Sorry to tell you that, but cool anime+cool music+HD, doesn't change the fact it's poorly made. So if you want to made better stuff, try to made more and more amvs and i'm sure that you make someday something awesome :D Good Luck! Sorry if i was harsh.
@KaizokuTalia I'm just an ametuer doing it for fun, i'm not claiming to be anything amazing. Perhaps you could tell me why its poorly made, not just that you dont like it.
@ThePinkFoxx First thing is lipflaps (when character moves mouth), you should beware of that. The second and the most important thing is that it's looks like you use (almost) random/epic/emotional scenes one after another without any plan. Those aren't match with song at all. You completly ignore music and beats.
Only first 12 sec of this amv looks really good. And if whole amv looks like this, I'm almost sure that you would had bigger chances with this amv contest.
@KaizokuTalia I also like to make amvs for fun. But i also like to made them better and better. I saw many good comments at this side, so i wanted to play the role of bad guy, because the worst thing is to believe that only good comments are valuable. Maybe next time if someone write that what you did is awesome, ask that person, why? Why do you think so?
@KaizokuTalia sorry i can't see that it's poorly made. the pictures are fitting to the music and it caches the feeling from the anime. it's a showdown, one of the greatest moments of the anime, puting in pictures from other parts of the anime would be ill-fitting. i think it's really well made because it doesn't shows the tragic ending, so it's no spoiling, i love it! (sorry for poor english)
@keika268 I only said my opinion, and reason why i thought that this amv is poorly made, i already written. If you liked it, it's ok. I only wanted to tell this amv maker, that she still needs some work. I didn't say that she should use part from other arcs, but she should try better on montage like she did in first 12 sec, that looked very good.
Hahahaha I remember this, :D just saw you posted on my age old AMV link of the forum -laughs-
I am a rather large onepiece fan so seeing ace's demise was quite... well you would know my feelings :P.
Look forward to seeing what you end up doing for waicon next year, I am rather annoyed that they changed the theme as it has destroyed what I was making... but oh well. PM me if you don't mind my giving you some of what I would call advice or indepth opinion on this amv.
I used Adobe Premiere Pro 2.0, it's nothing special apparently in the editing world and mine kept crashing ALL the time (very frustrating) but it's all I've got. I'm going to work extra hard to pump out a few AMVs for next years Wai-Con :) I'm thinking.... Thriller Bark!
@ThePinkFoxx you could just do their entire adventure~ liek pick a character and start from the beginning to the end, could be epic :o anywho, either way still post it up so I can listen -3-
hahaah 1:36 marco is like bring it on :p
M4levolence 4 days ago
pk les menootee lui empeche de attaquer?
onepiecehistoire 4 days ago
While this isn't the best AMV I've ever seen, I'm glad to see a Marineford AMV that isn't 50% flashing lights
CornishCreamtea07 3 weeks ago
Nightwish and One Piece...the Best Things!!!
zorracerufy 3 weeks ago
sa gere :)
melanie1386 1 month ago
me a molao mogollon
fransombrerodepaja 1 month ago
i saw this amv at thw wai-con 2011 competition and it was favourite! was wondering what episodes/movie u used it from? thanks :D
Animeislife11 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
nice :) ...
IsKechik 1 month ago
0:44 gf ace.
M4levolence 1 month ago
Sorry to tell you that, but cool anime+cool music+HD, doesn't change the fact it's poorly made. So if you want to made better stuff, try to made more and more amvs and i'm sure that you make someday something awesome :D Good Luck! Sorry if i was harsh.
KaizokuTalia 2 months ago 2
@KaizokuTalia I'm just an ametuer doing it for fun, i'm not claiming to be anything amazing. Perhaps you could tell me why its poorly made, not just that you dont like it.
ThePinkFoxx 2 months ago
@ThePinkFoxx First thing is lipflaps (when character moves mouth), you should beware of that. The second and the most important thing is that it's looks like you use (almost) random/epic/emotional scenes one after another without any plan. Those aren't match with song at all. You completly ignore music and beats.
Only first 12 sec of this amv looks really good. And if whole amv looks like this, I'm almost sure that you would had bigger chances with this amv contest.
KaizokuTalia 2 months ago
@KaizokuTalia I also like to make amvs for fun. But i also like to made them better and better. I saw many good comments at this side, so i wanted to play the role of bad guy, because the worst thing is to believe that only good comments are valuable. Maybe next time if someone write that what you did is awesome, ask that person, why? Why do you think so?
KaizokuTalia 2 months ago
@ThePinkFoxx umm main problem is lack of timing and the onscreen action not relating to the song lyrics. But hey we all start somehow, right? :)
ColdButterfly 1 month ago
@KaizokuTalia sorry i can't see that it's poorly made. the pictures are fitting to the music and it caches the feeling from the anime. it's a showdown, one of the greatest moments of the anime, puting in pictures from other parts of the anime would be ill-fitting. i think it's really well made because it doesn't shows the tragic ending, so it's no spoiling, i love it! (sorry for poor english)
keika268 4 weeks ago
@keika268 I only said my opinion, and reason why i thought that this amv is poorly made, i already written. If you liked it, it's ok. I only wanted to tell this amv maker, that she still needs some work. I didn't say that she should use part from other arcs, but she should try better on montage like she did in first 12 sec, that looked very good.
KaizokuTalia 4 weeks ago
one of the best 480p quality i've ever seen!
btw: very nice amv^^
Schrotti90 3 months ago
@Schrotti90 It's actually 720p :)
ThePinkFoxx 3 months ago
whats the name of the song?
brianjebus1200 4 months ago
@brianjebus1200 The Song is "End of All Hope" by Nightwish :)
ThePinkFoxx 3 months ago
Very cool video :o
And could you tell me what episode is 00:33 - 00:48 from, please? I've gotta catch up on these episodes!
LuvXHate 4 months ago
What is the name of this song?
isherper 5 months ago
One Piece+Nightwish=AWESOME!
destroymode 6 months ago
ace ...=/
TheLinkinparkdu68 6 months ago
Comment removed
TalosParoxi 6 months ago
Saw this at Wai-con, it's awesome :D
DecievedDain 7 months ago
Hahahaha I remember this, :D just saw you posted on my age old AMV link of the forum -laughs-
I am a rather large onepiece fan so seeing ace's demise was quite... well you would know my feelings :P.
Look forward to seeing what you end up doing for waicon next year, I am rather annoyed that they changed the theme as it has destroyed what I was making... but oh well. PM me if you don't mind my giving you some of what I would call advice or indepth opinion on this amv.
lostsanityreturned 7 months ago
Comment removed
SHarpyHaMMeR 7 months ago
what episode is that when ace fights back against the poison guy?
PurpleRoseTobi 8 months ago
y this no have views?
pokemonsaga 8 months ago
wow AMAZING video *_^ .. good job ( ;
OanimePoB99 11 months ago
NEW GS AMV /watch?v=t_XjwCr1m2s hope you like it. :)
DasAlienYota 11 months ago
gah i saw this at waicon!! so amazing! u shouldve won! btw wat amv software do you use?
Animeislife11 1 year ago
@Animeislife11
Oh thanks so much! That's really nice. :)
I used Adobe Premiere Pro 2.0, it's nothing special apparently in the editing world and mine kept crashing ALL the time (very frustrating) but it's all I've got. I'm going to work extra hard to pump out a few AMVs for next years Wai-Con :) I'm thinking.... Thriller Bark!
ThePinkFoxx 1 year ago
@ThePinkFoxx
sound awesome, thanks
Animeislife11 1 year ago
@ThePinkFoxx you could just do their entire adventure~ liek pick a character and start from the beginning to the end, could be epic :o anywho, either way still post it up so I can listen -3-
pokemonsaga 8 months ago
very well done!!!
roronoazoroson 1 year ago
Nice job, Carmall! :D I love the whole part that starts at 2:26, where everything is flashing up with Ace's silhouette.
Veleven 1 year ago