as long as we enjoy jacky's singing and be proud of his fan, the rest will not bother us, we cant force everyone likes him, just like not all the singers have the ability to sing without any frills.
@nrom this is part of a full concert, and this is the first song. he came onto the stage making some joke about eating fruit, and that is what he was chewing on
Both Andy Lau and Jacky Cheung are "Heavenly Kings". Instead of arguing between who is better, why don't we embrace and be proud of what both have contributed to the Hong Kong music Industry?
Personally, I like both their singing skills- they are of a higher standard than some current HK singers.
To all you Jacky Cheung's shit fans out there. It dosn't matter he is eating an apple or chewng gum. This is not a right thing to do on stage. Just be professional ok. There is always a "right" place to do a "right" thing - "you cook in the kitchen, sleep in the bedroom, shit in a toliet and in his case, sing on a stage and not EATING SHIT on a stage. I guess Jackie wants to show how cool he is on stage. You will never see Andy Lau do that kind of stupid acts on stage. Andy Lau rocks!!!!!!!!
@ozalice96 Come to singing skills, voice, style and stage manners, Jacky Cheung is not even good enough to help carry Andy Lau's score sheet. Yes, Andy Lau's fan likes to give out 'shit' and the Jacky Cheung's fan likes to eat 'shit'......hahah!!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@ozalice96 First of all, I wonde what media are you referring to?? Stop reading those trashy magazines, they are no good to your peanut brain! Second. Get your fact straight. Sam Hui is the 'God of songs' not that apple chewing Jacky moron. Third. Jacky's fans are so dumb & my vulgar style of writing is certainly fit the bill for those low IQ Jacky's fan like yourself. Fourth. I am so glad that I am not a fan of Jacky cause I don't want to be associated with a bunch of idiots. Andy Lau rocks!!!
@diehardcowboys First, media means press, TV, radio, magazines etc. My favourite magazine is 'Psychology Today' if you called that trashy. Second, Sam Hui is the 'God of songs' of the earlier era and Jacky, NOT Andy, is the current one. Third, a REAL gentleman will never resort to vulgarities to make his points. Furthermore, name-calling and false accusations are tactics adopted by people who attempt to strengthen their weak arguments. Fourth, thanks for being Andy Lau's fan, not Jacky's!
some songs are best suited for males & some for females. this song is best sung by a female singer. you don't see many female singers trying to sing My Way by Frank Sinatra right?
Try to listen to In Love With You sung by him & Regine....
unless anyone of you have performed internationally or are even musically inclined, move on...-.-
If what you are saying it is true, then the Bee Gees shouldn't have recorded this song. The problem with Jacky is that he is pausing too much in the beginning.
Anyone can tell the way he present himself before and during the song, he was chowing something in his mouth, that was so disrespectful, not just to the audience, but to himself.
He sang this song terribly... he's popular in Hong Kong does not mean he is always right and perfect. He maybe a very good singer, but definitely not this one.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
makes my favourite Bee Gees song sounds flat, there's no mood and magic in it. What's worse was the fact he was chewing and singing at the same time, there just seems no real emotions in it... he needs to put more passion into the lyrics... sorry, i give it a miss.
he normally sings much better than this. maybe because this is the first song in the concert, he is not warmed up yet. or maybe because english is not his first language.
English is not his first language, that's granted. But the reason why he was chewing apple was not to fit the lyrics of the song, but his mouth was dry. It was later explained that roughly translated as "Having an apple produces saliva".
this song was not only written grammatically incorrect, but he also sang it grammatically incorrect at times..replacing "were" with "was." horrible hair btw. this song is not a good one
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It would have been better if you would have referred to the original version because I know it's fine. It's "don't ever tell me..." or "don't insult my intelligence," but I'm simple starting the truth, the grammar isn't perfect and a nine year old could have told the difference.
He left out all the s's.
concubinage 6 months ago
as long as we enjoy jacky's singing and be proud of his fan, the rest will not bother us, we cant force everyone likes him, just like not all the singers have the ability to sing without any frills.
mangoxp36 10 months ago 2
as long as we enjoy jacky's voice and be proud of his fan, the rest will not bother us, we cant force everyone likes him.
mangoxp36 10 months ago
why the fuck is he chewing on something
nrom 11 months ago
@nrom this is part of a full concert, and this is the first song. he came onto the stage making some joke about eating fruit, and that is what he was chewing on
TheAsianMichael 4 months ago
Both Andy Lau and Jacky Cheung are "Heavenly Kings". Instead of arguing between who is better, why don't we embrace and be proud of what both have contributed to the Hong Kong music Industry?
Personally, I like both their singing skills- they are of a higher standard than some current HK singers.
garetyy 1 year ago 2
哥神!!!
w071767 1 year ago 2
To all you Jacky Cheung's shit fans out there. It dosn't matter he is eating an apple or chewng gum. This is not a right thing to do on stage. Just be professional ok. There is always a "right" place to do a "right" thing - "you cook in the kitchen, sleep in the bedroom, shit in a toliet and in his case, sing on a stage and not EATING SHIT on a stage. I guess Jackie wants to show how cool he is on stage. You will never see Andy Lau do that kind of stupid acts on stage. Andy Lau rocks!!!!!!!!
diehardcowboys 1 year ago
@diehardcowboys I didn't realize Andy Lau's fan likes to use the word 'shit' so much! You are right about
Andy Lau not eating an apple on stage as he won't be able to sing if he did that! Jacky (not Jackie) doesn't
need to show how cool he is on stage because he doesn't need to. Andy, on the other hand, needs to do
that because his voice alone is not enough to wow the audience. By the way, you can sing in the kitchen,
sleep in the sitting room and read in a toilet. Jacky trumps Andy any time!
ozalice96 1 year ago
@ozalice96 Come to singing skills, voice, style and stage manners, Jacky Cheung is not even good enough to help carry Andy Lau's score sheet. Yes, Andy Lau's fan likes to give out 'shit' and the Jacky Cheung's fan likes to eat 'shit'......hahah!!!!
diehardcowboys 1 year ago
@diehardcowboys If Andy is such a great singer, how come the media named Jacky as the 'God of songs'
instead of him? Your username sheds light on your vulgar writing style and your choice of idol reflects the
level of your musical taste. I am so glad you are not a fan of Jacky!
ozalice96 1 year ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@ozalice96 First of all, I wonde what media are you referring to?? Stop reading those trashy magazines, they are no good to your peanut brain! Second. Get your fact straight. Sam Hui is the 'God of songs' not that apple chewing Jacky moron. Third. Jacky's fans are so dumb & my vulgar style of writing is certainly fit the bill for those low IQ Jacky's fan like yourself. Fourth. I am so glad that I am not a fan of Jacky cause I don't want to be associated with a bunch of idiots. Andy Lau rocks!!!
diehardcowboys 1 year ago
@diehardcowboys First, media means press, TV, radio, magazines etc. My favourite magazine is 'Psychology Today' if you called that trashy. Second, Sam Hui is the 'God of songs' of the earlier era and Jacky, NOT Andy, is the current one. Third, a REAL gentleman will never resort to vulgarities to make his points. Furthermore, name-calling and false accusations are tactics adopted by people who attempt to strengthen their weak arguments. Fourth, thanks for being Andy Lau's fan, not Jacky's!
ozalice96 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@diehardcowboys how much do you know about professionalism?
gskhor90 10 months ago
Be professional man! Finish the gum chewing before start singing.
diehardcowboys 1 year ago
@diehardcowboys what usay is so naive
virnowi 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@diehardcowboys what u say is so naive
virnowi 1 year ago
@diehardcowboys so look you just can be a cowboy····learn something before writting this fool word
virnowi 1 year ago
I forgot to say my friend in HK burnt me this CD
but I loved it so much that I actually bought the
CD and DVD (with karaoke version) from the
record shop when I subsequently visited HK.
He's done a brilliant job in covering other
singers' songs. There are several of his own
songs too. Love you, Jacky!
ozalice96 1 year ago
Jacky said whenever he's in the studio making a recording,
he always eats an apple as the apple juice is closest to a
human's saliva which helps to soothe his throat. As this charity
concert would be made as a CD, he just wished to capture that
mood. I have the CD and that's what he said at the performance.
By the way, this CD is the highest selling CD for that year in Hong Kong..
ozalice96 1 year ago
He needs a coach. It spoils the song when he mispronounces the words. He could be so much better. What a shame.
9w2xyz 1 year ago
... first time seeing a professional singer chewing gum (or eating apple) while singing... this is bad though he was a great singer once
sgk5003 1 year ago
Who ever is questioning/challenging Jacky Cheung's vocal skills please watch the video below: and watch til the last second of the song please
youtube.com/watch?v=ZStoR9wYiNs
PerfectDiver 1 year ago
Comment removed
Passby12 1 year ago
I'm sorry to say but George Lam's version of 'First of May' leaves me in less dismay.
ChairmanChu 1 year ago
some songs are best suited for males & some for females. this song is best sung by a female singer. you don't see many female singers trying to sing My Way by Frank Sinatra right?
Try to listen to In Love With You sung by him & Regine....
unless anyone of you have performed internationally or are even musically inclined, move on...-.-
christhoo 2 years ago
@christhoo
If what you are saying it is true, then the Bee Gees shouldn't have recorded this song. The problem with Jacky is that he is pausing too much in the beginning.
whyicare 1 year ago
u sang better than Jacky Cheung in yo dream shit head!!!
puisakura 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crap i sang better than that in karaoke
imaginator 2 years ago
agree.
He sang this a little bit strange.
I think after his voice has some problem, he seemed losing a bit confidence.
simonsaid321 2 years ago
@simonsaid321 fuck out of here!
tupac0306 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song,Olivia Ong's version is much more beautiful.
LuvFS 2 years ago
Anyone can tell the way he present himself before and during the song, he was chowing something in his mouth, that was so disrespectful, not just to the audience, but to himself.
silkcook 2 years ago
agreed , if you watch the full length concert of like 2005 or something , hes eat an apple on stage . and I think hes chewing gum in this ,.
mickeyrox129 2 years ago
Whatch 2:20
He's eating an apple to embody the theme of song
LuvFS 2 years ago
Whatch 2:20
He's eating an apple to embody the theme of song
LuvFS 2 years ago
@silkcook when you see the full version, you will see,he is EATTING a apple in fact```lol
virnowi 1 year ago
He sang this song terribly... he's popular in Hong Kong does not mean he is always right and perfect. He maybe a very good singer, but definitely not this one.
silkcook 2 years ago
he looks drunk
meloninhk 2 years ago 2
JUST CANNOT TOUCH MY HEART...
HOKYINA616 2 years ago
english song no bad to jackey singing
2646524 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what the fuck are you saying?
6leafdom 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
makes my favourite Bee Gees song sounds flat, there's no mood and magic in it. What's worse was the fact he was chewing and singing at the same time, there just seems no real emotions in it... he needs to put more passion into the lyrics... sorry, i give it a miss.
milomilesaway 2 years ago
he normally sings much better than this. maybe because this is the first song in the concert, he is not warmed up yet. or maybe because english is not his first language.
myacnt8999 2 years ago 11
English is not his first language, that's granted. But the reason why he was chewing apple was not to fit the lyrics of the song, but his mouth was dry. It was later explained that roughly translated as "Having an apple produces saliva".
TimHowardII 2 years ago
He said "were" it's kinda australian accent that made it sound like "was"
Yene02021987 3 years ago
ermm btw the grammar of this song is correct :)
yunny18 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song was not only written grammatically incorrect, but he also sang it grammatically incorrect at times..replacing "were" with "was." horrible hair btw. this song is not a good one
stoplightslaw 3 years ago
I love his hair here!!
Yanamariel 3 years ago 2
he is singing'were'.but it is so short and combined with the next word 'small'.so you mistaken it
clownn 3 years ago
come on, you are chinese too, forgive and forget it
vitainthehouse 3 years ago
Come on this is the Bee Gees' song!
cxyian 3 years ago
your sick lol mind your own business out of here hater
juzzlikethat 3 years ago
songs arent meant to be written grammatically correct. and his hair is awesome
happipooh 3 years ago
The song is written by an American! The grammar is fine.
solidysnake1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Unless you have the intelligence of a nine year old in Language Arts, you would have known the grammar isn't perfect.
At "Now we are tall, and Christmas trees were small,"
It should be "Christmas trees ARE small" since it is present tense.
zerotran0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Jacky sang it wrong.
And you are wrong.
The original version is fine.
Don't ever call me that I have the intelligent of the a nine year old.
solidysnake1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It would have been better if you would have referred to the original version because I know it's fine. It's "don't ever tell me..." or "don't insult my intelligence," but I'm simple starting the truth, the grammar isn't perfect and a nine year old could have told the difference.
zerotran0 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
However, I do apologize for being such a jerk, I do not wish to farther cause any conflict.
zerotran0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dont try to change the lyrics
jimmy10189 2 years ago
he's chewing gum because so that ur throad won't get dried up from singing!? i guess!
jrotc1991 3 years ago
its an apple, it produces saliva, easier to sing.. lol he says it in the dvd
hohakgin 3 years ago
He eating apple,not chewing gum:-)
aimarderossi 4 years ago 28
Why is he chewing gum????
tammyx423 4 years ago