n.2: Lucid, profound, deep, cloudy and softly perturbed at moments, meditative,lost.Through a nebulous winter lonely night, hovering in space in silence, in exclusion from the exterior, apart from gusts of wind and cold,apart from light and life.
Most enjoyable and very educational. Truecrypt, you do music a great service by your intelligent posting,,and informed comment. Many thanks,,and Best Wishes !
Probably the other way around - Roslavets' music might have some traces of Scriabin influence. You are welcome not to like Richter, but your "by the way" sounds disparagingly.
I watched your video of Thalberg... you play very well. perhaps, you can upload YOUR performance of this Scriabin Etude and show us that you are better than Richter (no kidding).
Wonder what Scriabin would have written had he lived another 30 years (assuming he maintained his creative powers)...in all likelihood he would have run afoul of Stalin, probably composing works more unfathomable than anything by Prokofiev or Shostakovich
She doesn't compare. Technically she's on the same level, but the only pieces she plays are virtuoso works for their flash. I have yet to be moved by a Lisitsa performance. Richter moves me every time.
And you have to take into consideration the fact that technique has progressed significantly these last few decades. Its not difficult to find a 10 year old playing something which was once deemed as impossible for even a professional pianist.
Richter is just amazing. Unfazed by stupid coughing and restless audience during eerily beautiful no. 2.
It is hard to fathom how he manages the speed of no. 1 with the parallel ninths in the right hand! Crystal clear and precise. Unbelievable! He must have had hands and fingers made out of steel and elastic at the same time. Stelastic!
never heard these before. just listened with the music. Astonishing. as 777cc777 says, the finest player of scriabin. I've heard lots of people play, but how he creates and sustains these different layers of sound is beyond me. Each layer has a totally different - tone - quality. Thanks for posting.
we have only the first part of Mysterium,the Prefactory Act,completed by Alexander Nemtin.there is one recording of the Berlin Symphony Orchestra conducted by Ashkenazy.
Fantastic. Thank You Truecrypt to archive all this jewels on YT.
OP.65 n°1 is first of all a question of having hands big enough to be able to play it (Horowitz couldn't and told Richter it was sadly enough not possible for him). What Richter does in op.65 n°3 is pure madness and at the end totally "transfigure" the theme issued from op.65 n°1.
I doubt your comment about Horowitz not having a big enough hands for this. You spread Octave and a semitone. Most people can stretch that and Horowitz did not have small hands!
I have this on LP. He is,I believe the only one of all renowned pianists to attempt to play the very difficult Scriabin etude in NINTHS!!! He was indeed a true virtuoso even at the beginning of his career. BRAVO!!!
Michael Ponti plays it - the question is how renowned do you think he is...I think he plays Scriabin excelently, but sadly his cds (well the ones I have) have the worst piano/sound quality ever - tinny would be an understatement.
Can you give us the reference of that recording ? The third one is so f... awesome !
Thanks
mashcot 2 months ago
n.2: Lucid, profound, deep, cloudy and softly perturbed at moments, meditative,lost.Through a nebulous winter lonely night, hovering in space in silence, in exclusion from the exterior, apart from gusts of wind and cold,apart from light and life.
TheStefanNestor 2 months ago
The 2nd etude is totally unreal with richter
Spudboy41 3 months ago
Comment removed
Spudboy41 3 months ago
Most enjoyable and very educational. Truecrypt, you do music a great service by your intelligent posting,,and informed comment. Many thanks,,and Best Wishes !
Ivanhoe2 8 months ago
I prefer Horowitz in the third etude, but this is still absolutely phenomenal playing!
ggn1234 8 months ago
Oh dear God, the 3rd etude!
antsee 1 year ago
imo, the tempo of the 3rd is too fast
New4785689 1 year ago
What is the painting?
gaystereotype 1 year ago
magnifique ce dernier corpus(1912) ! ; la virtuosité de la premiere et la ferocité de la derniere sied a merveille a Richter tres inspiré
on se rappelle un peu le DEBUSSY des ETUDES mais en plus exalté; Richter la joue comme une sorte de tryptique;..........
44seann 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sounds like another great russian composer : Roslavets. I still don´t like Richter, by the way
henseltetude 2 years ago
Probably the other way around - Roslavets' music might have some traces of Scriabin influence. You are welcome not to like Richter, but your "by the way" sounds disparagingly.
truecrypt 2 years ago
Im sorry, maybe my english is not good enough.
I watched your video of Thalberg... you play very well. perhaps, you can upload YOUR performance of this Scriabin Etude and show us that you are better than Richter (no kidding).
Nice to meet you!
henseltetude 2 years ago
no problem ;) English is not my native language either...
I did play Op. 65, No. 3 but don't think it was up to Richter's level. I humbly accept his superiority.
truecrypt 2 years ago
Who cares?
mishima1974 2 years ago
Wow. I'm shocked I've never even listened to anything by Scriabin. This is amazing and it definitely seems to play a role in the foundation of Jazz.
Kedislol 2 years ago 2
That 3rd etude is so amazing!
Gulzt 2 years ago 9
It almost sounds Cagian, a la John!! Not very settling. It leaves you on the edge of your seat, not easy to listen to.
fcc61 2 years ago
i like the artwork
pianolistenerk 2 years ago 5
This is beyond ordinary music ... it is just phantoms and demons made out of sound, drifting from Scriabin's haunted dreams and into our minds.
cerzule 2 years ago 5
@cerzule couldn't have put it better
gymgymgymgym 1 year ago 2
Straordinario Slava!
nonsolomusicista 2 years ago
Wonder what Scriabin would have written had he lived another 30 years (assuming he maintained his creative powers)...in all likelihood he would have run afoul of Stalin, probably composing works more unfathomable than anything by Prokofiev or Shostakovich
soami2u 3 years ago 3
The first piece is SOOOOO difficult! He makes it seem so easy!! Amazing!
pureaKero 3 years ago
A century will pass by without anyone ever even coming close to his interpretation of these!
scriabinwasmydad 3 years ago
You're right perhaps,but listen Vlentina Lisitsa,and tell me if she isn't a Richter on female!:)almost I think so.
Ellinidara 3 years ago
She doesn't compare. Technically she's on the same level, but the only pieces she plays are virtuoso works for their flash. I have yet to be moved by a Lisitsa performance. Richter moves me every time.
coasterman16 3 years ago 2
And you have to take into consideration the fact that technique has progressed significantly these last few decades. Its not difficult to find a 10 year old playing something which was once deemed as impossible for even a professional pianist.
Lemonizm 2 years ago 3
Richter is just amazing. Unfazed by stupid coughing and restless audience during eerily beautiful no. 2.
It is hard to fathom how he manages the speed of no. 1 with the parallel ninths in the right hand! Crystal clear and precise. Unbelievable! He must have had hands and fingers made out of steel and elastic at the same time. Stelastic!
No. 3 martellato is also from another planet!
Awesome!
bartje11 3 years ago 4
Well he could reach a compound 5th with ease apparently, so playing those ninths would be like 7ths to us humans!
davidgray2 2 years ago 2
never heard these before. just listened with the music. Astonishing. as 777cc777 says, the finest player of scriabin. I've heard lots of people play, but how he creates and sustains these different layers of sound is beyond me. Each layer has a totally different - tone - quality. Thanks for posting.
music4sherry 3 years ago
magico
sugarve 3 years ago
ethereal moment of sheer poetry
getitstraight2001 3 years ago
Do you know anything about the piece Mysterium? Was it ever completed? Has anyone ever tried to play it?
pjioayncoe 3 years ago
we have only the first part of Mysterium,the Prefactory Act,completed by Alexander Nemtin.there is one recording of the Berlin Symphony Orchestra conducted by Ashkenazy.
fisherroastedpeanut 3 years ago
When did he write the op.65 etudes?
pjioayncoe 3 years ago
1911
truecrypt 3 years ago
Thank you so much! I've been looking for a recording of the 2nd etude op65 for a long time!
Kalen1457 3 years ago
perfect playing from the great Scriabinist................... and the painting also conjuratory ;)
777cc777 3 years ago
Fantastic. Thank You Truecrypt to archive all this jewels on YT.
OP.65 n°1 is first of all a question of having hands big enough to be able to play it (Horowitz couldn't and told Richter it was sadly enough not possible for him). What Richter does in op.65 n°3 is pure madness and at the end totally "transfigure" the theme issued from op.65 n°1.
20Regards 3 years ago
I doubt your comment about Horowitz not having a big enough hands for this. You spread Octave and a semitone. Most people can stretch that and Horowitz did not have small hands!
CoolWJL 3 years ago
Yes, he could easily get the biggest of tenths.
davidgray2 2 years ago
I have this on LP. He is,I believe the only one of all renowned pianists to attempt to play the very difficult Scriabin etude in NINTHS!!! He was indeed a true virtuoso even at the beginning of his career. BRAVO!!!
scriabinwasmydad 4 years ago 3
Michael Ponti plays it - the question is how renowned do you think he is...I think he plays Scriabin excelently, but sadly his cds (well the ones I have) have the worst piano/sound quality ever - tinny would be an understatement.
JASenior44 4 years ago