-And all this, my love, in fear of you

[Atropa]

So I found this a week or two ago.

This is brilliantly done. The first line from the Doctor is timed excellently for a quiet section.

I may have also downloaded the Ryan Star album because of this.

[MrJBMPro]

That was a fun edit.

[pacifistattack]

@smallville160 "Of course, who else?" In the doctor's own words.

[caradrake]

I absolutely love this video. The video and audio clips are both perfect, and I love the music that you chose.

[MrKatiewright]

LOVE the way you put the scenes together, and the spoken words (mostly River). Absolutely beautiful!

I could DEFIINTELY do without the song... but I really extremely don't like that sort of genre, so that part of my comment doesn't count in for my overall opinion :) LOVED this saga, great job!

[longtallemm]

That's beautiful :)

[HANWIND100]

Demons Run when a Good Man goes to war.

Night will fall and drown the Sun

When a Good Man goes to war.

Friendship dies, and true love lies;

Night will fall, and the dark will rise

When a Good Man goes to war.

i <3 this poem and doctor who!

thumbs up so people can see

[sandrew13]

whats the songs name?

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@sandrew13 Losing Your Memory, by Ryan Star.

[WannaBeANerd]

This gave me goosebumps

[FellFather]

lesbian silurians FTW!

[adamantix]

Perfect video is perfect! It's making my heart hurt! V.V

[Toftajim]

Hey Ninth Doctor, what do you make of this YT video?

"Fantastic!"

XD

[MarikSlade]

Dude.... that was one of the greatest Doctor Who tributes I have ever seen... Damn fine show man, damn fine show

[MrEpicJames]

subbed! That wasnt fine, that was amazing! This is the main reason youtube should just screw copyright :)

[AuglereDeRosenkinde]

.. You know. .the more I think about it... I think the spoiler "***************" for the next eppy is actually "I Can Be Rewritten."

O.O

Maybe Moffat will reboot the Doctor? Your excellent bittersweet

vid totally plays into this.

[MissJnC]

:O this is am.a.zing :) x

[Gazelle1708]

Mkay... I got chills...

[fabipuli]

Oh. My. God. Speechless.

[fireking38]

Two people are madam kovarian and colonel run-away

Thumps up

[aptspire]

@fireking38 now the thin-fat gay couple joined them :P

[LukePisonline]

That was... Breathtaking.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@LukePisonline Thanks! :D

[roselover411]

ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i actually started hyperventilating when i watched that episode!! i spazzed insanely for a few minutes.

[msnhao]

I can barely hear the words

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@msnhao Yeah, I noticed afterwards that they are difficult to hear in some spots (while I was making it, I was listening to it on my headphones, which made it significantly easier than when it's coming through computer speakers). But it's all transcribed in the description if you want to know what they're saying~

[pacifistattack]

This video is the prime example of why youtube should have an epic button.

Seriously, this video was fantastic absolutely fantastic.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@pacifistattack Thank you so much! :D

And an epic button would be pretty awesome. n____n

[LucLightWolf121]

You hit it out the park my friend. Great job with the editing and choice of song. It nearly gave me chills just watching it. A Good Man Goes To War is by far my #1 episode of the Doctor Who series from the time of William Hartnell to Matt Smith. Once again, kudos for creating a superb video. I almost wish it had been longer. Keep up the good work.

[TheCalebxy]

What's the name of the song?

[pacifistattack]

@TheCalebxy Losing your memory, by the artist Ryan Star.

[CasualtyFan101]

I cried

[leahlovesdoctorose]

@TheDanni0608

I completely agree! I just hope that everytime he looks at River he doesn't see a little baby in a cot!

[TheDanni0608]

Damn it !! I LOVE THIS!!! There's NO doubt in my mind that Steven will make me hate him. I JUST LOVE THIS EPISODE!! My eyes to were like O.....O watching this...I was SOO looking forward to who river was :D I hope the Docotr and River will still be in a "Stable"-if i should say that LOL-relationship. Hoping the - " Oh, i've known you since you were young"- thing wont make it awkward :L Is the Doctor counted as a man though.. She kills good "MAN".. I dunno BUt thank you :D:D:D:

[Iamtheidleidol]

Easily one of the best Doctor Who fan-made/tribute videos I've ever seen. Never heard that song before, but I now love it just from seeing it set to such a brilliant story with such great editing. Kudos to the creator (and to the Doctor Who team... And Ryan Star...).

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@Iamtheidleidol Thank you very much for your incredibly kind words! n____n

And yes, super kudos to the entire Doctor Who team and Ryan Star! :D They are all the best. n____n

[Iamtheidleidol]

@TurtlesOfTheHeart You're most welcome. Thank you very much for the video. :)

[jackvjackv]

...wow...



[LouBable]

OMG this is INCREDIBLE like the episode I just didn't want it to end it has to be one of the best Dr Who videos I have seen!!! Everything about it is totally amazing the editing, the clips you have used, the voiceovers I could just go on an on!!!!!!!!!!! PURE QUALITY I will have to like and put it on my favorites!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <33333333333333

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@LouBable Aww, thank you so much! I'm really really glad that you enjoyed it! :D

<33333333333333333

[xannara182]

wait is river the doctors child or is she amys child im kinda confused i love her

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@xannara182 River is Amy and Rory's child. :D

[Freddy2267]

The best episode yet!!!

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@Freddy2267 Absolutely! :D

[TaMant]

I love this video

Good Man Goes to War was a great episode

I love River <33

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@TaMant Thank you very much! :D

And indeed it was! :D It was spectacular! I can't wait for September now! :D

And I know River is just amazing~! :D

[doctorw2]

i wish that the episode a good man goes to war had been 90 minuets longer i really enjoyed that cliff hanger so much it was like watching a good japanese anime.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@doctorw2 Yeah, they did really well for the time that they had though. :D And it was indeed a super spectacular cliffhanger! :D

[Nessie6882]

wow....that's amazing...

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@Nessie6882 Thank you very much! :D

[xISm0keyIx]

absaloutly lush!

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@xISm0keyIx Thank you! :D

[LadyElessar13]

just amazing !! great job :)

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@LadyElessar13 Thank you very much! :D

[trickticks]

I like it

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@trickticks Thank you very much, I'm glad you liked it! :D

[PickloProductions]

Nice but the clips are waaaaay too fast for the song. It all feels sort of rushed. I'm actually typing fast in an attempt to keep up. ^-^

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@PickloProductions In my defense, I wasn't really accounting for people typing while watching it. XD But but but you have a fair point. I've re-watched it a few more times now, and I personally still don't feel that it's rushed, but thank you very much for your input and I'll keep that in mind! :D

[EllieBabiee]

my last comment didn't convey how much I actually love this video. It is one of the best video's i have ever seen. And also one of the best River tributes. It just goes to show that a video doesn't have to be super effecty to convey emotions. I hope one day I can make a video like this. This may seem a little weird, but I am working on a River video, and I would like to dedicate it to you, if that's ok? :) It truly is amazing! :D

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@EllieBabiee Oh my goodness, thank you so, so much! Reading this comment totally made my night. n____n And I would be so totally completely honoured if you chose to dedicate it to me. Thank you a million times over! :D

[missjemimaaa]

adding this to my favourites does not do it justice to how much i adored it

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@missjemimaaa Aww, thank you very much! n____n

[EllieBabiee]

this is really good :)

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@EllieBabiee Thank you! :D

[ginnyharryfan22]

Amazing. I'm still trying to wrap my head around the AGMGTW.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@ginnyharryfan22 Thanks! :D

[popesrose]

omg omg omg omg was all i could think after this episode ended.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@popesrose Me too!

[andrew1332]

Oh snap! is that Rory? he looks bad ass XD

Nice video!

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@andrew1332 THAT IS RORY THE ROMAN! XD

Rory the Roman is pretty amazing. I love it when he makes cameos. :D

And in case this is confusing, Rory and Rory the Roman are obviously the same person. It's just that the Doctor sometimes calls Rory Rory the Roman. So yeah. You'll see. :D

[jenfirelight]

Wow...

Really fantastic job on this video.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@jenfirelight Thank you very much! :D

[fate16aintsosweet]

I really dont know how people didnt get it. My friend and I sussed it out near the beginning who she was and we were just waiting for it to be out in the open cause noone believed us! It was pretty damn obvious, I love Doctor Who but I mean... if youre older than 12 I think you can suss out most of the secrets.

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@fate16aintsosweet It's good that you can guess it though. Because as Steven Moffat has said, a twist should always be guessable. Otherwise it just comes at you out of left field and it's no fun. :C And guessing is the most fun! :D Like, I loved reading through all the different theories that everyone had.

And if a twist is guessable, then you can go back and appreciate all the AWESOME FORESHADOWING that happened! :D

It's too bad no one believed you though. :C

[whiimsy]

ALLIE WHAT EVEN IS THIS?!?!? why are you so amazing honeeeeey? okay, so yeah i would never have connected this song with the episode, but it works so well for this and just generally for series 6 so far, and this video is magnificent! i love the subtle but pretty colouring, and your, as always, fabulous use of voiceovers - I DON'T EVEN KNOW HOW TO USE THEM AND YOUR SO GOOD AT THEM AND UH INADEQUACY BECAUSE ALLIE YOU ARE AMAZING. and i loved the quote from river/melody at the beginning - it...

[whiimsy]

was just so beautiful, and one of the best bits of the whole episode, and the way alex kingston delievered it was SUPERB! :D <3 AND YOUR JUST AMAZING AND I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS IS FOR ME. AND WHY IS IT NOT SEPTEMBER YET?!?!? HMMMMM! *_____*

but yeah, everything about this was perfect AND JUST RIVER/ELEVEN. OMG SHIP IT LIKE BURNING. and the way you put their previous scenes in, to contrast with this episode was just stunning and shows how even through this they're so solid - and i hope now...

[whiimsy]

the doctor can realise that he can trust her, absolutely and completely! :D <3 and just eurgh that bit at 1:05 with river and rory was beautiful, its just so sad because he's her dad and he is asking if she even knows who he is, and eurgh her face. MAH BB RIVER DON'T CRY. but everything about this was just so stunning, and the flow of this song fits both the epicness and the sadness of this episode into one, and you captured that perfectly my dear. :) YOUR AMAZING. HAVE I MENTIONED THAT? ;) ...

[whiimsy]

AND THAT LINE. WHY YOU MAKE ME FEEL SO MANY EMOTIONS WITH YOUR VIDEO ALLIE?!?!? "all the best of what we've done is yet to come." it's so eleven/river it hurts, but just everything about this episode was so perfect and beautiful, and you really summed that up - and the anger of the doctor as well, you captured perfectly in just the right way, and its just... despite the fact that you haven't been watching long you have such a sense of what doctor who is about, and thats displayed so clearly...

[whiimsy]

in your videos, especially this one! :) and the way you vidded that last quote was so perfectly heartbreaking, and you fit the perfect clips to it my dear allie, because it really is so true of the doctor - even if its never what he wanted. and i think the clips you chose to show the emotions of that quote, and the truth behind it, were just perfect. WHY YOU SO FLAWLESS AT VIDDING? HMMMM? ;D

AND JUST I CAN'T GET OVER THIS. IT IS PERFECT. THANKYOU SO MUCH MY DEAR. :D LOVE YOUUU!<3333

[whiimsy]

OH OH ALSO; you should totally finish that romeo x juliet video, because your fabulous and such! ;)

AND, ERM YEAH. THAT WAS ALL. i'm just gonna watch this a million times now because i want to vid this episode so badly but my computer won't install sony vegas, and i need a new laptop plug like NOW. D:

YOUR AMAZING ALLIE. ALL MY LOOOVE. ;D <333

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@whiimsy storytelling that they're doing! Like, I really love this development with the Doctor, how he has changed even if he didn't mean to. On one hand it's sad and on the other it's very human and inevitable and he's not human but he still has many human qualities AND OH MY GOODNESS I JUST LOVE THE WRITING IN THIS SHOW.

ANYTIME VEE. I LOOOOVE YOOOUUUUU TOOOO! :D

And I shall have to finish it some time. n_____n

YES. GET A NEW LAPTOP PLUG AND VEGAS.

ALL MY LOVE TO YOU AS WELL! <333333333333

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@whiimsy But seriously I hope that Rory and Amy stay on for another season - or however long Matt Smith is there for. They are all just so perfect together! :D And they're developing the characters so wonderfully~

YES. THAT PART WAS AMAZING. I was like "okay, she is totally your daughter. You do not get like that and start randomly explaining that it's your birthday over someone you've met twice.

Aww, thanks again! I'm really glad that I'm capturing things well, since it's such amazing...

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@whiimsy started saying it. I agree, it was a fantastic delivery! Alex Kingston is just really really wonderful. :D I NEED IT TO BE SEPTEMBER TOO WHY MID SEASON HIATUSES WHY?

I WILL SHIP THEM FOREVER THEY ARE LOVELY! :D And it's totally why these four make the best TARDIS team, they're all one big happy family! :D Amy Pond and her husband and daughter and her imaginary friend. :D Oh man, I jokingly feel a little bad for Rory though. All the important women in his life love the Doctor. XD

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@whiimsy Aww, thanks Vee! :D You are super amazing too! Do not say that you are inadequate because you are not at all! I love your vids, they are always amazing and heartfelt. :D ♥♥♥

And thanks! n____n In regards to the voiceovers, I pretty much just pick lines that I think are awesome, and then try to fit them into the music at unobtrusive times. Like, during held notes and stuff, so that they do not get in the way of the lyrics.

OH MAN THAT QUOTE. I was like "THIS IS SO EPIC" when she...

[QuidnamInferorum]

OH MY LORD, WHAT IF RIVER SONG WAS THE ONE IN THE SPACESUIT?!

I died when I saw this episode. Just died. I wasn't part of the "River is Rory & Amy's daughter" bandwagon, but I knew that the little girl in the suit was--there was no way she couldn't have been.

This episode was too brilliant for words--when River showed up, I don't think I breathed until the end of the episode.

AH, THIS EPISODE! I'M STILL TOO EXCITED TO FORM COHERENT THOUGHTS.

(Also, your vid is lovely, dearie!! Brilliant. =D)

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@QuidnamInferorum I KNOW. THAT IS MY THEORY. Obviously I don't know if it's right, but for the purpose of this video, I assumed it was. ^^;

I know! I was getting seriously worried that she wasn't going to show up, or that they weren't going to confirm who she was. And I was like "noooo Steven Moffat you promised! :C". Because like, they were cutting it kind of close there. But then she showed up and it was a wonderful end to the episode! :D

And thanks! :D

[QuidnamInferorum]

@TurtlesOfTheHeart Well, we can just pretned it's completely true. ^_^

I know! I was like, "Oh, this is just like Moffat! He's promised to tell us who River Song is, and now we have to--OHMAHGAWDAREYOUSERIOUS?!?!­?!"

You're very welcome, Allie!!! XD :hugs:

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@QuidnamInferorum I know! When she was like "I am telling you" I was like "I don't understand it. Am I supposed to understand it? What are those circles? Why is he so happy? What is going on telllll meeeeee"

And then it did. And then I was very happy. And then I proceeded to say "oh my god oh my god oh my god" over and over and my sister and her boyfriend thought I was crazy. XD

[TurtlesOfTheHeart]

@QuidnamInferorum Also hugs! I cannot believe I forgot the hugs! D:

SUPER MASSIVE BEARHUG OF LOVE TO MAKE UP FOR IT! :D <3333333

[QuidnamInferorum]

@TurtlesOfTheHeart I was just like "AH!! BRAIN HAS DIED!!!"

:MASSIVE BONE-CRUSHING COMA-INDUCING HUGS:

[fate16aintsosweet]

@QuidnamInferorum She is the one in the spacesuit, however now they are saying he turns out to not be such a good man so there is a chance she kills Rory aswell. It is definately her in the spacesuit, the little girl is a timelord - shes a time lord. And the fact that she shot the little girl is just cause she doesnt care about herself now because she cant live knowing she killed him...