I like both versions of this waltz you play :) I love how in the end you improvise by playing a random low key that isn't in the composition of the song, just for fun! It's really good and any time I look for different interpretations of this song I always think yours is the best!
Your corporal lenguage at the end says a lot, and not just the note. i read about the thing of heart and the medication stuff. you looked like that was troubling you, well, it must make you really happy to continue playing, this video i think it has a great emotional value and thanks for sharing it,
If you were gay,that will be ok,i mean cause hey, i like you anyway.Bacause you see, if it were me,i would feel free to say that i was gay, but i am not gay.
i wouldn't mind so much if people asked me once. but i've been asked like over a hundred times. Plus it's not even related to music? It's just annoying now. Has nothing to do with feeling free to say anything.
Well, this is actually evenue Q song lyric,just kind of remind me the song when people ask you the "question".Go check the song"if you were gay" and sorry to get you annoy.Nice play.:D
pretty amazing. I started playing piano a year ago, but i jumped into things i just learned songs. I didnt really know the theory of the piano or the basics. the only thing i really knew how to do was press keys. I started to watch your videos and im learing fast. But i was wondering how long do you think it will take for me to play in a rock band. i kinda messed around in one but i was not good enough.
dude your really good, im learning how to play a couple of the songs that u have on youtube, ive been playing for two years and my piano teacher goes too slow so i always look up songs like these, and yours are super good, lol
:) haha there's a game show on BBC with this music? that's hilarious! I never knew that! :) but then again I don't have BBC either! So how would i know!? :) anyway! thanks for listening!
On BBC Radio 4 there is a game show called 'Just a minute' which has this piece as it's 'theme tune'. I love Just a minute and I love this piece so I'm very happy! :)
wow i cant believe i clicked this video by accident. seriously i've been searching for this song for almost half a year! no joke!! man, i wish i could hug you!!
almost a year? wow, well interesting what you stumble over hey? Well, hugs are never a bad thing...well that's not true, a hug from a sweaty dude who hasn't showered for a month is not good... anyway ^_^ thanks for the comment
haha! wow you really picked a brutal song to start as your first song! This isn't the hardest song in the world, but it definitely is not the easiest, especially for a beginner to learn! :)
I'm learning this right now, slow practice is helping, its only hard when i play it at the right speed, and i'm the only one ever of my piano teachers students to have learnt it.... or learning it i should say....
yea, i didn't acsidently play that speed, my intention was to be quick, and there weren't any wrong notes until the very end where i hit a G instead of the A coming down. This is my fast version of the song, i have a slower more emotional version. but in this video i was going for speed ^_^
the middle section is the harder part of this.and it's hard to resist making it flashy,when it's really a salon piece.you need to respect chopin's score.your ending was awful and ruined the rest of the performance.
I'm quite aware this isn't the best i can do. I have tendonitous in both my arms as a side effect from medication i was forced to take because of a random heart condition i developed...it's a long story...I recorded this when i thought i might never be able to play again. This was one of my favorite songs from about 2 years earlier, so it was unpolished....
hen i had it all polished up I got standing ovations for this song always played it note perfect, and the most respected teacher and adjudicator in all the north said it was the best version of the song she's ever heard including the Chopin international competition. Your comment seemed pretty darn negative though? I looked you up and other people have talked about your negative comments...do you just like picking other people apart to make yourself feel better?
lypur i have re-recorded my version of this waltz, i would like to know your opinion, i will not attack, lol. there are only a few of us to share the information knowing the piece deeply
i can see that you enjoyed the song by playing it fast, but it's originally supposed to be a little bit slower. but im' not critizing at all in any way, good job 5 stars.
Your good, you have nice control and your right hand and left hand blend properly. However, in my opinion the middle is played too slow, along with the rest of the piece. And the speed will come to you with more practice. Also, you should add more emotion to your playing. Your good, but thats the difference between good and great. :)
well, you said there were "soo many wrong notes" where there only a few, 5, maybe 6? but you were right it needs more work but its always the same.... more work, a nd.. you critiziced my work so i did the same, what you wanted is really difficult to do with a fast waltz, you need to practise every day at least playing other things to have your hands ready, i didn't want to insult either,i think emotion is the first thing on chopin, good work anyway!
well, i guess all that would be your opinion. I can agree i played this with less than satisfactory emotion, i used to play this song better when I practiced it regularly. When I made this recording I had just relearnt the song that day, and only wanted a recording of it, because my tendonitous was getting really bad and I was scared I would never be able to play this song again.
i think your interpretacion is boring than mine,and this is because of the sonority, the center passage has to be a bit faster in my opinion, the crescendo is not good enough in the trino to finish on forte.you dont make nearly any difference in the whole work it seems is always forte, and buy some good microphones!!lol
in the beginning the acommpaniment sounds too much, it is a very similar end to the barenboim's one in one recital that is here on youtube. even with mistakes i prefer my recording,eh?lol, your recording is like a robot playing the piano, and there's no emotion, barenboim get's emotion on chopin recording's and pollini as well, that's what i thnk,it is not cientific, lol.
thanks you for the nice comment! the key to playing this song is, keep your arm above the keys, i think of my arms like it's in the clouds, and my fingers are far away enough so that when i extend them they can just barely reach the keys, this gives it that fast light sound. I could show you more in real life, but yea...you don't live in Prince George BC Canada by any chance?
I think you have all the notes down well. Needs a little more effect though. Add "drama" or more emotion to the songs transitions. Slow and easy in some parts. Good Job though. It's a tough music.
way better than ur old one, lol. u added more dynamics but it's still not enough to amuse people. again, try to be loud at the climaxes, that is how Chopin wanted. Watch my Minute Waltz hopefully coming soon, you'll understand what i mean!!!
Oh, you did see it, I didn't see this comment when i left my other reply. Yea, I'd love to see your version of it, when you get it on here, send me a message and attach the video to it. Thanks
I really like the way you play this. I started learning this piece about five weeks ago. I'm doing well with it, but now I need to work on the speed. Thanks for the encouragement!
Thanks! it's funny you say that you think i made it look easy. That's actually the key to playing this song. You need to keep your arms just above the keys, kind of like suspending your arms above, and let your hands float across the keys. While i'm playing this song, i just say "play it easy, play it easy, it's easy" over and over in my head ^_^ and it's funny, just saying that actually makes it easy!
Nice man, I'm currently working on this song for an audition at a college I'm attending next year, almost finished the second part of it. But that was well done
I love this song - this is one of the songs I always know how to play LOL even when I've been out of the game. Even though I'm not playing anymore, I think your technique is awesome =) When did you start learning?
I started when i was 5 years old. I know what you mean, about being out of the game. I've had tendonitous for about a year now. but I still love to play this song...I'm sure it isn't good for me to play it...but i love it!
You are a motherfucker of a player. Awesome rendition.
By the way, starting your instructional vids. Thank you for that.
Carry on!
nikolai1uno 7 months ago
I like both versions of this waltz you play :) I love how in the end you improvise by playing a random low key that isn't in the composition of the song, just for fun! It's really good and any time I look for different interpretations of this song I always think yours is the best!
juliburton 1 year ago
I love this its awesome i wish I could play this but I have only been playing for less than a year and am only in grade 5 :P lol good job anyways :)
sk8tergirldufhotmail 1 year ago
haha, at the end of this one youre like "thats how i roll, out", then youre newest one youre like "YEAHHHHH!!!"
anglofdth000 1 year ago
Damn your so good :)
CarrieLegendary 1 year ago
wow that was fast
holy cow
yati101 1 year ago
Your corporal lenguage at the end says a lot, and not just the note. i read about the thing of heart and the medication stuff. you looked like that was troubling you, well, it must make you really happy to continue playing, this video i think it has a great emotional value and thanks for sharing it,
8118995 2 years ago
Awesome! :D
ikkejr 2 years ago
a refilmed version in HD is coming SOON! :D
Lypur 2 years ago
Great! i cant wait ;-)
ikkejr 2 years ago
@Lypur thanks for you lesons they are really helpful, God bless you!
JUlIOBRANDAO 1 year ago
@Lypur can you do "Clash on a Big Bridge" too? it's pretty catchy. i believe you can :D
andretatontos 1 year ago
OH NO! This song has been my alarm song to wake me up for school! D: WHY!! now it makes me jump everytime I hear the begining D: NOOOOOOOOOO HEEEELP
winxcat 2 years ago 6
that wasnt too bad of you buddy, not too bad at all....
ILLUSIONFUSION1 2 years ago
butiful !
wyatt50000 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I fucking hate the ending fool!
andres52 2 years ago
It's not so bad....just a little too fast.
milonkill 2 years ago 2
I checked out your site Andrew, and I like it a lot. Very informative, and classy!
killingangel707 2 years ago 3
Nice. Better than I played it. lol
TheLovelyPiano 2 years ago
good perormance¡¡¡
michaelnyman1 2 years ago
I never mastered it and you certainly have. THankyou for some wonderful memories.
northernpost 2 years ago
Nice. I love the lessons too. I've actually started playing.
iamyouifyouareme 2 years ago
really good!
naruto5754 2 years ago
Could you please upload a video where you will teach us how to play the grande valse brillante op18.
AZo9jojo 2 years ago
Amazing too!!... ^^U
fowlshinigami 2 years ago
dont like the last note you added!!
cinnamonandpaprika 2 years ago 2
such a steezy ending. lol. nice.
jcammo123 2 years ago
its easy, in fact... i took a day to play it with my eys closed...
stagesix6 2 years ago
great playing, when i learn fur elise from your video i hope to play chopin's waltz in d minor, thank you for posting.
rufus39 2 years ago
you added a note at the end, the lowest D flat~ i like it !!
christophenwang 2 years ago
@christophenwang
I think he added the an A
rsoeyadi 2 years ago
nice. very different from how i play it but very nice. but one thing... dont fuck up the last scale thats brutal :D
greets
HomerJ666 2 years ago
how long did it take you to learn this?
its taking me FOREVER
cs51832 2 years ago
really? it took me about 2 or 3 hours...
HomerJ666 2 years ago
well then .. i guess im just not as good as you...
cs51832 2 years ago
wow thats terrific!! Piano Master :)! I wish i will one day play a half from this what you play. How long do you practice daily?
I begun 3 month ago with my piano, and at the moment it is real difficult, sometimes i hate it :D
oh... and many thanks for your tutorials!!!
Greetings
AJRSonor 2 years ago
WOW, look at those fingers move. This I've heard before, but I know for sure I appreciate it more today.
degbola 2 years ago
Who knows someday I will play just like this. I`ve started my classes last week. In ten years time, maybe :)
reboucasi 2 years ago 2
Well, i do watch your engagement story so i know your are actual .............. :P
babydragonball 2 years ago
holy shit! thats seriously one of the fastest songs on the piano!!... and the only one i cant play lol
hellofellow13 2 years ago
Good for you,at least now you know you have one goal to accomplish.
babydragonball 2 years ago
ended with an extra note remind me of Fryderyk... but if you ended up originally it might sounds like Chopin or maybe even Lypur XD
SIlentPianist47 2 years ago
Also 100% irrelevent
Moore0806 2 years ago
ive watched ur other vidios and my brother thinks your gay and he means it with no offence we think ur great but r u?
like gay?
cityboys12 2 years ago
100% straight
Lypur 2 years ago
If you were gay,that will be ok,i mean cause hey, i like you anyway.Bacause you see, if it were me,i would feel free to say that i was gay, but i am not gay.
babydragonball 2 years ago
i wouldn't mind so much if people asked me once. but i've been asked like over a hundred times. Plus it's not even related to music? It's just annoying now. Has nothing to do with feeling free to say anything.
Lypur 2 years ago
Well, this is actually evenue Q song lyric,just kind of remind me the song when people ask you the "question".Go check the song"if you were gay" and sorry to get you annoy.Nice play.:D
babydragonball 2 years ago
cityboys12: He's engaged.. to a woman.
TwistedxxTransistor 2 years ago
thank you for doing your homework ^_^ anyone who's watched my videos knows me well enough to know i'm engaged ^_^
Lypur 2 years ago
Haha, you're welcome.
Thank you for bothering to reply to that message! ^_^
TwistedxxTransistor 2 years ago
^_^ and thank you for leaving that comment.
Lypur 2 years ago
^_^
TwistedxxTransistor 2 years ago
@Lypur Well if she trips and falls down a well, look me up. I'm a Linux, too! :)
frauleinannika 1 year ago
ONE WORD: beautiful
Pirate4T 2 years ago
I just had to slap myself to make sure this was reality *jaw drop*
I love this song i even have it on my ipod. I like chopins music
allybeachbab3 3 years ago
pretty amazing. I started playing piano a year ago, but i jumped into things i just learned songs. I didnt really know the theory of the piano or the basics. the only thing i really knew how to do was press keys. I started to watch your videos and im learing fast. But i was wondering how long do you think it will take for me to play in a rock band. i kinda messed around in one but i was not good enough.
joriahbling 3 years ago
I'd love to see you do Stars and Stripes Forever by Horowitz!
tigerslayer2230 3 years ago
you have earned my subscription wow that was incredible i like the breakdowns u had too. looking forward to more from you soon
MSemeranSB 3 years ago
*jaw drop*
dillooon 3 years ago
ooh :) I like getting that kind of reaction from people
Lypur 3 years ago
WOW, I wanna do that!
EHMTalentShow 3 years ago 6
you can ^_^ with practise!
Lypur 3 years ago
This is VERY awesome. Keep up the good work.
MezzoPiano27 3 years ago
thanks! I'm glad you liked it
Lypur 3 years ago
dude your really good, im learning how to play a couple of the songs that u have on youtube, ive been playing for two years and my piano teacher goes too slow so i always look up songs like these, and yours are super good, lol
do you make your own music?
fritsandits 3 years ago
could i have your old piano??? hahahaha
imbored1996 3 years ago
but...it has so much sentimental value *sniff* *tears welling up in eyes*
Lypur 3 years ago
That was really really good!
SteinbachPlayer 3 years ago
Freak speed :)
culturedmind 3 years ago
You should play a Liszt Paganini etude, or Chopin Ballade. That would be awesome with your technique.
SireRage 3 years ago
Sigh... when will I be able to play this? Cool piece, and I fell in love with when I listened to the BBC gameshow "Just A Minute".
teoani 3 years ago
:) haha there's a game show on BBC with this music? that's hilarious! I never knew that! :) but then again I don't have BBC either! So how would i know!? :) anyway! thanks for listening!
Lypur 3 years ago
On BBC Radio 4 there is a game show called 'Just a minute' which has this piece as it's 'theme tune'. I love Just a minute and I love this piece so I'm very happy! :)
3blindmice95 2 years ago
lol this song is called 'minute waltz' but it actually takes 1 minute and 31 seconds XD
winxcat 3 years ago
Oh, my, that was fast! :D Great playing, I agree with Thomas. ^^
DariaVelZiutka 3 years ago
thank you!
Lypur 3 years ago
This is AWESOME! :D
thomandy 3 years ago 2
Why thank you Thomas! :) I'm thrilled you like it :) think I should relearn the piece and post up a GOOD quality version of this?
Lypur 3 years ago
wow i cant believe i clicked this video by accident. seriously i've been searching for this song for almost half a year! no joke!! man, i wish i could hug you!!
winxcat 3 years ago
almost a year? wow, well interesting what you stumble over hey? Well, hugs are never a bad thing...well that's not true, a hug from a sweaty dude who hasn't showered for a month is not good... anyway ^_^ thanks for the comment
Lypur 3 years ago
This was the very first song i ever learn't. I played it very slowly and without the left hand haha.
qwertyasdyaln 3 years ago
haha! wow you really picked a brutal song to start as your first song! This isn't the hardest song in the world, but it definitely is not the easiest, especially for a beginner to learn! :)
Lypur 3 years ago
I know. I decided to play a grade 6 song rustle of springs after 12 weeks of playing.
qwertyasdyaln 3 years ago
I'm learning this right now, slow practice is helping, its only hard when i play it at the right speed, and i'm the only one ever of my piano teachers students to have learnt it.... or learning it i should say....
aalg4c 3 years ago
ur hair look.... small :P
darkangel5968 3 years ago
Però ci vuole ELEGANZA anche quando si ha terminato di suonare!!
moemichan77 3 years ago
I no How to play that Song but i don`t think i could Play it as well as you did
TAYLER49 3 years ago
aww thanks! Hey awesome, you can play it to?! cool! I'd love to see a video some time
Lypur 3 years ago
NICE JOB MAN!!!!! I noticed you missed a few notes but it still sounds good. Nice job. ^_^
ItachiUchiha090987 3 years ago
Im on your Lesson no. 2 (^o^)/, i hope someday i can play these pieces too.
unkn0wnartists 3 years ago
bravo! amazing interpretation. you are truly talented.
snowboardracer 3 years ago
thank you very much ^_^ i'm glad you enjoyed it
Lypur 3 years ago
OMFG HOLY !@#$!!!!!!!!i wish i could play like that lol
Tutchmydog 4 years ago
lmfao! I love your reaction there! :D made me smile, then laugh. Thanks for that ^_^
Lypur 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
cut out the last D flat - sounds retarded - otherwise, very nice.
danenhod 4 years ago
bravo!!!
196823 4 years ago
you cant keep the same speed through out the whole song
w4113t 4 years ago
sorry, this piece wasn't polished when i played it. I played it much better before, but thanks anyway
Lypur 4 years ago
you´ve got excellent speed in the beginning, keep it up!
Piukkulintu 4 years ago 3
AAaaa te quedo super bien! me encanto! I like it alot....i really want to learn this song! GOod job!
luna9025 4 years ago
the begining its a bit fast
sotelomuniz 4 years ago
yea, i didn't acsidently play that speed, my intention was to be quick, and there weren't any wrong notes until the very end where i hit a G instead of the A coming down. This is my fast version of the song, i have a slower more emotional version. but in this video i was going for speed ^_^
Lypur 4 years ago
i didn't hear the wrong note. and when was there that extra note at the end?
thundercat287 4 years ago
on the final scale/passage i hit a G# instead of the A.... *sniff*
Lypur 4 years ago
the speed is actually very good
TIKTAKTO2 4 years ago 2
thank you ^_^
Lypur 4 years ago
muito rápido! :D
thiagolennon1 4 years ago
Hi! I'm studying piano too, I have a question, in how much time could you pratice that?
Minuet9 4 years ago
mmmm...maybe 3-4 months to get it learnt and polished...but it really depends on your ability
Lypur 4 years ago
the middle section is the harder part of this.and it's hard to resist making it flashy,when it's really a salon piece.you need to respect chopin's score.your ending was awful and ruined the rest of the performance.
strokerbn 4 years ago
I'm quite aware this isn't the best i can do. I have tendonitous in both my arms as a side effect from medication i was forced to take because of a random heart condition i developed...it's a long story...I recorded this when i thought i might never be able to play again. This was one of my favorite songs from about 2 years earlier, so it was unpolished....
Lypur 4 years ago
hen i had it all polished up I got standing ovations for this song always played it note perfect, and the most respected teacher and adjudicator in all the north said it was the best version of the song she's ever heard including the Chopin international competition. Your comment seemed pretty darn negative though? I looked you up and other people have talked about your negative comments...do you just like picking other people apart to make yourself feel better?
Lypur 4 years ago
not at all...i only commented on your vid to even the score with another user who you seemed to be rather too harsh with as well.touche?
strokerbn 4 years ago
ah, well sorry for the misunderstanding ^_^
Lypur 4 years ago
lypur i have re-recorded my version of this waltz, i would like to know your opinion, i will not attack, lol. there are only a few of us to share the information knowing the piece deeply
davidwe 4 years ago
i think u played amazingly ... simple as. well done!
jaina100 4 years ago
i can see that you enjoyed the song by playing it fast, but it's originally supposed to be a little bit slower. but im' not critizing at all in any way, good job 5 stars.
superspartan7171 4 years ago
I am actually learning this song right now, you did really good in my opinion, inspired to keep on trucking...haha, keep it up man
anthfrazier 4 years ago
Your good, you have nice control and your right hand and left hand blend properly. However, in my opinion the middle is played too slow, along with the rest of the piece. And the speed will come to you with more practice. Also, you should add more emotion to your playing. Your good, but thats the difference between good and great. :)
Borshkin 4 years ago
actually i gave you 4 stars twice
davidwe 4 years ago
well, you said there were "soo many wrong notes" where there only a few, 5, maybe 6? but you were right it needs more work but its always the same.... more work, a nd.. you critiziced my work so i did the same, what you wanted is really difficult to do with a fast waltz, you need to practise every day at least playing other things to have your hands ready, i didn't want to insult either,i think emotion is the first thing on chopin, good work anyway!
davidwe 4 years ago
i think that piano is not good enough for you.
davidwe 4 years ago
well, i guess all that would be your opinion. I can agree i played this with less than satisfactory emotion, i used to play this song better when I practiced it regularly. When I made this recording I had just relearnt the song that day, and only wanted a recording of it, because my tendonitous was getting really bad and I was scared I would never be able to play this song again.
Lypur 4 years ago
I think you're getting just a tad defensive over the whole thing, i wasn't trying to insult you, i accepted your video response didn't i?
Lypur 4 years ago
i think your interpretacion is boring than mine,and this is because of the sonority, the center passage has to be a bit faster in my opinion, the crescendo is not good enough in the trino to finish on forte.you dont make nearly any difference in the whole work it seems is always forte, and buy some good microphones!!lol
davidwe 4 years ago
in the beginning the acommpaniment sounds too much, it is a very similar end to the barenboim's one in one recital that is here on youtube. even with mistakes i prefer my recording,eh?lol, your recording is like a robot playing the piano, and there's no emotion, barenboim get's emotion on chopin recording's and pollini as well, that's what i thnk,it is not cientific, lol.
davidwe 4 years ago
Well done bro, great skills, keep doing your thing it is definitely worth it!
mille90210 4 years ago
thanks alot ^_^
Lypur 4 years ago
You played it PERFECTLY (except one slip at the end.) ;)
But it was simply AWESOME!!! I play this a tad slower, and my hands slip off the black keys. How do you keep them there?
Tlllllllllllllll 4 years ago
thanks you for the nice comment! the key to playing this song is, keep your arm above the keys, i think of my arms like it's in the clouds, and my fingers are far away enough so that when i extend them they can just barely reach the keys, this gives it that fast light sound. I could show you more in real life, but yea...you don't live in Prince George BC Canada by any chance?
Lypur 4 years ago
I think you have all the notes down well. Needs a little more effect though. Add "drama" or more emotion to the songs transitions. Slow and easy in some parts. Good Job though. It's a tough music.
mrsuavecs 4 years ago
way better than ur old one, lol. u added more dynamics but it's still not enough to amuse people. again, try to be loud at the climaxes, that is how Chopin wanted. Watch my Minute Waltz hopefully coming soon, you'll understand what i mean!!!
kevinthepianist3 4 years ago
Oh, you did see it, I didn't see this comment when i left my other reply. Yea, I'd love to see your version of it, when you get it on here, send me a message and attach the video to it. Thanks
Lypur 4 years ago
I really like the way you play this. I started learning this piece about five weeks ago. I'm doing well with it, but now I need to work on the speed. Thanks for the encouragement!
pianochick1 4 years ago
No problem ^_^, thanks for the comment. Good luck learning it!! it's a very fun song to play!
Lypur 4 years ago
nice job. I enjoy it. You make it look so easy
misschica51 4 years ago
Thanks! it's funny you say that you think i made it look easy. That's actually the key to playing this song. You need to keep your arms just above the keys, kind of like suspending your arms above, and let your hands float across the keys. While i'm playing this song, i just say "play it easy, play it easy, it's easy" over and over in my head ^_^ and it's funny, just saying that actually makes it easy!
Lypur 4 years ago
actually very impressive, and seems so effortless, good stuff.
MattTheOak 5 years ago
nice job, i just started this song today, tried sight reading the 1st page lol, (im 16)
lonewolf604 5 years ago
Nice man, I'm currently working on this song for an audition at a college I'm attending next year, almost finished the second part of it. But that was well done
Craigc30 5 years ago
thanks, i'm glad you liked it
Lypur 5 years ago
nice piano your dad is rich? lol
teriwoos 5 years ago
no...:S i work a full time job and a part time job to pay for it...
Lypur 5 years ago
I love this song - this is one of the songs I always know how to play LOL even when I've been out of the game. Even though I'm not playing anymore, I think your technique is awesome =) When did you start learning?
irisx 5 years ago
I started when i was 5 years old. I know what you mean, about being out of the game. I've had tendonitous for about a year now. but I still love to play this song...I'm sure it isn't good for me to play it...but i love it!
Lypur 5 years ago
it's a yamaha 5'3 baby grand
Lypur 5 years ago
Well played and the piano sounds very good...what make is your new piano?
grodob 5 years ago