Added: 4 years ago
From: marauders11
Views: 59,339
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (173)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I hate James. He made Sev's life living Hell AND stole the girl he loved. Speaking of Hell, remind me to ask dear James how hot it is down there while Sev and Lily chill in heaven!!

  • This song will always remind me of snape now.

  • grrrrr stupid beeping bleeping beeping james and his beeping bleeping beeping friends leave beeping severus ALONE!!!!! and everyone was saying hpow great james potter was and now i see this grrrrrrrr!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • James is a hottie

  • James is such a fag.

    

  • snape is great!!!

  • Harry's face is awesome. Poor kid, saw his dad doing bad stuff.

  • I was so excited to watch this particular scene because it was my favourite chapter in the book and of course, look what they do to it. :((

  • a day in the life (Y)

  • I love this song with this video..haha i just laugh all the time!

  • I don't think i'm right but wasn't harry's mom supposed to be in that scene?

  • Yep.

  • Yep, she was the one who told James to stop picking on Snape and that James was immature or whatever it was.

  • @LovelyComplex4 Yeah she's supposed to try and stop them but Snape calls her a "mudblood" and she gets pissed

  • Comment removed

  • I thought Sirius and James were two hot guys! what happened?!

  • whats this song?

  • This scene sucks. I was looking so forward to it and it was so disappointing. This scene was one of the biggest parts for the movies and I was hoping for it to be much better than this. Dx

  • this scene sucks in the movie!! It was so important in the book. And the marauders look so... no marauders! James looks almost like he's red haired. And young Snape also sucks compared to the great Alan Rickman!!

    Sorry for the movies' fans

  • :o SNAPE'S HOT!

  • I know! O: I believe so both when he is in the past and then the present Snape (i.e. first book, second book, third book, etc.). 8DDD!

  • Lol.. the beatles. That song just made my day

  • Very very ugly scene!! honestly i think any fan can make a much better work

  • Hahha!! A Day in the Life... LOL ^^

  • (in the film) they make them look really...? Un-hottish?

  • caya friki

  • Existen tantas fallas en esa escena, primero por que Lupin esta riendo (Se supone que deberia estar leyendo su libro) Sirius no tiene ni el porte ni la cara que dice el libro que deberia de tener , No esta lily, la escena dura 3 segundos, no no no no me gusta nada! es mas nisiquiera dieron con la tunica!

  • oh God, i totally hated this scene in the morning.

    it was completely wrong.

    and tooo hort.

    we missed a lot of information.

  • I totaly agree!

  • Me too! It is my best part, and it was so short in the moovie... By the way, the whole film was too short and i didn't like it at all. :/

  • Not best, favourite. Sorry.^^

  • @abbyemarlowx3 i totally agree the movie messed SO many things up! it made me sooo mad!

  • Eres increible, cada clip que veo en tu canal me sorprende aun mas, te felicito. Por otra parte, este mv, me viene bien ^^...acabo de descubrir hace poco como pega the beatles con el mundo marauder :O..

  • JKR se inspiro en lso Beatles para crear a los Marauders, Ella dijo que era una gran fanatica: Misma epoca, personajes similares (James-Lennon, Paul-Sirius, Harrison-Lupin y Ringo-Peter) si pega mucho los beatles cn los marauders.

  • caramba no lo sabia o_ó!...y en ese caso ahora si no podre parar de escucharlos ^ ^..porque me.. me gusta los marauders (!!).

  • Yo sabía que el hijo de John Lennon (Sean Lennon)se había quejado una vez por que decía que Harry Potter era un plagio de si mismo. Por alguna razon me hace pensar que John Lennon inspiro James Potter y Sean Lennon a Harry Potter. No se igual son tonterias mias, pero me llama la atencion el parecido de los Beatles con los merodadores

  • Lo más extraño, es que escogieron una Lily Joven para que no apareciera en la escena... Lol (What is most strange thing, is that they chose a Young Lily and she didn't appeared in the scene)

  • OMG SNAPE IS A CUTE KID

  • Brill idea. Great to be able to see everything. It was so quick in the film.

  • De hecho los Marauders estaban en los 60´s , deberian tener el look mas beatlesco y usar colores psycodelicos. James parece nerd

  • whats the name of the song

  • "A Day in the Life" by The Beatles. I think its the last track on the Sgt. Pepper album.

  • I♥Snape

  • Why is James' mouth all wonky?

  • Beatles and Harry Potter Rock!

  • that's not extended.. they just made the vid slower..

  • Erm, no. He /dies/.

  • No Lily. That pissed me off.

  • a hate this part of the movie... its sooo bad!!

  • lol the musics funny at the end. 00:25 it looks like harrys wearing lipstick ps he look kinda cute wen he was in schhool just in the walking bit at the start

  • The extended version wasn't on the dvd.

    I was very disappointed!

  • omg really!!! I was really looking forward to it!

  • this is so sad. i was like going to cry when i saw this part in the theatre. :(

  • Is this the music that plays during it! How did you get it! It's perfect!

  • No, there's actually dialogue during this illegally uploaded scene

  • ¬¬ Sinceramente...to esperando essa maldita cena sair em filme des de 2003...e quando sai não é nem ao menos uma cena ¬¬

    Marotos nada a ve

    Lily não aprece

    Lembrança RIDICULA

    AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAI Q OOOOOOODIOOOOOOOOOOO ¬¬

  • its sucks that theres no lily! >:(

  • They'd better not cut out my snapey's story, it's major important!! It has impact on the whole entire series, it's connected in every way possible.

  • I kno, that's how I felt

  • I don't see how they can cut the story of Snape. In OotP they reduced the whole memory scene to a minimum - but those who don't read the books will at least now know that James Potter bullied Snape at school. Considering the reason Snape protects Harry all these years hangs on his love and his guilt to Lily it would be an disaster if the films did not show this - and an insult to ALL Harry Potter fans.

  • Dito!

  • I LIKE YOUR NAME :) haha

  • hear hear

    SnapesPotionMistress

    Well put!

  • Thank you 'imtosexyformyself' :o) I guess I just voiced what all us ardent Harry Potter fans are thinking.

  • I love the scene in the book - in the film it isn't.

    But it's fun^^

    By the way, I have an picture of the real film-Lily.

    Who want to see it, write me a message. :)

  • that blank look on James's face is so hillarious. But they did screw up the entire series with this. Most likely, the sidestory of the Prince will be completely cut out of the seventh movie.

  • I honestly hope they don't. The movie didn't center close enough around Snape and his memories. That's going to bite them in the butt later... ._.;; I'm a dedicated Snape-er. We snape fans seem to know Snape better than anyone, really...

  • Hear hear!

  • If they cut it out of the seventh movie, then they've completely screwed up the whole series, because the reason Harry is even able to defeat Voldemort is COMPLETELY based around Snape and everything Snape has been doing through the years to protect Lily's son.

  • i cant belive how mean james is to snape! im on the 5 one but my sister reads um so sometimes when im riding in the car with her and her boyfriend, and she blurbs stuff out

  • they casted a role for lily but then they deleted her off -_- why cast someone then?

  • It sucks that Lily wasn't in the movie. It was one of the best parts in the book and they ruined it. And what is Harry doing there? If it's Snape's memory he's not meant to be there!

  • I agree!

  • Agree with you on the Lily part, bien sure. When it comes to the Deathly Hallows film they are fucked. I fear they will cut out the hole Snape plot.

    Harry is in there because in the books it's happens in Snape's Pensieve. But obviously Yates thought to show Harry invading Snape's privacy would put a wrong complexion on Harry. And that's shit.

  • love it

  • last film and book I read was the goblet of fire...what is this? and why are they so mean to Snape?...

  • You have to read the fifth book to get a better understanding.

  • sorry about the mistake in the nickname I had a two year old talking to me he can't pronouce snape so he calles him snudy...I typed that by mistake...it was suppose to be snivellus.

  • this clip should have the hole thing here, from Lilly in it to where he says "Who wants to see my take off snudys trousers?". and it should have the clip where James saves Snape.

  • Damn director! Lily is sucha important role! And love Alec here

  • that just makes me incredibly depressed.... I've fallen in love with Snape since the last book and i didnt cry as much as i ever have in a harry potter book as much as i did when i read "The Princes Tale"

    Honestly... Warner Brothers screwed this up so much... the 7th movies is going to be like "WHA? where did that come from?" if the people watching it havent read the books... HONESTLY

    good vid tho!

  • Oh my God...."The Prince's Tale" was the absolute BEST chapter in the entire Harry Potter series. I cried from beginning to end!

  • I know, Me too... I read it five times after finishing the book.. It was so sad... Snape's my favorite character too... :(

  • My favourite chapter in the seventh book,

  • awesome

    the song really fits

  • snape is such a misunderstood guy...

  • james potter needs a slap

  • no he doesnt he was just like that and he got a lot better as he grew up! and plus that actor is quite cute!!

  • well he does in mi opinion. he thought he was 'it'

  • exactly , this scene is like wrong. cos it isnt really his worst memory it was the mudblood bit. They better include the whole book basically in the last movie specially the princes tale chapter for anything to make sense.

  • Lol love the music. I hate how they left out Lily. That was the WHOLE point of it being snapes worst memory, calling her a mudblood. Now its going to be so random in DH with the whole snape-lily thing. If u read the books, it wasnt a COMPLETE shocker, but for the non-readers theyll be like wtf when did this happen? WB really screwed this one up :P

  • Although I would have loved to see this scene be done in its entirety, I don't think that Lily being involved was so important AT THIS TIME, because all the memory really showed originally was Lily trying to defend Snape and him calling her a Mudblood...there was no back story at that time, and no reason why Harry would have understood the significance of that comment. Harry didn't know that Snape had history with Lily.

  • hahahaha, the music to this is the best...

    Yes, they really made this scene too short, almost rushed. I was really looking forward to it and well, was let down...

  • I am sooo annoyed WarnerBros cut this scene short and missed out Lily and everything, when she is VERY important in that scene. AND (totally unrelated to this scene) They missed out like, most of the prophecy AND Harry's conversation with Dumbledore AND there was hardly any Tonks and..and...and ok I give up. lol :)

  • i think they should have showed Lily in this i mean i was waiting for the mudblood but they never showed it uhhh seriously!!!

  • "A Day in the Life" is the perfect song for this scene. John Lennon would have identified with Severus!

  • I watched the movie, but where is Lily? Was she even there?

  • I don't get this, on wikipedia there is a pic of James and Lily arguing in this scene, so where is she?!?!?!

  • they deleted the scene ;_;

  • grrrrrrrrr! No fair! Now theres hardly any marauder scene left. Another thing isn't James meant to have messy hair?

  • I know, that pisses me off. It's such a vital part to the story. It doesn't even look like it will be in DVD either.

  • i found that scne really mean, but kinda funny, you know? Like cause James says "who wants to see me take off his trousers?" [she snorts a short laugh behind her breath and continues] sorry about that.

    great vid! Ha!

  • I love the music ^_^

  • Ugh! Whenever I see this scene, I get so disgusted. It's not because of James' cruelty (though I am ashamed of that) it's becuase the scene is badly done. Why quick flashes? Why the 45 second memory? They should put more effort into it, it was more than half a chapter in the book. And Sirius, who I adore, is not handsome at all, like Rowling described him to be. Bleh. And I don't really like the music you put in, marauders11.. :/

  • dude after the fact that snapes memory becomes beneficial to the plot of the end of deathly hollows, WB is soo fucking screwed that they threw it out, now no one can tell why snape and lily stoped being friends!

  • well, the memory is shown again in deathly hallows.. they can't leave it out there can they?

  • it is david yates that ruined the whole thing really, it was his idea not to have it very long.

    I hate him.

  • I agree I really wanted to see more of the Marauders, I think JK should write a book about them, they are so much more interesting than this 45 second thing

  • i so agree what the hell???? uhh he ruined the whole thing

  • well, hey, they've still got the Deathly Hallows movie to film. They CAN'T leave that scene out then, because then none of the movie watchers will know if Snape was on Dumbledore's side or Voldemort's side. Plus, we'll learn more about Lily, and why it's so significant that Harry has her eyes.

  • They'll probably screw that up too. We don't want Alan Rickman outshining others now, do we?

  • and yes we do want alan rickman outshining others because he is the best character tbh

  • Exactly. It's not just that, but the whole scene where James and Sirius really hurt him. Now Snape's going to look like a Jerk to Harry "just because" when there's a reason behind it. Sorry, but I think Snape's being gyped again!!

  • I know! they will probably cut out everything in the princes tale sxcept for a few things of him and lilly and the part about harry!

  • He's SUPPOSED to still look like a jerk in OOTP. They don't WANT people to know all of Snape's story at this point...if they did, then there's no suspense left for the 6th and 7th movies.

    Everyone is forgetting that these books are told from HARRY'S point of view. Harry is not God, he can't see inside everyone's head or know what everyone is thinking. In OOTP, Harry hasn't yet found out the significance of this memory, nor about Snape's previous relationship with Lily.

  • Damn straight.

  • f**** WB, why in the hell is Remus laughing??? He was the unic who does not! he and lily! and in this little clip, he's laughing!!!

  • I just noticed that. He was NOT laughing in the Book, he distanced himself from "The Marauders". It makes him look just as rotten as James and Sirius were.

  • What's the worst part is...why is Harry there? He can't transport himself into Snapes dream unless he's using a pensieve. That's what ticked me off. Not to mention how very short the whole thing was.

  • Uh, Harry WAS using a pensieve, don't cha remember? o_o

  • Yeah in the fourth movie, but in the fifth he was practicing occulemncy or however you spell it with Snape and Snape got pissed and fired some kind of spell at Harry and Harry protected himself and some how he was transported into Snapes worst memory?? Doesn't make sense. Are you refering to the 7th book because I know harry used the pensieve in it. I was talking about the fifth movie. In the fifth book, yes he did you use a pensieve because he was caught by Snape by looking in it.

  • well in the movie, when Snape uses legilimency, with HArry he also apear in his memories, isn't? well, is a way to make the movie shortter...

  • No, the movie just changed it to perhaps make the scene quicker and more dramatic. In the 5th book, Harry looked into a Pensieve and saw some flashes of Snape's childhood memories, as well as his "Worst Memory."

  • Oh, btw, I just realized, you probably know how it all went down in the book, but were only questioning the movie's logic. XD Woops, sorry!

  • i am sooooooooooo mad @ warner bros!

    the media made this big thing about the girl who playes lily and she's not even seen!

    i am going to stop this review now before i say certain words that i will regret later... too late...

    FUCKING WARNER BROS----I HATE YOU...GO TO HELL DIPSHIT!!!!

    sorry

    -broadwaybabie

  • actually barbie, WB did put lily potter in the movie. i saw a pic on wikipedia with james and lily talkin to each other while snape is hanging in the air. go to wikipedia and search james potter and you'll see it there (if it isnt taken out). its from a french version novel of OotP. it's probably a deleted scene... :)

  • well, you have a point, but in the DVD extra scenes she does apear...

  • I hope they DO lengthen this scene in the DVD. Apparently there's a lot more to it(closer to the book). This was seen in the "test audience" version of the movie. Hopefully Alec Hopkins' scenes aren't left on the cutting room floor.

  • Can I ask where you saw this. They just released news on official Harry Potter Websites and they don't include SWM. It may still be in there but the don't mention it

    Sorry, I'll stop hogging the space here and raising a stink!

  • why did you have to put music in it?

  • At least he never out grew the long hair ;)

  • I was soooo angry when I watched this in the theaters!!! Me and my friends were like, OMG I can't wait to see Snape's Worst Memory! And then - they killed it. Where's Lily? Peter? Remus? Sirius? Is Sirius that guy in the back with, like, a freakin' afro? Why does James have blonde hair? Or is it brown? It's hard to tell. Anywho, it's supposed to be BLACK people, not brown! I have no idea how they're going to fix this now that Deathly Hallows has come out.

  • you're right, they really fucked up!

  • you know what i think they're going to do when the Dh goes out in theatres. Is their going to replay that bit of the scene but enhance it and extend it. Like what Harry Missed the first time. I think they wanted to make it as though, Harry Wasn't paying attention to where he was. He didn't even know his mom remus and them were there. He had only payed attention to Snape and His father because that's what was happening.

  • In Dh there going to make it that harry is more observant of that scene. Well thats what i think. Usually happens in movies. I still liked that they at least added it.

  • your right. WB screwed up the movie.

  • They did Sirius' hair like that to match Gary Oldman's look. I agree though, NOT what they have in the book. He definitely is NOT what I'd call "good looking".

  • But you can't really see him, I like the idea of his hair but chose the wrong face

  • the music totally killed the clip.

  • xodancerxo

    i hope so too!

  • 'a day in the life' by the beatles, to whoever wanted 2 kno

  • this would be great without the stupid music, words are so much better,

  • hopefully the whole memory will be on the DVD!

    and the marauders = <3

  • Are you blind? He has brown hair, idiots, and James is the leader, Sirius is meant to be the hottest one of them.

  • It's really a shame that they cut it down so short..no 'mudblood' scene?? That IS the reason why it's Snapes Worst Memory afterall..yea, smart move Yates and Co.

  • yes, thats the point. dont know how they will fix it in the end.. ^^ its a shame.

  • this really hacked me off!hellloo-where was lily?cant believe they butchered a scene i was lookin forward to so much!

  • How on earth did you get this?

    Kinda killed it with that song. I love the Beatles, but naaaah.

    I guess the movie killed this scene anyway coz it was so short and had no Lily! (And they showed the actress in a magazine.. so we all knew a girl had especially dressed up for the movie.. but she wasn't seeeeen!).

  • uhh james looks lyk a right nerd wasnt he lyk suppose to be a the hottest guy @ hogwarts or something?? wasn't he like the quarterback in highschool??

  • Quaterback at highschool???!! HA! This isn't america! In every country besides america there is no 'star member' of a sports team that's super hot or super popular. Nobody's better than the other and it's not like a stupid american teen movie. James is an average looking guy, but not THAT hot. He's supposed to look like Harry remember, just.. average. Sirius on the otherhand might be the fave with the girls. But just coz they're awesome doesn't mean they're all automatically hot too.

  • yea your probably right but still i never imagined James to be THAT nerd-like... by the way did you even see sirius, remus or lupin in here???

  • Is it just me, or does James look overly happy when he announces he's going to take off his pants?

    Oh and he does not look anything like James Potter should. He's Blonde!

  • This song just played on teh radio tonight...great song with this, I hope they have an extended deleted scene cos I didn't see Lily or Remus. And they had a really cool shot of Wormtail on mugglenet or something and I didn't see that.

    Thanks tons for the upload, though!

  • Nice job on fucking this scene up. Every single second matters in the final movie (It will be 3.5 hours plus at least or 2 movies) and now they have to go back and put in this scene in the final movie and waste at least 5 or 6 minutes. They may have never shown this scene, since that was probably a daily occurrence for Snape.

  • By our luck, that WHOLE chapter devoted to Snape's memories will prolly be stuffed into a 1 minute slot or something. As you know, "the average joe has read the books and stuff anyone else it's not as important as the final scene (which we'll extend to 30 minutes and make it oh-so-dramatic (while minusing the important dialogue)" So I agree with you a. Though wait.. theis was more like half a minute than 'wasting 5-6 minutes'

  • All it really has to show is Snape calling Lily a mudblood, which shuldn't take too long.

  • This scene is really CRAPPY. I loved this chapter, but here everything's just fucked up - beginning from the meaning, which is missing, and ending with Sirius, who is not that handsome at all :/

  • nice,like it how snape just launched off the ground..

    whats the song called?

  • A Day in the Life of by The Beatles

  • lily should be in this. snape's worst memory wasn't about the marauders. it was about him calling lily mudblood. why did they cut her part?!

  • Anyone who hasn't read the book will get a wrong idea of the marauders: what we get from here is 1)harry's father is a completely negative character 2)harry's father is some sort of a leader EVEN to his friends (both james and sirius attack snape;they were equally popular;the crowd shouting "james" is ridiculous) 3)remus obviously enjoys the show and goes along with the others(and we all know that he was neutral) and 4) young snape was a pitiable little boy unable to defend himself:)

  • The filmakers ruined the whole movie. How could they leave out the most important scene of all? Now the end isn't going to make any sense. :/

  • can u get that with actual sound not music please please it would be so great

  • Yeah, I bet they really regret not including Susie Shinner (Lily) in this now that the 7th book is out...hehehe.

  • It's like they missed the whole point of the chapter

  • Hopefully she will be in the deleted scenes on the dvd.

  • I really hate that they didn't include Lily in this!

  • I love the Song and the escene!

Loading...
Alert icon