Added: 4 years ago
From: Vanessabelle
Views: 170,169
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (266)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Shes so good LIVE!! BETTER THEN ALL GIRL SINGERS =)

  • thats miley half sister playing the guitar

  • Her Voice is AH-MA-ZING If u don't like it get your fucking ass out of here ! :)

  • Gosh, doesn't this girl hear her voice?!?! i would never have the guts to put myself so easy on shame

  • @katy1886 What the heck are you talking about? Her voice is fine and I have NO shame in saying that!

  • no is not.... you're reaaaaaaally wrong.

    listen celine dion, mariah, nelly furtado, bonnie tylor, there are so many good voices out there. that girl.... demi lovato i believe, has a much better voice, that girl CAN sing.

    i have nothing personal with miley. she better act than sing. i love her show but she has a terrible voice

  • oh yeah, i forgot about taylor swift.

    when she sung the anthem.... great performance

  • ok, not taylor, BEYONCE i forgot her

    that's a voice, or lady gaga

    choose someone, anyone else beside this brat

  • @katy1886 What on Earth are you babbling about? Miley can sing just fine. Beautiful on The Climb. It's not a voice you like, OK, but it's one that others do enjoy. No need to bring in an ARMY of other artists of various talents to demonstrate higher talent. No one ever said "Miley sings the Best! How bout leaving it at this. You hate her voice and I Love her voice. I'm not chaning your mind and you sure as hell aint changing mind! :)

  • well fine! but she just sounds awful

  • 1.put your hands on your mouth

    2.make a wish

    3.close your hands

    4.hold your hand to your heart

    5.send this to 3 more videos

    6.tomorow will be the best day ever

  • you goo job

    my name jennifer

  • i love this song

  • cool

  • superb.......and awesome.....

  • awesome

  • I went to the concert on Novemeber 7th 07 but they didnt sing this song =[...

    Oh well i love you miley.....

  • Great Father and Daughter duet. Great song!

  • i love how she performed on her birthday.

    thats dedicationnn. & i think its pretty cool how she performed in nashville on her birthdayy :)

  • i love this song . miley's dad is so cool i like it

  • miley ROCKS

  • Is this the end of one of the BOBW concerts ? its not the same on the dvd, maybe they changed it 4 her birthday :)

  • Wow god quality ! love it ;) ♥

  • super! si eu am fost la concertul asta!

  • I LOVE MILEY!!!♥♥She rocks:)She is the best:)

  • AGREED! I love miley too! She is amazing.

  • why doesn't anyone like her? She is actually good for her age and everything you read about her isn't always true. I think she is amazing and if you don't like her why are you watching her videos?

    Billy is good aswell :)

  • @kezzamckie i agree with you 100% i like miley & billy

  • This is a lovely song, it makes me cry lots when I hear it.

    It's awesome that it's like father & daughter too. :)

  • But it is better darker on Miley she is singing to light there! anyway she rox < 33

  • this song inspired me to make this account. I LOVE MILEY CYRUS.

    except lately on her miley world videos

    she acts like adrienne bailon

    ehhhh

  • bokie ;)

  • uplně mazec ne

  • wow,this is sad.i love her voice god she roxx.

  • it makes me sad when people say she can't sing b.c ik miley and your just jelous that you can sing as good as her

  • it makes me all smiley!!! =D

    i still love her hehehheh!!!

  • i love that song

  • this is the best song ever....

    this song is sooo cute...

    love it sooo much!!!!!!!!

  • this makes me smile so much!

    Miley's voice sounds sooo good

  • of all the live performances, this one is the best one, miley doesnt over sing it.

  • billy ray cyrus is alot better than miley in this song

  • miley has an amazing voiceeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!! ur just jealous of her becaus shes really good at singing and shes way prettier then u haters! she looks really pretty here! :DDDDDD

  • @MileyandJoBroFan1 ok... just because someone doesn't like a singer doesn't mean they're jealous. it's called an opinion. i'm not a fan of miley, i just like the song.

    i might sound kinda mean, but i'm just telling the truth.

  • @MileyandJoBroFan1

    totally girl

  • haha moonlightabc EXACTLY what i think. thank you for saying it. :D

  • thgguuhjuyuyuyiuyllypuiypiypoi­on

  • this is the best song ever

  • aww this is amazing

  • love this vid!thx!

  • this makes me cry! my daddy was so so so sad when i left him because my mommy left us.

  • Um, not trying to be annoying but, if you hate Miley, why did you even watch this video? I don't hate her, and I'm not a crazy fan girl. She's a singer and actress, period. Haters who think she only wants attention, you do realize that commenting on a video for Miley fans make you seem like attention brats, right?

  • this is a good song i love it

  • I don't love her and I'm not a fan, but I think she's pretty good at acting, more than in singing though she CAN sing..

  • You made your point like a dozen times and you are still hanging around here? Again and again, she can act, sing and has lots of talent. But yes, her father was absolutely instrumental in her having a beginning. Big whoop. lots of people get some sort of break. Shit just dont happen in a vacuum. Want an example of someone famous who has no talent? Paris Hilton.

  • she has the best clothes ever and the song is amazing

  • super

  • this is the best song I've ever heard

  • omg they are both awesome live here. go miley and billy ray!!!! :)

  • i really lOve that sOng!!!

    its really cute!!!

    and bOth sing wOnderful....

  • Before when he was young and famous EVERYBODY hated him! even like Tim McGraw and them, and now he is just using his daughter to get famous again. and she just sings other peoples crap and does what he says like a little publicity puppet. All she wants it attention from the media that's why she made those " Questionable " photos. I dont blame her if my dad was him id do that too. plus shes a teenager and everything a normal teenager does is emphasized to crack addiction when your famous.

  • I dont know the particulars, but Nashville has run many well known people out of town. Elvis, Johnny Cash etc etc, before they ran Billy Ray out. No one knows what people are like off camera, but we many times get a very good idea by their "on" behaviour to make a good judgement. Billy Ray doesnt come across as a personality "everybody" hated, though no doubt the big wigs who mattered had their way. As for your take on Miley, i think you are way off base and will leave it at that.

  • yummi088 nobody cares for what you're saying in this vid. so pls. keep the hatred in your mind, or just erase it. i don't like fights but plsss.what made you hate miley anyways? pls. reply. remember, im not angry

  • does anyone have the video of where nick gave her the 15 roses?

  • omg that was so amazing idk y ppl b hatin on her she can really sing that just pure proof ..so every1 need to stop hatin on her

  • aww what a lovely song.. i love miley she is amazing and i think you are such an amazing role model... kepp it up ly miley forever!! have a good birthday (Y) natt xxx

  • Great song. Her father's voice completely compliments her own. I hope any future duets with other singers are well thought out beforehand.

  • MOST people don't agree with your opinion on her singing ability, though I don't disagree with your opinion on her father's voice. However, your statement that he writes her songs for her is just pure balony. Other than this song, which was originally recorded with just BillyRay singing, what other song has he written for her? Before you make such ridiculous comments why don't you try reseaching some facts beforehand? It might actually strengthen your argument.

  • Huh? What music? All the Hannah music is written by people working for Disney. As for her own music from Breakout or Meet Miley Cyrus, just google them from wikipedia (assuming you dont have the cd's) and you will see who exactly are the song writers. That fact enough for you? If not then whatever. As for your musical preference. Its just that, a preference or opinion and its subjective. I happen to STRONGLY disagree with you, even if "most people" dont.

  • i disagree and im 16 and so does my mom and both of them dont write the songs for the show she write most of her miley songs and he write most of his if you dont belive me look up bottom of the ocean by miley and theres a interview were ryan sec calls her dad and her dad tells the story of how she wrote it about her fish and how he thinks its not fair that he had to divorce and someone run over his cat to write a good song and all that happened to her is her fish died so get ur fact right

  • if u ARE 16, u obviously havent payed attention in english class. see, theres this magical thing called a period!

    please repeat whatever u just said, but put some periods (and some sense) in there so i can understand it

  • um youtube has a 500 character count and i dont feel like making it in separate comments just for punctuation which if thats what you need to be able to read it then you really should not be on the internet

    and i dont give a rats ass about periods im not in english class im on youtube so im not going to get graded so i dont care

  • ok well u had 493 characters in ur previous comment, leaving u with room for 4 periods and 3 spaces. was that 4 sentences? if it was, u could probably shorten it.

    secondly, theres no criteria for being on the internet. if there were, i doubt u would meet it

    oh and so the only practical application for the things u learn in school r only to get good grades? gl getting a decent job w/out using proper punctuation.

  • amazing

  • mannn, i wish i could see milo live, ide rather see demi though(:

  • love her xx

  • she really knows how to sing if she pute her heart to a song

  • Shes the most BEAUTIFUL girl in the world and have the most BEAUTIFUL voice in thw world<<33<33 I'm your #1 fan 4ever miley<<3333

  • i love her voice!

  • I love Miley ( as a fan ) I wish I went to one of her concerts :(

  • I went :)

  • es super

    cuando

    miley canta

  • miley has an amazing voiceeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!! ur just jealous of her becaus shes really good at singing and shes way prettier then u haters! she looks really pretty here!

  • wow ther awsome!man her voice is so different from any other voice it so strong and powerful its just amazing

    she looks so pretty =]

    TEAM MILEY!

  • aww this was on her birthday:) <3

  • I LOVE MILEY!!! I love Miley's beutiful angel voice! Miley's the best!

  • she changed her name to miley because her father called her smiley miley. that is where miley came from. so it just stuck to her.

  • omg people arenet allowed to do that at concerts exept profeshanals

  • do what???

  • miley sounds awesome! that right there proves that she is excellant when feeling her best

  • I forgot, we also love Billy Ray, too! He's the best. And good-looking. :0P

  • Her name isn't Miley Ray because "Ray" is her Dad's middle name. My daughters love Miley and especially this song. I think Miley is great and a good role model for young girls. And I also LOVE her clothes. :0)

  • her name is miley ray, she legally changed it

  • She sounds great.

  • miley oficially changed her name to miley

  • who gave her the flowers?

  • her name is miley ray cyrus she canged it from destiney to miley lol not kidding

  • how come her name is not Miley Ray??!

  • i love miley's sister outfit! it is so adorable! i am a big fan of the skinny jeans.! is it true that miley's brother is in metro station? i lovee that band! there family has really good talent. i want this song to be my wedding song for my dad and i's first dance. i think it is a perfect song for me and my dad because he has just done everything for me since i was a little girl. and even though i am the youngest of 4 he never forgets about me.! I love my dad so much!

  • ya he is  have yo seen his snake bites

  • haha yeah.! hes sexy.!

  • ya he is like the lead singer sort of him and mason musso which happens to be mitchell musso's bro lol the all got talent

  • I Do 2!!!

  • u stupid people here are the facts miley had to fight to get hannah montana her dad was picked after her.

  • thats not true she told her dad to try again ok try going to pown shops or somthing cuse i have all of his cd fom like the 60s

  • They both are good!!!I like them both.

  • .. She's nothing without her dad ..

    God I love Billy Ray !! Ready get set don't Gooooooooooo :( the best song I ever heard ..

  • I was there they are SO good!

  • I like Miley better when she's singing this kind of stuff than when she's singing her "my best friend leslie said oh shes just being miley" crap.

    I love this song.

  • she is not famous cos of her dad her dad not tht famous he his known for 1 song realli. shes famous cos ppl love her shes a gr8 actor n singer n shes a sweet gal n great model so if u hate her fk u !

  • Want to know what's annoying? When people can't spell! Or use idiotic "Instant Messaging" terms like ppl and cos. It's annoying as hell. Learn to spell.

  • she sings really good in this song

  • You know what you people who think that way just are Jealous of her and no shes not famous cause her dad ok so i will tell you this GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT FIRST OK.

  • i love this song

  • shes not famous cause her dad shes famous cause she audition for hannah montana and she got the role and she made songs and a album and now shes a big star cause of hannah montana

  • so many people put Miley Cyrus down saying stuff like "Shes only famous because of her dad" i cant believe you guys that say that

  • ugh, i wish they would have sang at the concert i went to, she sang i miss you at the one in mn... oh well it was still good!

  • Great song...they are so adorable together

  • she was actually good in this. She should stick to singing country..its better for her voice.

  • i got back stage passes. billy ray is such a good singer

  • that girl sounds great i love this song~~

  • THIS MAKES ME CRY! it reminds me how much I ♥ my dad and how i can barely see him. :'(

  • I Think Mileyy Should Stick ToO Countryy Songs. Her Voice Suits It More And She Sounds More In Tune In Live Performances....

    Buhht Shes Awesomme !

  • well....i luv her dads voice but i really hate hers

  • i was there!!

  • I was there!! We were In the top on the right. I saw Billy Ray give someone a high five back stage. we could see the back stage stairs leadind to the stage.

  • omg tht is sooo cool!!! when i went in atlanta.. i was next to the side on the floor.. and we saw kyle massey so we asked him for a picture. :]

  • wow she sings baddd live...goodness!!fueraa!!get her outa here!

  • i ♥♥♥ this song i have a sae duet wi/ my cuzin on fridays cuz i go to the van andel arena every friday and i sing in front of like 2000000 or less people but i still like touch hands and stuff cuz it's my dream to come true!

  • Damn it haters! DO you not understand what i've been trying to say? She's herself. She's Famous, Damn it, Deal with that. All of you are probably just saying that cuz she's obviously got a life WAAAAAAY better than yours. SO zip it! She'll be whoever the hell she wants to be!!

  • wow ur seats sucked. i am sorry. lol

  • i looooooove her and i looove this song she is amazing!!!!!!!!!

  • you r a lucky girl

    you've been to her concert :o

  • she has an awsome voice!

  • shes got a beautiful voice

  • If she couldn't hit the right notes how the hell did they record the song??

  • they tweaked her voice in the cd,

    smart one!

    and overlapped it like 890789378 times

    and i saw her live and she really cant sing

  • she does and i watched the kca's last night and she didnt hit any right notes it SUCKED and she does lie about how shes a good girl and the only reason shes famous is because of her dad

  • she not famous cuz of her dad she adutioned 4 hm and got it cuz shes good not cuz of her dad and she doesnt suck and her dad even tried 2 keep her from acting so next time u want 2 trash sum1 get it strait!

  • Actually, she got the part cause she was the last minuet pick, she wasn't even suppose to be the star

  • Go Shut ur mouth Fool She has a big career and she will do it much better GO MILEY GO!

  • shes so hott.

    she has such a beautiful voice.

  • JEEZ I LUV THEM

  • each time this song is sang i cry it's a good song when miley first went up on stage we saw a singer of the future HANNAH MONTANA/MILEY CRYUS@

  • for all the people hoo think she cant sing.. yoo should go and search miley and her dad singing on oprah... she also sings miss you really good too... and she dose NOTT lip sing