@Sodikingemblung If you listen carefully, her voice is pretty damn good. IMHO, the guitar work is often じゃま and in-your-face. The dude is obviously very talented, but at times seems to fighting for the spotlight and gets in the way of her performance. If you're into jazz-type ad lib musical wankery, she might seem superfluous, but if you want to appreciate the original song, check out pretty much any other version, with or without her, and then you might appreciate how good she is.
This interpretation of Shima Uta lacks the true spirit of the song. For many generations my family lived on a small island off Nagasaki. So whenever I listen to other performances, the song recalls the lull of the gentle waves and the slow, simple life on the island. Shima Uta should not be so abrasive and rushed.
kinda sounds acustic very interestring but not something I could have playing loud enough for anyone else to hear because its like opera music (both very beatifull, takes a talented pewrson musically to sing) but not something my canadian family would admire, mabe in a sushi resturant.....sad ehhh
Different version of the song for sure, but it sounds pretty empty to me without the sanshin. Sorry if that offends people, it's just my opinion (it's like having Scottish folk music without the bagpipes to me).
What a masterpiece. It left me breathless and anxious, wanting for more. My thoughts overwhelmed me, "if this is a dream please don't awaken me as I would not want it to end".
I want her kimono lol but she is amazing! And I love this song so much. No american song is a beautiful as this! 3
TheJlee2006 3 weeks ago
Pretty Boy!
fukprc 1 month ago
未だかってきいた事の無い、島唄でした...。波動はつたわりましたよ、植田さん。
jyukutyo1 1 month ago
Tenho grande admiração pelo povo japonês, agora, ainda mais. Belíssima canção. Extraordinária CANTORA - Ayumi Ueda; Violonista Perfeito - Nazomi Yamaguchi.
Bravo.
Josmar - Brasil - Pernambuco.
josmarbrito64 2 months ago
THANK YOU I I FOUND IT YATA...
JEMIMA7 3 months ago
wow O_O <3
abrolacerveza 5 months ago
ばかあ
Sodikingemblung 5 months ago
あんた の 声 うるさいよ
Sodikingemblung 5 months ago
@Sodikingemblung If you listen carefully, her voice is pretty damn good. IMHO, the guitar work is often じゃま and in-your-face. The dude is obviously very talented, but at times seems to fighting for the spotlight and gets in the way of her performance. If you're into jazz-type ad lib musical wankery, she might seem superfluous, but if you want to appreciate the original song, check out pretty much any other version, with or without her, and then you might appreciate how good she is.
PhilipSneyd 4 months ago
This sucks!
deftcheng 6 months ago
This song brings back a lot of my childhood memories in Okinawa *sniff*
jouseki 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This interpretation of Shima Uta lacks the true spirit of the song. For many generations my family lived on a small island off Nagasaki. So whenever I listen to other performances, the song recalls the lull of the gentle waves and the slow, simple life on the island. Shima Uta should not be so abrasive and rushed.
laxman9677 11 months ago
Comment removed
laxman9677 11 months ago
try this version. Rimi Natsukawa sings beautifully. 島唄 - 夏川里美 copy paste on you tube search!
lehua16 1 year ago
kinda sounds acustic very interestring but not something I could have playing loud enough for anyone else to hear because its like opera music (both very beatifull, takes a talented pewrson musically to sing) but not something my canadian family would admire, mabe in a sushi resturant.....sad ehhh
crazymanthomas1654 1 year ago
do not combine the japanese traditional music to western classical music ok!
ToshiieOdaTokugawa 1 year ago
@ToshiieOdaTokugawa
why not? shimauta is not sacred. relax, and open your mind, ok!
libertango779 1 year ago
@ToshiieOdaTokugawa dny8ayuro wasnt comparing it. he/she said "i love this, AND the gackt ver"...
LOVEd3xt3r 10 months ago
Different version of the song for sure, but it sounds pretty empty to me without the sanshin. Sorry if that offends people, it's just my opinion (it's like having Scottish folk music without the bagpipes to me).
hardcharging 1 year ago
So beautiful expressions, feelings and voice...
petrustella 1 year ago
i love this, and also gackt version :D
dny8ayuro 2 years ago 5
What a masterpiece. It left me breathless and anxious, wanting for more. My thoughts overwhelmed me, "if this is a dream please don't awaken me as I would not want it to end".
rezzoro7 2 years ago
Incredible...Beautiful performance.
turr520 2 years ago 3
FANTASTIC!
Voice85 2 years ago 2
I really wish I could have gone to this concert!
blakebranchbass 2 years ago 2