Added: 4 years ago
From: dork23x
Views: 17,500
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (190)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Awesome <3 ...OMG...You almost had me tearing up at the goodbye <3

  • This is... this is the most incredible music video I've ever seen. You seriously made me tear up here.

  • ok I definately wanna see a remake of this once deathly hallows comes out

  • I listened to this song lately and I realized how perfectly it matches "The Forest Again".

    Your video is amazing!!!

    Loved it!

  • i hope there is a similiar scene in the movie...the song is perfect for the story

    you have done a great job!!!

  • Amazing! there is no other words for it... AMAZING! :D

  • wow this is really fantastic! well done!

  • Just sat staring at the screen for an entire, very long minute afterwards with shock/sadness/longing. But.. in a good way. It was really effective. I can't explain it. :'(

  • I've already commented ages ago but seriously this is amazing. :) Brought be to tears

  • ok good video but the people who are saying this is the best then you need to watch MissMagic23 HP vids they are probably the best!

  • lavidéo est très bien faite avec 30 seconds to mars ^^

  • Probably I've already said so, but this will always be the best video of HP 7. Especially considering how dumb the real movies are... great job! You should be the one directing the movies...

  • This...this is amazing. I love it.

  • This was so awesome!!!! It was bloody brilliant! lol (Ron is talking through me). You are a awesome video maker! :)

  • I'm not sure if I have ever commented this video before but I really should have because i've lost count of the amount of times i've seen it. It's my favourite HP video on Youtube. It captures the chapter so perfectly :)

  • OMG. Im like crying...♥

    AWESOME VID.

    ONE OF THE BESTS I'VE EVER SEEN.

  • i can't believe i never commented on this. its probably my fave hp vid ever done :) you did an amazing job on this!

  • This is absolutely amazing!! Awesome editing and capture of the best chapter in the series!!

  • This is so professional; it's like it was really made for the movie.

  • wow. amazing video!

    5 stars!

  • i seriously have watched this video a million times

    and cry every single time

  • briliant.

  • I love this video, keep watching it over and over again.

  • Omg wow I loved that. It was simply brillant well done :)

  • Awesome video!

  • one of the best vids i've seen, good job

  • Amazing. I can't think of anything else to describe how well done this vid was. Thanks for making it!

  • omg!! that was just AMAZING!!really nice job!

  • It was fantastic. Amazing editing. I almost cried... almost.

  • amazing, absolutely amazing

  • awesome is the only word i can find for that

  • Amazing!!

    Added to faves..

    Five stars.. :)!

  • bril vid.... i love to read the whole book for this chapter... :(boohoo cnt beleve how many people die :(

  • you know i honestly cried. this is the first HP vid to make me cry. i think it's the best vid on YouTube about "the forest again" at any rate. GREAT job.

  • bloody brilliant

  • Brilliaant editing

  • Truly brilliant editing there, not sure why this doesn't have more views! I love the combination and layering (I don't know the technical term) of the images and clips, to sum up Harry's life and friends.

  • This is such a gorgeous videe :D

  • he doesn't really die tho right :(

  • Beautiful and touching vid. Especially the last part, when it looks like Harry's saying "goodbye" to everyone. 5* and favs

  • 1:10 where all the people Harry cared about was great even if it was only the picture from movie #5 that Neville discussed with Harry.

  • Amazing! Great job! Good song and editing. It all fits

  • Good Job!!!!!!Makes me cry a lot!

  • great job! great song too, and i loved the kinda glowing effect... especially at 1:16 to 1:20.

    loved it.

  • This is amazing! Great job! 5*

  • i teared up---this such an emotional song and the editing was superb!!!

  • This heart wrenching....and Stunning. And those are to things I don't say a lot about videos. This vid had me breathless. Amazing work Five Stars!

  • Wow, this is amazing. :D I love it! 5 stars

  • that was so good it gave me chills x]

  • Absolutely amazing!

    This is my favorite 30 STM song.

  • this really is great thnx..i love your style

  • i got shivers watching this! 5* favs

  • so good. almosts makes me cry.

  • that's brilliant!so emotional...I can't wait for your next videos you're my favourite in youtube!

  • Always makes me cry

  • OH so heartwrenching at the end...5 stars and saved to my playlist!

  • Amazing! Especially when it comes to the 'Goodbye' part and the voice comes so heart-wrenching near the end... wow! What a great song for this particular chapter.

  • Wonderfull!! Love it! The song fits this chapter perfectly!

  • Absolutely fantastic!!!!!!! Beautiful editing and a perfect song!♥

  • better than I remember it being...and it was always my favorite!

    did you edit it since it was made?

  • Definitely the best chapter 34 video I've seen.

    Love the song choice.

  • Awesome! The best one i've ever seen! ×D

  • Amazing..!! Best 'The Forest Again' I've seen so far... 5/5

  • wow....

    i'm speechless...that was probaply the best video of "the forrest again" i have ever seen...more thees please! <33

  • wow, you gave me chills. Amazing editing!

  • WOW

  • wow, awesome!:D

  • that was beautiful :)

  • this was so well done! probably my favorite video of "the forest again"

  • Aww, This is just awesome !<3 I'm sure that the reale movie can't ever be this good.

  • Amazing!!! LOVED it!

  • so great and sad .. but very nice video .. well done !

    sehr gut ausgewählte szenen !

  • OMG, I nearly cried... =(

    One of the most beautiful and sad vids I've ever seen. I cried while reading this chapter in the book and I think you did a wonderful job with this video. Really amazing.

  • i cried when i read that chapter too! and i hardly ever cry

  • This is great, is the band 30 seconds to mars?

  • yep, it is

  • Greatly Arranged

  • omg you made me cry =( this is soo beautiful!

  • B-E-A-U-T-I-F-U-L

  • When they come to film "the Forest Again" for real, I doubt it could be as powerful as this.

    I loved the way Hermione, Ron and Ginny (and even Luna!) were playing in Harry's head during the first half, and then it switched to a deceased character for all of the "goodbyes" - almost as if Harry was joining them.

  • sooo good on of the best i hope u won cuz this on actolly made me cry so hard. omg it was amiazzing great job.

  • that was so amazing and so beautiful, you did an awesome job

  • i think i commented this already-but this vid is AMAZINGGG

    i actually cried when you showed the twins during the "goodbye" part

    this is so well made

  • Amazingly made!

  • That was just absolutely amazing!

    The best Harry Potter video I think I have ever seen on you tube. In the words of Ron "Bloody Brilliant!"

  • oh jesus...*wipes away the tears* that was amazing! the song fit perfectly! oh wow you did a fantastic job, good work!

  • the book is awesome. I luv that chapter! :))

  • OMG THAT WAS SO GOOD. it made me cry.

    awesome job. 5 stars. :]

  • This is the first fanvid video that has made me cry... Awesome job with the editing, perfect song choice.

  • ...I can't believe how many times I've watched this!! It truly is amazing and beautiful. When you show everyone during the "goodbye" it kind of breaks my heart...just a little

  • This is fantastic! I cried when you showed the twins. I'm still all choked up. Excellent video. :)

  • beautiful video!

  • it's really beautiful!

  • heart stopping

  • One word - Amazing!

  • OMG I am speechless and breathless. This is AMAZING!!

  • wow, this is definately one of my favorite "the forest again" videos! You did a really good job with the editing and the song fits perfectly. The ending when he starts singing "goodbye" was really said, i got a little choked up.

  • Oh my Gosh .. that was beautiful, fantastic, brilliant ...

    Perfect song, made me shiver ...

  • that's such the perfect song.

  • I've already watched this viseo about 20 times... And every now and then, I can't help but watch it again. It gives me chills, my mouth is trembling when he starts singing "goodbye", and I'm like "it's really the end, isn't it?". No more books, no more laughing or crying with Harry, the more human character in the world. I AM so in love with this video... and I can't believe I even wrote that sort of things JUST for a video...

    You really honored HP's world. Bravo.

  • wat song is this???

  • it says on my description

  • well done !

  • oh wow that was just so awesome and good they should seriously like show this amv when the 7th movie comes out just because its that good! I love love love it 5 stars and a fave!

  • gosh i luv this video!!!!!!!!! i watch it almost every time i get on youtube

  • this is really good best forest again video i have seen i cried its really good and the perfect song

  • I... cried

    (I'm a bit of a crybaby, but still... just wow)

  • WOW! That's amazing!I love this chapter so much when I read I cry a lot and your video made me cry again!

    The music fits perfecly to the story!

  • That was soo sad... well done though. I'm so glad that you didn't forget about Dobby...

  • that's amazing!!!! I'm practically crying! lol xxxxxx

  • how did you find something of lupin that looks like he came back from the ressurection stone at 1:18?

  • i got that clip of him from the end in ootp. its the part when he comes to the veil room

  • really? it really worked for your video!

  • great job your best work yet

    P.S funky name dork23x.....LoL

  • haha, yeh i wish to change it. but i don't feel like making a new account. i made up that username when i was like 12.

  • That was soo good. Really intense. Great use of clips! I was tearing up at the end.

  • that was so good!!!!

  • your vid is wonderful!! and i love this chap so much

  • Wonderful ! I cryed to the end when we see all them who are dead.

  • Lol, I have been watching this continously every day since you put it up. And god, I'm crying. It's so sad. Especially the part with the snitch, the overlap of Lucius's voice, and the whole "the last mistake before you die, so don't forget to breathe tonight. Tonight's the last, so say goodbye." sooo love it.

  • fantastic the editing was amazing!!!!!!

  • how did u make this? what program do u use? cause i have been looking and looking for a good one :)

  • WOW. Your editing was so fantastic. I am in love with this vid!

  • wow ...wow i luv the goodbye part how all the memories overlap it was phenominal.

  • You should really put this out on the internet to download. especially into like... ipod format. that would be so tight.

  • BRILLIANT!

    loved it - love this chapter - very sad and upsetting - brilliant music!

    brought tears to ym eyes!

    brilliant!

  • Isn't it cool how there were the perfect amount of 'Goodbyes'? : p

  • amazing!!!!!*five stars and favs*love the editing!!!

  • Absolutely perfect. Fantastic job! I have chills. Amazing.

  • i was in love wit fred to me and my friends made a fred weasely club and we where wearing the t- shirts with his face on. we went round town hehe and we got kicked out of new look!!

  • OMG this is AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!

  • this vid is a lot better than all the other Forest Again videos. yours is my favorite.

  • well done!

  • omg THIS IS AMAZING...I practically cried wehn it was saying goodbye and it was fred...and lupin and doby :(

  • This is the best Harry Potter video i have ever seen and you know i'v seen a lot of them! this is amazing !!

  • AMAZING.

    amazing.

    amazing.

    i nearly cried too 0.0

  • Omg, i died when I saw Fred and they were singing "Goodbye". I was so in love with him. x___x''

    Brilliant, 5/5.

  • Oh. My. Goodness.

    This is absolutely brilliant! One of the best vid I have ever seen, and probably the best one about this scene. I love it so much! I especially love the ending with "Goodbye" and scenes with people that died... I nearly cried...

  • I cant think properly, This was amazing. I loved how you showed clips from them all groing up together and the the relationships. Then you got to the Goodbye to the characters and that alone is tear worthy, but you did it perfectly. The song fits too well with the final story. So Good job!

  • there arent any words to describe how absolutely brilliant this video is.

    plz make more vids like this one!

  • omg :D

    i loved it

    made me cryy.

    *favs*

  • DUDE this video is amazing after i read that chapter and finished the book i found this video and watched it and started crying! it is so good i showed it to 3 other people and one thought it was from the seventh movie i was like no they didnt make it yet!lol

  • haha, yeh when i heard this song, it made me think of this chapter. its sad :[

  • WOOOOOOOOOW!!! i´m crying!! this is such an amazing vid!! perfect i must say!! really i loved it!!! a lot... xD fantastic! i´ve got lots of things to say but i´d never finish lol. Please make another one. :)

  • Wow. That's all I have to say. Wow.

  • This is beautiful. I love the colour scheme and the song is one of my favourite of 30 Seconds to Mars. Amazing stuff!!!

  • really good! i'm crying ¬¬'. what program did you use?

  • sony vegas

  • amazing really good video...well done, I just Love it ;)

  • really well done!Compliments!

  • simply amazing!

    my favourite chapter and it was beautiful!

    loved it!

  • thanks!!

  • Amazing video...you've got me teary-eyed down here. Amazing editing and just...wow. Loved it. 5 stars. :D

  • yes i got u teary eyed!. haha, no but thank you so much. really happy you liked it!

  • That was truely amazing video, one of the best chapters in the book and you portrayed it perfectly!

  • wow thank you<3

  • You created the MOST heart-trobbing, gut-wrenching, tear-jerking video on Youtube! I only teared up a little while reading that sad chapter, but you reinforced the emotions and multiplied them! AMAZING VIDEO! :) Great job... ;)

  • :D i can't say how happy i am to hear such great words comming out from someone like you, i feel really honored. thanks alot!

  • This is the best video I have seen on youtube. No joke. You've captured the scene perfectly, what with all the effects and the song. The song is perfect for this scene! You know, I wouldn't be surprised if WB approached you to ask if they could use this as like the template for that scene. But just with renewed scenes of Harry/Dan walking through the forest. A perfect 10. Nothing can top this. Amazing job.

  • oh wow, i feel honored. thank you so much. really glad you liked it :D

  • I still stand by that. :)

  • ....wow...amazing...i love the effects, it was just perfect...im speechless....

  • wow thanks!

  • the end of the song is sorta stupid... but this video is fricking fantastic. oh my goodness. that was REALLY well done. like, no kidding. wow that was really cool

  • well thanks, i don't think the end was stupid. i believe its the best part, and others think so too. but thats my opinion. anyways glad u liked it.

  • well i mean, the moaning/screaming goodbye was a little awkward, but the song was really good. yeah idk what i was trying to say. lol

  • ps:check out mine;-)

  • you're a genius!!! I didn't like the song very much but your video is amazing..the best montage I've ever seen until now!

  • Oh my goodness! Wow, this is absolutly Amazing! The song works so well, it almost seems like it was written for 'The Forest Again'. I love this so much! =) Fantastic job with the editing, and everything is just so... Amazing! Wow. Marvelous job &hearts;

  • =O THAT WAS BLOODY BRILLIANT! ^^ you did a spectacular job! honestly this is one of the best videos I've seen, and I've got tons of faves, and a defiant spot for this one too! *Faves*

  • oh wow thank you :D i'm really happy you liked it!

  • very very well done!!! amazing... and 30STM just makes it even better... awsome!

  • wow thanks! i love 30 seconds to mars<3

  • AUSOME...perfection :D

  • haha thank you ;]