Pete Doherty beim On3 "umstrittene Hymne"

[lilbrothaaa]

Kann mal jemand den gefühlt 90% der Deutschen einhämmern, dass das weder ein Nazilied noch verboten ist!!!

[TVomfgTV]

naja die Nazis haben das Nichraucherschutz gesetz erfunden, also da regt sich niemand auf ? oO

Heuchler ! xD

Und wegen ner Hymne sich aufregen ?

Warum alles so ernst nehmen, das ist alles Vergangenheit und wir sollten das alles mit Humor nehmen.

[DarkTemplR]

 Let's forget the PC language already, we don't want to live in Orwell's 1984!!! Wake up, Germany!

[synthmix1]

To rein in Jewish terror! Deutschland Awake! Europe Awake! World Awake!

[Tetsuoha]

That is so cool! Against the brainwashed self hater Germans.

[Dave88141]

Deutschland über alles! Europe Awake! 

[DestroyerAlexandros]

This guy is a retard!

[1980BoehseOnkelz]

der text ist eig. doch garnict schlimm die meisten sagen sich Oo die hymne war die nicht mal... und dan wird gleich falch über einen gedacht DEUTSCHLAND denDEUTSCHEN

[MusicMonk2]

hahaha

naund? die nazis haben viel benutzt was wir heute benutzen wie etwa das telefon oder haben sich brote geschmiert :) uhuuuu bin ich jetzt auch ein nazi weil ich mir auch morgens brote mache?

die erste strophe von dem deutschland lied ist aber auch nicht verboten, sondern damals war ja 'deutschland, deutschland über alles' in einem total anderen zusammenhang O.o

also leuts net so reinsteigern ich wär der glücklichste mensch der welt wenn doherty den gig zuende gebracht hätte :)

[Asti1910]

@MusicMonk2

Ohne Butterbrote und Peter Doherty wäre Deutschland auch ziemlich scheiße.

[Freimaurer28]

its sad but true, what is written by Winghun.

Hitler was disgusting, but also myself as a german i feel also disgusting about some other countries, who react in the same ways as Germany did it 70 years ago!

Its sad to hear that other countries think in this way that germans probably would sell theyre own mother before saying something political incorrect....

Sad to hear but damn true ;-)

Say something political incorrect and you are the next big nazi in town...its crazy but true

[sofachiller]

Coole Sache ! peinlich wenn Leute das irgendwie ernst nehmen und sich da noch reinsteigern - winghun is right!

[Nintendmo]

@winghun: i am german. the germans hate hitler and nazis! if there is a guy who sings the anthem which the nazis used, we will scream because we are not proud of hitler.

[Tetsuoha]

@Nintendmo You got a lot of brainwashing. Do not forget: Always the winners write the history.

[theN0body]

doitschland doitschland uber lalalal hahaha

[r1ch1etheman]

hahahahahahahaha nice one peter

[accuratesheep]

"Er hat, laut eigener Aussage ("MTV Home" vom 4.12.2010), den Text zugesteckt bekommen, ohne zu wissen, was er bedeute."

[OscarFingallWills]

What´s the big deal? Obviously Peter tried to provoke the audience and obviously he did so very successful. Peter starts singing the infamous part of the hymn - crowd reacts like Pavlov´s dogs. Germans should have more self esteem than to get all frantic only cos a musician embarrasses himself in trying to take the piss out of them in a deliberately tasteless way.

[winghun]

come on, guys, germans now are not the same they used to be. today's germans are the most liberal creatures on earth. and they are so funny! i think Pete just did a litte test on the german crowd: 'how much time do you need to make a german BOO?' an average german would rather kill his/her mom and children than do something politically incorrect! if Doherty had sung Deutschland unter alles, the whole crowd would have been shouting hurray. so stop blaming these funny creatures!

[ContagiouslyParanoid]

You could be right. But I think there is nothing bad about this attitude...

[winghun]

I'm glad you think that. Muslim and African immigrants needs a boxing bag. I wouldn't be suprised if one day all the Germans commit suicide, because existing is politically incorrect.

[ContagiouslyParanoid]

Whatever you say...

[winghun]

I wonder what you will say to your grandson, when your country turns into an Islamic state, just because you were too pussies to stand up and say enough.

[gr436]

also ich hab eh bei mtv gehört das ihm die strophe falsch zugesteckt wurde als scherz

[Schlottimagperlen]

ich muss ganz ehrlich sagen ich liebe pete doherty. und ich hab gehört er sei vorher shcon ausgebuht worden... und ich weiß nicht. kann man über sowas nicht hinwegsehen? stattdessen wieder riesengroß in der bild: SKANDAAAAAL!!!

das ist nur pete. dafür ist er bekannt. regt euch über sowas nicht auf.

[TheRuubs73]

guess the Germans are still upset what their grand-parents did 60 od years ago , I would be too !

[ContagiouslyParanoid]

Yes, most of them/us are.

[Alexokrat]

bloß doof das unsere so ziemlich die dunkelste von allen is und diese Strophe ist ein erheblicher Teil davon

[RockinDocDoc]

wie uns deutschen von den medien das hirn gewaschen wurde, zu glauben "deutschland deutschland über alles" sei in irgendeiner weise rechts einzuordnen....was sagen die franzosen? "vive la france" die spanier? "viva espana" und die amis? "god save america"...nationalstolz hat jedes land egal wie dunkel deren vergangenheit

[StevetheCoolman]

die erste strophe enthält aber auch die stelle

"von der maas bis an die memel

von der etsch bis an die belt"

was einem herrschaftsanspruch auf nicht zu Deutschland gehörige Länder gleichkommt (die gehörten auch damals nicht zu D.) - also geht das deutlich über nationalstolz hinaus

[morphinlounge101]

Was meinst du mit damals, das "Dritte Reich" oder die Zeit von Hoffman von Fallersleben (Texter des Deutschlandliedes).

[StevetheCoolman]

Meine damit die Zeit von Hoffman von Fallersleben bzw. die Zeit als das Lied zur Nationalhymne wurde (1922).

Ganz klar also dass diese Strophe schon allein wegen ihrer geographischen Beschreibung von Deutschland in unserer Zeit keinen Platz mehr hat.

[morphinlounge101]

Das stimmt für unsere Zeit. Von Fallersleben schrieb den Text allerdings 1841 im britischen Exil auf Helgoland, deshalb reflektiert es die damalige Zeit.

Hoffmann bezog sich auf die Gebiete mit deutschsprachiger Bevölkerung (Memeldeutschen).

Hoffmann wollte nicht die Expansion Deutschland, sondern die Einheit (Deutschland war ein Flickenteppich)

"Deutschland über alles" bedeutet nicht die Expansion, sondern die Einheit Deutschlands "über alles", also das oberste Ziel.

[morphinlounge101]

Zudem heißt es in dieser Strophe

"Wenn es stets zum Schutz und Trutze,

brüderlich zusammenhält" begriffe der Verteidigung

es steht nicht zum "Schutz und Angriff".

[A2Z83]

He apologized. So hes just ignorant not controversial.

[A2Z83]

some of the Germans were cheering.

[gossipgirlX0XO]

screw you, sauerkrauts eaters.

he's a damn genius.

[TJdipshit]

Wenn ich da gewesen wäre hätte ich dem irgendetwas hartes an den Kopf geworfen das dem die Rübe geplatzt wäre !

[Obasiliasfilosofos]

I thought those lyrics were brought in during the Imperial era and not the third Reich.

[kensei85]

LOL, he's a Brit taking the piss. xD

[paulgallagher13]

very funny

crowd overreacted in my opinion;

[TJdipshit]

Jaa?? du denkst DAS ist lustig?

Wie wäre es wenn du kleine Wurst mal besser im Geschichts Unterricht aufpassen würdest? Dann würdest du ganz genau wissen WIE lustig das ist !

[paulgallagher13]

entspannen, wußte er nicht, es war beleidigend.

die Sängerin selber Jude ist und trotzdem das Lied ist älter als die Nazis

[kantonerei]

In Deutschland sind alle 3 Strophen des Deutschlandliedes erlaubt, aber nur die 3. Strophe ist heute noch Teil der deutschen Nationalhymne. In Deutschland gibt es einfach zu viele Linke!

In Germany all 3 stanzas are allowed, but today only the 3rd is the official anthem of Germany. There are just in Germany to many left-wingers.

[KCgrunge]

sweet :D

[Kaiserbass1]

Okay, I can´t take it any longer now. We, the Germans, know very well what happened and learned from it. But over 60 years later we still aren´t allowed to have some patriotism. If we do, we are called Nazis. THIS is stupid. The truth is, if you did not listen to the regime in 3. Reich o even protestetd you were a dead person.

[igorokblabla]

You know what the most patriotic thing for you to do? name your son adolf.

Germans should be proud of their nation, but this kind of sh(staff) should not be allowed. This song represents the third reich, and nazism.

[thembrown]

lol what a mupped, should have paid attention to secondry school history

[sheridanrepton]

Maybe you should have paid more attention during the spelling lessons!

[thembrown]

oh behave

[TorSalqvist]

Can we ban Hitler's favourite food, drink, football team, city, hobby??? Can we ban Volkswagen, Berlin, the name "Adolf"??? Stupidity...

[TorSalqvist]

The lyrics of the Deutchlandlied was written in 1841 by von Fallersleben, and it's music was composed in 1797 by Joseph Haydn. Is Hayden, or Fallersleben nazi, racist or something similar? Brainwashed stupid "germans"!!!

[tommix68]

We German know´s our History! You didn´t, so shut up with your "Halbwissen über Deutschland" ! Atom are very usefull in some cases... should i love the atombomb anyway? So: the Lyrics from Hoffmann von Fallersleben are pretty nice, but not all usefull today because its soiled by bad guys in the past! No one is Brainwashed here!

[therealbangaio]

Young Germans have been brainwashed.

[snusansmammut]

Hahaha, he so did that on purpose. OFC. he knew that line was controversial.

[szuperpeti]

Germans can't be proud, cuz they are a sinned nation!!! (last 60 years brainwash)

For the germans, Germany should be "über alles"!

[AlastairSnaresbrook]

Pete Docherty is a moron. Trying to make out he is sophisticated by singing Deutschland Ueber Alles, which everyone knows anyway...

I would have been more impressed if he had sung the Horst Wessel song.

All together now: "Die fahne hoch..."

[d4d00d]

lolwut?

[cmoakinza]

0:19 -> Loooove that part xD

[wenomking]

todays "germany"=a zionist slave country.

[ChasehaWing]

history is something that can not be changed, and has shaped our culture whether we wanted it or not. All history should be preserved and protected, no matter what evil it caused in the past. For if we forget, then we'll make the same mistake, and fall back into another dark circle forever.

[fuoser]

it is the thing what ebony bones posted? and btw what for idiots are posting here? "unsere hymne" ??? jewish puppetmasters? brainwashed? omg... im not brainwashed or manipulated just because i dont love a nation what is full of children of nazis plus full of neonazis - but on the otherside i would not get angry just because someone who is a fckn junky since years want to shock. and if he d sang this in another city im sure the people had clapped till blood came out of their fingers. just sad.

[mgabor82]

I think the germans are so afraid of their jewish puppetmasters, that they rather hiss the singer off the stage who is singing their original anthem.

Its pathetic....

Wake up real Germany

[WUNDENFLAMME]

Exactly!

People who did boo were just selfhating Marxist retards!

Germans in general are not upset!

Because this line is part of their anthem!

But some people are so dumbed down that they hate themselves, their country, their tradition and culture!

I piss on these mind-slaves!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Obasiliasfilosofos]

The singer is a Jew dumb ass

[MonchitoES]

Im pretty sure nazis would not like junkie scum like him.

[alanjayee]

@MonchitoES hahahaha thats hilarous

[joancatala]

GEGEN NAZIS!!!

Estúpid de merda!!!

[littleborz]

aber noch immer grösser denn deins.. Dieser junkie vollgekokst und als ausländer.. Und Deutschland? Wo seid ihr? Ihr spuckt gerade eure Anthem.. Egal ob es einmal in eine kritische Zeit was anders bedeutet hat. Brainstorming hat euch völlig erreicht..

[Odinstafel]

ich frag mich nur warum hier gepfiffen und gebuht wird..... sicher nicht aus dem grund das hier ein drogenkranker unsere hymne verunglimpft....

[funlivelife]

what a fucktard...

[Veszett01]

What's wrong with you germans? You are so completely brainwashed? This is one of your national symbols, dont loose it, because of media and other lies...

[zionband]

Are you an american Veszeet ?? It seems to be. I'm not an american nor German, but can really understand the Germans and you know what ? They were humble enought to change the way they sing their national anthem since the 2nd war because of the nazism connotation of the 1st verse. Their nation made a huge mistake on the past, so others did, but they are ashamed of it. Good to remember forever their people and people from other nations how we should NOT to be. Congratulations for you Germans !

[Veszett01]

What is that mistake, they were leaded by propaganda? The national-socialists maked the same what communists, or USA, or Izrael, or the whole Eu, but the last four are the idols, and the first is the evil? They changed it, and they lost a part of their culture. They dont know about that, but they lost abilities, and got new ones, which maked from them perfect targets, for the globalisation. American? Im not a blind slave of zionists, excuse me! I'm a proud hungarian...

[supremewhiteguy]

cant sing - hes no McCartney

[NSBM74]

Ich bin total schockiert mich der Vater meines Großvaters war halb deutsch, aber nicht dumm und sie sind jetzt die Deutschen respektieren die Ausnahme! Deutschland über alles! "

[NSBM74]

Unglaublich, dass die lettische Volk deutsche Volk, sind einer Gehirnwäsche unterzogen, vielleicht, wenn ihre Nationalhymne geht, auch give a damn? Was geschah mit den Menschen? ausschließlich in Ihrem Haus ist gegen die Schweiz stimmte gestern nicht mehr gebaut werden Minarett des deutschen Volkes in Deutschland, Ausländer seinen Arsch lecken? des jüdischen Volkes in den Medien so ausgelöscht das Wort Patriotismus?

[mcity88]

Sorry this man is Jewish and singing the German National what is racist about this? he's choosing an ancestral side and it's not his Jewish side

[popoe13]

Hey, at least he didn't bust out with some "Horst Wessel Lied." Now that would have been funny...

[Gutenberg1]

kann es nicht sein, dass er die eigentliche Hymne singen wollte, um dem Publikum zu gefallen, aber wusste nicht, dass wir inzwischen die dritte strofe als hymne benutzen? Ich meine, bei so viel Kox ist es doch klar, dass er keinen klaren Kopf hat :)

[HoraceScope]

Finally all those drugs have killed the last bit of prodigy brain left in him. I don't know why anyone would want to see that arsehole junkie live anyway.

[papasch1umpf]

i think germany is the only nation in the world where the people are this disturbed by their past that they are insulted when someone sings a patriotic anthem

[routeoz]

one reason they are 'disturbed' is the carpet bombing we subjected their cities to. that really screwed them up.

[PaleSSz]

germany is not the only nation... think about hungary...

[orgay3]

Fuck him!

I understand that he was trying to be sarcastic in some kind of way, but this was very disrespectful and mindless of him. Good that he was kicked out!

[AlexLikesBritain]

Well, I think he doesn't know what this first verse means. I mean most of the German don't know its meaning.

BUT I must say, that I hate Nazis, and yeah, actually most German do that. I just hate the predjuice that all German are Nazis, and like Hitler, and what he did. They don't do!

[TehWilly94]

wow, someone with a brain

i hate nazis aswell, but im not one

i dont know what problems people have with their prejudices about all germans being nazis

those are probably even more nazi themselves than "we" are

[HungarianVeritas]

I bet in the German schools all students have to write down 100 times this text every single day. But let me tell you something: You Germans will always be the evil people no matter what how many times you will kneel down before the Jews. Can be hard to live with a guilt complex.

[TehWilly94]

i dont live with any guilt cuz i havent done a shit

and no we dont have to write down anything nazi-like

[letterbekmen]

hmm the "german

people are the ones booing him. i wonder if the russians would boo a singer because of singing a communist song

[Gellande]

I think this was not a provocation, but a good/cheap commercial

I mean tomorrow all around the world the jewish press and internet media will be writing about this

so this guy gets big publicity:D

[volxjaeger]

Deutschland, Deutschland über alles,

Über alles in der Welt,

Wenn es stets zu Schutz und Trutze

Brüderlich zusammenhält,

Von der Maas bis an die Memel,

Von der Etsch bis an den Belt........

[Mike500001]

Provocation just for provocation's sake. Or maybe he is uneducated about the meaning of the first verse. But somehow i doubt it.

Disgusting.

[krajoka]

Ébredjetek már seggfejek. Saját magatokat fülyülitek ki. Európa legagymosottabb népe.

[Gutenberg1]

a magyarok után

[troublemakerw]

henrikepoeta!

fuck you, son of a bitch

he made it not right!

i´t not right what you say.

Du kleiner Hund.

Klar wahren die nazis das problem und nicht das land , wie kann deutschland b.z.w das heutige deutschland für seine geschichte.

Keiner redet gerne über das thema weil es einfach schrecklich wahr.

[henrikepoeta]

He made it right, the problem is not with the NAZI, it is with the country...

man, NOBODY can stop a song, even if it is a cover, only because of being a hymne, even if in a prohibited version!

[Gellande]

Is it a provocation? German croud didn't like it.

Anyway I don't think it was a good idea, modern germans are frightened of anything which connects to Hitler

[ZBmuzik]

Nice! :-)

[HeleneForever0086]

Mais pourquoi il a fait ça ???

[HungarianVeritas]

Il a essayé de redonner leur fierté peut-etre.

[stonercrawler1]

peut-etre il n'a pas su q'on ne chante pas les premieres phrases en allemand.