Added: 2 years ago
From: Starcross42
Views: 34,094
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Your motion is operated by your hand... You have a magnet in it and move it up and down, you created this energy, and use the magnet to repel the object... This same motion is seen in all videos of this nature. Nice try

  • Just observe people, don't make any assumptions. Anyway this is all about learning, one way or the other :D

    But don't be mad!

  • @EllisEndye Oh yes. Your point was well made.

  • lol his other hand is so obvious

  • Don´t you all see his other hand? And the irregular movement of the wheel, caused by his pushing? Good morning, people. If you wanna see something real, look for v-gates.

  • @octogunsalata Keep up. No pushing by my hand. But lots of help from the hidden batteries. No such thing as perpetual motion. But thanks for watching so close.

  • can you just make one of these but larger then generate power for your house or something?

    im young so dont say im an idiot for saying this

  • @sabermage1 Not an idiot at all. Lots of smart people for hundreds of years have worked on this very problem. The truth is that it takes energy to make energy. There are 'hidden' batteries that make this and all similar devices work. People want to believe that somehow magnets are magic and just tapping that magic energy can give you something for nothing. Research the problem yourself and you will have a life of fun discoveries. But no magic.

  • why did you put so much effort into something you made as a joke??

  • I have perpetual motion machines that move 9.10938188 × 10-31 kilograms continuously around a ~1.0 × 10-10 meters radius.

    Most importantly, these machines never break or wear out and are guaranteed to maintain their motion in virtually any extreme environment. Motion will not cease for a million years, guaranteed.

    Order now, you will receive ONE BILLION of these machines for ONLY $1.00 +S&H.

    Quantities unlimited.

  • @mindprism Oh I want one. But just one.  Really have no use for a billion of them. Just one would be nice. Can you send one? The chanced you could tell me both when and where it will be an any single time are a bit difficult to do however...

  • @Starcross42 {Can you send one?} Sorry, there is a minimum order. Of course we cannot guarantee you will receive precisely one billion, but you will receive at least that amount.

    Did I mention that the devices are self-repairing, if the moving parts falls off it will search the environment for something to replace it with. They also come in "multi-cylinder" models in case you need more than 1 moving part.

    Check out my product catalog at ptable com. All models have a the exact same price!

  • @mindprism Sweet! I served on a presidential committee with element #106 back in 1989. And I held half of a critical mass of element #94 (the thing he invented) while I was at Los Alamos. So, for $1 I can order a batch of #78 or #79?

  • @Starcross42 Due to national security concerns, certain products are unavailable. But seeing how the wholesale value of #78 and #79 are at their current levels, we can certainly ship you a billion units for $1 + S&H.

    For an accurate quote though, I will have to see what UPS is going to charge me to send 1/3,000,000,000,000th of a gram. Would that be ground or air?

    These devices are incredibly small, but there is a quantity discount of 10% for every 1000 fold in your order.

  • it take energy to create magnets this is your input energy i have tried myself with permanent magnets so create on of these machines and failed every time i know you can do it it just take the right combination and arrangement and/or even a magnetic field barrier(barriers like this don't exist to my knowledge) i would like to see one of these machine finished with all the details i know it can be done. they don't need wires or electricity or wind or gas they have no moving parts they just rotate

  • @thepresident1981 It can NOT be done. Sorry. And 'just rotating' IS a moving part.

  • friction will eventually stop it

  • Man, people haven't posted in a while. Most recent comment 1 month ago? Jaysus, people just dont like lego anymore.

  • This thing is real. I made one very similar , but smaller.

  • so i dont understand how any energy is added, its all self contained theres no bettery or wind or anything

  • @silentsniper441 No, this is a trick. Read all the comments on the first one.

  • so could this thing actually produce electricity?

  • anyone noticed his hand spinning the wheel during the whole video? watch it closely again, in top left corner of the screen! this is fake!

  • @PTBlackDog ... *faceplam*

  • anyone noticed the top left corner of the video? look closely during the whole video! his hand his spinning the wheel! this is fake!

  • Comment removed

  • what is the use of the transistor? which has the battery the motor or the coil? can you please tell me everything i need to know on how the inductor coil was made? i have seen the link on the description but it seems unclear to me.

  • @00pleasehelpme Do you have any electronics skills at all? I did not change anything from the "Top Secret" Simply removed the electronics and glued them to the LEGOs.

  • @Starcross42 No. im just a student.

  • @00pleasehelpme Your profile say 25 years old? This is a 'trick', like all perpetual motion machines. There is no machine that will move without an input of energy. I used it to help my students understand the tricky parts of electricity and magnetism.

  • @Starcross42

    The universe is such a machine.. so you're statement is completely false. Perceptual motion is possible, however it would require much smaller and much more precise machines that are made of nano-structures or even pico-structures to work. Friction is only a problem today because our instruments are too large to fit into the gaps between atoms so they are forced to "rub" on them.

  • @Starcross42

    Also a perfect circle of pyrolytic graphite on top of a permanent magnet in a vacuum would keep spinning forever, unfortunately pi isn't a real number :(

  • can you please give me the exact link where you based this device from? please answer ASAP thnx

  • @dhianne2024 This is a trick. I based the movement on the electronics found inside a toy. Google "Top Secret Toy" and you can get your own. Good luck.

  • @dhianne2024 This is a trick. I based the movement on the electronics found inside a toy. Google "Top Secret Toy" and you can get your own. Good luck.

  • can you please give me the exact link where you based this device from? please answer ASAP thnx

  • Free energy is not here. You'll never generate the return of original energy invested without an additional stimuli (i.e. your hand). No ones covering anything up. It doesn't fully work. Full Stop.

  • OK, so the capacitor is discharged quicker than the fan can charge it up? My understanding is that you can't get more out than you put in......unless you have a gain medium.

  • Powered by it's own energy I see

  • to all those who failed the concept of an induction coil and how it works...

    An induced current by a CHANGE in magnetic flux, will move in the direction that in turn when observed, would generate a magnetic flux that is in opposition to that of the inducing magnetic field.

    This is not a kick back effect

    As the magnet approach the coil, it is REPELLED, at it moved past it, the perpendicular change in distance is 0, no force is generated.

    As it moves away, it is ATTRACTED = loss of energy.

  • How long will it run without having to give it a physical boost/spin to add extra charge into the system? Interested in this as a toy or curiosity rather than as proof/disproof of free energy.

  • Comment removed

  • in short the more coils you have the more force you can turn the wheel with. The only reason your wheel is slowing down is because you stopped at 2. Go on prove me wrong!

  • @TheFreeweaver u are stupid, and proven wrong already by the countless other idiots who fail at concept before practice.

    And so did all the other Edisons.

  • Lets look at this logically. 1. Air and bearing resistance do not increase by adding coils 2. there is no back-EMF so that cannot increase by adding coils 3. the coils kick back is directly proportional to the magnets passing by. so, by adding another coil, you would get a free kickback. Add another and you would get another free kickback, and so on...

  • Hold on ... let me get this strait. You believe you have debunked PM. OK i don't believe in PM either. But...

    1. First and foremost you have eliminated back EMF (resistance from cores). Bearing this in mind, if it takes only 2 coils to drive the wheel for a long time with only bearing and air friction slowing it down then i have a request.

    In your next vid please add another 4 coils. 2 as more drive coils and 2 as collectors wired to a separate cap. please see next comment

  • Comment removed

  • clever! xD

  • Starcross:

    I tried to do your continuous movement machine, but lenz law it works also in switch time. I made with a motor axis with magnets in axis to see if amp consume gets up when I switch the coil in the right time.

    What can I do?

  • Starcross:

    I tried to do your continuous movement machine, but lenz law it works also in switch time. I made with a motor axis with magnets in axis to see if amp consume gets up when I switch the coil in the right time.

    What can I do?

  • look in the top left corner of the video. his hand is CLEARLY moving the wheel. Thus, perpetual motion is just a myth in this video.

  • Since it basically recycles the energy it uses, can't you then attach a generator to create electricity to say charge a battery?

  • 0:29 he taps the machine to keep its speed up, i do believe the definition of perpetual motion entails something about no required external energy ?

    hmm .. douche bag ?

  • I dont understand now how it is not a perpetual motion machine. If the fan fills the capacitor then the capactor pulses the coils and there are no more hidden wires, then it is a closed loop and it runs continualy so it is a perpetual motion machine even though it runs in a slightly different way than he explained before?

  • whether there is a capacitor or not if there is no wire running from a powersource to the machine then it is still generationg enough power to keep itself turning is it not? It would then still be a perpetual motion machine, wouldn't it? If the fan fills the capacitor and the capacitor pulses the coils then its a closed loop and still a perpetual motion machine. Im not trying to prove anything here but i would like somebody to tell me what is going on

  • *max facepalm* smaaaaaaaaack :) I love how people go you can't create energy from nothing... blah blah blah. Oh really! get an aluminium rod loads of copper wire. attach end of copper wire to the rod, wrap the rod with brown paper (or another dielectric), wind coil over the paper all the way down, add another layer of brown paper and wrap the coil over that... rinse and repeat :) Bury it in the earth with leads coming from it and measure voltage... shock horror, free energy earth battery!!

  • Very clever. I knew why your explanation in the last video was wrong, but couldn't figure out the trick. How long would it take your machine to run down?

  • lol..free energy has been around for almost 30 years.Check the work of john bedini and tom bearden. The laws of physic are bs. lmao. nice lego...

  • It is right : a device that produce output energy with 0 input energy don't exist. This is because there is no place in the universe with 0 energy. But we can build devices that convert a form of energy in to different ones. If you can find a spot in universe with no energy, then and there I will build a perpetuum mobile.

  • @jrussellslack

    Took only a few minutes to make a perpetual motion machine that convinced a lot of people. ALL perpetual motion machines are tricks. The game is to figure out HOW THE EXTRA ENERGY IS ADDED. The best ones that you see online have a trick. They all do. It's basic physics. Newton didn't invent it so as to keep the big power companies in control. Inertia was around before it was given a name.

    However, throughout history people have searched. Hope you had fun looking.

  • @Starcross42 I dont understand now how it is not a perpetual motion machine. If the fan fills the capacitor then the capactor pulses the coils and there are no more hidden wires, then it is a closed loop and it runs continualy so it is a perpetual motion machine even though it runs in a slightly different way than he explained before?

  • @brandonhill7 sry for the first 2 I was having trouble posting :)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • hahaha! rotating a CPU fan at that very slow rate will not produce a voltage enough to energize the induction coils. I have used a CPU fan to power a 3v led diode and the minimum rotating speed to produce 3 volt is when you attach the CPU fan to a rotating electric drill. less than that the Led wont light

  • @Starcross42

    I considered your reveal and have come to the conclusion that your not telling the real story. It is not possible for the fan motor to produce enough voltage to fire the coil ever 30 degrees since the motor at best could only produce a few mV. Therefore I conclude you are using a battery hidden under the capacitor case. Your quite a trickster. I love it :O)

  • This is just another hoax within a hoax eh? This is as physically impossible as the last explanation you gave. Hilarious, I love it.

  • which is the value of capacitor cual es el valor del capacitor?

  • Wait so no batteries are involved? It powered itself? You didn't directly say that but its what I interpreted from what you said?

  • These are 2 szeperate videos!!! You can also see his hand on the top left spinning the wheel!!!

  • OK a question. The rotation speed is quite slow so I imagine you are only getting a fraction of a volt to charge the capacitor. So have are you to overcome the forward bias of the diode? I'm curious because I thing is would be interesting to replicate this.

  • buen trabajo magnifico!!!!!!!!!!!

  • yea that wasn't working on its own at all, I saw his hand forcing the wheel to spin.

  • roflmfao!!!! ur awesome,dude!!!oooo.....my ribs hurt now:( lol,thats all i can say now,lofl!i still think overunity is possible,tho,and i think ill spend the rest of my life trying different ideas out,in spare time of course!!!first one soon to come,please watch it when i post it in about a week or 10 days!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @MegaTweek420 Ya I won't be holding my breath waiting. Have fun though as it's fun to discover you've wasted your time when yu could have been doing something meaning ful. But by all means carry on DUDE! I'm also ROTHLMAO Peace

  • I like it!

    I think you are still leaving something out but at least you're not talking Hillbilly Science like many on hear who believe in Perpetual motion and free energy generators.

  • All this video has done is raised more questions!

  • lol pwnd

  • so how do i make one

  • you pushed the wheel!

    YOU LIAR!!!!!

  • this machine is pretty smart. but, as all perpetual motion machines, there is a draw back. not very much torqe, and magnets run out of power after a while.

  • The magnets will not run out of power as long as the fan is spinning as electricity is generated and in turn induce a magnetic field in the coil due to Lenz's Law or some other law. And if you mean the magnets on the spinning wheel, it would not run out of power as long as it spin pass the induced magnet(coil).

  • oh ok i get it. sweet!

  • I'm confused. Where is the battery? Where is the energy source?

  • It work like an AC generator.

  • so you just left out this "minor" function of the machine in the first video....lol

  • There is no perpetual motion. There is a 'trick' to this too. It's all about THINKING. I've got a great book about the search for perpetual motion and it goes back 100 years or more.

  • Oh, just replied to the original video you made about magnets not being an infinite energy source in the first place. I didn't find this one till after. I agree with the thinking lesson, that even if there is no perpetual motion at the end of the rainbow, we shouldn't discredit the idea of much more efficient energy just because it's not perfect.

  • so what is the efficiency of this? does it slowly loose energy or gain or stay at a constant cheers ^_^

  • You're an oxymoron, and your videos are a perpetual waste of time. I can't believe you spent all that effort making such a pointless point.

  • You, are hilarious.

  • Hello, nice work, thank you for posting it ! Now, would you tell what is the Transistor you using ? And also, how many rounds have the coils and how thick is the string ? Thank you.

  • lol dont know if this is true on this video, Look at the hand in the top left corner, the thing slows down and the had give it a spin. It was done about 20 times in the video. lol

  • So, there is no battery? Just a Cap? I'm not interested in perpetual motion, but what does interest me is that it kept spinning for a period of time without disruptive slowness. Did I miss something?

  • @VideoVegetable yes he was pushing it with his hand... watch closer

  • That makes me really mad. I thought that it was actually real.

  • did it realy work ? i would like to create it can you help me ? it is wonderful

  • Thank you very mutch for post this video....Great idea here...dont never forget what you do litle you can do big...visit my channel my friend ,you are very welcome

  • PERPETUAL motion is not impossible, but FREE ENGERY is. Simple example: the earth orbiting the sun. not including external influence (such as other planets and non-perfect orbit, and solar flares) the earth will orbit the sun forever: there is no friction or air resistance. however, if you try to take energy out of the system, then it will continuously slow down the orbit until the earth crashes into the sun. thus, perpetual motion is possible, but it wont give you free energy. Yes?

  • You are taking the words "perpetual motion" too literally. The concept of perpetual motion is that that there can be a net increase of the energy content in a closed system.

  • What you say makes sense, if energy is completely conserved in a system then it should be transformed from one source to another and ultimately recycle itself. As for "free energy" I think the term refers to energy harnessing techniques that have not yet been capitalized on(hence "FREE") The term "free energy" does not refer to some magical source of energy that comes from no-where, it refers to the financial aspect of available energy that can be easily tapped into, given the correct methods.

  • I like the way you think.

    Energy is FREE it is the machine to covert it for practical use that costs money.

  • I'm afraid whenever you take some energy from a coil, the rotor will be braked by the same amount of energy, because of the Lorentz Force.

  • fans have high resistance b.c they are eletro magnetic engine...

  • Not if it isn't connected to anything.

  • Sorry, I replied before I watched the whole video.

  • wow dude

    so you not only wasted ur own time, but everyone elses...

  • Very slick! And yet, isn't it sad that so many people still don't understand that it's a trick, even when you explain it? (I particularly like the question about "bigger transistors")

  • Can you tell us what you used for the large wheel with many disk magnets bonded to it? Where can I buy one and who is the manufacturer?

  • I would like to replicate one of the coils you used to construct this. Can you explain what the iron core diameter/lenght was? Also what was the AWG wire sizes/lenght you used? Wound bifilear? What transistor and diagram of hookup?

  • How long does it run by itself without external power(only capcitor, etc, in a closed system)? It looks pretty nice.

    I know for a fact that Bedini has a similar system running for some 5 years now under a sealed plexiglass box(you can see this 1h doc about him on google video.

    What you did reminds me of a simple version of his Bediny motor.

    Search on youtube: "Reidar Finsrud" for a genuine(magnet/mechanical) selfrunning closed system.

  • so... ur just a lyer

  • You read "perpetual motion" and were expecting something else?

  • i read lego and expected the truth

  • You read LEGO and expected a working perpetual motion machine? I'm so sorry.

  • i see you are a one of "those" who deny the greatness of Lego and the powers that lie within... SHUN!

  • @chargerx150 I did too :(

  • tell me this isn't the dumbest practical joke you've ever seen!

  • its only perpetual motion if the energy created is = or > the energy use. this is impossible however because energy is lost to friction. and since electricity is the movement of electrons, all motion creating friction, this does not create energy or recycle the same energy. and as the laws of thermo-dynamics state. energy is never created or destroyed, it only changes forms.

  • Hi there,I would like to ask if it would be posible to put stronger tranzistors, so that the unit would not stop? I wached your videos e few times, but didnt undersdant, do you wire the coil at first to one side,so that the energy comes to the tranzistor, and than wire back,so that the energy creates a magnetic field oposit wheels magnet's field?

  • But you are pushing your wheel with your hand its seen on the left higher corner. your are doing it for a half vid dude :D

  • I talk with my hands and you see the movement of my hand from time to time and think that is the secret. Sorry. The trick isn't that simple. See the other videos where it runs for a long time all alone.

  • Enjoying your videos. Any chance of a schematic diagram for this device? I'd like to see the relationship between the cap and the dual coil transistor configuration. If the generator on the rotor keeps the cap charged then isn't this device self powered? Best Regards

  • Good thinking.

  • Thanks StarX42, perpetual motion zealots are like religious ones, it is faith that drives them, and no evidence can disprove their belief. When you ask for a test of hypothesis they start rolling out the old dogma-the 'Government conspiracy' and 'all science isn't yet known', 'there is hidden energy in that magnet', and eventually you get tired of arguing with them, because people without logic, can argue anything. Many of the comments for this video have completely missed your point. Funny!

  • Funny pair of videos. Cleverly done, and somewhat plausible. Well done! You fooled 'em!

  • so its NOT perpetual motion?

  • No, sorry. I keep waiting for the people with REAL perpetual motion machines to post their videos, but so far, nothing.

  • wait a second...how is this not perpetual motion? if they keep spinning the wheel and the wheel keeps charging the transistors then whats....oh the friction will never let it generate enough to overcome...the friction. yeah cause on the original, he lets it go in fast mostion, and you can see it slowing down some...is that right? Somebody help me understand why this wouldnt go forever.

  • you are right. its basically a generator running on its own electricity. the reason why it would not go on forever is because of e.g friction, air resistance, gravity...etc

  • wow very clever u got me.....

  • It can be done. I built one of these 20years ago using only permanent magnets, a record player and plastics VCR gears, all plastic construction, 75 magnets on disk, 13 gear driven switching pole magnets to switch the poles from north to south , it took over 4 months to figure out how many magnets to use/placement/ timing, It was so cool when it ran all by its self getting faster and faster by the second, unfortunatly it all exploded and the record player disk broke my $400 dollar front window

  • Whatever. Gears generate an incredible amount of friction. Your device would run for 1/2 a second.

  • did you even listen to what he said?????

    HE WAS MAKING A DIVICE TO TRICK PEOPLE. Atleast pay attention to the video before commenting,

  • this is still perpetual motion..... isn't it?

  • "perpetual" motion is motion running own its own motion, i think, so no. this runs on motion which gives electricity, which gives motion, so it can't be perpetual motion.

    But who cares? it's free energy, isn't it? and isn't it just fun to build and watch?

  • i want to build a big one and power my house lol, is it possible?

  • lol you could try

  • How would you tap the "free energy" from this device? If you drained the capacitor, the coils wouldn't energize.

  • there is no free energy involved. this machine runs on its own energy it created (although you have to start it off)

  • Im to dumb to understand whats going on, but a least my ignorance is original lol.

  • If it is build properly and properly with Iron wire coils with the right circuit and much bigger dimensions to overcome the losses, you can use the property and amplification of the magnetic fields by iron to get this system into overunity mode.

  • I would suspect the iron would saturate and lock the hall sensor on and stall the system such that it never gets that far. Eventually the batteries go dead and that's it.

  • hmmm wow those were very goood i like i like it haha seriously though im very intrested on learing how to do that ... u got me questiong wheater or not i can do it [=

  • Well, it was the integrity then ... :P

  • LOL you are having to much fun with this stuff.

    You going to show the battery on the other side of the Cap??

    I suspect that for the next lesson.

  • Well, ah, yes actually. And the wire coming from the motor... fake too. The entire set up was shown on the overunity blog the same day as my video first posted. People looked right at it and still didn't see it. I'm pretty amazed by that.

  • A layered reveal like this is exactly what a magician would do. Show a solution that is just as much magic as the original show. But they would NEVER reveal the real trick. Didn't you feel good knowing what the answer must be? and you really didn't need me to confirm it either. THAT is called authentic assessment in the education world. Getting an answer that you know is true without having someone confirm it. Problem with schools is that we just want an answer without thought!

  • That explains the misleading 'reveal'. Lenz's law (actually Faraday's Law) does not usually involve any magnetic delay which you propose 'is actually a good idea". Of course multiple coils could be cascaded by resonance to split that conservative field but ...

    It would be much easier to place a battery in the end of your coil and switch the coil using the transistor. Everything else is just dressing.

  • And that is, in fact, the trick.

  • The hope is what sells all of this, even i play with the ideas, though do not believe in the idea of OU.

    By most folks ideas gasoline would be such. LOL

  • Well this one is a simple examination. 1: claims can not be true. 2: components that are seen from the first video, and what is needed to do the video.

    This is the reason whipmag has been a pain. I can not as of yet replicate the damn thing. LOL Yours I easy could.

  • We don't need PM gen. There is enough termal, wind, atmospheic and sun power to supply us with abundance of enrgy.

  • Don't waste real researchers time watching your NOTHING. It distracts real people watching this and wastes our time, your an idiot. certified one. A hoax has nothing to gain.

  • Saw your posted videos... Thanks for your input.

  • 'ashtwerth': What would YOU know of a Real researcher? I've done research at Los Alamos (a national lab here in the US) and I know about REAL research. I though the whole LEGO perpetual motion thing a BLAST! Very well done. All the clues were there. He built a 'coil' but then had to remove it to get the device to run. Best puzzle I've seen in a long time. I did check out YOUR posts. None. Don't ever speak for me again. That is the sign of a true 'idiot'.

  • Are you saying that there are REAL researchers out there trying to find the REAL LEGO perpetual motion machine? Where did they get their funding, Nintendo? Seriously? You click on a video that says LEGO and perpetual motion and you are looking for something REAL? And you are calling ME an idiot?!?

  • Folks are in hopes that the intuitive ideas of such can be shown to be true.

    A lot of the old greats played with such also.

    Idiots, no just fools like me, though this was an easy see that it was fake. certain things missing.

  • That's why I visit those sites. To see how people try to solve the problems and how they 'circumvent' physics. It's useful to me to understand how people approach a problem. Perspective is very useful.

  • Most are easy, some raise questions. Such can be fun.

    There are a great many many folks out there do believe.

    The hydrogen cells for cars right now is a great one to find folks doing, every town I stop in, I can find some one playing with such. I can usually find some one playing with different methods of the old tried and hoped things also. If one asked around some one with claims is looking for financing for such also. One gets to see a lot of strange things with the last one.

  • So the americans as the leader of the world should go back in time before rockefeller&co

    and bury out the Hit N' Miss engines with flywheels? yes, why not?

    They were close to OU compared to daily energy-losses.

    If there is comes common research on efficiency,

    we could probably power our world with one AA battery. Not OU but good as well.

  • At least, there is a hope in the OU-scene, that NicolaTelsa..ups Alsetalocin made use of magnetic viscosity by ripping of flux very fast.

    Sad, that he might just has used a "Tractormag"-unit or such.

    .. Maybe i should go ahead with enhancing some steam-engines instead of looking for ZPE?

  • Steam Engines?!? I did my Masters thesis on energy use in the world and how the use of modern steam engines (nuclear power) became more favorable as people better understood the global energy needs. We still waste way too much however.