this is the demo version. the chronology of the 'suck' songs goes like this: first, a version was done on pigface's Gub album. then nin started playing it live. then, there was one version performed for a tvt records showcase-type thing. then, this demo. and finally, it was released on broken.
Whispered, toward the end of the CD version. Might be easier to pick out of the mix with headphones on.
Also, yeah, this is from a concert, not a demo. But the audience seems to love it. :-) [And you won't need headphones to hear them cheering.] No problem, so do I.
@rawrrcupcakeface Actually, no it's not. It's an old time fist motion that used to be used in old English pubs by pretty women that meant "you suck" and they would do it when men hit on them.
I hate to say this but I just stole this on the Internet. if you have the Pigface album then upload every song and let me know! I need to learn and compare you know?
This song was on two Pigface albums before it was put on the NIN "Broken" EP, It's been awhile since i had the CD, but this sounds like the version from "Welcome to Mexico Asshole", the other version was "Gub". I think this was written with pigface, which was why it was one of the "hidden tracks" on the Broken cd/tape, the other hidden treack was a remake of an old Adam Ant song i think.
I think this song in general is one of the sexiest songs ever made. But i also think its as good as the version on there ep Broken where did you get this by the way?
This is fucking brilliant. The album version is watered down and shitty, whereas this has that gritty, grungy feel that early NIN has.
tl;dr I fucking love it.
AriadnesThreadx 3 weeks ago
This kills the album version.
FoetalSpace 3 months ago
Awesome!!
RussX5Z 10 months ago
Is this the live version?
ViewWatchGori19 1 year ago
hell yeah
jjanis 1 year ago
this is actually a Pigface song (Reznor being an early part-time member of Pigface).
DharmaMidget 1 year ago
@DharmaMidget so did trent write it then or??
ChildIncomplete 6 months ago
i wish he put the suck suck suck on the broken album
yagsisiht99 1 year ago 2
It's the DEMO sent out by TVT with SUPERNAUT ... That cd case looks very very familiar ...
djsloane 1 year ago
@djsloane I believe a band called "Taste Of Sugar" had a similar cover for their single "Hmm Hmm".
v73k1 7 months ago
even better version.. awesome!
xFrankIero14 1 year ago
Wow, this version is great (why the hell does it surprise me?:D)
Mertule93 1 year ago
love this... should have been a a radio release...
BlackoutDOTcom 1 year ago
this is a live version
AOCRkid 1 year ago
@AOCRkid
sounds like AATCHB to me
starstruckstarfuck 1 year ago
@starstruckstarfuck lol the link's right over there it's not
AOCRkid 1 year ago
This version has a more ministry sound to it than the broken one.
LeadBasedPaintFiend 1 year ago
this is the version that was played on the radio back in the day. I was so used to it. It's a bit different on the 'broken" CD
CatW2Kidz 1 year ago
@CatW2Kidz No suck suck suck on Broken. The chorus is more like the version on the Pigface album Gub. Music is totally different tho.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
How... Does it... FEEL!? Suck, suck, suck!
larwa556 1 year ago
This is probably my favorite song by Trent. Cool to see different versions out there.
BrianPsychicBabystar 2 years ago
When does it say
"A thousand lips a thousand tongues
A thousand throats a thousand lungs
A thousand ways to make it true
I want to do terrible things to you"
I can never hear it
autumnailbi05 2 years ago
It's not in the demo version, i guess. It's there in the Broken-Version, at the very end.
MeInHighDefinition 2 years ago
That's my favorite part of the song. It surprised me one day back in school... had my headphones on and was like "wow didn't know that was there"
BrianPsychicBabystar 2 years ago
That is said at the very end when Trent is barely whispering it--at least on the CD track
This versions seems different from the broken albums version. I wonder if it is one of the LP versions.
amrchaos 2 years ago
this is the demo version. the chronology of the 'suck' songs goes like this: first, a version was done on pigface's Gub album. then nin started playing it live. then, there was one version performed for a tvt records showcase-type thing. then, this demo. and finally, it was released on broken.
suicidecontrition 2 years ago
right at the end of the song
yagsisiht99 2 years ago
@autumnailbi05
Whispered, toward the end of the CD version. Might be easier to pick out of the mix with headphones on.
Also, yeah, this is from a concert, not a demo. But the audience seems to love it. :-) [And you won't need headphones to hear them cheering.] No problem, so do I.
0mn1vore 4 months ago
A chick sucking a dick! Duh!
XD
rawrrcupcakeface 2 years ago 17
@rawrrcupcakeface Actually, no it's not. It's an old time fist motion that used to be used in old English pubs by pretty women that meant "you suck" and they would do it when men hit on them.
haha I'm just messing with you.
STVYT 11 months ago
I hate to say this but I just stole this on the Internet. if you have the Pigface album then upload every song and let me know! I need to learn and compare you know?
sevendust9 2 years ago 3
@sevendust9 No suck suck suck on Broken. The chorus is more like the version on the Pigface album Gub. Music is totally different tho.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
boy is the studio version an improvement
WLDFLD 2 years ago 2
this isn't a demo you can hear people cheering in the beginning obviously
GonejaDash 2 years ago
derp.
firej666 2 years ago
AWEsome
mrway667 2 years ago
What's that picture supposed to represent?
TheDivineVessel 2 years ago
Looks like a chick giving a blow job.. lol
EthernetKid 2 years ago
lol, well it fits the title of the song, I guess...
TheDivineVessel 2 years ago
yes, what possible connection to the song title could it have
hmmmmmmm
WLDFLD 2 years ago
This is off the Broken EP
the 99th track.
NyQuilNyQuilNyQuil 3 years ago
I've never heard this version before, It's pretty good :O
Rhii 3 years ago 10
This song was on two Pigface albums before it was put on the NIN "Broken" EP, It's been awhile since i had the CD, but this sounds like the version from "Welcome to Mexico Asshole", the other version was "Gub". I think this was written with pigface, which was why it was one of the "hidden tracks" on the Broken cd/tape, the other hidden treack was a remake of an old Adam Ant song i think.
HexMarksthespot 3 years ago
I think this song in general is one of the sexiest songs ever made. But i also think its as good as the version on there ep Broken where did you get this by the way?
givewingstomytriumph 3 years ago
Ive already posted this... but just so youll get the email notification.....
This sounds like version that was on the pigface CD "Welcome to Mexico: Asshole"
HexMarksthespot 3 years ago
aww bummer he dosent say in this version the old into ¦ this is a song about sex with animals(see pretty hate 89 if you don't belive meow) =3
deathzeath 3 years ago
Trent Reznor doing the lyrics for this song with Pigface covering the music is even better.
Great either way.
Medazzone 3 years ago