the most beautiful scene, so well done! Can't get it out of my head. I know when I watch it I will cry, but I can't help but watch it. It's so bitter-sweet.
Creo que la escena da lugar a muchas interpretaciones igualmente válidas. Me parece que la idea de enfocar la otra mesa es ubicarnos en la mirada de Robbie, hacernos tomar su perspectiva de las cosas, que es la más dolorosa. Por lo demás, la mirada es un elemento importantísimo en la película, tanto por lo que ven como por lo que interpretan los personajes y cómo se expresan sin recurrir a las palabras.
hes staring off because he can't look into her eyes without feeling some sense of pain, and a rememberance of what happened the night he was arrested and falsely accused.
ok just checking. They pan the camera shot over to the empty table and the women, and I didn't know if it had any connontation or if it was just him breaking the moment.
I have a question. What is robbie staring off at after he says "oh god"? It seems as if he is noticing somethin apart from breaking the oddness of the moment. I am assuming it is the 2 women not having husbands, but I am not really sure. Maybe somebody who has read the book would know.
omg i say this movie and it was amazing!!!!!!! it was sooooo sad!!!! i thought the acting was terrific!! but i must warn you if you havnt seen it yet when you do see it, afterwards you feel kind of depressed cuz its sooo sad thru out the whole thing!!!!!!!!!
01:22 - 03:15, again, I don't think I have seen such great acting as this, in a very long time, especially McAvoy... he is absolutely amazing, I can truly feel his pain. Knightley is good as well, but nothing compared to McAvoy.. in my opinion.
Joe wright does an excellent job of portraying the scene and choosing actors to portray it. You get the sense of joy, uneasiness, and the tension of not being able to believe what stands before them after such a long time.
THANK YOU FOR THIS SCENE!!!! very touching what they say... especially.... if we know... it was uncosciusly their last meeting ever... " white-blue house at the sea coast" at the postcard... and they never met again alive... ******************* seeing this first time at cinema thought it very pretty, re-seeing it again, knowing the story's end, made my eyes wet... thanks for uploading. love it.
I think this is my favorite part of the movie. I looked through like every Atonement video on YouTube after I saw the movie at the theater for that restaurant scene and couldn't find it, so I'm so glad I got to see it again now.
I don't want to even begin to think what the heart must feel like at that given ttime.
TheLalala1729 3 months ago
This is my favourite scene of the movie
1foottall 4 months ago
holy frick james mcavoy <33333333
arianedenisesite 5 months ago
at 1:30 i was like oh sweet lord Robbie looks so sad. i wanted to cry too.
itzkool309 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
best movie ever!
timega 7 months ago
why does she say 'sorry'?
KatScarpignato 7 months ago
@repn87 I completely agree with you there.
HPgeek2 7 months ago
I lol-ed when I saw "Have a Guiness when you're tired" at the back of the bus when he's running.
ValerieArian 7 months ago
this movie is the one which made me adore james mcavoy,such a tallent
zceylan 7 months ago
what does he say at 1:55 !!
MsPenelope121 8 months ago
omg i cant look it without crying.. :')
lee290895 1 year ago
God, his eyes are such an ICE BLUE .
I want to stair at it all day .
sulaka123 1 year ago
omg every time i watch this scene my heart melts into a puddle! I absolutely LOVE him!
mrsnovakdjokovic 1 year ago 2
This film was so cheated at the Oscars, especially McAvoy. Everything he does in this film is so sincere.
HPgeek2 1 year ago 6
this is truly some of the best acting
i've ever seen! thank you so much for uploading this
MadDevi 1 year ago
OMG HIS EYES !!!!
sapapihe 1 year ago
dearest cecilia,dearest cecilia,cecilia....................i love that.i could get lost in this scene 4ever.so romantic and beautiful.
jamima444 1 year ago
what does he say after she says that she has to be back at the hospital in half an hour?
Swizle13 1 year ago
@Swizle13 'oh god' i think.he doesnt want her to leave so soon.hes suddenly overcome with emotion in think.
jamima444 1 year ago
@Swizle13 "oh god, is that..." (all the time we're going to have?)
1972sissi 1 year ago
@cassyroxursox It's heartbreaking isn't it! Beautiful scene.
carrotstick24601 1 year ago
I would like incorporate this video,please!
maryanmartins14 1 year ago
heartbreaking...
ALWYNxox 2 years ago 5
does this scene happen in the book? or is it another scene briony made up (like the confrontation scene
movi3srock 2 years ago
this happened.
sangredelangel 2 years ago
@movi3srock
Briony didn't make it up. It happened. This is the last time they saw each other though.
hibbelnverpoort 1 year ago
the most gorgeous scene in a movie ever!!!
IVIaroon5 3 years ago 6
i love James McAvoy! :D
erana724 3 years ago 2
i love it when robbie's hand fell down when cecilia touched him, somehow it's very sad!!
lailamukarom 3 years ago 6
what did robbie say at 1:54??
lucy15wa 3 years ago
i think he said " you cant" or "oh god"
basically he doesn't want her to go
moviegoer28 3 years ago
"oh God, that's.."
sweeeeetieeeee 3 years ago
@lucy15wa I think he says a mixture of you can't and oh god.
mrsnovakdjokovic 1 year ago
great film.
numbersyesno 3 years ago 2
2:00 to 2:17 what did robbie stare at?
sweeeeetieeeee 3 years ago
i think he was staring at the old ladies, tried to help
teziiii 3 years ago
just realized that he actually stared at the old lady remembering his mom
sweeeeetieeeee 3 years ago 2
yup its so bitter-sweet and the same scene happened to me 3 years ago
sweeeeetieeeee 3 years ago
I forgot, is this scene before or after Dunkirk?
harwin13 3 years ago
Before Dunkirk.
themaster4life 3 years ago
love this scene. watch it at the movies, its even more sad..somehow
teziiii 3 years ago 2
the most beautiful scene, so well done! Can't get it out of my head. I know when I watch it I will cry, but I can't help but watch it. It's so bitter-sweet.
gfrank74 3 years ago 3
omg thank you SO much for posting this!!
mrsdarcy26 4 years ago
Creo que la escena da lugar a muchas interpretaciones igualmente válidas. Me parece que la idea de enfocar la otra mesa es ubicarnos en la mirada de Robbie, hacernos tomar su perspectiva de las cosas, que es la más dolorosa. Por lo demás, la mirada es un elemento importantísimo en la película, tanto por lo que ven como por lo que interpretan los personajes y cómo se expresan sin recurrir a las palabras.
elidelplata 4 years ago
what?
Horseiam 3 years ago
when he mouths "i love you" there at the end I just almost die. Its so beautiful/tragic. *sigh*
hheavier 4 years ago 8
omg i know every time i watch it i just start tearing up
paigeberollin 3 years ago
why does he say "oh god"?
lovvaclamm101 4 years ago
i think it was cause he though they had more time. He wasn't prepared to only have 30 minutes with her.
AoibheannStateira 4 years ago
keira was good but james was amazing
lvu16 4 years ago 43
i read the book.
hes staring off because he can't look into her eyes without feeling some sense of pain, and a rememberance of what happened the night he was arrested and falsely accused.
Briexx 4 years ago 6
ok just checking. They pan the camera shot over to the empty table and the women, and I didn't know if it had any connontation or if it was just him breaking the moment.
frambesbuckeye 4 years ago
I have a question. What is robbie staring off at after he says "oh god"? It seems as if he is noticing somethin apart from breaking the oddness of the moment. I am assuming it is the 2 women not having husbands, but I am not really sure. Maybe somebody who has read the book would know.
frambesbuckeye 4 years ago
those beautiful blue eyes
shennentel 4 years ago 5
omg i say this movie and it was amazing!!!!!!! it was sooooo sad!!!! i thought the acting was terrific!! but i must warn you if you havnt seen it yet when you do see it, afterwards you feel kind of depressed cuz its sooo sad thru out the whole thing!!!!!!!!!
pvt64 4 years ago
One of my fave scenes from the movie!
FairyCutie86 4 years ago 3
He has such a way with love movies...same in becoming jane....he makes me wish i was an actress lol
lfdoug15 4 years ago
01:22 - 03:15, again, I don't think I have seen such great acting as this, in a very long time, especially McAvoy... he is absolutely amazing, I can truly feel his pain. Knightley is good as well, but nothing compared to McAvoy.. in my opinion.
Lejon83 4 years ago
You always know when u are watching REALLY good actors, because u can really FEEL the love between them-its raw.
Look at the way the look at each other from 0:40 to 0:47.
The pain in their eyes, the look of longing for each other, the hurt.
Wow, these two do an AWESOME job of portraying this.
Anyone agree with me?
Louisa1212 4 years ago 9
Joe wright does an excellent job of portraying the scene and choosing actors to portray it. You get the sense of joy, uneasiness, and the tension of not being able to believe what stands before them after such a long time.
frambesbuckeye 4 years ago
.. so sad!!!
Ketch67 4 years ago
i'm pretty sure the tearoom is my favorite seen. that and dunkirk.
olNB 4 years ago 2
MartaMarmottina 4 years ago
Or maybe he says "You can't".
trebelclef 4 years ago
I think he says "Oh God!"
This is the best acting I have ever seen!
trebelclef 4 years ago 2
McAvoy in this scene is probably the best acting I've seen in a very long time. And I think he says: "Oh god" as well, I can truly feel his pain. :s
Lejon83 4 years ago 5
what does he say after she says i've got to get back to the hospital
loveyoubella 4 years ago
Oh God. If you watch the DVD with subtitles it tells you and thats what he says. Because they talk so fast you can't actually tell sometimes!
BOHAA001 4 years ago
Good idea. I watched it with subtitles........he says "you can't..."
trebelclef 3 years ago
I think this is my favorite part of the movie. I looked through like every Atonement video on YouTube after I saw the movie at the theater for that restaurant scene and couldn't find it, so I'm so glad I got to see it again now.
mgclark2 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this. What an amazing scene. Robbie is so hopelessly in love.
deeday 4 years ago 4