@BigMexico993 What you said does not apply to Reckoner. 'Reckoner' on IR is a completely different song than 'Reckoner' in 2001. In case you didn't know, that song from 2001 was released as an entirely new single in 2009.
Jonny is on bass while colin is grabbing something to eat for the guys "hurry lets do a webcast before colin gets back! Phil: Why Thom?. Thom: For the lulz :)"
funny you mention that, because the drums on the final version are definitely an homage to can. same with "go slowly" off of in rainbows. not so much in the studio version, but the live version definitely is an homage to "thief." figures radiohead loves can, right?
Amazing!! Masterpiece.. Glad that I've lent my ears to this song and glad that i've downloaded the entire album for free at DownloadMusic/./im , remove the slashes..
@MolesAsses yeah, jonny said radiohead's drug of choice is aspirin ha. and i remember thom saying once that they all experimented with drugs and were not impressed with the results. i'm pretty sure ed smokes weed though.
@vicprobey haha well everyone has to start somewhere with songs. I think sometimes they try many directions for songs, some they don't. But yeah, this is definitely a really fun bad jam together haha.
in the middle it sounds alittle bit like modest mouses jam parts of there tracks. And did he say some microsoft guy bought him like a monkey was this like a gift. correct me if i wrong what does this dude like work at a desk all day and listen radiohead in his free time and was like this man is genius let me just give him a monkey. awe so good i want a monkey. haha
this is great - i love how it is so raw and dodgy. shows how a song can go from one idea and turn into something else entirely. the final cut of "there, there" is one of my favorite radiohead songs, and i love it live.
I thought that Thom thought that "How To Disappear Completely" was his favorite of their songs. (I don't like the song; my favorites are Talk Show Host and There There)
It was before KID A. I have a super poor quality mp3 of this song..
but this video cuts around 2 minutes of the band playing these last seconds over and over again...
I love so much this unfinished version that I was a little bit disappointed with the final version, the first time that I've heard it at Benicassim Festival =)
It definitely would have required some polishing but it has a nice Bends-era throwback feel to it. The riffs fill in for the tribal drumming quite well, plus it could have offered some potential for extended improv for live performances. Ah well, the finished version is killer too.
I do not like this version at all. I like the album version loads, probably one of my 5 favourite RH songs. The demo version of There There was good too. No better or worse than the album version. Different, is all.
1. they just don't stop playing versions of the songs until it has a groove. many bands just play although you can't bang your head to it.
2. they listen to a lot of unique and rare music, so they come up with rare atmospheres. most bands listen to pearl jam, nirvana, and other very popular bands - they can't play anything new.
3. they're not please with just a good song. when they're done with the song - they "ruin" it - jonny's job basically.
c'mon, this is just a fumble about "writing session", you can really tell how much thought went into the final arrangement, it takes a long long time to come up with a definitive version of a song. Esp with their ridiclously high production values!
I really like this old version. And wow!!! Fucking Jonny is playing his brother's fucking bass! How fucking cool is this? I love Radiohead! Long live Radiohead!
common its pretty cool, i mean to hear such a jam of such a good song is something really pleasant and special, these short "jams" (gems =) was one the best part of The Most Gigantic Lying Mouth of All Time
Fuckin love this raw version of this song, the bass is fucking awesome!
bolamb1 1 month ago
Jonny Greenwood playing bass?!? OMG!!!! PANIC!!!!
ambskater97 4 months ago
Sorry thom! Must fast forward to awesome jam/improvisation of this amazing song!
mortar12 5 months ago
I think a lot of their songs start out raw and edgy and then they sand off the edges and get a very polished masterpiece. Just look at Reckoner.
BigMexico993 9 months ago
@BigMexico993 What you said does not apply to Reckoner. 'Reckoner' on IR is a completely different song than 'Reckoner' in 2001. In case you didn't know, that song from 2001 was released as an entirely new single in 2009.
jibbyfoob 6 months ago
It always surprises me how clear Thoms voice it even though he thrashes it about as if he's covered in flies.
I guess that's just Thom.
And Jonny is such a badass, stealing his big brothers bass and using it to have a jam sesh.
YurzAndMyne 10 months ago
ha ha there there underwater - this is sooooo wonderful
roblowefan1 1 year ago 2
thom looks like Mr.Bean when he says yesterday hahahah
beantongue01307 1 year ago
What the fu** has happened to Thom's voice??!
Jus kidding ;)
TheLordHodne 1 year ago
Jonny needs to become my music teacher
katenzcool 1 year ago 3
Bass part is EPIC
ElAullidoDeLaNada 1 year ago
Jonny is on bass while colin is grabbing something to eat for the guys "hurry lets do a webcast before colin gets back! Phil: Why Thom?. Thom: For the lulz :)"
jonjonwhii 1 year ago
the end of this version sounds so much like something that would have been from can's "tago mago".
MicahBuzan 1 year ago
funny you mention that, because the drums on the final version are definitely an homage to can. same with "go slowly" off of in rainbows. not so much in the studio version, but the live version definitely is an homage to "thief." figures radiohead loves can, right?
protomanhasballs 1 year ago
Radiohead do it Evolucion
who more can do this?
nobody!
TTheLuis 1 year ago
Comment removed
akikarvonen 1 year ago
I put this on sometimes just to listen to the alternate verse.
dansta187 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Amazing!! Masterpiece.. Glad that I've lent my ears to this song and glad that i've downloaded the entire album for free at DownloadMusic/./im , remove the slashes..
TBN1174 2 years ago
the old version is pretty nice not better than the album recording but still nice
Midnightpitbull2 2 years ago 2
jonny plays everything. mercenary of instruments he is!
hubustunk 2 years ago 23
i friggin love this version personally
hodgins 2 years ago 4
Jonny playing the bass... thas cool
williamcorleto 2 years ago
Jonny : "We did a bad version of it on a webcast once..."
where can i find that bad version
cause what i hear is great
yeahyeahyaha2 2 years ago 3
Wow, they definitely improved with the final version of this song, didn't they.
I guess they must have been high off their shit when they played this.
degree7 2 years ago
From what I gather out of some interviews I've seen, I'm pretty sure none of the members of Radiohead do any kind of drugs.
MolesAsses 2 years ago
Aren't they stoned during this video?
degree7 2 years ago
No; Thom is just a silly, silly man. (:
MolesAsses 2 years ago
Dude, he is high out of his mind, no doubt about it.
degree7 2 years ago
@MolesAsses yeah, jonny said radiohead's drug of choice is aspirin ha. and i remember thom saying once that they all experimented with drugs and were not impressed with the results. i'm pretty sure ed smokes weed though.
MicahBuzan 1 year ago
i'd love to be high with radiohead's gear.
robotophobia 2 years ago 2
is it that bad?
cause i like this version...(but of course i prefer the album one)
ziggystardust93 2 years ago
that was cool
BrendanOC 2 years ago
they are "high" for sure
pereiraelcristian 2 years ago 4
Looks more like Jonny than Phil on bass...
frostbitestudios 2 years ago
Colin (Jonny's Brother) is the bassist, but I know what you are talking about; It really does look more like Jonny on bass
AgentoftheAge 2 years ago
i think that's quite obvious but it's Jonny on the bass in this video.
ziggystardust93 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
haha this sucks
jegranja88 3 years ago
Can someone show me the interview that's being spoken about in the video info?
Nostalgiahatesme 3 years ago
It is on the most incredible lying mouth.
faerygyrl16 3 years ago
Hahaha, ok.
Nostalgiahatesme 3 years ago
it just shows radiohead's ability to fill out the skeleton of a song this version sounds great b/c its raw
pfading 3 years ago 5
WOW!!! I think its very encouraging to other musicians to see that radiohead sucks sometimes as well.
vicprobey 3 years ago 3
totally agree!!!---
Amnesiac18 2 years ago
lol i think that was just a recording of them practicing...it looks like it at least
rey5000 2 years ago
@vicprobey haha well everyone has to start somewhere with songs. I think sometimes they try many directions for songs, some they don't. But yeah, this is definitely a really fun bad jam together haha.
KyostiG 2 years ago
in the middle it sounds alittle bit like modest mouses jam parts of there tracks. And did he say some microsoft guy bought him like a monkey was this like a gift. correct me if i wrong what does this dude like work at a desk all day and listen radiohead in his free time and was like this man is genius let me just give him a monkey. awe so good i want a monkey. haha
fronczek123 3 years ago
he said he got a russian egg from some big fish in microsoft
theshakedownstreet 3 years ago 2
@theshakedownstreet
And got some free petrol using his celebrity status!!
YurzAndMyne 10 months ago
Mhhh...
FAKETREE81 3 years ago
this is great - i love how it is so raw and dodgy. shows how a song can go from one idea and turn into something else entirely. the final cut of "there, there" is one of my favorite radiohead songs, and i love it live.
mondaybox 3 years ago 19
@mondaybox
me too <3
faerygyrl16 1 year ago
haha jonny looks so out of place.
jonnygreeny111 3 years ago
is Jonny playing the bass?
*giggle*
moomoo2046 3 years ago
Free gas 'cause you're famous is a perk
tophersc 3 years ago
I thought that Thom thought that "How To Disappear Completely" was his favorite of their songs. (I don't like the song; my favorites are Talk Show Host and There There)
But I'm glad to hear that Thom likes There There.
Nostalgiahatesme 3 years ago
I wonder if the dude behind the camera knew that there was a drummer playing as well...
holydingbat 3 years ago 6
lol
mrmchpisto 3 years ago
amazing. :s
Seechz 3 years ago
I remember that webcast!!!
It was before KID A. I have a super poor quality mp3 of this song..
but this video cuts around 2 minutes of the band playing these last seconds over and over again...
I love so much this unfinished version that I was a little bit disappointed with the final version, the first time that I've heard it at Benicassim Festival =)
paranoidArnold 3 years ago
lol soooo different. does seem like its from the bends.
Heratio123 3 years ago
Still amazing but the final version is just amazing. One of the greatest pieces of music ever written. And live, its simply breathtaking...
TaylorKingMusic 3 years ago 3
i have this version on mp3, message me if you want it!
getinnocuous 3 years ago
can you send it to me please
paranoidkid17 3 years ago
pssst.
*nudge nudge*
moomoo2046 3 years ago
it's been months but if you could send it to me I'd be so grateful! mktrees at gmail?
mktrees 3 years ago
Final for the win.
..though it was nice to hear this.
Lyrik 3 years ago
Is there anywhere i can get this in mp3 format??? i want it badly
ColinoM 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
download it from here
mrmchpisto 3 years ago
they shouldve released this
AOCRkid 4 years ago
this sounds great, really bendsy. the studio version blows it away but i don't mind this.
wesside333 4 years ago 2
bendsy is a good word. I was thinking of the same thing, but couldn't put it into a word. Good job there, wesside333.
unrealnews 4 years ago
OMG this is good
ColinoM 4 years ago
It definitely would have required some polishing but it has a nice Bends-era throwback feel to it. The riffs fill in for the tribal drumming quite well, plus it could have offered some potential for extended improv for live performances. Ah well, the finished version is killer too.
caligo641 4 years ago
I do not like this version at all. I like the album version loads, probably one of my 5 favourite RH songs. The demo version of There There was good too. No better or worse than the album version. Different, is all.
Collins1990 4 years ago
How the heck do humans come up with such good music? How the hell did they come up with the final version of There There? Damn it!
Radiohead420DJ 4 years ago 5
@Radiohead420DJ here's how i think it happenes:
1. they just don't stop playing versions of the songs until it has a groove. many bands just play although you can't bang your head to it.
2. they listen to a lot of unique and rare music, so they come up with rare atmospheres. most bands listen to pearl jam, nirvana, and other very popular bands - they can't play anything new.
3. they're not please with just a good song. when they're done with the song - they "ruin" it - jonny's job basically.
imslicc 4 months ago 2
c'mon, this is just a fumble about "writing session", you can really tell how much thought went into the final arrangement, it takes a long long time to come up with a definitive version of a song. Esp with their ridiclously high production values!
EtcEtcAndEtc 4 years ago 3
This version reminds me more of something from the Bends than from Hail to the Thief. Just my opinion.
AsaiMoonsault 4 years ago 4
absolutly correct, it's sound like my iron lung or one of the bends track, i was just thinking that when see your comment
malasnoticias2210 4 years ago
this is nice, but studio version is sooo better!
twiggybass 4 years ago
this version of there there is terrible the one on HTTT is a million time better im so glad that they put that one on the album
jamie0215 4 years ago
"i try to
but i could never win
AN IMPOSSIBLE SITUATION
THAT I COULD NEVER WIN"
I miss those lines in the album release!
mydearkate 4 years ago 3
the old version is a million times better than what was on HTTT
mydearkate 4 years ago
I really like this old version. And wow!!! Fucking Jonny is playing his brother's fucking bass! How fucking cool is this? I love Radiohead! Long live Radiohead!
Radiohead420DJ 4 years ago 3
wow, Jonny plays bass.. cool
linking84 4 years ago
Someone might translate the interview of thom yorke to spanish, we are many persons that we do not know Englishman completely
please
radioheadcastro 4 years ago 3
where can i download this??
anyone have links to a torrent please send
AOCRkid 4 years ago
i'd kill to see radiohead just completely jam out all their songs like this at a show.
skan 4 years ago
yeah nice version
TEZCA13 4 years ago
they are cool for do this
TEZCA13 4 years ago
this sounds much better than the crappy quality one i heard years ago. studio version still trumps this but this is a nice jam :)
ripelivejam 4 years ago
lol. Big white telecaster. heh Anyway, he's playing Collin's Pbass.
xXamnesiac81Xx 4 years ago
its ok...i like the album one though...huge change
radiohead00000 4 years ago
wow......they really turned that one around nice though
kyluv5994 4 years ago
Crazy vid! Haha!
Jemma19 4 years ago
It sounds like an old song,
but is sooooo cool.
P.S: Is Johnny playing bass ???????? Jesus!!!
Lemonille 4 years ago
if you learn guitar or piano, you can play almost anything...but that has nothing to do with jonny greenwood. he's at chuck norris status
AOCRkid 4 years ago 2
this sounds like The Bends
FQuezo 4 years ago
WOW,let's fight each other over what Johnny's playing. grow up you moron's.
dunn56 4 years ago
Jonny's bassline almost makes the song sound disco-y. Such a hugely sound/mood from the version that made it on record.
omniculex 4 years ago
i love when he throws down the "someone on your shoulder" riff on the bass
amason327 4 years ago
Yeah, a big white telecaster with 4 strings an octave lower than usual - in the shape of a P bass.
coyel 5 years ago
porra, parece Los Hermanos
golatuza 5 years ago
common its pretty cool, i mean to hear such a jam of such a good song is something really pleasant and special, these short "jams" (gems =) was one the best part of The Most Gigantic Lying Mouth of All Time
NamelessLT 5 years ago
This is definitely a jam cause that looks like jonny on the bass
Lickmereet 5 years ago
no its a telecaster guitar
OrangeKubrick 5 years ago
no thats very much a fender bass
the0208 4 years ago
I rewatched it and you're right - it's a bass.
Sorry buddy.
OrangeKubrick 4 years ago
I'm pretty sure this was just a jam session. There's no way something like this would've fit in with what they were doing at the time.
tymanrocks 5 years ago
superb.
cansing 5 years ago
wow, thats really bad, amazing how they transformed it, it's a beautiful song on the released version. thom was funny.
nightveda 5 years ago