certain weight.

  • What do you think people's BMI's should be, 22? Mine's 18. I fuckin hate my body and my life. I'm a bulimic boy.