I think that this is a worthy modern rendition of the Bach original. The first time I heard it, I thought it was an advertisement and I didn't get it. Now that I see it is not an advert, I get it, and appreciate it for the "modern revision" that it is. I kind-of like it.
Your weak creativity doesn't let you see... world is in motion . Nothing wrong in picking a beauriful pice like Bach's Toccata and turn it into a modern piece. I'm preety sure if Bach could have all the resources that we have nowadays, he would come wth pieces like that. (not compairing, of course, the author of this arrangement to Bach. don't get me wrong).
* * * Dear friends, mutantmushroom: Thank you deeply for sharing this wonderful and lovely performance... From this Unique Celestial-Song Music Creator, JS Bach, Music Creation from Heavens-Stars. Have a great time. Best regards, Javier V. Maldonado * * * *
If this is a Bach performance, I just don't understand why the video needed to include a pretty open dress, hair blowing in the wind, and romantic posing in front of the camera.
@maslina10 I think Myleen would have made things quite hard for him, but I'm sure he would seriously have enjoyed it. Might have found it difficult though to choose between Myleen and the Vanessa Mae interpretation of his masterpiece.
@evilman01234 They certainly didn't - sounds like the voice of another old fart clinging desperately to the past.. You can bet your life Bach would have liked this, but then again he was a true progressive. He wasn't stuck in some musical time warp like many of his so called admirers
This is nothing short of a master piece and Bach would be proud! I'm sure he's applauding from his grave. Let creative minds and those who appreciate the finer things in life be and for those who can't go back to your TV's!!! Just saying...
lets remember when bach wrote this, this WAS POP MUSIC. if he wrote it today, it would be different. bach was a musician, and at that time, you chose the old pipe organ, crappy harpsichord, or the new fangled piano.
This was the first version of the song that I ever heard, and then I checked out the original.
I love this - it is very new, original and very different. I like that it's modernised.
I mean if you guys hate it so much, don't be so snobby about it, you can just go and listen to the original, elsewhere, no one's forcing you to be here.
I think the new versions of the classical pieces make the old ones more accessible for the younger people. if we left all the old piece were they are in ten years they might be completely forgotten. this way someone might think 'I wonder what the original sounded like' and if not then nothing has been lost right?
I'm SOOOOO TIRED of mean, nasty people saying mean, nasty things. SHE IS A HUGE TALENT, PERIOD. YOUR NASTINESS ACCOMPLISHES NOTHING. NOBODY LIKES A CRITIC. TRY BEING AN ARTIST!!!!
To people incesantly hating upon this, ofcoourse its not the BEST version of this piece, but TRUST me, coming from a 16 year old, we either let modern artists interpret things on their own, let artists be artists, let them take the music and make it more acessable for people my age or simply let the music die with you... The originals will always be there, but the appreciation wont be unless people stop sneering at todays art with such snobbery, its intimidating people and frankly quite rude.
True, but we don't like being surprised by misleading/incomplete titles. I do admire the interpretations of many contemporary artists of these old pieces, but sometimes, it can get annoying and seem wannabe-ish. in the example of this video, the song is good, but the image is silly... last thing, the original music might still be there, but it will get lost under a pile of dust.50 years later, on hearing the original people would probably say Bach is a time traveller who copied off Myleene Klass
@Changles That is an extremely closed minded thing to say. Art is about the most loosely defined thing in the world, saying this isn't art is just idiotic.
@propertyofjoey Let it die then. There is no point in appreciating music reinterpreted as such blasphemous garbage as this. It's too easy to forget, that it is the composer whose musical message we aim to observe and who decides how a piece of music should be interpreted and the performer who is supposed to be intelligent and well educated enough to interpret that message accurately. If this is the only way Bach may be appreciated. Then the message is gone and the music as good as dead. I'm 16!
@propertyofjoey Dude, just because something is being interpreted in a new way doesn't mean it's good. It can still be bad... and this is bad. This s what happens when you make someone famous because you know guys will want to titty fuck them and not on merit as an artist.
And if this girl is 16, hat's disturbing the way she's behaving.
@AshillaBeige I'm not aying its good or bad, I'm saying you dont have to LOVE it but dont be so harsh on it because CLEARLY someone is buying it, someone likes it, and thats life, thats a difference of opinion its just ONE interpretation from a thousand different ones nowadays, most people my age see a certain snobbery with classical music that can be quite clearly stated and THAT is what stops alot of people from listening and stating their opinions on the music THATS what I was addressing.
@propertyofjoey Just because people buy Justin Bieber doesn't make it good. People buy crap all the time, and it's fine to be harsh when something is legitimately stupid. It's fine to make critical comments. Maybe you should think before you type illogical nonsense.
@AshillaBeige I'm not sticking up for modern music, I'm saying that things evolve and not always in the way we like, this isint the best rendition WE KNOW but at the same time musical snobbery such as yours dosnt make it any better, people like what they like, and they have just as much liberty to, its none or your business what others listen to, music is a universal, diverse language, what you find stupid someone else might find intreguing so unless you're Bach himself..shut up.
@AshillaBeige My point is not that she's interpreted it this way, its the fact that she can, and that it will make NO SIFFERENCE how she covers it because the music is still the same, you dont have to listen to it cause frankly it dosnt matter..it wouldnt matter if everyone LOVED it or HATED it, this music wont be remembered for this interpretation, it will be remembered as a stand alone piece and THIS isint going to change how we remember it, so let people do as they please.
I'm sorry but myleene Klass is totally shit at piano - even Lady Gaga is better than her lmao.. she's totally killed a great piece by Bach using crap pop 'influences'.. alwayys thought this even when it came out when she was playin on gmtv when i first saw it..
This may not be Bach's masterpiece, but it's a very good version of it. Besides of the original, this one is the best I've ever heard. The original will always be the original, and nothing will top it.
@realmystery You are inadvertently so absolutely correct my friend. I believe there are around three thousand recorded 'originals' as you call them. Your statement places Klass exactly where she belongs: she is the best of the brand of Toccata that are recorded in bedrooms on electric guitars and stylophones.
@FireflyFanatic3 Various interpretations are refreshing and always welcome. However, I doubt that some talentless media whore can make Bach's music sound better than it already is.
@Benderrr111 it doesn't matter who she is or what else she's done, that prejudices you against her and this piece. I have no idea who she is or other things she's done and therefore I am judging meerely the piece and the music on it's own.
She's not trying to make it sound better than it is, she's just using the melody as something to work on to create something new and different, she never claimed this piece was better than the original.
@Benderrr111 Your'e just the kind of bigot the musical world can do without. Bachs music cannot sound how it already is, because it exists only on the printed page. How it sounds depends on how someone plays and interprets it. Yes this is different from some interpretations and might not appeal to everyone, but however you look at it Myleene Klass has a talent which I suspect you will never aspire to. Huge numbers of people enjoy her work. How many enjoy yours, or have even heard of you?
@Benderrr111 Your just the kind of retrograde bigot the muscial world can do without. Bachs music can not sound better than it already is as it exists only in print. How it sounds depends on how someone plays and interprets it. This version might not appeal to everyone but however you look at it Myleene displays a talent I suspect you will never aspire to. Her work is enjoyed by a huge number of people. Can the same be said for you? I think I detect a huge slice of jealousy.
Well... That sounds modern but nothing can give the real feelings like with organ... With organ you can feel the hatred, sadness, happiness.. Bach knew that so that he made his masterpiece with organ.. In this, all of the enstruments are scream like "please stop this. I dont want to be played."
@cchj768 Far from making a mockery of Bach's masterpiece, they keep it alive and allow it to reach a much wider audience. Bach's work is not the property of some music establishment' old fart's club. It belongs to everyone. I have recordings of this work by a number of artists including Martin Jean and James Kibbie (played on original baroque organs). They live comfortably side by side but are all very different. People like Myleen can spark an interest which might otherwise be absent
just another sexy idiot who took some piano lessens when she was a kid and now she is playing only with one hand wow I am not imprest at all I think Vanessa mea has more agility and talent and more appeal that is if you have yellow fiver
@gabreil1music Don't know about piano lessons as a kid. What I do know is that as a child she attended the Guildhall School of Music and Drama, and later graduated from the Royal Academy of Music, University of London. (bit more than a few piano lessons I reckon). As for playing with one hand, it doesn't matter one bit if she plays with her toes. What matters is substance not style. I don't detect a hint of jealousy do I ?
@blackbeasthamish not at all i am a successful studio artist you can check it out and and i earn a living doing it and i am a man i see this all the time the take some one that looks good and make her or him a star and say that they are all that but but no one care if its true or not but any way i see your point about giving some more glamour to music this day any thing that most kid are listening to is crap that would be better to hear
@FireSath This one is a goddamn sex bomb - I reckon she would have made things hard for Bach if he were still around. ha ha! Oh, and the music's good too.
@blackbeasthamish I didin't say she isin't sexy. I said that I don't like girls acting like porn stars while they are making music video about classic music.
@FireSath I take your point, but I think this video is a long way from beng pornographic, though I wouldn't argue that its a bit raunchy. I am someone to sees nothing wrong in bringing a bit of glamour into the world of classical music, which is occupied by far to many "old farts" if you will pardon the expression. I suspect you are not one of these however and I have total respect for your views, I just like to think there is a bit of room for diversity and experimentation in music.
@blackbeasthamish just another sexy idiot who took some piano lessens when she was a kid and now she is playing only with one hand wow I am not imprest at all I think Vanessa mea has more agility and talent and more appeal that is if you have yellow fiver
@GoWithTheFlo99 Yet another purist classical luddite - fortunately one of a dying breed. To compare this with the Black Eyed Peas is fatuous - they don't possess any noticeable talent for starters. Mylene Klass on the other hand does, even if it's not to your taste. Incidentally, I also like the more formal interpretations invariably played on large cathedral organs . I think Bach would have been more open minded and actually loved this. He might well have been swinging in the aisles.
Why is everyone talking about Myleene Klass instead of the music? Why has it got all lascivious and corse? This country just thinks about sex ALL the tiome!!!
@MrLuvlyJubly I think it is because the world of classical music is inhabited by a lot of old farts who prefer to live in the past. If music is performed by someone young and with obvious sex appeal, however talented they might be, rather than some stufffed flannel suit, it sends them into a frenzy of self-righteous indignation. They forget entirely about the music and channel all their engergies into criticising the performers appearance and demeanour. There - I feel better for that!
@MrLuvlyJubly I understand and have an appreciation of classical music , having come from that kind of background. What I don't have however is the blinkered dinosour approach to it which many classical adherents seem to display, together with an "I know what's best" kind of attitude. Music is a living entity and should be allowed to evolve. The constraints of the 17th - 19th centuries dictated how it was played but it can still be performed differenttly whilst preserving its character
@blackbeasthamish Agree entirely! Finding this arrangement so addictive I said: "why don't I play anymore??" (used to practice 8 hours a day, passing examinations etc) SO....after many years of ruining my fingers on a pc keyboard, am warming up with some BACH 2 & 3 part inventions.....Wow, it feels wonderful! (Thankyou Myleene, violinist, arranger, director, set visualizer etc.)
I must say that I really loved the spirit of this performance and I really liked the embellishments.... But I really think that there were to many passages cut out that could have really made this work shine. :)
Classical music is very complicated to listen to. I usually have to force myself to listen to a classical piece several times before I enjoy the piece more than a standard pop song. This is why classical music isn't very popular, most people can't be bothered to listen to it and appreciate it or simply don't have the time. This is also why most people prefer watered-down versions of classical pieces, such as this.
@andrew190495 so true! and then when it suddently appears to something relative such as twillight movie "clair de lune" or Muse "nocturne Eb" they seem to really love what many usually would even hate(at least what they tell)
Classical music is epic, and rythmical music is for the body.. :P
i somehow wish this was played on Organ. But i love this so much... Myleene is an excellent pianist! I'm playing htis at the moment on Piano... and an easy version on organ... But i don't think mines Half as good ! At least.. being as good as Myleene is something to aim for!
Terrible: F
0darrow 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello 2O12 ♥˛. (´• ̮•)*˛°*/.♫.♫\*˛.*
berklee24365678 1 month ago
I think that this is a worthy modern rendition of the Bach original. The first time I heard it, I thought it was an advertisement and I didn't get it. Now that I see it is not an advert, I get it, and appreciate it for the "modern revision" that it is. I kind-of like it.
riggy001 3 months ago
i liked toccata, until I watched this :(
subzeroPrawn 4 months ago
grab the rotten tomatoes!!!
raywilliamfan2 4 months ago
Interpretation beautiful;-))).
Lorejn1 4 months ago 3
I'm a teen, but I rather listen the original version.
cpandreylaur 4 months ago
Bach, its OK buddy... just let it all out, were on your side.
mvs13I2 4 months ago
she should be naked while playing this
MsDeathcrush 4 months ago
Your weak creativity doesn't let you see... world is in motion . Nothing wrong in picking a beauriful pice like Bach's Toccata and turn it into a modern piece. I'm preety sure if Bach could have all the resources that we have nowadays, he would come wth pieces like that. (not compairing, of course, the author of this arrangement to Bach. don't get me wrong).
pcpfree 5 months ago
I really liked it, not better or worse than the epic SKY version just...........different. Myleen has a real talent, who'd of thought it :-)
mojosabien 6 months ago
JavierVMaldonado 7 months ago
whats this song actually called? is there sheet music?
therayray20000 7 months ago
@therayray20000 Toccata and Fugue and yeah, everywhere
ArchaicMusics 6 months ago
LOL
malicieusekiki 7 months ago
one of the best thiings I have ever heard
bored9318 8 months ago 8
@bored9318 I agree - its one of the best things I have ever heard also.
Cherrytime1 8 months ago
and what ealce can she play??????????????????
frostsatyricon 8 months ago
She's hot.
HeyRuka 9 months ago 2
@HeyRuka You are sherlock
F14Lolcat 4 months ago
If this is a Bach performance, I just don't understand why the video needed to include a pretty open dress, hair blowing in the wind, and romantic posing in front of the camera.
maslina10 9 months ago
@maslina10 I think Myleen would have made things quite hard for him, but I'm sure he would seriously have enjoyed it. Might have found it difficult though to choose between Myleen and the Vanessa Mae interpretation of his masterpiece.
blackbeasthamish 8 months ago
I think this is a fine piece.
Barragg 9 months ago
Even though this isn't as good as the original im very relived that modern artists are still appreciating the masters of REAL music. :)
Destromaniac 9 months ago
this is my favorite version /watch?v=6JX13LwnZss sends shivers down my spine x
sexdrugsandrave 9 months ago
I see most videos of Vanessa has disabled commenting becouse its a really shit... very awful...
chairday 9 months ago
Listening to this makes me Balch
thesparkflyer 9 months ago
Comment removed
SweetestPea1000 10 months ago
yes..wow..amazing
RVialle 10 months ago
amazing
sbjazz22 10 months ago
i dont like her but the song is great
kanatapaw 10 months ago
Nice Bach-less dress....... sorry
retephgiel 10 months ago 16
They should defs have done the toccata theme in double octaves at the end for one hell of a climax :D
Chopianist3 10 months ago
I was once told; if you can't say anything nice don't say anything at all. I like this rendition
henblydd 10 months ago
Bach is spinning in his grave
TonyWRO 11 months ago
@TonyWRO from joy that his pieces of music are still being remixed
foch0 10 months ago
@TonyWRO yes playing with himself wile thinking of myleene !!!!!!!
theelectkickenass 10 months ago
she was born in 1978 she is not 16 year old
theelectkickenass 11 months ago
Great job!
bored9318 11 months ago
ANYONE KNOW WHERE I CAN GET SHEET MUSIC FOR THIS?!? i really like this version and want to learn it!
BANANAGURL77 11 months ago
i wonder if alicia keys can play this song .
MegaKingofkings24 11 months ago
1:10 is so smooth
Stijn9019 1 year ago
these people only made it better big time & mylene is so fine
theelectkickenass 1 year ago
These People Totally ruined this Timeless Master Piece.
evilman01234 1 year ago
@evilman01234 They certainly didn't - sounds like the voice of another old fart clinging desperately to the past.. You can bet your life Bach would have liked this, but then again he was a true progressive. He wasn't stuck in some musical time warp like many of his so called admirers
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
This is nothing short of a master piece and Bach would be proud! I'm sure he's applauding from his grave. Let creative minds and those who appreciate the finer things in life be and for those who can't go back to your TV's!!! Just saying...
TheOsler 1 year ago 2
I really hope to God that the video I just watched was an advertisement for piano lessons, because if this is for real, the end is near.
Neurotripsicks 1 year ago
lets remember when bach wrote this, this WAS POP MUSIC. if he wrote it today, it would be different. bach was a musician, and at that time, you chose the old pipe organ, crappy harpsichord, or the new fangled piano.
nemoskull 1 year ago 2
This was the first version of the song that I ever heard, and then I checked out the original.
I love this - it is very new, original and very different. I like that it's modernised.
I mean if you guys hate it so much, don't be so snobby about it, you can just go and listen to the original, elsewhere, no one's forcing you to be here.
FireflyFanatic3 1 year ago
i wish i have the music sheet of myleene klass toccato because it has violin..hahahahaha... violin player here... :)
Dualz101 1 year ago
I think the new versions of the classical pieces make the old ones more accessible for the younger people. if we left all the old piece were they are in ten years they might be completely forgotten. this way someone might think 'I wonder what the original sounded like' and if not then nothing has been lost right?
MsSteefXD 1 year ago 2
i love this !!!!!!!!!!
GeorgeLoveful 1 year ago
I'm SOOOOO TIRED of mean, nasty people saying mean, nasty things. SHE IS A HUGE TALENT, PERIOD. YOUR NASTINESS ACCOMPLISHES NOTHING. NOBODY LIKES A CRITIC. TRY BEING AN ARTIST!!!!
mysticman9 1 year ago 2
nice
theelectkickenass 1 year ago
To people incesantly hating upon this, ofcoourse its not the BEST version of this piece, but TRUST me, coming from a 16 year old, we either let modern artists interpret things on their own, let artists be artists, let them take the music and make it more acessable for people my age or simply let the music die with you... The originals will always be there, but the appreciation wont be unless people stop sneering at todays art with such snobbery, its intimidating people and frankly quite rude.
propertyofjoey 1 year ago 100
True, but we don't like being surprised by misleading/incomplete titles. I do admire the interpretations of many contemporary artists of these old pieces, but sometimes, it can get annoying and seem wannabe-ish. in the example of this video, the song is good, but the image is silly... last thing, the original music might still be there, but it will get lost under a pile of dust.50 years later, on hearing the original people would probably say Bach is a time traveller who copied off Myleene Klass
supervellous 1 year ago
@propertyofjoey Well said the master pieces will always be with us why simple they are used everyday in films....Adverts for the tele etc etc ....
SALTYDOG7181 1 year ago
@propertyofjoey This ain't art - the video is horrible exploitative commercial nothingness
Changles 11 months ago
@Changles The sad point of todays music industry is..sex sells...I dont like it, nor do alot of people but for some reason it sells
propertyofjoey 11 months ago
@Changles That is an extremely closed minded thing to say. Art is about the most loosely defined thing in the world, saying this isn't art is just idiotic.
julian1000 11 months ago
@julian1000 You're right. Thanks for opening my eyes. This is very creative and elegant
Changles 11 months ago
@Changles Thanks, I thought so too!
julian1000 11 months ago
@propertyofjoey Let it die then. There is no point in appreciating music reinterpreted as such blasphemous garbage as this. It's too easy to forget, that it is the composer whose musical message we aim to observe and who decides how a piece of music should be interpreted and the performer who is supposed to be intelligent and well educated enough to interpret that message accurately. If this is the only way Bach may be appreciated. Then the message is gone and the music as good as dead. I'm 16!
9UnneccesaryPerson4 11 months ago
@propertyofjoey Dude, just because something is being interpreted in a new way doesn't mean it's good. It can still be bad... and this is bad. This s what happens when you make someone famous because you know guys will want to titty fuck them and not on merit as an artist.
And if this girl is 16, hat's disturbing the way she's behaving.
AshillaBeige 11 months ago
@AshillaBeige I'm not aying its good or bad, I'm saying you dont have to LOVE it but dont be so harsh on it because CLEARLY someone is buying it, someone likes it, and thats life, thats a difference of opinion its just ONE interpretation from a thousand different ones nowadays, most people my age see a certain snobbery with classical music that can be quite clearly stated and THAT is what stops alot of people from listening and stating their opinions on the music THATS what I was addressing.
propertyofjoey 11 months ago
@propertyofjoey Just because people buy Justin Bieber doesn't make it good. People buy crap all the time, and it's fine to be harsh when something is legitimately stupid. It's fine to make critical comments. Maybe you should think before you type illogical nonsense.
AshillaBeige 10 months ago
@AshillaBeige I'm not sticking up for modern music, I'm saying that things evolve and not always in the way we like, this isint the best rendition WE KNOW but at the same time musical snobbery such as yours dosnt make it any better, people like what they like, and they have just as much liberty to, its none or your business what others listen to, music is a universal, diverse language, what you find stupid someone else might find intreguing so unless you're Bach himself..shut up.
propertyofjoey 10 months ago
Comment removed
SweetestPea1000 10 months ago
@AshillaBeige My point is not that she's interpreted it this way, its the fact that she can, and that it will make NO SIFFERENCE how she covers it because the music is still the same, you dont have to listen to it cause frankly it dosnt matter..it wouldnt matter if everyone LOVED it or HATED it, this music wont be remembered for this interpretation, it will be remembered as a stand alone piece and THIS isint going to change how we remember it, so let people do as they please.
propertyofjoey 11 months ago
@propertyofjoey Absolute bullshit.
Harmonyww 10 months ago 2
@propertyofjoey
its like saying Toccata by Sky was terrible. This chick is the modern version of Sky, when you think about it
RICKROLLBLENDER 6 months ago
@propertyofjoey Agreed. People who does'nt like innovation are close minded. This is a piece of art and deserves nothing mor admnmiration.
pcpfree 5 months ago
@pcpfree I meant Deserves nothing BUT admiration.
pcpfree 5 months ago
@propertyofjoey Wow man, it's really relieving to see someone in today's youth with a little knowledge! I salute you, my friend :-)
southafricanwhitey 4 months ago
@propertyofjoey original is better
woelloem 3 months ago
I'm sorry but myleene Klass is totally shit at piano - even Lady Gaga is better than her lmao.. she's totally killed a great piece by Bach using crap pop 'influences'.. alwayys thought this even when it came out when she was playin on gmtv when i first saw it..
scottamgreig 1 year ago
This may not be Bach's masterpiece, but it's a very good version of it. Besides of the original, this one is the best I've ever heard. The original will always be the original, and nothing will top it.
This video got my thumbs up.
realmystery 1 year ago 2
@realmystery You are inadvertently so absolutely correct my friend. I believe there are around three thousand recorded 'originals' as you call them. Your statement places Klass exactly where she belongs: she is the best of the brand of Toccata that are recorded in bedrooms on electric guitars and stylophones.
Kurzula5150 1 year ago
le dieron en la madre a Bach... una vez más
Oscarbrash 1 year ago
poor Bach...
Benderrr111 1 year ago 35
@Benderrr111 actually I think he'd be very pleased that his music had survived this long, and it was being re-done and re-interpreted even now.
FireflyFanatic3 1 year ago
@FireflyFanatic3 Various interpretations are refreshing and always welcome. However, I doubt that some talentless media whore can make Bach's music sound better than it already is.
Benderrr111 1 year ago
@Benderrr111 it doesn't matter who she is or what else she's done, that prejudices you against her and this piece. I have no idea who she is or other things she's done and therefore I am judging meerely the piece and the music on it's own.
She's not trying to make it sound better than it is, she's just using the melody as something to work on to create something new and different, she never claimed this piece was better than the original.
FireflyFanatic3 1 year ago
@Benderrr111 Your'e just the kind of bigot the musical world can do without. Bachs music cannot sound how it already is, because it exists only on the printed page. How it sounds depends on how someone plays and interprets it. Yes this is different from some interpretations and might not appeal to everyone, but however you look at it Myleene Klass has a talent which I suspect you will never aspire to. Huge numbers of people enjoy her work. How many enjoy yours, or have even heard of you?
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago 2
@Benderrr111 Your just the kind of retrograde bigot the muscial world can do without. Bachs music can not sound better than it already is as it exists only in print. How it sounds depends on how someone plays and interprets it. This version might not appeal to everyone but however you look at it Myleene displays a talent I suspect you will never aspire to. Her work is enjoyed by a huge number of people. Can the same be said for you? I think I detect a huge slice of jealousy.
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago 2
@Benderrr111 what about her } BACK { it looked very nice to me !!!!! along with her legs
SALTYDOG7181 1 year ago
@Benderrr111 you' re right
even1222 5 months ago
@Benderrr111 Wtf ? Poor YOU.
FleshStarvingBass 4 months ago
@FleshStarvingBass hahahaha suck it
Benderrr111 4 months ago
Well... That sounds modern but nothing can give the real feelings like with organ... With organ you can feel the hatred, sadness, happiness.. Bach knew that so that he made his masterpiece with organ.. In this, all of the enstruments are scream like "please stop this. I dont want to be played."
SercanSalkir 1 year ago 4
i have the MP3 is anyone wants it
oongoy 1 year ago
Wtf is this. They're making a mockery of Bach's masterpiece with her spastic piano playing and the shitty pop influence.
cchj768 1 year ago
@cchj768 Far from making a mockery of Bach's masterpiece, they keep it alive and allow it to reach a much wider audience. Bach's work is not the property of some music establishment' old fart's club. It belongs to everyone. I have recordings of this work by a number of artists including Martin Jean and James Kibbie (played on original baroque organs). They live comfortably side by side but are all very different. People like Myleen can spark an interest which might otherwise be absent
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
just another sexy idiot who took some piano lessens when she was a kid and now she is playing only with one hand wow I am not imprest at all I think Vanessa mea has more agility and talent and more appeal that is if you have yellow fiver
gabreil1music 1 year ago
@gabreil1music Don't know about piano lessons as a kid. What I do know is that as a child she attended the Guildhall School of Music and Drama, and later graduated from the Royal Academy of Music, University of London. (bit more than a few piano lessons I reckon). As for playing with one hand, it doesn't matter one bit if she plays with her toes. What matters is substance not style. I don't detect a hint of jealousy do I ?
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
@blackbeasthamish not at all i am a successful studio artist you can check it out and and i earn a living doing it and i am a man i see this all the time the take some one that looks good and make her or him a star and say that they are all that but but no one care if its true or not but any way i see your point about giving some more glamour to music this day any thing that most kid are listening to is crap that would be better to hear
gabreil1music 1 year ago
2:13 what is that sound affect called?
iggymydog 1 year ago
The piano jizzed its pants...
vernymax 1 year ago
MOAR talent, less Britney spears PLEASE
vernymax 1 year ago
this thing is laughable, sorry
vernymax 1 year ago 2
nicht schlecht, hört sich sehr gut an, NICE
Hesslon09 1 year ago
Why is it so windy in that house, and why aren't they in the same room?
JABLONGO 1 year ago
I don't like, well, females who try be goddamn sexbomb at the same time theyre playing some instrument, violin, piano, what ever.
Like this one.
FireSath 1 year ago
@FireSath This one is a goddamn sex bomb - I reckon she would have made things hard for Bach if he were still around. ha ha! Oh, and the music's good too.
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
@blackbeasthamish I didin't say she isin't sexy. I said that I don't like girls acting like porn stars while they are making music video about classic music.
FireSath 1 year ago
@FireSath I take your point, but I think this video is a long way from beng pornographic, though I wouldn't argue that its a bit raunchy. I am someone to sees nothing wrong in bringing a bit of glamour into the world of classical music, which is occupied by far to many "old farts" if you will pardon the expression. I suspect you are not one of these however and I have total respect for your views, I just like to think there is a bit of room for diversity and experimentation in music.
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
@blackbeasthamish just another sexy idiot who took some piano lessens when she was a kid and now she is playing only with one hand wow I am not imprest at all I think Vanessa mea has more agility and talent and more appeal that is if you have yellow fiver
gabreil1music 1 year ago
It's like Bond theme music :]
RinoaZelda 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BREAKING NEWS:
CNBC AND FOXBUSINESS ANCHORS ARRESTED FOR ILLEGALLY ACCESSING AND MONITORING PRIVATE EMAILS AND CALLS.
This is going to happen soon this is not a joke tell everyone you know.
111WLee 1 year ago
MAGNIFIQUE <3
joliejuju502 1 year ago
WONDERFULL MUSIC
meni1969able 1 year ago
Great !
@->--
DraGaNica85 1 year ago
che brutta versione, povero bach. E' un COITUS INTERRUPTUS.
slapbengio 1 year ago
kiero tocar el violiin!!! xD
Jhenneziithaa 1 year ago
kiero tocar el piano y el viliin >.<'
Jhenneziithaa 1 year ago
Amazing!
Timberfake110 1 year ago
ke pianoforte lucido!!!!!!
MrZoccoloduro 1 year ago
AMAZING........VERY NICE ......
Erikajust 1 year ago 3
~
The violinist beautifully complements Myleene's playing.
Does anyone know who he is?
PurePussCat 1 year ago 2
~
The violinist beautifully complements Myleene's playing.
I wonder who he is?
PurePussCat 1 year ago
This variation of "toccata" is a perfect soundtrack for some hollywood film for a youth, but not more!!!
Bomjable 1 year ago
Sounds like crap, what a shame.
aliasxr 1 year ago
I want her
conmeomecapconmeocon 1 year ago
shes so talented!
4everLarose 1 year ago
Great. Great music for a car advert. Or maybe a bank.
TreyRoque 1 year ago
I'm completly agree she is so hot!
THANATOSLABEL 1 year ago
The most talented person here is J.S.Bach who composed the toccata and the person who has arranged the music with bass n violon . I like it ..
ZekBlek 1 year ago
Myleene will always be tainted with hearsay!
Vickylizzy 1 year ago
ahhh! Have loved this song ever since I first saw it In Fantasia from Disney!! <3
MRSavoi3 1 year ago
I listen to an ecclectic mix of music including classical and I do enjoy this version of Toccata.
But why are people arguing on here?!? If you dont like the video just go away!
Thanks to whoever posted this.
lcwaterworth 1 year ago 2
This is a bit over the top in my opinion.
To much glitter and glamour.
DeHeld8 1 year ago
this vid hurt my soul. people shouldn't be worshipped because they are attractive.
Cheeto717 1 year ago
-just perfect for this fin melancolyholic saturdaynight.. thanks...
TheGizzmo79 1 year ago
DISGUSTING. What a disgrace to the original piece. If I want pop, I listen to black eyed peas, not to this.
GoWithTheFlo99 1 year ago
@GoWithTheFlo99 Yet another purist classical luddite - fortunately one of a dying breed. To compare this with the Black Eyed Peas is fatuous - they don't possess any noticeable talent for starters. Mylene Klass on the other hand does, even if it's not to your taste. Incidentally, I also like the more formal interpretations invariably played on large cathedral organs . I think Bach would have been more open minded and actually loved this. He might well have been swinging in the aisles.
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
1st CLASS from Myleene Klass
She Makes Classical Music Look and Sound SEXY AGAIN
SALTYDOG7181 1 year ago
Why is everyone talking about Myleene Klass instead of the music? Why has it got all lascivious and corse? This country just thinks about sex ALL the tiome!!!
MrLuvlyJubly 1 year ago
@MrLuvlyJubly I think it is because the world of classical music is inhabited by a lot of old farts who prefer to live in the past. If music is performed by someone young and with obvious sex appeal, however talented they might be, rather than some stufffed flannel suit, it sends them into a frenzy of self-righteous indignation. They forget entirely about the music and channel all their engergies into criticising the performers appearance and demeanour. There - I feel better for that!
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
@blackbeasthamish Good I wouldn't want you to feel sad, then you might actually understand classical music. Never mind.
MrLuvlyJubly 1 year ago
@MrLuvlyJubly I understand and have an appreciation of classical music , having come from that kind of background. What I don't have however is the blinkered dinosour approach to it which many classical adherents seem to display, together with an "I know what's best" kind of attitude. Music is a living entity and should be allowed to evolve. The constraints of the 17th - 19th centuries dictated how it was played but it can still be performed differenttly whilst preserving its character
blackbeasthamish 1 year ago
@blackbeasthamish Good for you. Glad to hear that.
MrLuvlyJubly 1 year ago
@blackbeasthamish Agree entirely! Finding this arrangement so addictive I said: "why don't I play anymore??" (used to practice 8 hours a day, passing examinations etc) SO....after many years of ruining my fingers on a pc keyboard, am warming up with some BACH 2 & 3 part inventions.....Wow, it feels wonderful! (Thankyou Myleene, violinist, arranger, director, set visualizer etc.)
erniemajor 1 year ago
Wow. Who directed this thing? Who is the set designer? I'll rent it anytime!
erniemajor 1 year ago
Cudowny :)
Dorota19688 1 year ago
Oh Gosh!!! This is amazing!!!
yaoibanshee 1 year ago
I'd love to be those piano keys that she's putting her hands on
JazzyZenBrotha 1 year ago
"There's a draft in here" LOL
Loved the music tho ^.^
Gallantgal 1 year ago
I must say that I really loved the spirit of this performance and I really liked the embellishments.... But I really think that there were to many passages cut out that could have really made this work shine. :)
But, I still really like it. :)
MrsAlexisClyde 1 year ago
Such a beautifull song!
Please go and check our version of this song - we're violinists :)
Enjoy it.
** Diamond Strings **
diamondstrings 1 year ago
windy castle, wind blows everywhere ;)
Robfoxman 1 year ago
hay wa
maiduyquynhf 1 year ago
perfect
prophet708 1 year ago
man, the music is as sick as the video. I'm soo gonna download this
rapi321 1 year ago
genious :)
Nillerb 1 year ago
I listen to this everyday. I can't get enough!
aerialgymnast10 1 year ago
so beautiful
Amr2573 1 year ago 3
Pure Klasse ....
SALTYDOG7181 1 year ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think this version is tame and lacks the sexual energy of a full orcestra, but good nonetheless
MrMichaelj1982 1 year ago
perfection!
viktorvenomvalmont 1 year ago 5
The original version for organ is better.
choopmac 1 year ago
That is awesome///
havenxxxua 1 year ago
it was 10 days and I can't stop listen to this track , thanks Mutantmushroom
kamilmansor 1 year ago 2
Superowy :)
Dorota19688 2 years ago 4
Classical music is very complicated to listen to. I usually have to force myself to listen to a classical piece several times before I enjoy the piece more than a standard pop song. This is why classical music isn't very popular, most people can't be bothered to listen to it and appreciate it or simply don't have the time. This is also why most people prefer watered-down versions of classical pieces, such as this.
andrew190495 2 years ago 5
@andrew190495 so true! and then when it suddently appears to something relative such as twillight movie "clair de lune" or Muse "nocturne Eb" they seem to really love what many usually would even hate(at least what they tell)
Classical music is epic, and rythmical music is for the body.. :P
VSKCREW 1 year ago
She looks great after her nose job. Kym Marsh has also had one as well.
strawberrylaralara 2 years ago
is she the host of the screening room? on cnn?
futurestar94britfan 2 years ago 7
yes she is
mutantmushroom 2 years ago
can anybody tell me where i can find this sheet music please? x
NSMJx 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
An insult to Bach. She has nice legs though.
BigBoss7777777 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is not Toccata
ballat4u 2 years ago
@ballat4u : are you deaf?
Exeklap 2 years ago 3
i somehow wish this was played on Organ. But i love this so much... Myleene is an excellent pianist! I'm playing htis at the moment on Piano... and an easy version on organ... But i don't think mines Half as good ! At least.. being as good as Myleene is something to aim for!
strangevictoria 2 years ago
Its Myleene Class :D great Pianist *thumbs up*
lfgeoghegan 2 years ago
Amazing Arrangement...
darkman7717 2 years ago
orochimaru theme?
mastersiryus 2 years ago
To all you CLASSICAL SNOBS who write comments. Any way to open up classical music to a new listeners is a great idea....
Totes59 2 years ago 2
I love this!
BamseMums97 2 years ago