Creo que lo mas importante en la manera en que ellos enseñan es el hecho de las obras llegan temprano y no luego de un frustrado cantidad de libros de tecnica que tambien son dificiles 維也納音樂教育 muy bien deberas corregir la afinacion y los libros de tecnica pero esta claro q tienes un gran talento
uhm...I wouldn't say this is exactly a piece where you would smile very much since it's very intense,and the style of this piece is not a piece where you would sway with the flow of the music. Music is a talent and a gift. Some people cannot tell a note worth a shit,and some can hear the slightest off pitch. But also, the difference in your work ethics and how much you are pushed to your limits can determine your skill. Not race.
Have you guys missed the most OBVIOUS clue here? She is Asian. I have nothing against Asians, but it is a plain fact that this kind of thing is far too common among this ethnicity. It is not because Asians are good at everything. It is Asian society influencing the parents to push their children harder and harder. Trust me, you can tell if one is enjoying their instrument.
i dnt knw what everyones complaining about. she looks like she's pretty into it to me, her body may not be "swaying" but her hands seem to be enjoing themselves :3
You can do a scientific study teaching a selected group to play a difficult song. After 1000h practice (just 1 song) see how many can play it?
Gymnasts from E Europe (places like Romania & Bulgaria) used to get gold medals in competitions. You put kids in environment with few distractions (TV, movie theatres, video games), I am sure they'd be successful doing what they're trained for...
For her age she did good but I feel like this piece is for someone who can handle a lot of vibrato and have wide range if emotion while not having any trouble getting the notes right. She looks very bored and lineage doesn't want to play it. But she definitely has some talent
I am not sure if some people understand what it takes to be a virtuoso...
Talent obviously has some part, but it's more practice than talent...I would recommend all of you guys to read "Outliers" by Malcom Gladwell...he talks about 10,000 hours of practice to be excellent on something...this could be playing the violin or playing the piano or even computer programming...
If you think about how to get to 10,000 hours by 10 years old, or even 20 years old, you can do the math on how many hours a
The child prodigy doesn't exist, but only more or less talented children and you can only help them with more or less success, but not forcing them for a long period, if they don't accept your "offer" (the same like force them to eat something they don't like).
Than, the "artificial talent" doesn't exist, but only more or less of the talent.
But one thing is "natural": there are a lot of persons like "audrrey..." who've been forced to became the racist, or, at least, to live without criteria!
How can someone say this is ARTIFICIAL talent? There is no such thing. Playing this well doesn't come simply from technique and practice. There needs to be emotion BEHIND the playing for it to sound this amazing. Sure, you can create melodies with proper technique, but to create music like this you need to have a love for what you're doing. This girl is obviously taking this seriously, and think about it. She's in front of a large crowd. OF COURSE she's going to take it seriously!
Do you know that Christianity is correct? The world around us reveals that G-d DOES exist, and the historical evidence reveals that Jesus Christ really did come to this earth and there is overwhelming evidence that Jesus Christ really did physically rise from the dead. Jesus is coming again and the signs of the end times that were foretold in the Bible are coming to pass.
I don't know if is an artificial talent or not..I hope for her only only to like what she is doing and I hope she has enough time for play with toys and dolls because also if she has a so straordinary talent I don't think she wants to spend hour and hour of her little days on the tuning, technic of bowing and shiftings.I really hope for her.
Wow, aznsoul3, you think it's a real talent? Do you know what is music? When I heard this, I was shocked and flustered, I wondered did she handle vibration, the espagnol feeling, or even find the notes. NO NO NO
how she learnt it is all through her own hard work even if it is the result of being forced every one keep leaving such coments saying she's being forced to do this and it's artificial talent but if she didn't practice she wouldn't be this good i think it is unfair to her. going through with all the practice just to hear everyone criticise her???????
true, but parental pressure is not all bad. in fact, parental pressure is key to most childrens' success (in moderation however). we also cannot assume from this video that she is being forced simply because of her pensive mood and facial expression.
This is an excellent performance for a child. Emotion and character is developed with time, but it is wonderful she is learning these pieces now and developing her technique. Later she can revisit these pieces and play it with the maturity of age. In addition, you can see from her movements that she has a lot of natural talent for the instrument, and the main problems are intonation, which is a matter of better technique (not emotion!).
Way to go! Continue developing your technique when young!
The highest notes in a phrase are always out. Strange, when the other notes are all totally accurate and crystal-clear. Winning a competition like this, the only decisive factor is her age. If I were her parents I wouldn't proudly post this. It's an emotional piece and emotionally she's far from perfect. 'Emotional' practice comes with age, so whoever chose the piece isn't thinking properly too. Could have taken something straight off Vivaldi / Bach, would do even better and perfect the piece.
I think she enjoys playing the violin, but not to the extent that he parents force her to play it. In fact, because of the pressure from her parent she may even have developed a bit of a dislike for it. Also, it's a lot of pressure to be a prodigy, as Itzhak said most prodigies burn out before they have a chance to become truly successful. It'll only be 7 years until this girl is 14 and we all know what can happen to children at that age.
To all the people complaining about how she doesn't understand the music or anything: Get a life. The end. No matter what you think, you have to admit: this kid has great technique. She sure does look like she's into the music. I know that I always look angry and grouchy when I play performances.
how do you people know she doesn't enjoy the violin and she was forced to? just because she's not smiling doesn't mean she doesn't like to play the violin.
She's got talent, but she has needs to work A LOT on the technical part of her playing AND this piece. Maybe its her teacher was too eager, but later, she's going to regret it. If she goes on like this, she will have to spend around 4 YEARS fixing everything. She needs to slow down and actually get that violin working properly
People who claim this as artificial talent must be jealous. Unlike people playing video games all day, she probably treats music as an enjoyment instead, much more productive I'd think. And how do u tell that she's not enjoying playing? That she's not "swaying" enough? That she's not smiling while playing? Different people have different playing styles. Learn to accept that and the fact that some people are just more talented at a younger age.
Okay, since we're both asians here, I think we would both understand what is happening.
I am trying to not stereotype, but I really don't expect her to be playing video games, especially at this age, and when she has high expectations of her violin playing. But I guess you are right that I shouldn't be assuming that she doesn't enjoy playing. ^-^
This girl likely lives in China, and it's expected that this stuff happens. But idk, she could be a future world player. You never know.
as a taiwanese violin player who has played this symphonie, i can say that she does have talent but its clear that she doesnt enjoy playing the violin. i get how she feels. however, as i have gotten older, although my parents still force me to practice, i have grown to express myself through music and enjoy it more. so, she has hope in that respect. i hope this girl sees this comment, because you are really really great and have so much potential if you learn to love it.
i am half tawianese and i also play the violin, and im currently working on this concerto at the age of fourteen. Compared to her, im not very good :P but in my little hometown im really good, and i know a lot about asian parents dealing with talent. thing is, they do push. and yes, i have experienced forced practice, and it isnt fun. but its not like they actually abuse her! (most likely) yes, it is a gift, but if you hate it like i do, its also a curse :(
herpaderpaderpderp I don't care if she's 5 and cries she's gonna practice 25 hours a day. What's that? You hungry? Win some fucking awards and then we'll talk.
@OrianaDiazL You make me sick. They're not Chinese. Look, it says Taiwan. Yes they do have childhood. Just because they're Asian doesn't mean that their parents force them to play the violin. Some people actually LIKE to play on their own without any forcing from their parents.
@theviolinmusicfan I didn't read the description, man! Well, I just said so becasue I have chinese friends whose children are forced to...But honestly it is not about me or abput what U think but about the little girls talent :) Oops!!! She's cute, by the way :) Oh.. take your medicine.. I made U sick XD
@audreyeatworld Artificial? what do u mean? I just think it is normal for them to play like that!! :)And yes.. I agree with u when y say they are forced.. My friends' children are..... but who knows.. they like it as well XD and this little girl plays really good :):)
@audreyeatworld ya...she is good,but something is kinda missing...I guess I can say that she is VERY good technically,but still "immature" for a hard musical piece like this.The music and the passion is not really coming out...
Artificial talent?? What does that mean for a 7 year old who can play better than most undergraduate music students?
She has a lot of natural talent, and if she is not discourage by comments such as yours, she may develop into a wonderful musician by the time she is a teenager.
This is wonderful playing by a very young child, it is truly admirable. Keep learning! We wish you all good things for your future!!
Aight, that comment was posted 9 months ago, 3 cool points for you.
Okay, you are right that I shouldn't judge her without knowing her story, but that also goes for you. However, it's not only possible, but likely that she has been forced to get to this standard by her parents. That's just how it works in China. But I do wish her luck, I just hope she hasn't been staying inside practicing Espagnole, instead of playing outside with her friends.
@audreyeatworld I looked up Elli Choi and I really don't see how you can come to the conclusion, based on watching this video, that the girl in this video has been forced and is "artificial" and Elli hasn't and is "natural." You think that because this girl is from China (it's Taiwan, FYI) and some children there are forced, then she is? But Asian children in the US, Korea, etc. also deal with that stereotype, and doesn't that mean Elli had to have been forced too?
I am chinese myself and I know that most are forced; not some. Elli Choi discovered her love for violin. I don't know how this girl began to play violin, but it's actually likely that her parents insisted her into learning the instrument.
Also, that comment was posted a year ago. You can read my renewed opinion further through the comments.
@audreyeatworld If you listen closely and more carefully, she's actually got something going on. Plus, she's got a brilliant stage presence going on for someone her age, and if the performance was artificial, that aura wouldn't be there.
soo... who wants to guess how many times this kid was beaten into playing the right notes at home?? just like the little miss pageants contestants are....
Firstly it sound boring... But after awhile it shock me! It is so unbelievable! Oh my gosh! She's expression is so good... It is good if she become a teacher next time.
Firstly it sound boring... But after awhile it shock me! It is so unbelievable! Oh my gosh! She's expression is so good... It is good if she become a teacher next time.
Her musicality is AMAZING - I'd love to see her again in a couple years when her arms and fingers have grown a bit and she's graduated to a full size violin - oh the things she could do then.
One in a million are BORN with this gift. Don't blame the parents for "pushing" her. She's a natural! No kind of pushing of the rest of the million kids will produce what you see here.
One in a million are BORN with this gift. Don't blame the parents for "pushing" her. She's a natural! No kind of pushing of the rest of the million kids will produce what you see here.
Little Star, congratulations, you are a miracle. Keep up the good work and enjoy the results of your dedication... and sometimes let everyone know, that you indeed enjoy playing the violin.
I am very excited to see a little girl from my hometown doing so well. I am wondering why any child who is great in playing an instrument has to be pushed by his/her parents.
She will eventually rise above. My daughter is 7 and plays on a half size, and is terribly unchallenged by the more childlike songs. It depends on the kid, she may have violinists in her family that play this piece and has learned by listening or playing along... I think she is great and ba humbug to all the neg. commentators!
I find so endearing that she is playing this piece at seven years old and she still has placement stickers on her bow. Also it sounds crappy because how good of quality do you expect a quarter or even half size of a violin to be?
I'd say she's talented....or just has been practicing a lot and stuff...but I really don't like her sound. It's not very nice, sounds kinda crappy, like I'm surprised she can play this concerto the way she sounds. I mean I know this piece isn't easy, I mean I'm working on Lalo's Cello Concerto now, but I don't know, I don't think her sound has matured enough. Plus I hear chinese violins are crappy, and if she has one, that could explain a few things about the sound.
it may be torturous for her to have to practice so much. if she's practicing 7 hrs a day, it's not as much of a gift as one sees in this video. and it's only torture if she doesn't enjoy it. most of the time, these child stars are pushed by parents.
yeah, of course she's not as good as an adult violinist (intonation/bow, that stuff). but you must consider that the sound would be a lot better if she played with a 4/4 violin
Although it is played very well for her age, I agree with queenofthevideos: she should play something that is more suiting her age. She will have time to play the really difficult music, and now it is more like learning a trick.
This piece is beyond her. I bet she would be excellent if she tried something easier. She should work on her vibrato, its too slow and maybe she should try this piece when she has a bigger violin because the high notes dont sound that good.
Vibrato has many different colors to some pieces in this case her vibrato is just fine. but she could very well indeed use a little more RED (or whatever) in her vibrato for some parts of this piece like when she shifts into the higher notes for instance.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
guys dont feel so ashamed. shes completely out of tune. and her little extra articulations ruin the mood and spanish theme of this piece. this is a horrible performance.
is that a joke? I won a competition with this piece -- $500. i don't care how old she is, if you're going to play and perform a piece, it better be good, otherwise don't play it.
she has quite a few intonation issues. even though this was 'great' for her age, i dont think that she should, rather anyone, should be symphonie espagnol at such a young age as this. bravi anyway though. :)
Creo que lo mas importante en la manera en que ellos enseñan es el hecho de las obras llegan temprano y no luego de un frustrado cantidad de libros de tecnica que tambien son dificiles 維也納音樂教育 muy bien deberas corregir la afinacion y los libros de tecnica pero esta claro q tienes un gran talento
frankcisyarmi 1 day ago
uhm...I wouldn't say this is exactly a piece where you would smile very much since it's very intense,and the style of this piece is not a piece where you would sway with the flow of the music. Music is a talent and a gift. Some people cannot tell a note worth a shit,and some can hear the slightest off pitch. But also, the difference in your work ethics and how much you are pushed to your limits can determine your skill. Not race.
MontblancChan 1 week ago
Fantastic sound and energy, speed of bow, concentration, technique... Good for her! Bravo to her teacher, and congratulations to this girl.
kirinphoebe1 1 week ago
Level:ASIAN
suzerhande 1 week ago
I'm 13 and i can't play as well as her :( .....psh..... asians....wait i'm asian.. does that mean i'm a bad kid?
inkymouse123 2 weeks ago
@inkymouse123 No, it just means you mom needs to be sent to Tiger Mom Training Camp ;-)
LorenzoNW 1 week ago
Have you guys missed the most OBVIOUS clue here? She is Asian. I have nothing against Asians, but it is a plain fact that this kind of thing is far too common among this ethnicity. It is not because Asians are good at everything. It is Asian society influencing the parents to push their children harder and harder. Trust me, you can tell if one is enjoying their instrument.
xXL3GITAMACYXx1 2 weeks ago
Bravo. :-))
meiangie 2 weeks ago
A pesar de sus 7 añitos y vena la seriedad y madurez con que toca!!! maravillosa...
Luchitaviolinful 2 weeks ago
Asian
TheCombatArmspwner 2 weeks ago
Champion of Vienna Cup...NOT an easy win!!!
lago4 2 weeks ago
She has excellent control, fine technique....a real pro at such a young age....spoken by an ex violinist
vandijkav 3 weeks ago
Her technique and artistry are really good! This is really impressive.
periola 4 weeks ago
Random comment: I like that crisp snap she's got going on at the end of certain notes^^ The pianist's playing was beautiful, also :D
NIPPONkidd 4 weeks ago
sehr schön! Wunderschön!! <3
Meerjungfraumann93 1 month ago
Artificial talent? That's probably the dumbest thing I've ever heard!!
Talent is talent.
csdyson13 1 month ago 4
i dnt knw what everyones complaining about. she looks like she's pretty into it to me, her body may not be "swaying" but her hands seem to be enjoing themselves :3
alfredchick09 1 month ago
That is the hardest music in the whole world!! You know, I'm an amateur violinist.
SailormoonLexi2002 1 month ago
For her age the technique is very good...
You can do a scientific study teaching a selected group to play a difficult song. After 1000h practice (just 1 song) see how many can play it?
Gymnasts from E Europe (places like Romania & Bulgaria) used to get gold medals in competitions. You put kids in environment with few distractions (TV, movie theatres, video games), I am sure they'd be successful doing what they're trained for...
thepianoplayer416 1 month ago
For her age she did good but I feel like this piece is for someone who can handle a lot of vibrato and have wide range if emotion while not having any trouble getting the notes right. She looks very bored and lineage doesn't want to play it. But she definitely has some talent
Peanutbuttrluv 1 month ago
I am not sure if some people understand what it takes to be a virtuoso...
Talent obviously has some part, but it's more practice than talent...I would recommend all of you guys to read "Outliers" by Malcom Gladwell...he talks about 10,000 hours of practice to be excellent on something...this could be playing the violin or playing the piano or even computer programming...
If you think about how to get to 10,000 hours by 10 years old, or even 20 years old, you can do the math on how many hours a
mtopbas 1 month ago
The child prodigy doesn't exist, but only more or less talented children and you can only help them with more or less success, but not forcing them for a long period, if they don't accept your "offer" (the same like force them to eat something they don't like).
Than, the "artificial talent" doesn't exist, but only more or less of the talent.
But one thing is "natural": there are a lot of persons like "audrrey..." who've been forced to became the racist, or, at least, to live without criteria!
setta50 1 month ago
How can someone say this is ARTIFICIAL talent? There is no such thing. Playing this well doesn't come simply from technique and practice. There needs to be emotion BEHIND the playing for it to sound this amazing. Sure, you can create melodies with proper technique, but to create music like this you need to have a love for what you're doing. This girl is obviously taking this seriously, and think about it. She's in front of a large crowd. OF COURSE she's going to take it seriously!
xAbbiChanx 1 month ago 2
Comment removed
audreyeatworld 1 month ago
thats disgusting..
Kullervo884 1 month ago
she is a genius.
blessing!
joosangbai 2 months ago
how does she memorize that???????????? she is really good
violinsforever12 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Do you know that Christianity is correct? The world around us reveals that G-d DOES exist, and the historical evidence reveals that Jesus Christ really did come to this earth and there is overwhelming evidence that Jesus Christ really did physically rise from the dead. Jesus is coming again and the signs of the end times that were foretold in the Bible are coming to pass.
marionetemanJ 2 months ago
I don't know if is an artificial talent or not..I hope for her only only to like what she is doing and I hope she has enough time for play with toys and dolls because also if she has a so straordinary talent I don't think she wants to spend hour and hour of her little days on the tuning, technic of bowing and shiftings.I really hope for her.
Lusciaa 2 months ago
I'm learning this at 12 :\
ButterflyAlleyCat 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
search SnapShot Boys the click back to this page YOUTUBES VERY OWN GLITCH lol @ CameraCrewFilms pointed it Out
topsquadcross 2 months ago
Wow! ...and by memory!
jaykay1053 2 months ago
Wow, aznsoul3, you think it's a real talent? Do you know what is music? When I heard this, I was shocked and flustered, I wondered did she handle vibration, the espagnol feeling, or even find the notes. NO NO NO
apluspianist 3 months ago
HOLY CRABCAKES
Tigeratheart 3 months ago
Good performance for a youngster. I'd suggest giving her a chromatic tuner.
Calebless 3 months ago
how she learnt it is all through her own hard work even if it is the result of being forced every one keep leaving such coments saying she's being forced to do this and it's artificial talent but if she didn't practice she wouldn't be this good i think it is unfair to her. going through with all the practice just to hear everyone criticise her???????
lisayuxinyu 3 months ago
true, but parental pressure is not all bad. in fact, parental pressure is key to most childrens' success (in moderation however). we also cannot assume from this video that she is being forced simply because of her pensive mood and facial expression.
ConquistadorAlfred 3 months ago
Out of pitch, no espagnol music's feeling, more slower than the original speed!
She was definitely forced to play this hard piece.
apluspianist 3 months ago 2
how many years old is he
qvhuyhn 3 months ago
Comment removed
qvhuyhn 3 months ago
bravo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
11171117100 4 months ago
this isn't helping the asian-musico-superiority-theorem..... she's been playing since she was a zygote...
JazzBluesClassical42 4 months ago 2
This is an excellent performance for a child. Emotion and character is developed with time, but it is wonderful she is learning these pieces now and developing her technique. Later she can revisit these pieces and play it with the maturity of age. In addition, you can see from her movements that she has a lot of natural talent for the instrument, and the main problems are intonation, which is a matter of better technique (not emotion!).
Way to go! Continue developing your technique when young!
expgnwlf 4 months ago
Comment removed
expgnwlf 4 months ago
음정이전혀않맞다ㅋ,,
choisubin96 5 months ago
@choisubin96 dude i know lollll....
jslee12 5 months ago
bravo
winston050 6 months ago
The highest notes in a phrase are always out. Strange, when the other notes are all totally accurate and crystal-clear. Winning a competition like this, the only decisive factor is her age. If I were her parents I wouldn't proudly post this. It's an emotional piece and emotionally she's far from perfect. 'Emotional' practice comes with age, so whoever chose the piece isn't thinking properly too. Could have taken something straight off Vivaldi / Bach, would do even better and perfect the piece.
chungtinlong 6 months ago
Technically it's good... but it's just too unnatural. I'm learning this piece, and it's quite hard.
ButterflyAlleyCat 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
respect
IliutaValentinIonut 6 months ago
respect
IliutaValentinIonut 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think she should look up Ellie Choi. They are both very good.
sayanikaeya 7 months ago
Ii think she should look up Ellie Choi. They are both very good.
sayanikaeya 7 months ago
I think she enjoys playing the violin, but not to the extent that he parents force her to play it. In fact, because of the pressure from her parent she may even have developed a bit of a dislike for it. Also, it's a lot of pressure to be a prodigy, as Itzhak said most prodigies burn out before they have a chance to become truly successful. It'll only be 7 years until this girl is 14 and we all know what can happen to children at that age.
Ekskaliberr 7 months ago
she also has great intonation, and very mature phrasing especially for her age.
jin12345678 8 months ago
To all the people complaining about how she doesn't understand the music or anything: Get a life. The end. No matter what you think, you have to admit: this kid has great technique. She sure does look like she's into the music. I know that I always look angry and grouchy when I play performances.
missngbrownie 8 months ago
i think she is way too young to understand the music... playing an instument isn't only about tehnic and, in this case, intonation...
singuralka 9 months ago
Pauvre petite....
On imagine pas le travail qu'elle a dû subir pour en arriver là. Elle n'a pas de plaisir à jouer, ça s'entend et c'est normal..
Elle tient la vitesse, fait ses preuves au niveau de la technique mais ce qu'on ne lui a jamais appris, c'est aimer...
Et c'est indiscutable, c'est ce qui fait la différence entre amateurs et grands.
Mais elle a le temps de grandir...
Bonne chance à elle
cecechant 9 months ago
how do you people know she doesn't enjoy the violin and she was forced to? just because she's not smiling doesn't mean she doesn't like to play the violin.
MusicalBunny1 10 months ago
ugh fuckin asians, i cant stand this shyt
NYCroxmysocks 10 months ago
She's got talent, but she has needs to work A LOT on the technical part of her playing AND this piece. Maybe its her teacher was too eager, but later, she's going to regret it. If she goes on like this, she will have to spend around 4 YEARS fixing everything. She needs to slow down and actually get that violin working properly
mattkim824 10 months ago
c'est un peu faux tout de même.
KARYUWORLD 10 months ago
this is sickening.
getdeported 10 months ago
People who claim this as artificial talent must be jealous. Unlike people playing video games all day, she probably treats music as an enjoyment instead, much more productive I'd think. And how do u tell that she's not enjoying playing? That she's not "swaying" enough? That she's not smiling while playing? Different people have different playing styles. Learn to accept that and the fact that some people are just more talented at a younger age.
aznsoul3 10 months ago 30
@aznsoul3 , i agree. i think the reason she isn't smiling is because she's nervous.
mchanviolin99 10 months ago
@aznsoul3
Okay, since we're both asians here, I think we would both understand what is happening.
I am trying to not stereotype, but I really don't expect her to be playing video games, especially at this age, and when she has high expectations of her violin playing. But I guess you are right that I shouldn't be assuming that she doesn't enjoy playing. ^-^
This girl likely lives in China, and it's expected that this stuff happens. But idk, she could be a future world player. You never know.
audreyeatworld 9 months ago
@aznsoul3 In addiction: Did usually musicians giggling while playing instruments?
lailaefederico 1 month ago
She is so little and she's playing this. Either she practices 5 hours every day or she's magic. Is that a half size violin
pluebin 11 months ago
99.99999999999(well you get the idea)% of the violinists in the world got pwned
mchanviolin99 11 months ago
Phantastisches Geigenspiel, die Kleine wird eine ganz Große
musikus48 11 months ago
child exploitation much?
dropsoffaith 11 months ago
as a taiwanese violin player who has played this symphonie, i can say that she does have talent but its clear that she doesnt enjoy playing the violin. i get how she feels. however, as i have gotten older, although my parents still force me to practice, i have grown to express myself through music and enjoy it more. so, she has hope in that respect. i hope this girl sees this comment, because you are really really great and have so much potential if you learn to love it.
Irisflower42 1 year ago
to everybody:
i am half tawianese and i also play the violin, and im currently working on this concerto at the age of fourteen. Compared to her, im not very good :P but in my little hometown im really good, and i know a lot about asian parents dealing with talent. thing is, they do push. and yes, i have experienced forced practice, and it isnt fun. but its not like they actually abuse her! (most likely) yes, it is a gift, but if you hate it like i do, its also a curse :(
Irisflower42 1 year ago
wat is this i dont even
herpaderpaderpderp I don't care if she's 5 and cries she's gonna practice 25 hours a day. What's that? You hungry? Win some fucking awards and then we'll talk.
Yif14 1 year ago
EXCELLENTE.. PERFECT.. but.. Do chinese children ever have a childhood??
OrianaDiazL 1 year ago
@OrianaDiazL You make me sick. They're not Chinese. Look, it says Taiwan. Yes they do have childhood. Just because they're Asian doesn't mean that their parents force them to play the violin. Some people actually LIKE to play on their own without any forcing from their parents.
theviolinmusicfan 1 year ago
@theviolinmusicfan I didn't read the description, man! Well, I just said so becasue I have chinese friends whose children are forced to...But honestly it is not about me or abput what U think but about the little girls talent :) Oops!!! She's cute, by the way :) Oh.. take your medicine.. I made U sick XD
OrianaDiazL 1 year ago
look at that straight pinky
XnepoX 1 year ago
musicality- 10/10 for her age
technicality- 5/10 why play a piece like this so early? it's too technically advanced for her age and physique
Jctankk 1 year ago 3
你很好!
kiop9000 1 year ago
She has real talent, but I think it's artificial talent... she looks like she's been forced to do this :/
If you want to see a child prodigy who actually really understands and LOVES the violin, you should search Elli Choi.
audreyeatworld 1 year ago 18
@audreyeatworld Artificial? what do u mean? I just think it is normal for them to play like that!! :)And yes.. I agree with u when y say they are forced.. My friends' children are..... but who knows.. they like it as well XD and this little girl plays really good :):)
OrianaDiazL 1 year ago
@audreyeatworld ya...she is good,but something is kinda missing...I guess I can say that she is VERY good technically,but still "immature" for a hard musical piece like this.The music and the passion is not really coming out...
MisteriosaVampiria 7 months ago
@audreyeatworld
Artificial talent?? What does that mean for a 7 year old who can play better than most undergraduate music students?
She has a lot of natural talent, and if she is not discourage by comments such as yours, she may develop into a wonderful musician by the time she is a teenager.
This is wonderful playing by a very young child, it is truly admirable. Keep learning! We wish you all good things for your future!!
expgnwlf 4 months ago
@expgnwlf
Aight, that comment was posted 9 months ago, 3 cool points for you.
Okay, you are right that I shouldn't judge her without knowing her story, but that also goes for you. However, it's not only possible, but likely that she has been forced to get to this standard by her parents. That's just how it works in China. But I do wish her luck, I just hope she hasn't been staying inside practicing Espagnole, instead of playing outside with her friends.
audreyeatworld 4 months ago
@audreyeatworld Well, I don't know what you're talking about because she obviously has tons of musicianship.
TheCatholicFaithfu 2 months ago 2
@audreyeatworld thats wat the parrents do if they want the kid to be succsefull they make them pratice 24/7,...
marmarf11 2 months ago
@audreyeatworld I looked up Elli Choi and I really don't see how you can come to the conclusion, based on watching this video, that the girl in this video has been forced and is "artificial" and Elli hasn't and is "natural." You think that because this girl is from China (it's Taiwan, FYI) and some children there are forced, then she is? But Asian children in the US, Korea, etc. also deal with that stereotype, and doesn't that mean Elli had to have been forced too?
bloodredrosez 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bloodredrosez
I am chinese myself and I know that most are forced; not some. Elli Choi discovered her love for violin. I don't know how this girl began to play violin, but it's actually likely that her parents insisted her into learning the instrument.
Also, that comment was posted a year ago. You can read my renewed opinion further through the comments.
audreyeatworld 1 month ago
@audreyeatworld If you listen closely and more carefully, she's actually got something going on. Plus, she's got a brilliant stage presence going on for someone her age, and if the performance was artificial, that aura wouldn't be there.
xxxDolceMelodiesxxx 1 month ago
wow! amazing, to play like this at her age....very big talent, i'm so envious =) =)! i love her!
Kandee90 1 year ago
cuuuute
iluvmusik16 1 year ago
Great player, cute girl, there's talent everywere.
Bravo girl!!!
reginotrevinocastro 1 year ago
not an easy piece to play ,intonation misses slightly on slow passages,the complicated parts she nails almost perfect.
yomotoro 1 year ago
Amazing in every way. Sounds superb!
shortie1845 1 year ago
soo... who wants to guess how many times this kid was beaten into playing the right notes at home?? just like the little miss pageants contestants are....
anyways if this didn't happen its awesome.
havik82 1 year ago 2
for her age.. astounding.. but.. I think there is a lot of ground she should have covered technically before starting something like Lalo...
Mrtchaikovskyful 1 year ago
Bravo!!!!!!!!!!!
robviolin1 1 year ago
i really like the stickers on her bow ;-)
AmelieWuensche 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Firstly it sound boring... But after awhile it shock me! It is so unbelievable! Oh my gosh! She's expression is so good... It is good if she become a teacher next time.
rUshhelI 1 year ago
Firstly it sound boring... But after awhile it shock me! It is so unbelievable! Oh my gosh! She's expression is so good... It is good if she become a teacher next time.
rUshhelI 1 year ago
Her musicality is AMAZING - I'd love to see her again in a couple years when her arms and fingers have grown a bit and she's graduated to a full size violin - oh the things she could do then.
mocchiorox714 1 year ago 2
she amazed me.=) aww
MagicalTalesOfWolves 1 year ago
tht girl is really good! ^^ she's gonna be really talented when she grows up!
petalpop96 1 year ago
great for her age, but she looks really upset.
emilywilliams420 1 year ago
Very cute!
KosteckiAdam 1 year ago 2
God!! how can she plays for that way?? !!! maybe something i´ll can play some instrument!! girl you are awsome!!
07FCV 1 year ago
wow...I'm ALMOST twice as old as her...ok maybe about 3 years older? and I can't play this half as well. it's so CUTE!!! but still really good...:)
chocomarshmallow1 1 year ago 4
One in a million are BORN with this gift. Don't blame the parents for "pushing" her. She's a natural! No kind of pushing of the rest of the million kids will produce what you see here.
How about telling us this kid's name!
AlanHemenway 1 year ago 2
One in a million are BORN with this gift. Don't blame the parents for "pushing" her. She's a natural! No kind of pushing of the rest of the million kids will produce what you see here.
How about telling us this kid's name!
AlanHemenway 1 year ago 3
wow! wow! this is awesome!
hu8777 1 year ago
La petite fillette est toute mignonne! BRAVO!
MisterQuizzz 1 year ago
hamma cool =)
gut gemacht kleines mädchen :D
mariechen1552 1 year ago
Little Star, congratulations, you are a miracle. Keep up the good work and enjoy the results of your dedication... and sometimes let everyone know, that you indeed enjoy playing the violin.
GeorgeOfZala 1 year ago 2
小妹妹提琴拉得很棒。 請繼續努力。
vioguru 1 year ago 2
I am very excited to see a little girl from my hometown doing so well. I am wondering why any child who is great in playing an instrument has to be pushed by his/her parents.
Kudos to her parents!
vioguru 1 year ago
brava!
hanajitarou 1 year ago
wow!!!!
yonghuiAssen 1 year ago
genius! omg bravo!
yscslim 1 year ago
1 of my fav violinists... 5/5 starZ
MagicalTalesOfWolves 1 year ago
good job dear
femzgigo1 1 year ago
Not the best version i ever heard..but for her age its really good...I played this song with the age of 13...
kleindammermann 1 year ago
She will eventually rise above. My daughter is 7 and plays on a half size, and is terribly unchallenged by the more childlike songs. It depends on the kid, she may have violinists in her family that play this piece and has learned by listening or playing along... I think she is great and ba humbug to all the neg. commentators!
thestringdreams 1 year ago
@thestringdreams wait is this your daughter?
tennisbeasta1234 1 year ago
Bravo!
garyi123 2 years ago
gosh shes really good for her age!!! actually, shes good for any age ;)
fiddleheadlyd 2 years ago
Toca muy bien, son en estas cosas donde se ve el trabajo.¿ Me puedes dar las partituras?
housemalaleche 2 years ago
I find so endearing that she is playing this piece at seven years old and she still has placement stickers on her bow. Also it sounds crappy because how good of quality do you expect a quarter or even half size of a violin to be?
jesusatepie 2 years ago 4
There are a lot of things her technique could use, but for her age, this is astounding.
King9Dante 2 years ago
O.M.G!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
brotherandsisteam 2 years ago
heyy is says tht this was in 2004 so like its been five years and how good do u think she is ??? =]
nicee job
dogpaw814 2 years ago
I'd say she's talented....or just has been practicing a lot and stuff...but I really don't like her sound. It's not very nice, sounds kinda crappy, like I'm surprised she can play this concerto the way she sounds. I mean I know this piece isn't easy, I mean I'm working on Lalo's Cello Concerto now, but I don't know, I don't think her sound has matured enough. Plus I hear chinese violins are crappy, and if she has one, that could explain a few things about the sound.
Oathkeeper1992 2 years ago
can u do better?
thakingofchina 2 years ago
BRAVOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
crisboga25 2 years ago
it may be torturous for her to have to practice so much. if she's practicing 7 hrs a day, it's not as much of a gift as one sees in this video. and it's only torture if she doesn't enjoy it. most of the time, these child stars are pushed by parents.
switchfgirl 2 years ago 13
Its not torture. Its a gift.
Violinkoala08 2 years ago
Can someone tell me what Grade level/book this piece is in?
audreyeatworld 2 years ago
сколько ей лет
How old she&&
ViolinaMary 2 years ago
Oh my got!!!You are relly good
anna6913 2 years ago
i never knew how long this song was
Twiddleywinks 2 years ago
imagine how epic she'll be fullgrown with accual weight on her arm
BBoyAsianFlash 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
intonation's flat, scratchy at areas she used shorter bows, rapid bow changes also.
didn't manage to catch certain notes, bow control not nailed in yet.
i'd take valerie and dominique any day
neverendingcycle 2 years ago
calmate maestro, ya quisieras tener esa edad, tocar frente a toda la escuela y ganar esa copa ;)
jaimebricio 2 years ago
yeah, of course she's not as good as an adult violinist (intonation/bow, that stuff). but you must consider that the sound would be a lot better if she played with a 4/4 violin
msdoroc 2 years ago 3
thats good!!!
i like the arrangement for piano too
phoolisness 2 years ago
Nossa, MUITOS BOM!!! PARABÉNS!!
Deus Abençoe cada vez Mais!
spalladeolinda 2 years ago
Should really have five stars
dauiske79 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
One prodigy Asian kid is impressive. Ten thousand of them gets boring.
halneufmille 2 years ago
agreed
Horatiojk 2 years ago
One unknown idiot making a useless comment in a nice video is disregarded. Ten thousand of them gets boring.
verokungfu 2 years ago 4
somehow i feel as if that violin is speaking with a young child's voice....
animaniac126 2 years ago
Although it is played very well for her age, I agree with queenofthevideos: she should play something that is more suiting her age. She will have time to play the really difficult music, and now it is more like learning a trick.
macascu 2 years ago
Wow! Great!
piano6861 2 years ago
That's of course too difficult for her and she must have practiced it a lot, but she did it amazingly well and she seems to enjoy her violin
joanna4659 2 years ago
Parabéns!!! Esta menina emociona o mundo inteiro, não importa em qual idioma pensamos, todos sentimos a preciosidade musical.
ALBINOCARLOS 2 years ago
Comment removed
TimChoFsho 2 years ago
she should take those stickers off of her bow now that she's like good and all!
BeautifulMusic1000 2 years ago
This piece is beyond her. I bet she would be excellent if she tried something easier. She should work on her vibrato, its too slow and maybe she should try this piece when she has a bigger violin because the high notes dont sound that good.
queenofthevideos 2 years ago
Vibrato has many different colors to some pieces in this case her vibrato is just fine. but she could very well indeed use a little more RED (or whatever) in her vibrato for some parts of this piece like when she shifts into the higher notes for instance.
BeautifulMusic1000 2 years ago
in my opinion, i think she shouldnt be playing this, its too hard for her. when shes older, she nail it well!
queenofthevideos 2 years ago
actually, i think she's already nailing it pretty good :)
jenny1340 2 years ago
Shouldnt kids play music for kids? Happy and funny? definitly not Lalo... It just... dont fit :(
still very good. Just not something I expect to hear from young girl.
ManWithManyShurikens 2 years ago 3
Poor kid, I'm sure, her whole childhood consists of 'practice, practice, practice'... rather than friends or playing
smilinwiebke 2 years ago 3
yees she indeed is tortued...lol
sobal79 2 years ago
whats wrong with that?
phoolisness 2 years ago
mui bien tokado bastante bien saludos wapita
Ostirala 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
guys dont feel so ashamed. shes completely out of tune. and her little extra articulations ruin the mood and spanish theme of this piece. this is a horrible performance.
nolie94 2 years ago
I'd like to here you play this better. :P
hurryupsucker 2 years ago
is that a joke? I won a competition with this piece -- $500. i don't care how old she is, if you're going to play and perform a piece, it better be good, otherwise don't play it.
nolie94 2 years ago 2
Maybe you're good maybe your full of sh... I'm sure that if you don't recognize that this kid is fantastic you'll never be a great violinist.
carlospintodacosta 2 years ago
especially when she still has sticker on her bow
nolie94 2 years ago 2
She's like, 2. Give her some credit.
Milky111wtf 2 years ago 18
agreed, this is pretty damn impressive for what, a 6 year old? i mean really. props. i wonder how long it took her to learn it..
oli3654 2 years ago 3
she has quite a few intonation issues. even though this was 'great' for her age, i dont think that she should, rather anyone, should be symphonie espagnol at such a young age as this. bravi anyway though. :)
ninabobina14 2 years ago
I gotta admit, i think she plays better than me;P
slateflash 2 years ago
man. I am a lot older than her and only have the first two pages learned.
blooskies 2 years ago
ridicule
assagatassa 2 years ago
wow. i feel like an idiot. she plays with so much power! i wish i can play the piece this well...
bakanumber1 2 years ago