I love all of the meaningful comments on this video, usually VOCALOID videos have comments such as "OMG!!11! LEN IS SO HOTLOLOL!!1!", I'm glad to see some more, insightful comments on some of the more majestic VOCALOID videos.
Huh. I always interpreted "From Y to Y" as...from fork to fork. Two people come together, and travel one path, creating one Y. And now, it's time to say goodbye, as one path splits back to two, the second Y. And maybe someday, they'll come back together, another Y.
Miku as a singer uses the word "Boku", so the subject of this song is a male. Also like "Just be Friends" by Luka, all songs have not sung from female viewpoints just because the woman has sung. Though there are 100 or more kinds of Japanese subjects, in English only "I". Is this inconvenience?
Apparently this song was dedicated to a person with the initial "Y" by the maker of this song who's Initial was also "Y" by coincidence. At least thats what I read about it.
Actually, the title is like a letter. The composer's name starts with a Y and his ex girlfriend's name does too. So the song is from Y (the composer) to/for Y (the ex girlfriend) :D
this song reminds me of falling in love with this girl i like ontill she didnt like me she like this other guy so i always keep my head up miku make my life good when i am sad i look forward to miku
I absolutely love this song. It's so close and personal, unlike some of the other more general, generic love songs. And yet, this is something most people can relate to. There is no poetry, no excess flowery words. It's so...raw.
OneRoom is..a very brave person, for being able to tell his story like this to so many strangers.
wow so many Japanese responses... If I had to guess, she did something bad and doesn't think she's worthy of her BF anymore (who probably broke up with her over it).
Yeah... Some of us have been there before, its not a nice place to be.
@SweetyLeia yup i've heard a lot of people say that.its just different for us becuz our different way of looking at life:D each vocaloid may not be real,but their songs speak to me more than most songs with actual people singin them.at least one song relates to me somehow its kinda weird :p lol
I hate those people who dislikes this!!! maybe they didn't clean their ears for a decade!!! man!!! this is really good... I love it! my number 1 favorite vocaloid song!!! I love sad songs like this, some sad songs turns out as BORING
but this one is different!! I love hatsune miku! the best vocaloid!!!
agree? and i also love ryo (the composer of this song) i watched the
project diva 2nd's video for this and it made me cry.... >_<
this song brings pain in my chest!!! (i feel miku's pain too)
@rushdrift hatsune miku (who is part of vocaloid if you dont know). just other people from nico nico douga did a lot of covers on this song, like "Magnet" or "Just Be Friends" and other songs
In Hatsune Miku: Project Diva 2nd, the video for this song was of Miku and an astronaut... Maybe he went to space and they had to separate because of the time difference or something? [[I read Hoshi no Koe before...]]
It is Miku. I know she's not singing crazy high like usual, but that doesn't mean it's not her. Personally, I think she sounds a lot better in lower tones like this. Not so grating on the ears.
Yeah..that's pretty much what Vocaloids are. I'm just saying I love how the artist altered her voice to sound this way. It's very beautiful. Even though her voice is based on an actual human's voice I think Miku can already sing better. (:
I love all of the meaningful comments on this video, usually VOCALOID videos have comments such as "OMG!!11! LEN IS SO HOTLOLOL!!1!", I'm glad to see some more, insightful comments on some of the more majestic VOCALOID videos.
BibloManiacz 1 day ago
My Boyfriend who is a BIG fan of Miku and he cried. I am a big fan but I can't cry on Miku songs D'8
bluebluebluemango 2 days ago
I love Hatsune Miku! <3 You make bright songs! :'D
Vocaleisure 1 week ago
@xdante0vergilx we dont intend to let it stop anyway
AzureFlameCloud 1 week ago
is it just me or does it sound like Luka is doing the echo's??
PeacefulNightmarePro 1 week ago
This song makes me want to cry. It's so touching!! TT~TT
VKFan42 2 weeks ago
Touching song *sniff, I can't believe there are 7 dislikes, stupid people who can never find love >:[
soluv12 4 weeks ago
i thought it was YtoY bcuz it looks like a negi (Y) :/
nikari98 1 month ago
@nikari98 What does miku's favorite...uhm food?... have to do with the lyrics or meaning for the song?
DemonicDrone 1 month ago
It remind with someone. I miss him, a lot
CathTheLittle 1 month ago
Huh. I always interpreted "From Y to Y" as...from fork to fork. Two people come together, and travel one path, creating one Y. And now, it's time to say goodbye, as one path splits back to two, the second Y. And maybe someday, they'll come back together, another Y.
XGeneral2000 1 month ago 6
@phenomenal8400
Miku as a singer uses the word "Boku", so the subject of this song is a male. Also like "Just be Friends" by Luka, all songs have not sung from female viewpoints just because the woman has sung. Though there are 100 or more kinds of Japanese subjects, in English only "I". Is this inconvenience?
poconyanpocopoco 2 months ago in playlist VOCALOID songs
Y to Y is like Y_Y in my (shallow) opinion. Like a crying face. But the top rated comment by @inspringiris is more deep and awesome. ^-^
ronaldli5 2 months ago
Y is just like ... a leek, right ?
0o0Missmanga0o0 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for 初音ミク 6
これ歌詞めっちゃいいね・・・
なけるよ;;
radloveshiba 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ooh~ Is Luka doing the harmony in this?
BouncyTheEmpoleon 2 months ago
ちょびっとルカ入ってる?
mikuVoice0373 2 months ago
who are them actually? :O
TheDdance 2 months ago
@TheDdance HAHHAHAHAH whut ._.
TheKinochan 2 months ago
this song had a great feeling xD
try the 39's giving day version it's awesome too
VanellaVanero 3 months ago
ということは、ジミーサムの当時の彼女はネギなのか・・・・・・・・・・・サーセン
bokuranonagato 3 months ago
Is Luka doing the background vocals?
TohruTwinkie 3 months ago
@TohruTwinkie Yup :3
doremidreams 3 months ago
@TohruTwinkie ikr? it sounds like her :D
TheKinochan 3 months ago
@TohruTwinkie ya... haha ^3^
AnimeFreakie 3 months ago
i love how this song is a little faster than you'd expect, but it still has that depressing feel. c:
funjojo678 3 months ago
Yはネギの事だょ☆
hea4123 4 months ago
@hea4123 は?
japaneesejello 3 months ago in playlist miku
ジミーサムのブログ曰く、
原案となったのは「from A to Z」
込めた意味は、A=始まり・Z=終わり
始まりから終わりまで、となる。
そして何故Yとなったかというとジミーサムと当時の彼女(作曲する以前に別れたと思われる)名前のイニシャルがYだったから。
そしてその時の自身の想いをこめたと思われるのが、時系列順の「Pierrot」→「from Y to Y」→「Calc」の三曲
tonikukoc007 4 months ago
泣いてもいいですか?
あーもうめっちゃ泣ける。
melt39saelove 4 months ago
Después de versión de Clear...
Es esta la interpretación mas linda, tierna y bonita de la canción *-*
Haku <3
AkumashiroAkasumi 4 months ago in playlist yowane haku
T.T
thorium95 4 months ago in playlist 初音ミク
for people that dont now the back singer is luka not mku lower toned just so you guys and gals know
likevid123 4 months ago
@likevid123 I KNEW IT! :D thanks for confirming it :D
Emoraven280 4 months ago
from a to z
MyonShizuku 4 months ago
ハーピーバスデイミクさn!!!
animekirby100 4 months ago
Happy birthday Miku! ^^
Rrrita413 4 months ago
この曲めっちゃ泣ける!!
takuvoca2 5 months ago
ジミー最高!
この曲は、永遠に歌い継がれると思う。
ボカロはオタクじゃなくても好きになっていいはずだ!
てか人は誰しも何かのオタクなんだ!
wami3939 5 months ago 8
I cried when playing this for the first time on PD2 ;___;
Kuriinn 5 months ago
cant help it , how cant i cry for hatsune miku Songs even though she is not human ,
WE who actually make her alive guys , She is alive in our hearts =']
so please keep vocaloid in your heart :')
- Vocaloid Fan to All of the fans , please dont let it stop!
xdante0vergilx 5 months ago 115
Is it just me or does this song reflect my life in a way I cant even describe? It makes me want to cry. :')
Sango415 5 months ago
This song is fantastic.
PekanChan 5 months ago
Is gumi sing the background ^^;
mikublackrockshooter 6 months ago
@mikublackrockshooter No, it's Megurine Luka ^^
takashitheswordsman 5 months ago
@Memuburein i dont knoooowww ^__^ lol
girWUZhere759535 6 months ago
@girWUZhere759535 Yes, it's luka.....GIR, what are you doing in my house?
MemubureinDibbu 6 months ago
in this one part of the song is luka or mikuo singing?? cuz it sounds like luka but other people r saying its mikuo
girWUZhere759535 6 months ago
@girWUZhere759535 It's Luka. :)
oOSukiiHanaOo 6 months ago
@twillycool3 huh, no, it's luka. A great and beloved composer like Jimmy would never use mikuo. :|
MemubureinDibbu 6 months ago
Nice.! Y_Y
ASIANREDFOX 6 months ago
this video has me crying all the time
simonezhane 7 months ago
my daily dose of miku before school :D
theetohfuone 7 months ago 7
Mikuo in the back XD !!!??????
twillycool3 7 months ago
@twillycool3 no its luka
simonezhane 7 months ago
@simonezhane no its mikuo :D
twillycool3 6 months ago
so sad. :( this is the second top emotional song for me, next to Hatsune Miku's Eight Hundred.
and that ring. it's like she's already been engaged and still they broke up in the end. :'(
you're so awesome in bringing out a certain emotion, Miku. that's why people love you. :')
KairinxLilianne 7 months ago
I know this is a sad song and I love this song so much but I cant help but notice this yesterday.
The title where it says "Y", I cant help but think the Y looks like a leek.
Leek which is Miku's character item. Get it? :D (pointless comment)
LukaKanon 7 months ago
低い声もミク??
sakuma107 7 months ago
ooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!! this song is great!
DarkRessuruction16 8 months ago
I'm crying so much right now, because all of this happened just a while ago...
lyokoprincess151 8 months ago
Apparently this song was dedicated to a person with the initial "Y" by the maker of this song who's Initial was also "Y" by coincidence. At least thats what I read about it.
suborou 8 months ago
With Regards to the title of the Song...
I think.... (for me) it goes like....
From A-Z... of the Alphabet
A to B.. B to C....... Y to Z (if you reached "Z" it means it's the end..
there's no more alphabet next to Z)
with regards to the meaning of the Song..
It's like... Miku doesn't want to end the Story yet...
so... it's still from Y to Y...
because when she reached "Z" it's like... THE END :)
no more... =) ? (this is just my point of view)
inspringiris 8 months ago 298
@inspringiris Sounds interesting.
PuertaChannel 8 months ago
@inspringiris that... makes sense :3
eternalife14 8 months ago
@inspringiris That was so interesting :D Smart of you to think that! <3
LukaKanon 7 months ago
@inspringiris
maybe you thinking too much... maybe from Y to Y means from tear to tear... like Y_Y ....
yoyorsp 6 months ago
@inspringiris
Actually, the title is like a letter. The composer's name starts with a Y and his ex girlfriend's name does too. So the song is from Y (the composer) to/for Y (the ex girlfriend) :D
AzusaNakano0 4 months ago 6
@inspringiris It's about true history about Jimmy nothing related to Miku :3
byakuyabou 2 months ago in playlist anime and vocaloid :D
What a lovely song
CrucifixtionSpiders 8 months ago
Comment removed
Tsuna1st 8 months ago
5 people don't know English or Japanese
hoangwar 9 months ago
this song is pretty <3
VocaNekoHime 9 months ago
wonderful music and voice ever
fenixz001 9 months ago
this song reminds me of falling in love with this girl i like ontill she didnt like me she like this other guy so i always keep my head up miku make my life good when i am sad i look forward to miku
earRAPE1123 9 months ago 6
Like this song, its nice
darkdoom9999 9 months ago
Wats this song about? It's beautiful but I don't quite understand it
morahble 9 months ago
@morahble I think its about someone breaking up with miku -.-
fiddlestick113 8 months ago in playlist MY MUSIC
For every 708 people only 5 people dislike this song. Why? Because Luka is only backing vocals.
kpopgiiirl 9 months ago 2
700th like!
MultiAnonymousdude 9 months ago
till it's that time, "see you"
oh dear... I found that part to be very.... sad TwT I rated this my best vocaloid song so far...
seaweevil 9 months ago
i can relate with the song..in fact a friend of mine posted it in my wall after i told her my love problem
xXHATOKi11Xx 10 months ago
Really? 5 dislikes? BUT THIS SONG IS SO BEAUTIFUL D:
TaintedInnocentGirl 10 months ago
I absolutely love this song. It's so close and personal, unlike some of the other more general, generic love songs. And yet, this is something most people can relate to. There is no poetry, no excess flowery words. It's so...raw.
OneRoom is..a very brave person, for being able to tell his story like this to so many strangers.
CaramellOtter 10 months ago
Wow, A miku song that's too LOW to sing!
Gosh, this girl's range is from sea to shining sea.
TookieLooCookies 10 months ago
Better than Clear by far ;)
TheFishWhat 10 months ago
sad lyrics
blossomchu 10 months ago
if i were to have a gf like miku, i wouldn't leave her for sure:D
pitaten8838 10 months ago 4
ここにいる人はジミーサムPのコメント知らないんだろうなぁ・・・
zengshan7 10 months ago
3:18 My heart almost came out of my chest on that part lol ;)
darkhedgehog45678 10 months ago
Wow. She's sounds amazing in this song.
AnnaBaby64 10 months ago
WHY isn't this song on iTunes? D:
Truevectorfan 10 months ago 5
Luka-back-vocals ftw!! :D
GummiieBaerchen 10 months ago 5
私はこの曲を愛して(=^.^=).それは素晴らしいです!私は、彼らが離れてまたは一緒に、音をどのように愛だけ〜
I love this song (=^.^=). It was wonderful! I just love how they sound, apart or together.~
xSuzukichanx 11 months ago
i love this song
mephilesisepic1 11 months ago
sorry Miku , Clear does it better, lol
Sevilou 1 year ago 5
@Sevilou =_= fuck you!
Vocaleisure 1 month ago
wow so many Japanese responses... If I had to guess, she did something bad and doesn't think she's worthy of her BF anymore (who probably broke up with her over it).
Yeah... Some of us have been there before, its not a nice place to be.
lordtac1 1 year ago 3
@lordtac1 Quite so. This song just gives out the exact feelings of a person in such a situation. Gotta love this.
bmagic21 11 months ago
AAAAAW THIS IS SOOO PRETTY AND SAAAD TOO!!!
darkshojogirl 1 year ago
自分もmaneko999さんも、次は絶対に大切なものを見失わないようにしましょう!
二度と同じ道を辿らないように、お互いが記憶にならないように大切に愛せるようになりましょう!!
TAKUYAuver5th 1 year ago
うわー。。自分のたどってきたそのまんま!のストーリーだ。強がった~一時は別れた~反省した~気持ちを伝えた~帰ってきた。またねが実現した。みなさんかけがえのない相手は大事にしようね。つよがっても帰ってこないかも知れないんだよ。もう会えないかも知れないんだよ!覚悟して強がろうね。自分はほんとに素直な人間にちょっぴりなれた。
maneko999 1 year ago 3
大病と戦ったあの14年間が蘇ります。。。。←腫瘍とたたかいました
maneko999 1 year ago
:') <--- that is all
brykeso25 1 year ago
なんだか、元カノのこと思い出してしまった・・・(泣
なんで別れちゃったんだろ・・・・
TAKUYAuver5th 1 year ago
@TAKUYAuver5th 自分も経験あります。失ってはじめて気がつくありがたさ。。。そして愛。。。
maneko999 1 year ago
That is a horribly sad song I love so much. Kaito and Meiko's version is also beautiful
princesszelda98 1 year ago
3:16 is cool
Essa698 1 year ago
I think this is one of my favorites :)
beebop97 1 year ago
Makes me sick how people can dislike a song so filled with emotion and meaning :/
Jenny11209 1 year ago 7
this song is based on composer's real experience.
his real name is yuma and his ex girlfriend's name starts with y
so this song is from oneroom(composer) to his ex girlfriend...
"Pierrot" and "Calc." were also made for her.
estella7ful 1 year ago 105
@estella7ful Now it makes sense!
Aelita59 1 year ago
@estella7ful Gosh so sad o_o
And they say Vocaloids can't give any emotion... This song is so rich of meaning.
SweetyLeia 6 months ago
@SweetyLeia yup i've heard a lot of people say that.its just different for us becuz our different way of looking at life:D each vocaloid may not be real,but their songs speak to me more than most songs with actual people singin them.at least one song relates to me somehow its kinda weird :p lol
hitsugayaandLsgirl 6 months ago
@hitsugayaandLsgirl Exactly ! Now song is mostly marketing, it's kinda weird o_o
What I like with vocaloids is that people work for free to write and compose their own music with their own feelings.
SweetyLeia 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
shasha if ur reading this hi ^^
angelckk1 1 year ago
ca any body tell me the meaning of ''Y"?
is that the shape of the leek or something?
iheartquest18 1 year ago
@iheartquest18 I never thought of that xD But this song sounds a lot deeper than leeks..sooooo~ But amazing thought :3
MrsExplosiveCookie 1 year ago
I not only love the lyrics, but miku sounds somewhat different in this song, like shes right next to you and consoling your heart x)
MrsExplosiveCookie 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hahaha, I'm gonna get so much hate for this but...
She sounds like a duck.
Ricewarrior01 1 year ago
i relate so well with the song it made me cry T_T
felicityeufy 1 year ago 3
Is Luka in here?? I swear I can here her as backup and echo...
Sesshoumarurulz 1 year ago 4
Negai negai *-*
Malav1ta 1 year ago
I fell in love with this song, and now I can't stop listening.
xXTouketsuXx 1 year ago
I liked this song from the very first time I heard it , now that I know what the lyrics mean , I feel that they are specialy wrote to me u.u sigh*
valois12345 1 year ago 2
May I borrow the translation for a video im making? I will of course give your or the translator full credit.
Hauntedserenity 1 year ago
I hate those people who dislikes this!!! maybe they didn't clean their ears for a decade!!! man!!! this is really good... I love it! my number 1 favorite vocaloid song!!! I love sad songs like this, some sad songs turns out as BORING
but this one is different!! I love hatsune miku! the best vocaloid!!!
agree? and i also love ryo (the composer of this song) i watched the
project diva 2nd's video for this and it made me cry.... >_<
this song brings pain in my chest!!! (i feel miku's pain too)
CKchan21 1 year ago 2
now i know why this was at the top of the vocaloid charts for a couple weeks...
blueasajay 1 year ago
The most sadest cutest song every :O
MikuHatsuneable 1 year ago
I can't believe people don't like this
poonhehehahaster 1 year ago
Oh geez, this song is heartbreaking no matter how many times I hear it.
So incredible but.... 「またね」 ;___;
gahtzuah 1 year ago 3
This kind of seems like Miku's own version of 'Why Don't You Call Me Yet?"
THANK YOU for the translation! ^^ I think this is my fave Miku song now! :)
Tetolicious 1 year ago
im really confuse this song who is the real singer???
rushdrift 1 year ago
@rushdrift hatsune miku (who is part of vocaloid if you dont know). just other people from nico nico douga did a lot of covers on this song, like "Magnet" or "Just Be Friends" and other songs
Mechon05 1 year ago
i can't press any key When i play Project DIVA 2nd , This song.
and also take me here.
lakushas 1 year ago
In Hatsune Miku: Project Diva 2nd, the video for this song was of Miku and an astronaut... Maybe he went to space and they had to separate because of the time difference or something? [[I read Hoshi no Koe before...]]
diamondwhiteritz 1 year ago
i love this song ......<3 so LOVEly...=)
CandyMage28 1 year ago
this song is really ssad base on the eng lyrics
pitaten8838 1 year ago
Comment removed
pitaten8838 1 year ago
Sounds like Append used badly, but it's actually just normal Miku too low, isn't it?
MinamiUotani 1 year ago
In this tune, the "disappointed love of jimmy-thumb P" is a tune of the theme.
No tune "Relation between miku and Luca".
kuma5690 1 year ago
SUGGE DARO
katonmaster 1 year ago
since luka's the one do the back vocals, could it be another mikuxluka? *nosebleeds*..just joking!! XD
Godleymangaka 1 year ago
T^T
mikeyhahaha 1 year ago
How..is it not a sad story..she longs for her ideal future that was no longer of existence.. so she started..walking..turning her back ..
Geira2 1 year ago
ルカ姉が
コーラスではいってるw
Sai0Luki 1 year ago
this originally sung by LOLA from vocaloids version 1
mewtrisha 1 year ago
@mewtrisha ....Whut?
doremidreams 1 year ago
Woah, this is like the Miku Hatsune version of Just be friends by Luka Megurine..... x3
HREsama 1 year ago
I am sure I leard Luka in there like Mikus echo on some words
CyanBaka1 1 year ago
anyome knows where ca i download this song???
MissGalCherie 1 year ago
Great Heartbreak song...
im downloading it now....
XxBloodyCrumpet23xX 1 year ago
waahh it makes me cry!!!no,im crying right now!!
xxx3shaxxx 1 year ago 3
LOVE! <3
onaharaxtwins 1 year ago
Sounds a little similar to "Dark Append miku" : D
DarkBlueCatxVocaloid 1 year ago
Funny how Luka is doing the back vocals
Paulinho8624 2 years ago 243
Comment removed
aisutetei 2 years ago
@Paulinho8624
All this time i thought it was Len O____o
hahah thanks~ ^^
LukaKanon 1 year ago
yeah sure I do think this is better..
xxxxZexionxxxx 2 years ago
i think miku sounds great in both high pitch voice and low pitch voice...^-^
kaitoXmikuXlen 2 years ago 193
@kaitoXmikuXlen Luka was doing the lower pitch O.o
Eclipsa00 1 year ago
yeah i think miku is better here, in lower tone. high pitch diva is always rin ( i think personally, don't hate me)
supershitwalktheway 2 years ago 22
damn such a powerfull and emotional song, i almost broke out a tear, beatiful !
keep up the good work! <3
zappzoe 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nice but this is not miku it sounds so different....but her pronounciation is like miku's maybe its just her pitch is wrong...its too low...
xxxxZexionxxxx 2 years ago
It is Miku, the creator of the song just played with the pitch and voice
doremidreams 2 years ago 2
It is Miku. I know she's not singing crazy high like usual, but that doesn't mean it's not her. Personally, I think she sounds a lot better in lower tones like this. Not so grating on the ears.
SushiNyan 2 years ago 26
I always thought this song was beautiful, but now that I know what she's saying, I love this song even more. <3
I almost cried!
chibikaeru 2 years ago 4
So sad D:
fishchimes 2 years ago 5
切なくて 懐かしくて 美しい歌
genen15parsent 2 years ago
Wow.
Truley beautiful...I must favorite..
jpopprincess101 2 years ago 10
Oh yeah~! This song is on "Vocalostar". I love this one. ^^
InvaderSTELLAR 2 years ago
Where does one download? I looove this song :D <3
Bobertha 2 years ago 7
I like how Miku sounds in this song.(: It's very different and charming.
xoxoJannet 2 years ago 8
actually, its only vocaloid. its not really a person, it is technology. different, right?
TheGuavaHead 2 years ago 8
Yeah..that's pretty much what Vocaloids are. I'm just saying I love how the artist altered her voice to sound this way. It's very beautiful. Even though her voice is based on an actual human's voice I think Miku can already sing better. (:
xoxoJannet 2 years ago 7
3:16
I got soooooo many chills~!
nomuamada 2 years ago 9
can you send me a link to download this song? i really like this song
Mechon05 2 years ago 3
I want to get this song. Where can I download it?
GoldAnnaple 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
0.o; ... This sounds terrible. D:
GuitarHeroine14 2 years ago
<333333
kurono67 2 years ago