Sorry if this a weird question, but shoud the use of a minor or C major be used? as you have stated, counterpoint is the use of melodies, a minor and C major are observations of harmony. So would one need to examine the intervalic relationships with each the other lines? or is the relationship with the cantos firmus the important observation?
ugly counterpoint, I'm sorry. There are mistakes, many mistakes. You have to buy a good manual of counterpoint and you have to study it. The fourth did not bind (bar 2 fourth quarter oboe) and so on. You have to study.
Mr. Pino, I enjoy constructive feedback and yours is not. I have a lot of good counterpoint manuals and have studied them deeply. Before commenting you should read the video description ("it wasn't prepared...there are a few mistakes..."). If you can improvise florid four voice counterpoint without "mistakes" you should become a teacher (I'm not, just a simple musician).
Anyway my favourite composer is Magister Perotinus Magnus and I really can't get rid of medieval habits in my counterpoint ;)
Sorry if this a weird question, but shoud the use of a minor or C major be used? as you have stated, counterpoint is the use of melodies, a minor and C major are observations of harmony. So would one need to examine the intervalic relationships with each the other lines? or is the relationship with the cantos firmus the important observation?
DiesIrae676 3 weeks ago in playlist More videos from artofcounterpoint
ugly counterpoint, I'm sorry. There are mistakes, many mistakes. You have to buy a good manual of counterpoint and you have to study it. The fourth did not bind (bar 2 fourth quarter oboe) and so on. You have to study.
pinodambrosio71 1 month ago
Mr. Pino, I enjoy constructive feedback and yours is not. I have a lot of good counterpoint manuals and have studied them deeply. Before commenting you should read the video description ("it wasn't prepared...there are a few mistakes..."). If you can improvise florid four voice counterpoint without "mistakes" you should become a teacher (I'm not, just a simple musician).
Anyway my favourite composer is Magister Perotinus Magnus and I really can't get rid of medieval habits in my counterpoint ;)
artofcounterpoint 1 month ago 2
thank you so much!
jacky25511 1 year ago 2