The best waltz in C sharp monor Ip. 64 No. 3 that I ever heard in my life! That's the big pleasure to watch and to hear that. Thank you, you are great! Do the best as you can :)
Dziękuję :) Wspaniale jest usłyszeć coą tak wspaniałego. Gratuluję talentu! I zyczę wszystkiego co najlepsze! J.
tak czytam te pochwalne peany... Nie odmawiając absolutnie Rafałowi wielkiego talentu i muzycznej inteligencji chciałbym jedynie zaznaczyć, ze ta interpretacja walca naprawdę nie jest wybitna... Ktoś napisał o tym walcu, że "niesie w sobie dźwięczność, słodycz i melancholię", tutaj słyszę tylko melancholię, brakuje lekkości, na dodatek szybsze partie piu mosso są jakby mechaniczne, brak legato, płynności. Dla mnie niedoścignionym majstersztychem pozostanie interpretacja Janusza Olejniczaka.
nie słyszałem nigdy interpretacji olejniczaka (a przynajmniej nie przypominam sobie bym ja slyszal), ale znajac go z pewnoscia ciekawie interpretuje tego walca.
ja ze swojej strony natomiast polecam wykonanie harasiewicza nagrane dla philipsa w latach 60 - bardzo dobre.
co do tej interpretacji rafala, to faktycznie czuc w niej lekka mechanicznosc lewej reki, natomiast wykonanie z konkursu jest moim zdaniem wysmienite.
@mx19idlewilder interpretacje Olejniczaka bez problemu znajdziesz na youtube. Ja słyszałem tego walca na żywo kilka razy w wykonaniu pana Janusza, na moim kanale możesz nawet znaleźć jedno z tych nagrań [Chopin live recording], jeśli poszukasz w gąszczu innych filmów :)
Genetically he resembles to Chopin.. Maybe his unique interpretation and talent is explained because of that..like if he was made of something different as other piano players..The right touch, the right soul and genes to perform that way..
@yourfriend7l este vals es precioso tambien puedes encontrarlo en mi cuenta de youtube interpretado por mi... no se comparan las versiones pero dime tu opinion
I cannot imagine how Rafal Blechacz feels when he walks into a room where people stand up and admire him with such awe. He is has reached the peak of the mountain, people. I get the chills to see him! I get the chills. Bravo! Thank God for Chopin and this great pianist! I'd proud to be Polish just by Chopin.
This is seriously the most convincing interpretation of this piece I have ever heard. Everything it is perfection: the touch, the phrasing, the dynamic, the tempo,... He clearly deserves a standing ovation!
@lifehappens Didn't you listen to Rachmaninoff play this? I'm not derisive of Blechacz, he's one of my favourite artists... But Rubinstein, Rachmaninoff etc are much higher above!
i love playing this piece. its filled with so much passion...although he is a fantastic pianist, i believe that the interpretation was well off. he is so good though, i love it when he plays the heroic more.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i love playing this piece. its filled with so much passion...although he is a fantastic pianist, i believe that the interpretation was well off. he is so good though, i love it when he plays heroic more.
first creators - they are genius.And they are one.Too many mans in our world can play indeed like that.But they cant make powerfull melody.If man replay somethin - he's sux.
I couldn't agree more! Just gentle, beautifully played, and not so much physical expression that distracts the audience from the beautiful music itself!
ive played on a steinway before haha. though i am undeserving. because the keys are made of ivory, they tend to be slippery. but once you adjust, you really can make a unique sound - not like anyone else who plays it. steinways are famous for that reason.
I start to believe that most of the people under music training have lost their true notion of music..Is there anyone here, without judging and criticizing, that is able to listen to this divine music, feel it's joy and be moved by it?? please everyone!!stop being ridiculously judgemental and start to LISTEN!
"Emotionally miserable"? Not all of Chopin is melodramatic and full of thunder. I think this interpretation was perfect and appropriate, not to say beautiful. If your piano teacher would have kicked you in the head for that performance, that would make them an idiot.
That's just what i'm saying,THANK YOU binblies! And next time kak2510, try not using technisisms to false out a completely valid approach. I WILL show you my interpretation and like I told you i'm not a concert pianist, and i'm sure I won't hear any good comments from you, but anyways i'm don't play piano so that people call it "romantic piece", I play piano to express my feelings, if you think that piece has any emotion whatsoever please try using something to clean our ears.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm no concert player, but still my teacher would've kicked my head if I played that song like that, it has no feeling in it whatsoever. Considering this particular waltz is actually hard to play, the performance is not bad at all, but he should add some fortes and pianos, maybe some rubatos, but he played emotionless...
I'm like so much younger than him, but I have some stuff to say about this performance. He is pretty fast during the "Piu Lento" section of this piece. But his speed during Piu Mosso is pretty constant after the tempo rubato, not like me I play this piece more like the Minute waltz ;]
lucifer wow ur sorta rude there lol.. correction u were rude... the 3rd beat isnt "refined" its true.. but perhaps he intended it to be like that.. dont judge ppl by ur own perspective always
im about to play this in a competition in about 3 hours >.< im scared.. lol...
stop analyzing it and degrading it like that...he got standing ovation for his performance and won the competition...if ur so amazing y dun i see u competing. its embarassing how ur criticizing and downright insulting someone else;s work like that
Sorry fot that, but it seems your listening culture is insufficient. His performance is at the level of a real art! and those undermelody (as you said) are arts of polyphonic which are typical in Chopin's style of writing. These are basic which you should have learnt... my dear.
If you feel that voicing the thumb (like Godowsky did it) is not Chopinesque, then you don't know his music very well. Look at the markings in the l.h. of the D flat nocturne (as well as similar occurences in countless other works). It's actually 100x more natural here, than to emphasise the notes that he asks the player to bring out in order to imply lines within the texture.
3 beat refined with choice. His not well chosen, not what a waltz is. Stick out, clipped. Waltz regal dance of grace, restraint. 3rd beat must be less. Go to "1" then. Sorry if you not hear before.
They are short but very few of them are 'clipped'. That is something entirely different. 'Waltz' is a wide ranging term and there is certainly no substance to the idea that they cannot be played with short third beats. They don't 'stick out' either. If you use your ears you'll find that the 2nd beat is given more of an emphasis, quite consistently. Also, it has been widely stated that Chopin's waltzes were not designed for dancing to. He used the form in his own manner.
Indeed, it's not worth arguing with somebody who makes the ludicrous claim that the 3rd beat is 'sticking out' here. If you can't hear properly then it's not going to lead anywhere. It's almost as amusing as your claim that the first bar of the thirds study should be played 'from the wrist' and not with the fingers. I didn't say that you referred to dancing, but you DID imply that with reference to short 3rd beats. Look at some of Chopin's pedal marks in the waltzes. Short 3rd beats are fine.
Technika to filar,ale oprócz niej jest coś jeszcze,nie da się ukryć,że pan Blechacz to ma.
Niebywała skala barw,imponująca głębia którą słychać w każdej nucie,wrażliwość po prostu wylewa się z tego młodego artysty.
elven234 3 days ago
The best waltz in C sharp monor Ip. 64 No. 3 that I ever heard in my life! That's the big pleasure to watch and to hear that. Thank you, you are great! Do the best as you can :)
Dziękuję :) Wspaniale jest usłyszeć coą tak wspaniałego. Gratuluję talentu! I zyczę wszystkiego co najlepsze! J.
JuliaC11 2 months ago
Best interpretation I've ever heard and believe me, I heard many. But it is not surprising - who can play Chopin better than a Pole?
But I have one question: Why is he walking off the stage so fast? : )
An2quamaraN 1 year ago 2
@An2quamaraN hes nervous??
druglover200 1 year ago
tak czytam te pochwalne peany... Nie odmawiając absolutnie Rafałowi wielkiego talentu i muzycznej inteligencji chciałbym jedynie zaznaczyć, ze ta interpretacja walca naprawdę nie jest wybitna... Ktoś napisał o tym walcu, że "niesie w sobie dźwięczność, słodycz i melancholię", tutaj słyszę tylko melancholię, brakuje lekkości, na dodatek szybsze partie piu mosso są jakby mechaniczne, brak legato, płynności. Dla mnie niedoścignionym majstersztychem pozostanie interpretacja Janusza Olejniczaka.
pmsmorga 1 year ago
@pmsmorga
nie słyszałem nigdy interpretacji olejniczaka (a przynajmniej nie przypominam sobie bym ja slyszal), ale znajac go z pewnoscia ciekawie interpretuje tego walca.
ja ze swojej strony natomiast polecam wykonanie harasiewicza nagrane dla philipsa w latach 60 - bardzo dobre.
co do tej interpretacji rafala, to faktycznie czuc w niej lekka mechanicznosc lewej reki, natomiast wykonanie z konkursu jest moim zdaniem wysmienite.
mx19idlewilder 1 year ago
@mx19idlewilder interpretacje Olejniczaka bez problemu znajdziesz na youtube. Ja słyszałem tego walca na żywo kilka razy w wykonaniu pana Janusza, na moim kanale możesz nawet znaleźć jedno z tych nagrań [Chopin live recording], jeśli poszukasz w gąszczu innych filmów :)
pmsmorga 1 year ago
he brings out so many inner voices in this brilliant masterpiece; he certainly deserves 1st place
AvidHobbyist 1 year ago
he looks so exhausted, let him go home and sleep - poor thing
VeraTymochko 1 year ago
starts at 1:59
AvidHobbyist 1 year ago 5
how can 10 people dislike this?
frankwong1983 1 year ago
Makes me wish I was Polish. I bow down.
TheAL845 1 year ago
Genetically he resembles to Chopin.. Maybe his unique interpretation and talent is explained because of that..like if he was made of something different as other piano players..The right touch, the right soul and genes to perform that way..
alchavezb 1 year ago
do they really applaud for 1 min and 39 sec? holy shit
Liqliq888 1 year ago
perfecto!!!,
adoro toda la pieza, en especial en las partes 2:47 , 3:52 , y 5:02
buen trabajo
yourfriend7l 2 years ago
@yourfriend7l este vals es precioso tambien puedes encontrarlo en mi cuenta de youtube interpretado por mi... no se comparan las versiones pero dime tu opinion
d4ni3lschi4v0 1 year ago
@d4ni3lschi4v0
ok lo hare
yourfriend7l 11 months ago
@yourfriend7l jajajaja va :)
d4ni3lschi4v0 11 months ago
Washington must see
PolishAmericanDC 2 years ago
i enjoyed this performance so much that as if the video lasts for only a blink, and i have to watch and listen to it over and over again...!!!
frankwong1983 2 years ago 2
What a gift!
Gregory98 2 years ago 4
the only thing i can say is WOW
zuzu1025 2 years ago 13
I cannot imagine how Rafal Blechacz feels when he walks into a room where people stand up and admire him with such awe. He is has reached the peak of the mountain, people. I get the chills to see him! I get the chills. Bravo! Thank God for Chopin and this great pianist! I'd proud to be Polish just by Chopin.
cjla1987 2 years ago 13
This is the closest I've ever felt to Chopin. Amazing interpretation <3
angle021 2 years ago 5
great interpretation, so much feeling
daughtersprince 2 years ago 9
Comment removed
pejkr 2 years ago
This is seriously the most convincing interpretation of this piece I have ever heard. Everything it is perfection: the touch, the phrasing, the dynamic, the tempo,... He clearly deserves a standing ovation!
sampledogcopycat 2 years ago 29
completely awesome!
komentattor 3 years ago 7
after 3 years of searching, this is the best interpretation of this piece i have found...
lifehappens 3 years ago 25
I agree. It's so natural, so beautiful...
"I feel at home with Chopin" said him. I understand that when I'm listening to him.
Lyapazavecunhee 3 years ago 7
@lifehappens imagine how you wasted your years!!! and you found just that! wow.
fabioso82 1 year ago
@lifehappens Didn't you listen to Rachmaninoff play this? I'm not derisive of Blechacz, he's one of my favourite artists... But Rubinstein, Rachmaninoff etc are much higher above!
satyu131089 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love playing this piece. its filled with so much passion...although he is a fantastic pianist, i believe that the interpretation was well off. he is so good though, i love it when he plays the heroic more.
kyleclef 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love playing this piece. its filled with so much passion...although he is a fantastic pianist, i believe that the interpretation was well off. he is so good though, i love it when he plays heroic more.
kyleclef 3 years ago
i love playing this piece. its filled with so much passion.
kyleclef 3 years ago 4
first creators - they are genius.And they are one.Too many mans in our world can play indeed like that.But they cant make powerfull melody.If man replay somethin - he's sux.
Armorid 3 years ago
Comment removed
jacanx3 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Jay Chow is better.
im serious.
lol
wnsbug 3 years ago
Jay Chou plays the waltz like farting.
I'm serious
You NOOB
SIlentPianist47 3 years ago 4
u do realize im just kidding
u dont have to be so immature
wnsbug 3 years ago
hahaha... seriously... I'm just kidding about "You NOOB" ... and "NOOB" go nothing to do with this?
SIlentPianist47 3 years ago
it hurts man... u didnt have to remind me that im a noob
im gonna go cry now. see ya...
wnsbug 3 years ago
Comment removed
jacanx3 3 years ago
Perfekt. Bravo, Rafal Blechacz!
stefanobeere 3 years ago
na widowni widać pełną kulturę, ludzie wiedzą kiedy mają siedzieć cicho
sochidi 3 years ago
this piece is like orgasmic!
I can play some of it.
I want to learn the rrest.
lemondrop3663 3 years ago
I can't play piu mosso well ^^
Awesome performance
zielarzopl 3 years ago
i love this piece so much which is why i find it so hard to study it myself, im so afraid to make mistakes..
jessmford 3 years ago 2
He makes it look so damn easy!
I play this piece.
Love it!
Annissa14 3 years ago 2
Gentle. Chopin lives in Blechacz. Simply gentle.
thenoelwanhl 3 years ago 10
I couldn't agree more! Just gentle, beautifully played, and not so much physical expression that distracts the audience from the beautiful music itself!
ttttln 3 years ago 9
great!
bbr79 3 years ago
When was this video taken?
madeincaribbeans 3 years ago
Warsaw, Poland, Europe
sousique 3 years ago
thanks but my question was WHEN :)
I meant was it a long time ago or not?
madeincaribbeans 3 years ago
21 XI 2005
ArloMusic 3 years ago
dziękuję ^^
madeincaribbeans 3 years ago
I can't stop listening to this!
bomberchicken 3 years ago
I love this so much, it tastes like toblerone!
bomberchicken 3 years ago 6
Hello, let's see the fan site on Rafal Blechacz (winner or the 15th International Chopin Piano Competition) : rafalpianist.ifrance. com
bast31 3 years ago
i would kill to play on that piano. it's stunning..
he's not too bad either :)
krystle823 4 years ago
ive played on a steinway before haha. though i am undeserving. because the keys are made of ivory, they tend to be slippery. but once you adjust, you really can make a unique sound - not like anyone else who plays it. steinways are famous for that reason.
RF264 3 years ago
I have played on a steinway too. They are beautiful, every note as clear as crystal, even when you play fast or with the pedal!
bomberchicken 3 years ago 4
The first 1 min 30 seconds is applause... ...that's 25.9% of the whole video.
1w4t7i0 4 years ago 6
haha..u r too free
knnfuck 4 years ago
I start to believe that most of the people under music training have lost their true notion of music..Is there anyone here, without judging and criticizing, that is able to listen to this divine music, feel it's joy and be moved by it?? please everyone!!stop being ridiculously judgemental and start to LISTEN!
chopinspoland 4 years ago 7
This is a very beautiful piece of music and Blechacz's interpretation is absoloutely wondferful! I agree with you 100%!
bomberchicken 3 years ago 2
"Emotionally miserable"? Not all of Chopin is melodramatic and full of thunder. I think this interpretation was perfect and appropriate, not to say beautiful. If your piano teacher would have kicked you in the head for that performance, that would make them an idiot.
tjblok 4 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
technically perfect emotionally miserable expected more from a zimmer student....... overall I've heard worse
bineblies 4 years ago
That's just what i'm saying,THANK YOU binblies! And next time kak2510, try not using technisisms to false out a completely valid approach. I WILL show you my interpretation and like I told you i'm not a concert pianist, and i'm sure I won't hear any good comments from you, but anyways i'm don't play piano so that people call it "romantic piece", I play piano to express my feelings, if you think that piece has any emotion whatsoever please try using something to clean our ears.
tooray1 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm no concert player, but still my teacher would've kicked my head if I played that song like that, it has no feeling in it whatsoever. Considering this particular waltz is actually hard to play, the performance is not bad at all, but he should add some fortes and pianos, maybe some rubatos, but he played emotionless...
tooray1 4 years ago
i think you should be 'kicked' for call a romantic piano piece 'song'. please let us hear your interpretation.
kak2510 4 years ago 3
true.
1w4t7i0 4 years ago
absolutly this is the BEST part of "winner's concert"
amoopeji 4 years ago 3
This is the best time I've seen this played on youtube.
craigmosdell 4 years ago
same here! after hearing this piece played by rafal blechacz, i just cant listen to anyone else play it
lifehappens 4 years ago 3
i've been searching through youtube versions (professional ones) of this waltz for almost an hour... i think this is my favourite so far!
durandal06 4 years ago 5
I can't lsten to anybody else play it after listening to him!
bomberchicken 3 years ago 9
One of the best versions of this waltz I have ever heard... A true master.
Lustre1987 4 years ago 5
I think this is his favorite chopin piece cause this is the only one he plays meaningful during the whole competition
kwastormayt 4 years ago
en el tercera parte le falta chicha pero por lo demas perfecto!
heltorrr 5 years ago
I'm like so much younger than him, but I have some stuff to say about this performance. He is pretty fast during the "Piu Lento" section of this piece. But his speed during Piu Mosso is pretty constant after the tempo rubato, not like me I play this piece more like the Minute waltz ;]
sorelmaleclement 5 years ago
lucifer wow ur sorta rude there lol.. correction u were rude... the 3rd beat isnt "refined" its true.. but perhaps he intended it to be like that.. dont judge ppl by ur own perspective always
im about to play this in a competition in about 3 hours >.< im scared.. lol...
Pianizt 5 years ago
I like it how he plays it... great!
r19rsi 5 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can't stand his LH 3rd beat in the fast part, it's not refined. And pulling that undermelody in the RH thumb there is downright embarrassing.
luciferkybrd 5 years ago
stop analyzing it and degrading it like that...he got standing ovation for his performance and won the competition...if ur so amazing y dun i see u competing. its embarassing how ur criticizing and downright insulting someone else;s work like that
lifehappens 5 years ago 4
Sorry fot that, but it seems your listening culture is insufficient. His performance is at the level of a real art! and those undermelody (as you said) are arts of polyphonic which are typical in Chopin's style of writing. These are basic which you should have learnt... my dear.
nickiechong 4 years ago 2
Ha ha - funny long distance online attempt at condescend!
luciferkybrd 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Good try, but sorry you wrong. His playing from cold practice, not all expressive. Polyphony forced here, tasteless. Hope you learn this.
luciferkybrd 4 years ago
Bullshit.
cziffra1980 4 years ago
If you feel that voicing the thumb (like Godowsky did it) is not Chopinesque, then you don't know his music very well. Look at the markings in the l.h. of the D flat nocturne (as well as similar occurences in countless other works). It's actually 100x more natural here, than to emphasise the notes that he asks the player to bring out in order to imply lines within the texture.
cziffra1980 4 years ago
I don't exactly find this playing overwhelming, but what is a 'refined' 3rd beat? That's a new one.
cziffra1980 4 years ago
3 beat refined with choice. His not well chosen, not what a waltz is. Stick out, clipped. Waltz regal dance of grace, restraint. 3rd beat must be less. Go to "1" then. Sorry if you not hear before.
luciferkybrd 4 years ago
They are short but very few of them are 'clipped'. That is something entirely different. 'Waltz' is a wide ranging term and there is certainly no substance to the idea that they cannot be played with short third beats. They don't 'stick out' either. If you use your ears you'll find that the 2nd beat is given more of an emphasis, quite consistently. Also, it has been widely stated that Chopin's waltzes were not designed for dancing to. He used the form in his own manner.
cziffra1980 4 years ago
Nobody said anything about dancing (good try, different argument). Childish phrase "if you use your ears" not worth arguing.
luciferkybrd 4 years ago
Indeed, it's not worth arguing with somebody who makes the ludicrous claim that the 3rd beat is 'sticking out' here. If you can't hear properly then it's not going to lead anywhere. It's almost as amusing as your claim that the first bar of the thirds study should be played 'from the wrist' and not with the fingers. I didn't say that you referred to dancing, but you DID imply that with reference to short 3rd beats. Look at some of Chopin's pedal marks in the waltzes. Short 3rd beats are fine.
cziffra1980 4 years ago