Actually, this IS the SCA. Cut and Thrust is a varient of the rapier fighting. It is in test mode now to be an "Official" combat style, but you must be authorized in rapier first. Our Barony in Meridies has put on a few of these Cut and Thrust Demos.
Cut & Thrust is fully legal and active in the Midrealm, and has been for a while, now. You also do not have to be rapier authorized at all, if you don't want to - you can go straight to cut & thrust. We also have a historical requirement and tougher auth/training requirements, than most, too.
The barrier was a relatively common part of foot combat during the middle ages. If I recall correctly, even Fiore mentions it in the preface of his treatise.
Sorry but foot combat != tournament fighting. They didn't take barriers to the field. And Fiore's mention of "The Barriers" or "fighting in the barriers" is referring to fighting in tournaments in general. He says it is better to fight in the barriers than in earnest with sharps for obvious reasons.
Tournament fighting was a big part of Medieval life for many Nobles. They valued tournament fighting as a display of military prowess. It think we should give them the benefit of the doubt that it was a worthwhile endeavor.
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ummm...This isnt SCA! its live steel, we dont use live steel in SCA
constantinemacgavin 3 years ago
Actually, this IS the SCA. Cut and Thrust is a varient of the rapier fighting. It is in test mode now to be an "Official" combat style, but you must be authorized in rapier first. Our Barony in Meridies has put on a few of these Cut and Thrust Demos.
Grimmloch 3 years ago 3
Cut & Thrust is fully legal and active in the Midrealm, and has been for a while, now. You also do not have to be rapier authorized at all, if you don't want to - you can go straight to cut & thrust. We also have a historical requirement and tougher auth/training requirements, than most, too.
flechyr 3 years ago
Ah.... Thanks for the explanation. Just never seen one of those before, but of course, my knowledge of Fiore is limited.
GnPdemon 3 years ago
Not to be nitpicky... but why the barrier?
GnPdemon 3 years ago
The barrier was a relatively common part of foot combat during the middle ages. If I recall correctly, even Fiore mentions it in the preface of his treatise.
flechyr 3 years ago
Sorry but foot combat != tournament fighting. They didn't take barriers to the field. And Fiore's mention of "The Barriers" or "fighting in the barriers" is referring to fighting in tournaments in general. He says it is better to fight in the barriers than in earnest with sharps for obvious reasons.
wvdmc 3 years ago
Correct. My use of the term "foot combat" was in reference to tournament combat on foot. :)
flechyr 3 years ago
Okay.
For what it's worth, I feel this is a great stride in the right direction for the SCA.
wvdmc 3 years ago
Tournament fighting was a big part of Medieval life for many Nobles. They valued tournament fighting as a display of military prowess. It think we should give them the benefit of the doubt that it was a worthwhile endeavor.
tsafa1 3 years ago
Damn, I wish I could have made it to MKAOD this year.
MIT1369 3 years ago