@Nateh918 Jews dislike this because God refers to them as his bad grapes
(Isaiah 5:7) For the vineyard of the LORD of hosts is the house of Israel, and the men of Judah his pleasant plant: and he looked for judgment, but behold oppression; for righteousness, but behold a cry.
Try reading the whole chapter or better yet the the Bible!
The American civil war is still the deadliest war in US history 612000 dead. A prelude to the massacres of WW1.I wonder why Europeans didn't see it coming and marched out with medals shining.
@Durendal33 Europe had the Crimean War, the Franco-Prussian War and many colonial wars to base their decisions on. The problem was both sides thought they HAD learned from these conflicts, but they were the wrong things
i always think of proud yank when i hear this song but now look at the usa there broke and have the black jesus runing things wat the fuck happen man wtf happen
musicians used to be able to sing religious songs in public?? he'd be thrown in jail for singing this today. (not completely joking, either). beautiful song. great performance. :)
@GrandNagusRom What an assinine comment. Some brothers fought against each other, some sons opposed their father, but not that many. Do you really think that the millions emancipated from cruel and inhuman bondage by the advance of the Union forces could be said to have lost. Do you think for one moment that the United States as presently constituted could have have ever come into being with the whole abhorrent slavery apparatus intact? Many lost but in no sense did everyone lose.
@SoCalBuck42 There was actually mexicans in the civil war too. On both sides Yankees and Confederates...Mexico actually saved our asses from the french...The French were trying to invade the U.S. through northern mexico while the U.S. was weak due to the civil war. Thats why we observe Cinco de Mayo, obviously you didn't know that....if your saying some mexican disliked it. Next time get your Intel right with your cheesy remarks.
@Chon12490 The french weren't invading us and the Mexicans didn't stop them. Napoleon put Maximilian, in Mexico as an attempt to control the area. He'd wanted to get a foothold in the New World again. Obviously, putting this puppet leader in charge of Mexico was in direct defiance of the Monroe Doctrine. He only got away with it because the US was involved in the Civil War. We eventually helped the Mexicans kick the French out of Mexico. Just saying. But he's just bein a dumbass racist
I don't know why, but when he pulls his guitar behind his back at 1:38, the strap looks like a bandolier or baldric, which makes him look a bit more like a minuteman. It's as if to say that he is willing to be a soldier for his God- his guitar and music as his rifle. Maybe I'm reading too much into this, but I can't help but think that even perhaps these subtle movements, and his marching at 3:15 makes this song all the more beautiful and meaningful, whether it was intentional or not.
No, I don't think your reading too much into it. I mean to me, I can clearly invision him back in those days. Your right about the 1:38 mark it's almost chilling how close it looks like that.
I went to school when this song was allowed and proudly sung!!! Todays generations do not realize what has been lost in todays public education system
@oranjeleeuwen1 I find it offensive for people to patronize my generation. I truely hope that you get a thesarus for Christmas because your language is very rude. June Carter would back hand you.
Amazing performance from JR - almost like a character from the Bible - it's been said before and his charisma & legend seems to grow over time. Walk the Line R.I.P.
Sadly the Man In Black would not be allowed by law to sing this song to our troops to were he still with us. Even Chaplains can no longer by law mention the word "God" in their words to U.S. servicemen today. :(
Slavery was completely BARBARIC and INHUMANE but I do wonder if we could have resolved the the slavery issue like all the other western nations without killing 1/4th of our population. Many other nations at that time paid the slave-holders for their slaves and banned slavery without war.
@GrandNagusRom I'll tell you who won the war, the United States won the war, because we are still one united nation. IF not there would be both a United States of American and Confederate States of America
Well this 'song' is in the Ancient & Modern Hymnbook used by the Anglican Church - it has beautiful words - and I loved it so much that 41 years ago it was sung at my wedding. I can say that unlike many wedding hymns nearly all the congregation knew the words by heart and it was sung with gusto.... Oh and I'm not American - live over the pond in the grand UK.
When the great Johnny Cash presents this grand old song it becomes more than a song, it is a story taking place in front of us all and we begin to feel the heart beat of a Nation divided while these brave souls place themselves into the line of fire. Place themselves into the line of our Nations history.
Southerners were mislead by their leaders. Kind of like our country now. Its easy to believe something when its all you have ever been taught. People put too much faith in man instead of god and that is our first mistake.
i dont dislike the confederate states of america because they used slaves(although i don't condone slavery), i dislike them because they were traitors to my great country
@kingoftheworld656564 its good slavery isnt the reason cause there were 4 confederat slave states and 2 union slave states so your own "great" country was as bad
@sexywpgboy im aware. everyone thinks the war was about slavery but it really was about taxes and states rights. i just think that the southern states should have taken a different approach to solving the problem rather then seceeding
@ksmith8446 Umm...Yeah they can. It was written by a Yankee gal. In Washington, DC. The, not as popular, southern version was so poorly written that its popularity never took off. I have a book with it written in it, but I've never heard it sung by anyone except myself; and don't expect my youtube video anytime soon!
It was not sung by both sides; not by the traitors: "let us die to make men free" it says.
lcmagill 1 day ago
I like when he said a person does not have to be rich to own a song
yutubemomma 5 days ago
why does he strum his guitar on the fretboard and not on the sound hole? i've noticed he does it all the time...
SanctumVeri 1 week ago
Oh Christ, I totally got chills listening to this.
chalicechiq 1 week ago
This is, and always was, a yankee blue belly song. Never sang by CSA soldiers or militia!!
TheBuster31 1 month ago
@TheBuster31 correct CSA #1 we did not loose we gave up :::
waylntat2 3 weeks ago
This song wasn`t sung by both sides.
pelinallat 1 month ago 2
@pelinallat If Johnny Cash says they did then they DID.
imaStonesFan 2 weeks ago 2
WOW!!
noaj8121986 1 month ago
who had to be THAT GUY who disliked this? really?
Nateh918 1 month ago
@Nateh918 ever heard of osama bin laden?
tsunayoshisawada 1 month ago
@Nateh918 Jews dislike this because God refers to them as his bad grapes
(Isaiah 5:7) For the vineyard of the LORD of hosts is the house of Israel, and the men of Judah his pleasant plant: and he looked for judgment, but behold oppression; for righteousness, but behold a cry.
Try reading the whole chapter or better yet the the Bible!
BigJEWMachine 4 weeks ago
If any Human Really does go Straight to Heaven It would have Been Mr.Cash
Gegamel76 1 month ago
@Gegamel76 hey look a troll
davidvcolarusso 1 month ago
the oine yank that watched this didnt like it... this is amazing
gunnut3345 1 month ago
The American civil war is still the deadliest war in US history 612000 dead. A prelude to the massacres of WW1.I wonder why Europeans didn't see it coming and marched out with medals shining.
Durendal33 1 month ago
@Durendal33 Europe had the Crimean War, the Franco-Prussian War and many colonial wars to base their decisions on. The problem was both sides thought they HAD learned from these conflicts, but they were the wrong things
thebigJM92 1 month ago
@thebigJM92 Still a shame we lost a great singer like Johnny Cash
Durendal33 1 month ago 2
@Durendal33 Definitely
thebigJM92 1 month ago
i always think of proud yank when i hear this song but now look at the usa there broke and have the black jesus runing things wat the fuck happen man wtf happen
brokenhillcabbie 1 month ago
Here's the thing. There's just no way any Confederate who ever fought in the ACW was singing this song as they marched home. LOL
TheRARaines 1 month ago
musicians used to be able to sing religious songs in public?? he'd be thrown in jail for singing this today. (not completely joking, either). beautiful song. great performance. :)
a35intheShade 2 months ago
@a35intheShade Amen! The Statler Brothers did so as late as 2002!
SuperOffgrid 1 month ago
see you in heaven johnny reb
See you in hell billy yank
erketjetter 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@GrandNagusRom What an assinine comment. Some brothers fought against each other, some sons opposed their father, but not that many. Do you really think that the millions emancipated from cruel and inhuman bondage by the advance of the Union forces could be said to have lost. Do you think for one moment that the United States as presently constituted could have have ever come into being with the whole abhorrent slavery apparatus intact? Many lost but in no sense did everyone lose.
UISTMAN59 2 months ago
Comment removed
UISTMAN59 2 months ago
@GrandNagusRom Amen brother
Smiley8569 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
What asshole dont like this?
Luckisaor 2 months ago 28
@Luckisaor maybe it's a Vogon: tatatataaa... no....
Sudoku123456789 2 months ago
@Luckisaor Some mexican
SoCalBuck42 2 months ago
@SoCalBuck42 There was actually mexicans in the civil war too. On both sides Yankees and Confederates...Mexico actually saved our asses from the french...The French were trying to invade the U.S. through northern mexico while the U.S. was weak due to the civil war. Thats why we observe Cinco de Mayo, obviously you didn't know that....if your saying some mexican disliked it. Next time get your Intel right with your cheesy remarks.
Chon12490 1 month ago
@Chon12490 The french weren't invading us and the Mexicans didn't stop them. Napoleon put Maximilian, in Mexico as an attempt to control the area. He'd wanted to get a foothold in the New World again. Obviously, putting this puppet leader in charge of Mexico was in direct defiance of the Monroe Doctrine. He only got away with it because the US was involved in the Civil War. We eventually helped the Mexicans kick the French out of Mexico. Just saying. But he's just bein a dumbass racist
Nateh918 1 month ago
Johnny Cash, Legend.
kophead81 2 months ago
I don't know why, but when he pulls his guitar behind his back at 1:38, the strap looks like a bandolier or baldric, which makes him look a bit more like a minuteman. It's as if to say that he is willing to be a soldier for his God- his guitar and music as his rifle. Maybe I'm reading too much into this, but I can't help but think that even perhaps these subtle movements, and his marching at 3:15 makes this song all the more beautiful and meaningful, whether it was intentional or not.
Sramaram 2 months ago 11
@Sramaram
No, I don't think your reading too much into it. I mean to me, I can clearly invision him back in those days. Your right about the 1:38 mark it's almost chilling how close it looks like that.
111Chance 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Sramaram That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life.
MrBradDelaney 2 days ago
Thank you for posting this.
Lddy 3 months ago
I went to school when this song was allowed and proudly sung!!! Todays generations do not realize what has been lost in todays public education system
czar4freedom 3 months ago
@czar4freedom You went to school? Oh wow.
Dibbleg1 2 months ago
@Dibbleg1 You're being a cunt.
oranjeleeuwen1 2 months ago
@oranjeleeuwen1 I find it offensive for people to patronize my generation. I truely hope that you get a thesarus for Christmas because your language is very rude. June Carter would back hand you.
Dibbleg1 2 months ago
@Dibbleg1 Oh no! Not a backhand! how the hell is anyone patronizing your generation? and I'm sorry for I offended you. You're being a vagina. Better?
oranjeleeuwen1 2 months ago
@oranjeleeuwen1 You very polite. Thats better. I like vagina.
Dibbleg1 2 months ago
@Dibbleg1 I'm surprised.
oranjeleeuwen1 2 months ago
@oranjeleeuwen1 Your a very intelligent human being too. God bless you.
Dibbleg1 2 months ago
@Dibbleg1 haha I'm an A student so I thank you for the compliment.
oranjeleeuwen1 2 months ago
@oranjeleeuwen1 Your very welcome. Now go pull your bottom lip over your head and swallow.
Dibbleg1 2 months ago
@Dibbleg1 You're really funny! That may have been one of the stupidest things used as an insult that I've heard in a while.
oranjeleeuwen1 2 months ago
Amazing performance from JR - almost like a character from the Bible - it's been said before and his charisma & legend seems to grow over time. Walk the Line R.I.P.
Cash900EX 3 months ago
0 dislike what now!
wassssssssup245 3 months ago 2
Everyone who loves Johnny Cash...has a big heart!
joyless666 3 months ago
Absolutely amazing! Very patriotic and heartfelt.
MissMannabelle 3 months ago
OMG I miss Johnny and good old musical TV shows like his!!!!!
mrbigal4u2c 3 months ago
Awesome song, sung by a stellar man.
LetsWaitAndSee 3 months ago
why do they not have a WOW button on YOUR REACTION??
unlost 3 months ago
Can almost smell the corn.
roberreesq 3 months ago
That's my cousin.
UltimateDragon709 3 months ago
his voice always moving, even after so many years
Aryan194466 3 months ago
great song, great singer,great message.
Big G
gerard1875 4 months ago
johnny cash there will be never another.
Lumotaku 4 months ago
I'm pretty sure it was mostly the north that sung this.
johncisney15 4 months ago
@GrandNagusRom
Unless we're fighting aliens, of course.
mudkipzbastard 4 months ago 2
I had no idea this existed.... thank you so much
DavidofThe 4 months ago
@GrandNagusRom Amen
gkopacz 4 months ago
@GrandNagusRom Black people who were no longer slaves were winners.
Hermey7777 4 months ago 2
@Hermey7777 YOU HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD!!! thanks for posting that comment
unlost 3 months ago
Stupidest war ever, and this makes me depressed.
evelynann84 5 months ago
Am I right in saying that the Civil War in America killed more than all subsequent wars combined?
MZophiel 5 months ago
@MZophiel no i dont think so, i think WW2 was teh worst and killed 50 million i think
patriciacarrasco 5 months ago
@patriciacarrasco I meant American troops (from both sides). Sorry was a bit drunk when I wrote that and wasn't very clear.
MZophiel 5 months ago
@MZophiel American troops, yes, no other war had more American casualties then the Civil War
katbig3 5 months ago
@MZophiel The civil war casualties, exceed loss of Americans in all its other wars combined, from the Revolution through Vietnam.
Chon12490 2 months ago
Like all Cash songs - he gives his all !
hitcher177 5 months ago 2
Sadly the Man In Black would not be allowed by law to sing this song to our troops to were he still with us. Even Chaplains can no longer by law mention the word "God" in their words to U.S. servicemen today. :(
JubaL609 6 months ago 2
Slavery was completely BARBARIC and INHUMANE but I do wonder if we could have resolved the the slavery issue like all the other western nations without killing 1/4th of our population. Many other nations at that time paid the slave-holders for their slaves and banned slavery without war.
wtmj100 6 months ago
@wtmj100 The problem was the South would not accept anything and were ready to go to war.
banlin1958 4 months ago
@GrandNagusRom I'll tell you who won the war, the United States won the war, because we are still one united nation. IF not there would be both a United States of American and Confederate States of America
MoneMtwoAbrams 6 months ago 2
Thanks for posting this... and thanks for the warning - my timbers were shivered. Fabulous video.
stillrestless99 6 months ago
For some reason this makes me want to play fallout 3
TcC2317 6 months ago
Well this 'song' is in the Ancient & Modern Hymnbook used by the Anglican Church - it has beautiful words - and I loved it so much that 41 years ago it was sung at my wedding. I can say that unlike many wedding hymns nearly all the congregation knew the words by heart and it was sung with gusto.... Oh and I'm not American - live over the pond in the grand UK.
chig1947 6 months ago
my mom loves this song
Ilvmys 6 months ago
Johnny Cash is the voice of American music!!!!!
shanski2011 8 months ago 2
With deep sincerity and down to earth attitude.
A very moving performance.
klokheten 9 months ago
over 600,000 dead to free the slaves and keep us united.
darylasmith 9 months ago
@darylasmith Nothing to do with the slaves research history
and get it right half of those folks that died were Irish Decent.
ihc1963 8 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@GrandNagusRom ... if all there were was us.
wwjpalmer 9 months ago
Comment removed
wwjpalmer 9 months ago
When the great Johnny Cash presents this grand old song it becomes more than a song, it is a story taking place in front of us all and we begin to feel the heart beat of a Nation divided while these brave souls place themselves into the line of fire. Place themselves into the line of our Nations history.
Schnitzelschitzen 10 months ago
@CrackaStoleMyBoat As much as I agree with your sentiment, I'm afraid this isn't the forum for it.
abargle 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The south shall rise again!
gentleman9876 1 year ago
Southerners were mislead by their leaders. Kind of like our country now. Its easy to believe something when its all you have ever been taught. People put too much faith in man instead of god and that is our first mistake.
America1779 1 year ago
i dont dislike the confederate states of america because they used slaves(although i don't condone slavery), i dislike them because they were traitors to my great country
kingoftheworld656564 1 year ago
@kingoftheworld656564 its good slavery isnt the reason cause there were 4 confederat slave states and 2 union slave states so your own "great" country was as bad
sexywpgboy 1 year ago 2
@sexywpgboy im aware. everyone thinks the war was about slavery but it really was about taxes and states rights. i just think that the southern states should have taken a different approach to solving the problem rather then seceeding
kingoftheworld656564 1 year ago
so beautiful yep the staler bros;,,,./.
grizzlybad56 1 year ago
Johnny Cash does this like nobody else can , My brother Jack is working on this for a show song . Thanks again and keep'em comm'in !!!! Don :)
donderback 1 year ago
Like The legend said, it was sang by both sides, so you yanks can't take credit for it all. thank you much!
ksmith8446 1 year ago
Comment removed
billyIiberty 1 year ago
@ksmith8446 Umm...Yeah they can. It was written by a Yankee gal. In Washington, DC. The, not as popular, southern version was so poorly written that its popularity never took off. I have a book with it written in it, but I've never heard it sung by anyone except myself; and don't expect my youtube video anytime soon!
jasoneb2006 1 year ago
This song has all ways made me Proud to be an American . I all ways think of Abe Lincoln,,,, TY sooooooooooooo much for posting 5*****
riff490 2 years ago
"It's Ray Smith here :) And I can assure you Tony and I are English born and bred"
I'm confused.
shakeypitt 2 years ago
super
das ist musik
tarzan557 2 years ago
super
das ist musik
tarzan557 2 years ago
Wow... I've never heard this before. Johnny Cash is the best. Thanks for posting this.
stillrestless99 2 years ago 30
Goddamn amazing.
FickleDawn 2 years ago 2
This is fantastic! Thank you so much for posting it!
JohnnyCashShow 2 years ago 3