Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (271)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • how she couldn't have been won?!!?!!???

  • omg dont compare her to others. She sounds like Amelia Lily, wich sounds great btw :)

  • She sounds more like Pink!

  • Goosebumps. The way she hit those top notes makes your skin crawl!

  • GOD I LOVE HER

  • [iminent=isMLm7d79l2]

    _____________

    I have just posted a cool BigEmo!

  • Gary is a fucking prick...

  • I'd love to sing like her, such a great powerful voice and I love this song too :D

  • AMEZING!

  • how dare someone call her "Thick" she is curvaceous, I bet she only weighs 125 at most!

  • @pinkthornkitty I think they meant that she's stupid. I don't think she is but who knows..who cares.

  • @aedaii no they said she was fat and look how thick her legs are.

  • @pinkthornkitty they're normal lol

  • she win?

  • @giulia10a Nope, She made it to the Final and finished in 3rd place.

  • Amelia kicks lady gagmes ass!

  • oh my god ! :o

  • Is that lady gaga or amelia? i cant hear the different

  • If she sang FIGHTER by Christina Augelia, she would win this competition.

  • Love it!

  • I still love this! <3

  • she should of won as she is a fantastic singer hope to see cds out soon u go girl x

  • she looks like Alexandria from America's Next Top Model.

  • What a great song choice? why is she so beautiful? what a rock chick! and would just like to also add this is better than the original sorry lady gaga! <3

  • Amazing!

  • good singer or nut, she is trouble. u can see from her face

  • Rock chicks rock!

  • O_O!!!! SHES SOUNDS BETTER THEN LADY GAGA HERSELF!!! XDDD!! AMAZING!

  • what are people talking about she needs to be better before you start calling her great. she sounds like she doesn't have control of her voice. i thought it was a c-

  • Lady Gaga + Pink + Christina Aguilera = Amelia Lily

  • amelia lily has a natural talent!!!!!!!

  • perfeckt!!!!

  • she should of won

  • just . . . WOW O.O

  • all i read is lady fucking gaga, forget her.amelia is a million times better.....

  • am ın the only one who thinks amelia is better than little mix

  • She sang this EXACTLY like lady gaga sings it - She can go so far - she should really record songs like these

  • she sung that JUST like lady gaga - she's THAT good!

  • THUNDER THIGHS!!!

  • Sounds like Lady Gaga and Christina Aguilera. What a voice! Love her.

  • I can't believe someone would come from such a shitty town like Middlesbrough, you've done all the me and the Boro proud!!

  • Her voice sounds like Lady Gaga and Christina Aguilera. 

  • @DshankumMusic she got a hint of Pink up in there too

  • Amelia is just awesome :D

    Even if she hasn't won, I'm sure she'll be able to do something in the music industry :)

  • gary said she was shouting, well he can go fuck himself

  • she got the same voice as lady gaga holy shit she's good ;d 

  • i thought you were going to win ur amazing good work :)

  • I've always thought she was brilliant, but this performance was the one that made her my favourite! Can't wait till she releases an album!

  • listening to lady gaga sing this live and amelia.. amelia can hit the high belting notes better than gaga can... im impressed.

  • Sing offs arn't supposed to make our eyes water for god's sake! It's to show of their vocals and that's excactly what she did!

  • Fit as fuck with a voice to match.

  • She has great voice.

  • I prefer janet devlin,.. we had so many amelia lillys

  • Comment removed

  • @IrishDanceable name me 5 amelia lilys, janet devlin is just another wanabe.

  • damn she's a pretty singer !

  • this vocal was shaky, and she missed a few notes; not to mention it was boring. I wouldn't have wanted to see her win. If a professional came on stage and sang like that, I'd be embarrassed for them.

  • @TheUncutAngel exactly. I thought this was a little weak.

  • @TheUncutAngel i agree, i thought some parts were really flat:p shes pretty though lol

  • too slow but good

  • Gary does not care about how good they are, only that he makes his acts look good at the expense of others, even if their act is 10/10.

  • SHE WAS AMAZING. Garry madee a cheap comment. 

  • Its good but this performance should never or beat Craig, he was so much more heart felt.

  • VOTE AMELIA! <3

  • JANETS GONE YEY!

  • I've got the hots for Amelia :}

  • 0901 61 61 605

    CALL AND SAVE Amelia Lily tonight.......

  • my list of winners

    1. Little mix

    2. Ameilia lily

    3. misha

  • @furifurigirl That would be an awesome final.

  • @furifurigirl Well that's just sexist.... Marcus is more talented than little mix

  • @bkn7365 how was he sexist? XD just cuz theres only 1 guy left and his opinion that some of the girls are better than him atm

  • @bkn7365 NO U IDIOT LITTLE MIX ARE GR8 SO DONT DIS

  • @furifurigirl Don't dis? NO NEED TO TYPE IN CAPITALS. Wasn't need to be calling me an idiot, coz I could just have easily said something derogatory to you.... CUNT

  • @furifurigirl PERFECT FINAL

  • the reason Gary said what he said was to influence Tulisa. Gary knew, Louis and Kelly would send Craig home and he successfully influenced Tulisa. Thank god Deadlock saved her! Everyone vote for the best vocalist of the season - Miss Amelia Lily! 05! <3

  • I like Amelia, and I disagree with Gary I don't think she shouted this song. She's got a good voice, but after the show she has to be careful with the songs she releases if she gets signed. If she releases cover after cover like a lot of reality show "rejects", people are going to forget about her. I don't think she'll win, and it's a shame because I think if she wasn't knocked out, and was still in it this week, I would REALLY like her! Such a shame. MARCUS TO WIN!

  • @xxEllee

    i think of any of the acts of this series, amelia has the most potential to make a real go of a career on an international scale...but i agree that she'll need to be *very* careful about what material she records. if she goes down the mainstream route then i think she'll be dismissed as a mere popstar and if she tries to do the whole pop/rock thing then she could end up being overlooked (as there are so many acts like that already). something both rock and bluesy would be best.

  • amelia please go home your boring andf bland janet ftw.

  • @woody8878 Please, that is so contradictory. You can't try to offend Amelia by calling her boring and then support Janet. Amelia is way stronger vocally and it isn't as painful as listening to her.

  • @Yasmin24895 Preach! Janet is as dull as dishwater. Amelia can work a stage, that's for sure. Pop star Amelia Lily FTW! :D

  • AmeliaLilyOffic Amelia Lily

    Guys please please vote for me tonight n tomorrow, I really don't wanna go home tomorrow n can't face being in the bottom two again!!xx

  • AM-ELIA = AM-AZING

  • Comment removed

  • Janet please go home, you're such a boring singer

  • @twisttiz fuck off, hater

  • Gaga is legend

    Help young talent, UK vote Amelia lily.

  • craig was better...

  • i love amelia but i want her to come in 2nd for the only reason that her mentor is an idiot and doesnt give any of her girls help and when she does, she favors misha. this week she missed 3 days to film her new music video. shes using this show for endorsment and i love how Tulisa is giving her all to help little mix. kelly takes all the credit for her acts good performances and none for when they do bad. i still love amelia and want her in the final

  • lol the usa version is shit compared to our version. HUGE mistake. thats what he gets for betraying us.

  • gary barlow is a prick! i liked craig but i was soo rooting for amelia especialy when garry made that bitchy comment..talk about playin dirty this year!

  • cant belive gary said she shouted her way through that. shes an amazing singer, i wouldnt say that he is! x

  • Gary get a flippin grip man, u talk about misha leaving with her integrity but i think its you who should worry about that! Please please guys don't forget to vote for Amelia Lily! We all don't want to see her in the bottom 2 ever again!!! We want her to go all they way so lets support her by voting for her! Kelly rowland barely supports her because she's got her favourites so we need to take amelia to the finish line!! PLEASE PLEASE SHE NEEDS OUT VOTES... VOTE AMELIA LILY! :) She deserves it!!

  • this kid is amazing,I don't get some of these comments... ya'll a whole bunch of ignorant fucks... and Gary is just a bitter bitch.. like wtf..she did not shout at all..she was spot on..okay fine,craig is brilliant I admit he shouldn't have gone..but bottom line is that someone had to go... and anyone leaving would have been bad because they are all so good.. but competition is competition... and to the other sets of ignorant fucks calling "bully misha" get over it..jeezus she's amazing too.

  • Amelia to win!!!

  • If Gary had listened to the song, he would've known that this is the way that the original song is actually sung.

  • i've listened to this performance all week, both on itunes and youtube, and i don't hear the supposed shouting that gary said. a great performance, liked it better than her performance of think if im honest

  • I seriously think that I've already watched this video 226.772 times. I'm so in love with it!

  • Make sure you vote for her this week. she needs her fans votes

  • I have nothing against Amelia but the fact she was already eliminated in the 1 live show proves she isn't that good, I think Craig should've stayed

  • @JustPumpThatBeat Craig is terrible hes boring. Amelia is amazing she should of stayed in from the start. she can win this 

  • @JustPumpThatBeat

    Craig is so boring and has no versatility. He makes me fall asleep. The only reason Amelia was booted off on week 1 was because all the other 3 girls were so amazing and it was a really hard decision. Amelia has an amazing voice with star quality.

  • I like Amelia, but it wouldve been funny to see her be eliminated .. :/

  • I really wish she'd get better song choices. It's all about song choices. And Kelly doesn't seem she's too keen on Amelia doing well. If Simon was Amelia's judge, she'd probably win.

  • I luv her voice it's so powerful 

  • Why the hell was this bitch in the bottom?! Lol an I thought only us Americans got the voting wrong, which happens ALOT.

  • She so didn't shout! Amelia has such an g voice for a 17 year old girl

    Gary is sadly mistaken

  • Well i am glad it went to Dead lock this time cos Amelia is a very good singer and Gary was gutted because craig was in the bottom 2 Neither of them should of been there my personal opinion i think it should of been the Bully Misha B But that is just my thought althogh I think Janet is a one trick poney too soo But there ya go.

    GO Amelia Is what you want and where u belong babe x

  • What is gary on about. You are ment to put power into the song and its called Passion!! Something you aint got garry I have seen this VIDEO like 50 times!!!

  • kelly only cares about misha

  • @blastthatradio same colour

  • guys u really need 2 start voting 4 this girl. she has a talent no one else in the competition has. kelly has got to start giving her better songs though! VOTE 4 AMELIA!!!!!!!

  • ...oh and Gary was probably feeling bad since his poor song choice was the reason nobody voted for lovely Craig. Just saying.

  • Gary made himself a cheap comment like he accused Louis and Tulisa.That was amazing!She is one of the strongest vocalists this season and also what is Kelly thinking ?Dont get me wrong I respect her a lot but she is the reason Amelia was in the bottom two because of the song choices.I was excited but when I saw"Think".Aretha Franklin?I couldnt belive it .If she keeps on giving her songs like"Think"(bottom two) or "Billie Jean"(ELimination,she will leave soon enough and that would be shameful!

  • Amelia or little mix to win, gary is a biased prick and i'm glad he's only got one act left, not too long ago he was rubbing it in everyones face he had three acts left and they all had one or two. Now he's only got marcus and marcus won't win because he has nothing special, he'll end up like all the other male winners of x factor if he did win. Sorry all you marcus fans, yeah he can sing, bt he's a cheap version of bruno mars, we already have him.

  • amelia GOD blass you i am hapy... UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU THE world pppop

  • I dont care if she wins! JUST PLEASE vote so shes in the final, so the final show wont be boring, I mean Misha Janet and Marcus, whata boring final that would be ugh!!!!!! AMELIA FTW if she doesnt win, Little mix to win!

  • 1st AMELIA LILY

    2nd Little Mix

    3rd Janet

    4th Marcus

    5th GET MISHA B OUT!

  • IM GLAD SHE WAS IN THE BOTTOM 2!!

    JUST SO I COULD HEAR HER VOICE AGAIN :D

  • craig should of stayed not amelia!

  • Does anyone know her vocal range?

  • Please whoever made the impossible happen!!!!! for Amelia to come back - to arrange for her to be announced first safe on the next results show!!!!

    Amelia best judges house performance in the history of X factor her Queen song best performance in the entire history of the X factor!!!!!! without a doubt we just need the best winner to add to this list!!!!!!

  • kelly gives her crap songs for obvious reasons..........

  • @bombayg

    agreed, the acts sing their own survival songs though don't they? this is by far her best performance from the live shows imo...and her "e.t." still tops anything that kelly (no1 misha b fan) has given her.

  • Good riddance !!

    Bye Bye Tubby, back to your cage and indulge in a biscuit binge !

  • I used to really like Gary, but in this competition he's way too competitive :/...Ameila certainly wasn't 'shouting'....and there are other times where he's been totally unfair to acts not in his own category -.- Thank goodness she got through! I hope she sings a Pink song one week :)

  • Is it true that Amelia's turning blind?:|

  • @JessandLiss No she said she has type 1 diabetes and that if she didnt regulate her blood sugar properly by injecting insulin she could go blind, and this is more difficult to maintain when she is regularly performing due to adrenalin levels. The papers blew it out of proportion of course and the headlines were like 'Amelia will go blind if she sings again' or something like that. Stupid fake journalists

  • Amazing voice; Horrible dress

  • omg people plz vote for Amelia lily i dont want her to leave the competition and this week she nearly did :(

  • love her voice. I love also Sophie Habibis and Kitty Brucknell and Little Mix and Misha B and Janet.

    I love X factor UK than USA!!!

  • 1. Janet

    2. Little Mix

    3. Marcus

    4. Amelia

    5. Misha.- shes a bully, as long as she doesnt win im happy.

  • The only 2 that have intresting voices are Misha & Janet. This girl could always have a good career in porn..

  • reminds me of shania twain for some strange reason

  • 1. Amelia

    2. Marcus

    3. Little Mix

    4. Misha B

    5. Janet

  • PINK ?

  • Amelia is going to eat Little mix up in the final!

  • gary just want to take her down and that's why he said she shouted her way trough the song. this is amazing

  • When i first heard this i was like ooo gaga is on x factor then saw Amelia was singing it

  • absolutely amazing

  • What's up with her bloated eyes? I can't concentrate on anything else but looking at that swollen undereyes

  • I dont know why ppl say she's like a British version of Christina A, I know she has a strong voice, but Christina has much more than that. Anyways I really like her!!!!

  • I have this awful feeling Janet will be in the final to bore us to sleep, sorry Janets voice is not for me. Really hoping for Amela, Little Mix and Marcus for final, that will ba a brilliant final show...

  • @jassia18 she is going to be in the final mark my words.

  • For 2 minutes and 38 seconds the competition was not about the judges but Amelia

  • AMELIA LILY vs LITTLE MIX. No others please

  • better than gaga live

  • Please whoever made the impossible happen!!!!! for Amelia to come back - to arrange for her to be announced first safe on the next results show!!!!

  • Just gotta love her then little mix then Marcus. i don't care about the rest lol

  • Ok here's he list of my favourites:

    1. Misha Bryan

    2. Janet Devlin

    3. Little Mix

    4. Amelia Lily

    5. Marcus Colins

    Don't get me wrong, I like Marcus, just not as much as the others.

  • @yoshi3794 Awh.xd

    Mine;

    1. Amelia Lily (she didn't deserve to go on the first live show, she's amazing)

    2. Janet Devlin

    3. Little Mix

    4. Misha B (I liked her on the first live shows when she added rap into the songs, but now not so much) :o

    5. Marcus Collin

  • @yoshi3794 i must say i agree with you on first 3

    my fav are

    1.Misha

    2.Janet

    3.Little mix

    4.Marcus

    5.Amelia, dont really like her tbh shes not that good she shouts

  • Gary! Amelia sang so beautifully, and just because she's not in Gary's group, he says she was shouting her way through it! She was AMAZING! He could at least have to grace to say something truthful and non-biast! Go Amelia!!! :D

  • Comment removed

  • @MegaAilsa3000 lol, he was obviously going to go for craig. He said that about amelia because he didn't give a shit what he said to her, he knew immediately who was getting his vote.

  • @MegaAilsa3000 i think he's jealous he could never sing on his own, remember his solo career? lol...don't worry neither does anyone else ;)

  • What the hell was Gary thinking? She's fantastic... OK, you had to back your own act, I understand, but don't insult people. Amelia's a star, the only star on X Factor this year!

  • Louie is the biggest fan of Amelia of all the judges!! It would be better if he mentor her now as Kelly's heart is on Misha!

    How in the world did Kelly turn Janet Devlin to the worst of the act after she gave such a great performance from Auditon and Bootcamp. Amelia - Run as far away as u can from Kelly!!!

  • I LOVE AMELIA SO MUCH ;S i want her in the competition till the end ;\

  • After last week's performance and this performance I think she's won already and will have a queue of record companies ready to sign her

  • She is way too off-key in the first half.