Lastly, to put it in simple words....The Jews were Foreigners in all of Eastern Europe...believe it or not, most Europeans knew and believed this fact then and hundreds of years before that time. The Jews were extremely prosperous wherever they went..including Germany. One of hitlers most famous speeches told of how the Jews Came to Germany from the Middle East, with nothing, they prospered and flourished and now they need to be dealt with. "Do not take what is my right" in other words.
Not only do Sephardic and Ashkenazim share very similar DNA, they are more closely related than the people in the countries they had resided in for hundreds of years.
A great example of Jews being considered a race...and this is the most major of them...HITLER. Jews were not murdered in Germany and much of Eastern Europe because of Religion. The Nazi's "Knew" the jews were foreigners from another country and this is one of the main reasons they were mass murdered.
Um...Princematt7...You are absolutely wrong. Jews are considered a race. By most people they are considered a race. You are simply talking of Logic and what a logical mind may think...humans are absolutely illogical. It may be Jewish Law that defines Jewish Identity. You are also incorrect about Jewish Genetics. Genetics has already proven that both Sephardic Jews and Ashkenazi Jews...although seperate from each other for hundreds of years do share major Genetic Similarities.
as the Lakota nation has tribal procedure and law to determine who is a memberof their tribe, who is not, who is expelled and who is adopted, so does Judaism..
The Jewish Bible ( Tanakh ) tells from the beginning book to the end that the righteous of all nations ( Jew or Gentile ) have the capacity to connect directly to God, merit blessing and a place in the world to come. Every human is equal before God according to the Jewish religion. Atonement is directly from God. Shalom
The covenant people, Israel have been MULTIRACIAL since the days of Torah, Moses' wife, Zipporah was a black woman. There have been Ethiopian Beta Yisrael since the days of Solomon! And I repeat, one cannot convert to a race. One may convert and become fully Jewish.
It is against Jewish law for any Jew to discriminate against a convert to Judaism. Since the time of the Torah converts have been accepted as fully Jewish, and this is the case in all branches. We are not even supposed to refer to the fact that they are converts! It is up to them if they wish to identify themselves as such. They are Jews, period.
You can become a member of a tribe or nation if you meet the criteria of citizenship. And the covenant people, Klal Yisrael, remain as in the earliest days of the covenant..a nation. It hasn't changed.
Reform Judaism (of which I am a member) will consider as Jewish one whose father is a Jew IF the child was RAISED in Judaism actively and exclusively.
A Jew who converts to Hare Krishna is just as apostate, but there exists no Jews for Hare Krishna or Hare Krishna Judaism evangelical groups spending millions of dollars a year in campaigns to convert secular Jews by convincing them it is a form of Judaism
Jews are in NO way a RACE..other than as members of the human race.
When a Jew adopts a belief that is in conflict with the Jewish religion, the belief does NOT become a " Jewish belief" just because a Jew chooses to believe in it. THAT is the conflict Jews have with the Christians who call themselves Jews if they deceptively try to present their Christian belief AS Judaism.
One who has left the Jewish people for the foreign faith of another people must undergo the steps of TESHUVAH , which means repentance and return to the God of Israel. Some groups may require that the individual also requires immersion in the mikveh before being accepted back, but they do not require the formal steps of conversion should the person wish to return.
According to Jewish law they're not counted in a minyan,( the minimum number of adults required for certain prayers and other mitzvot), they can't be buried in a Jewish cemetery, they cannot be given honors to go up to read Torah at a synagogue, and they may not be allowed to speak for the Jewish people. They CAN however, return without formal conversion should they repent of their idolatrous or foreign god worship and then be embraced again as full members.
Now if one born into the covenant becomes apostate through rejection of the covenant by adoption of another belief contradictory to the covenant, they are still be considered a Jew, but for all intents and purposes, they're not given the status of a member.
. An atheist Jew may live Jewish ethics and identify with their people, but they did not take on foreign beliefs contradictory to the monotheism of Torah and become “estranged“ from the Jewish people. An atheist may not convert *to* Judaism to become a member of the tribe because an affirmation of faith in the God of Israel is required to JOIN.
One born a member of the tribal covenant nation Israel (Jewish) may not be observant or even believe in God and they’re still a full member, a Jew. They may not be a good member or an active member but they’ve not renounced membership by following something ELSE instead of Judaism. An atheist or a secular Jew is not trying to call something ELSE Judaism. That is how one may be an "atheist Jew". Not believing that there is such a thing as deity, any deity is not following a false deity.
he Jewish nation began as a group of tribes and our connection to one another is still from the perspective of a tribal nation. (example: as the Lakota nation has tribal procedure and law to determine who is a member of their tribe, who is not, who is expelled and who is adopted, so does Judaism)
and while that is how we relate to one another, other rabbis say that we should not redefine our identity based on the fact that some people confuse the definition of a nation people, with a nation state, or courtry. Further complicating this detail is the State of Israel. Israelis are citizens of Israel and may or may not be of the covenant nation people, Israel. See important definitions at the bottom.
However, one may technically be a Jew if their mother is a Jew, but apostate to the covenant of Israel and no longer considered a member of the nation if they leave it for the covenant of faith of another religion. A few rabbis have suggested that rather than identify the Jewish people as a nation, as the Torah itself calls us directly, we refer to ourselves as “family”..
The Jewish people are considered both a nation and a religion. Our connection is primarily one of faith (religion) through the covenant of Israel, yet membership is also conferred by birth, through matrilineal descent. One may also become a part of the nation Israel by adoption of the faith of Judaism and formal procedures of conversion.
One who converts to Judaism is considered as FULLY Jewish as one born Jewish and their children are Jews. This has been the case since the times of the Torah.
There are many ethnicities that are distinctly Jewish. There are the Mizrahi (from the Middle East and North Africa).The Sephardi (Spanish) and the Ashkenazi, (German, Polish, Russian and other Eastern European), the Beta Yisrael of Ethiopia, and the Cochin of India and others that are each different as to cultural practices and foods, but it is the faith and covenant that binds them all together as Klal Yisrael.
We are Klal Yisrael, the community of Israel. . *MANY* different and distinctly Jewish cultures and ethnicities have developed over the millennia in Diaspora lands. The Diaspora refers to the Jewish presence outside of Israel after the destruction of the First and Second Temple periods and the Bar Kochba revolt.
People related to one another share genetic markers. The Hebrews had no concept of genetics. Jews began as a family, then as a small group of tribes and has remained tribal in nature. However, Jews are NOT considered a race. Jews are not *an* ethnicity. There is simply no *single* Jewish ethnicity. Neither ethnicity or race define Jewish identity. I repeat, it is Jewish law that defines Jewish identity.
Jews are a nation people, Israel (tribal origin) bound by an eternal covenant of the faith (religion) of Judaism. It is the laws of Judaism, given by God to the covenant nation, Israel, in the Torah, that determine Jewish identity. It is not a matter of “blood” but of self-determination through the laws of the Jewish people. I know that sounds repetitive but I repeated that because that appears hard for some to grasp.
When you try to make peace with ignorance you get war. When you try to smile you get a frown. When you love you receive hate. When you compliment you receive insults. When you speak the truth you get lies. I understand sir that you don't like me or care for anything I say but I ask you this one question if you are so confident in your heritage why do you continue wasting your time arguing with others over your heritage. If this makes you are proud then be proud and forget what others have to say
@Voiceofknowledge " if you are so confident in your heritage why do you continue wasting your time arguing with others over your heritage"
Simple. This is a public forum. There are young impressionable minds who come to youtube and read this kind of slander about my people. Young minds that dont know any better. And this kind of slander has been used time and time again to whip people up to attack Jews, again and again. When Hitler spewed his poison, no one argued with him. THAT's why I do
@Voiceofknowledge Hateful? What and whom have I directed any hatred towards You want someone spewing hate, look in the mirror you pathetic hypocrite.
Live off the name? Do you think people give you things for being Jewish, or what? Probably never existed? LOL. You have the education and common sense of a 7 year old. There is no doubt that ancient Judea existed. There are historical records, ruins, etc. It was a part of the Roman Empire eventually. Where do you think the Bible comes from, fool?
@Voiceofknowledge Before you wanted to argue with me based on the Bible. I notice you dont have any answer to the Biblical passages I posted. So not only do you know nothing about history & archaeology, or biology & genetics, but you dont even know the Bible all that well. The idea that the Jews were chosen by God to receive the Torah, etc, is the basis of all Abrahamic religions. Islam and Christianity do not even make sense otherwise. So what exactly is your point, other than racism?
"The DNA crap is the same as the " world is flat" theory. "
LOL, No, DENYING the proven FACT of genetic science is PRECISELY like claiming the world is flat when we know its round, imbecile.
What does modern medical science have to with "white supremacist propaganda"? What kind of ignorant rhetorical stupidity is that? There are scientists in every nation around the world of every race and color. They ALL use the same same DNA science, and would laugh at your ignorance.
@chained2it I love you brother believe it or not and I have nothing against your heritage. I hope that you and your people can continue to grow in faith. Oh and if you really want to talk about scriptures and see how much I know then respond to me and I will give you a party line number and we can meet in a room and discuss these thing. I know you may respond with rude and hateful commentst but I love you anyway. Take care buddy.
P.S. I graduated HS and I paid attention in my classes.
@Voiceofknowledge Do you know what this video is about, fool? That's a Roman sculpture of the head of Josephus, a Jew from Judea around the time of Jesus who was a war prisoner of the Romans and became a famous historian for them. He wrote a lot of very famous books, 2000 years ago, Maybe you;ve heard of him, lol.
And notice how much he looks like a lot of modern Jews today? Funny how that works.
@chained2it You know something I gave you what you wanted. I am not racist and I know my bible pretty well. It's funny, when I came at you respectfully with facts you criticized me by calling me a "drunken preacher". I didn't say anything mean or hateful towards you in the beginning but you were quick to prejudge me. Then when I flipped the script you were quick to say you never said anything hateful towards me and the called me a hypocrite. Wow brother. That was an experiment and it worked.
@Voiceofknowledge Are you kidding me now? After the blatantly racist and hateful comments you made towards Jews? Now you claim it was all insincere? You revealed your true face, and it was filled with hatred. I did not judge you in any way before that. I called yo a drunken preacher because I was having a dispassionate discussion about historical facts, and you preaching the gospel. It was like 2 different conversations. But after your racist tirades, I think we have nothing else to discuss
@Voiceofknowledge '". I didn't say anything mean or hateful towards you in the beginning "
I did not say anything mean or hateful to you until you directed such comments towards me. Nothing. And I never said a single racist or bigoted thing about anyone. Unlike you. And now you claim it was an "experiment". How dishonest. What were you expecting? For me to off on a racist tirade like you? And now you;ve closed your account? What a fraud
@chained2it I know the truth. I am very well skilled in ancient civilizations and history. I honestly wanted to see your reaction to bigotry and hateful comments. You were already very defensive from the start. Calm down brother it isn't that serious. One thing I can say about all humans is this: We are all born and we will all die. Jews are great people. I have some wonderful Jewish friends who so happen to be Ashkenazi. I apologize for disrespecting you but please try not to be so rude Lol.
'honestly wanted to see your reaction to bigotry and hateful comments"
Really? How convenient. So basically, you're dishonest?
' You were already very defensive from the start"
Of course I am. Most people on this page hate Jews. And you chose to argue with me, the one Jew here, rather than anyone else. That said it all. And when I asked you why you only had words for me, you were silent. I gave you no disrespect until you disrespected me an my people
Is your heart pleasing in the sight of G-d? Are you giving to the poor or clothing the naked? Are you leading by example and inspiring the youth in your community? Are you loving humanity and working towards the enlightenment of all man-kind? Are you making time for the disadvantage kids who live all around this world? We all face problems and NO-ONE is greater then anyone else. My question to you and all who read this is WHERE IS YOUR HEART?? For that is what matters to God. One love.
@Voiceofknowledge "Are you making time for the disadvantage kids who live all around this world?"
That has nothing to do with what we are discussing, Do not presume to preach to me. We are simply debating historical facts. We're not debating what matters to God. Stick to the subject.
"NO-ONE is greater then anyone else."
And no one has claimed anyone is greater than anyone else. Jews do not believe themselves to be better than anyone. Chosen for a special obligation does not mean greater.
Is YOURS? Who are you to ask such a question? And why do you direct it at me and not others? Are you a missionary to the Jews?
"are you loving humanity and working towards the enlightenment of all man-kind?"
Again, are YOU?
You ask to discuss dispassionately and without emotion, and then you go off like a drunken preacher. If you cant have an objective discussion about history, thats not my problem
@Voiceofknowledge The debate here is directed at that who wish to claim that modern Jews are not the descendants of the ancient Jews. Perhaps you should direct your argument towards them and not me. I know who my ancestors were. Its as simple as that. This is a debate about ancestry, not about God and religion. Stop interjecting your own agenda
@Voiceofknowledge Judaism is as "solid and unchanged" as any religion is. But all religions grow and evolve over so many centuries. The 1600s? You have no clue what you are talking about.
As far as DNA, please, dont make me laugh. Let me guess, you never graduated high school? Just never paid attention in biology class? LOL. You clearly have zero education about genetics. I'll defer to what science can PROVE to be true, regardless of what any primitive-minded medieval fool "believes"
An example of people converting to hebraism because of the Jews is found in the book of Esther 8:17. My point is very simple, G-d isn't concerned about your bloodline or facial features but he is concerned about your heart. Abraham is blessed with descendants in many nations of the world(Genesis 26:4,Exodus 32:13). Why? Because G-d is faithful to his word. Know who you are and seek not vain arguments over genealogies. We are dust of the earth and we shall return to the earth.
@Voiceofknowledge The word is Judaism not Hebraism. And of course people have converted to it over the centuries. And in doing so, they joined in with other Jews and added their own lineages to the bloodline. Anyone can convert and join the tribe. Their descendants will share the lineage of Isaac.
Physical features are irrelevant. But the Bible does specifically and explicitly state the Covenant is for those of specific bloodline. But that doesnt mean God's blessings are not for all. God set the Israelites apart and gave them a mission, That mission is stated in the Covenant. God's blessings are for all mankind. But the Bible states that God has a special relationship with the Israelites, and that it can be a blessing OR a curse.
When it comes to the Covenant, the Bible says God is indeed concerned with lineage. It states that the Covenant was for Abraham and his descendants, but only through Isaac, not Ishmael. And from Isaac descendants, only Jacob (Israel) and not Esau. It says this explicity. That doesnt make Israelites better than anyone. It simply means those of the Covenant have unique obligations towards God that others do not, just as a priest does
This is what the Bible says on the subject of the Covenant and bloodlines
Genesis 17:7
"And I will establish my covenant between me and you and your offspring after you throughout their generations for an everlasting covenant, to be God to you and to your offspring after you"
You can argue with the Bible if you wish, but thats what it says. And it continues with more on the subject
Then God said to Abraham, “As for you, you must keep my covenant, you and your descendants after you for the generations to come. This is my covenant with you and your descendants after you'
But the Bible also makes clear that the Covenant is not for ALL Abraham's descendants, but only through Isaac's lineage, as it states in Genesis 17:19-21, and through Isaac to Jacob
" Then God said, “Yes, but your wife Sarah will bear you a son, and you will call him Isaac. I will establish my covenant with him as an everlasting covenant for his descendants after him. And as for Ishmael, I have heard you: I will surely bless him; I will make him fruitful and will greatly increase his numbers. He will be the father of twelve rulers, and I will make him into a great nation. But my covenant I will establish with Isaac"
Genesis 17:19-21 clearly and explicitly states that the Covenant only applies to the bloodline of Isaac. That has nothing to do with being greater than anyone. Just as the High Priests of the ancient Temple of Jerusalem carried certain obligations towards God that lay people did not. The Jews are essentially God's nation of High Priests. That does not make them better or worse than anyone. Just as someone "chosen" for any obligation like military service or jury duty is not greater
" The Babylonian Talmud is one of the most racist and corrupted documents "
You have no idea what the Talmud is or what it really says. And the central part of the Talmud, the Mishnah, was written in the Holy Land (in the Galilee) just like the Bible was, around the 2nd century AD. The rest was compiled in Babylon 500 years later.
"yet most reform Jews go by it more than the torah."
LMAO! You call me arrogant while you spout ignorant stupidity like that as if its the truth. You have no idea what a Reform Jew is. Reform Judaism barely uses the Talmud at all. Many dont use it AT ALL, like Karaite Jews.
@Voiceofknowledge Ahhh, so now the real you shines through. Speak your mind, brother. So much for your "God loves us all" rhetoric. Go ahead and reveal all your prejudices and bigotries, your ignorance and embrace of stereotypes. You cannot extract any of your nonsense from my words, yet you continue to argue against points I did not make, And now you reveal yourself to be no more than a petty hypocrite with the same loathesome views of Jews as any other ignorant racist. Sad and pathetic
"Jewish people are nothing more than a bunch of people who arrogantly promote themselves over every other branches of humanity in the name of a God that they stole from other cultures."
What an absolutely hateful and racist statement.
" a lot of people that cause trouble in this modern age have been European Jews."
"I would never want to be apart of a group of wicked people such as the Jews."
etc. etc.
Nothing but pure bigotry and racism. What a fraudulent hypocrite u are
within this gigantic family that we are all apart of God chose a tribe for himself so that all the world may know his righteous name. This group of people became known as the Israelites. Again my friend his choice had nothing to do with any external features. This group that he chose for himself was to be a a nation filled with kings and priest. They were to be a light unto the nations and through their obedience to God all the nations of this earth would be blessed(Genesis 22:18)
" Again my friend his choice had nothing to do with any external features."
And again I ask you for about the 5th time now, where have I said otherwise? You are arguing against a point i never made. Others have made race an issue here, not me. So why do you continue to argue with me and against a viewpoint I have not expressed? Are you talking to me, or to yourself?
Abraham our forefather was not chosen by God because of his skin complexion, hair color, height, weight ect but because of his heart. That is what God looks for in all people despite your nationality or "race". Haven't you read what is written in the scripture(1 Samuel 16:7). It is written that we are all descendants of adam and eve and later Noah and his three sons. Therefore we are apart of one gigantic family and all of us are made in the image of G-d.
@Voiceofknowledge "Abraham our forefather was not chosen by God because of his skin complexion"
I am aware of that. And that has absolutely nothing to do with anything I have said. My argument is simply that so-called "white" Jews of today are just that - Jews, the descendants of the ancient Israelites. Of course Abraham was not chosen for physical reasons. And only a racist would say otherwise. But the Israelites were a nation, like any other nation, from a particular set of tribes
@Voiceofknowledge "It is written that we are all descendants of adam and eve and later Noah and his three sons"
Yes, but that is religion, not history. And again, it has nothing to do with the topic. Even accepting the Biblical account, how is that relevant? We are not all Chinese. We are not all Bantu. We are not all Indian, Russian, Scandinavian, etc. And we are not all Israelites. Its as simple as that, and that has nothing to do with God. We're talking about a nation of people, not God
sorry for this failed attempt. How do YOU know that this is an accurate depiction of Josephus??? Read his book The Wars of The Jews and find out that he documented that over 1,000,000 Hebrews fled into "Africa". Ancient Historians can give you the truth about the Hebrews......We have bas-reliefs in Assyria, Babel and paintings of us in Egypt during all our captivities.....One day soon people will know that Yahuwah has not forsaken us....this nonsense will go on for a little while longer...
@chained2it Sure, according to Torah, nevim & Ketuvim the hebrews always ran south when they were in trouble, Egypt greater, lower and upper, and even ethiopia but accoring to you scholarly "desearch", ah mean research, they only and finally went north...another wiki-armchair historian and intellectual!
@bansadok What does the Torah have to do with events of 70 AD, fool? It is a matter of historical record that Jews fled to North Africa, where well-known Jewish communities have lived for thousands of years, Wikipedia? LOL As if. Look it up yourself, anywhere. Obviously, you know nothing of North African or Jewish history for the last 2000 years. Yes, many fled to Egypt, until Egypt expelled them in the 1960s and they fled to Israel. They dont look much different than European Jews either
@bansadok "he hebrews always ran south when they were in trouble"
WOW. That means a lot. Is that the eleventh commandment? Thou shalt always flee south? Funny how they did not even leave a trace of themselves, but Jews in North Africa were known for thousands of years. Go look up the Jews of Morocco, Tunisia, etc.
@bansadok Jews have lived on the Tunisian island of Djerba for thousands of years. The oldest continually used synagogue in the world is there, along with a Jewish community that has existed there since biblical times. Funny how none of them are black, or ANY of the Jews of North Africa and the middle east. How about Persian Jews. who have been there since biblical times, as recounted in the Book of Esther? They arent black either
@chained2it It really doesn't matter if they were dark skinned or very paled all that matters is the morals and values of this group of people. Genetically we are all related. Jews are all across the globe and come in many different shades and sizes. The Lemba tribe of south africa are also jewish and they have very dark skin. "There is one [non-Jewish] group, however, for whom DNA analysis has provided a direct link to the Jews of biblical times. These are the Lemba."
@Voiceofknowledge "t really doesn't matter if they were dark skinned or very paled "
Of course. But why are you arguing this point with me as opposed to others? I am arguing in the face of those who make claims of "false Jews" and deny my people's ancestry. People who claim lightskinned people cannot be descended from the Israelites, etc. Which is historically absurd. Yes, we are all genetically related, of course. That doesnt mean we all had the same historical ancestors 2000 years ago.
@Voiceofknowledge "The Lemba tribe of south africa are also jewish and they have very dark skin."
Of course. The Lemba are descendants of Jews who came to Africa from Yemen, about 800 AD or so. Probably to escape Muslim persecution at the time. Probably not more than a dozen Jewish men or so, from the genetic record. They married local African women, and to this day no man is allowed to marry into the Lemba, only women. That's why they're black but have preserved their Jewish genetic lineage
@chained2it My point is simple, the Israelites were/are a very big family whose descendants are more numerous than the stars in the sky(Genesis 26:4). So never limit a promise and blessing of God to one particular group, skin color, eye color, hair type ect. You are very knowledgeable and I'm sure that you are very familiar with this information. So in closing love all, appreciate all and bless all. Peace unto you my friend.
Regardless of whatever you may interpret Genesis 26:4 to mean, the fact is that the Israelites were in fact never a very numerous people. Israel was a small nation. That's why it was vulnerable to foreign conquest so often in its history. And 10 of the 12 tribes were scattered by Assyria and lost to history. The only descendants of the Israelites known to history are the Jews
@chained2it Okay lets establish this before I comment any further. I am not going to argue about an ancient civilization. I will only make statements that I can back with the holy scripture. Also God is the one and only that can make all hidden things known to us. So let us reason together not based off emotion but off of truth. Let me began with basic knowledge so that this "race" situation can be squashed.
@Voiceofknowledge THis debate is about the Israelite people of history, not what it says in scripture. If we are talking about history, then talk about history, not religion. History and religion are 2 different subjects/ Israelites were people, like any other people, not the walking repository of all things Biblical. The Bible is the holy book that came to the rest of the world from them. I am not conversing with you out of knowledge, not emotion.
"God is the one and only that can make all hidden things known to us"
No, God gave mankind an intellect above all other creatures that enables us to discover hidden truths and facts. Our minds are gifts from God, I dont toss gifts back in the face of the God who gave them. God gave us minds and brains to use as intended. Now, can you have an objective discussion like a normal human being without sounding like a preacher? We're not talking religion here
@Voiceofknowledge "I am not going to argue about an ancient civilization."
But that is indeed what we are discussing, the people of an ancient civilization known as Israel, and later as Judea. The subject of this video is about a historical person, not a figure of the Bible. Josephus is not mentioned in the Bible. We know him from history, He was, in fact, a historian. And this is a historical debate, not a biblical one. You're inserting your own agenda here
@Voiceofknowledge "So never limit a promise and blessing of God to one particular group, skin color, eye color, hair type ect."
Of course. All people are God's children. But according to the BIble, the Covenant applies to only one nation, the Jews. It basically means that Jews carry religious obligations towards God that are specific to Jews and Judaism under the Covenant, and they are blessed in return for honoring the Covenant. That has been the basis of Judaism for thousands of years
@Voiceofknowledge And it also means that Jews face God's wrath for failing to honor the Covenant, for failing to do what Gentiles are not obliged by God to do. It is a 2-edged sword.
classical like ben stiller!i see in 2 seconds if someone is jewish!like the most people see that iam greek!if you are an original of your race or folk this is the resume!its ok!big nose and ears not only jewish have it!the eyes are important some arabs have the same skull cause they are semites too!
@Kerasounta modernJews..."They are predominantly brachycephalic, or broad-headed, while the Semites of Arabic origin are invariably dolichocephalic, or long-headed" (Jew. Enc. X (1905), 284). Semites have been long-headed, but the modern Jews were predominantly round-headed... the racial origins of the Jews, not with the Semites, whose language they adopted, but ...Hittites of Mesopotamia, whose broad skulls and curved noses they appear to have inherited" (Jew. Enc. X (1905), 284)... Shalowm.
@bansadok Umm., according to DNA, which is the only legit biological scientific means of determining ancestry, European Jews are primarily of middle eastern ancestry. According to the National Academy of Science and every other institution that studied it
@bansadok Gee, anthropological racist garbage from 100 years ago. How relevant.
How quaint. What's next? Nazi theories of German racial superiority? Or of black inferiority? The 1905 Jewish Encyclopdia, eh? Bullshit. See if you can find a single copy of any Jewish Encyclopedia that actually says any such thing. It says nothing about any skull measurements anywhere. You are quoting an internet fraud. You dont have a copy from 1905, liar
Propaganda my ass. This bust has been around for many centuries. Wikipedia did not invent it. Try looking it up instead of foolishly accusing people of "propaganda". This is common knowledge
@chained2it the phrase "Common knowledge" is often used by arrogant people who think that because something is accepted by themselves or their little circle as a fact, that that information is undisputed and indisputable. They go so far in assuming that once its on the internet, Wikipedia, et.c then it must be true! My friend the fact that you are shouting that it's common knowledge proves that it isn't common knowledge . Peace.
@bansadok "My friend the fact that you are shouting that it's common knowledge proves that it isn't common knowledge ."
No, it proves that some people are uncommonly ill-informed. Other than that, yout r post ins pretty meaningless and irrelevant to anything I said. I deal with facts
@juanamary999 Seems that we are listened to, we make impressions and we set a standard. Thanks for the confirmation. May YAH help us to raise our standard higher as the Yaphetim-Jews and the rest of the goyim look on. Shalowm Alaikhem.
Lastly, to put it in simple words....The Jews were Foreigners in all of Eastern Europe...believe it or not, most Europeans knew and believed this fact then and hundreds of years before that time. The Jews were extremely prosperous wherever they went..including Germany. One of hitlers most famous speeches told of how the Jews Came to Germany from the Middle East, with nothing, they prospered and flourished and now they need to be dealt with. "Do not take what is my right" in other words.
s76yu 10 months ago
Not only do Sephardic and Ashkenazim share very similar DNA, they are more closely related than the people in the countries they had resided in for hundreds of years.
A great example of Jews being considered a race...and this is the most major of them...HITLER. Jews were not murdered in Germany and much of Eastern Europe because of Religion. The Nazi's "Knew" the jews were foreigners from another country and this is one of the main reasons they were mass murdered.
s76yu 10 months ago
Um...Princematt7...You are absolutely wrong. Jews are considered a race. By most people they are considered a race. You are simply talking of Logic and what a logical mind may think...humans are absolutely illogical. It may be Jewish Law that defines Jewish Identity. You are also incorrect about Jewish Genetics. Genetics has already proven that both Sephardic Jews and Ashkenazi Jews...although seperate from each other for hundreds of years do share major Genetic Similarities.
s76yu 10 months ago
i take it that this was before jewish nose-bobs were invented...
CrackerJackLee 1 year ago
as the Lakota nation has tribal procedure and law to determine who is a memberof their tribe, who is not, who is expelled and who is adopted, so does Judaism..
Princematt7 1 year ago
Torah calls us the covenant NATION many times.
Princematt7 1 year ago
The Jewish Bible ( Tanakh ) tells from the beginning book to the end that the righteous of all nations ( Jew or Gentile ) have the capacity to connect directly to God, merit blessing and a place in the world to come. Every human is equal before God according to the Jewish religion. Atonement is directly from God. Shalom
Princematt7 1 year ago
The covenant people, Israel have been MULTIRACIAL since the days of Torah, Moses' wife, Zipporah was a black woman. There have been Ethiopian Beta Yisrael since the days of Solomon! And I repeat, one cannot convert to a race. One may convert and become fully Jewish.
Princematt7 1 year ago
It is against Jewish law for any Jew to discriminate against a convert to Judaism. Since the time of the Torah converts have been accepted as fully Jewish, and this is the case in all branches. We are not even supposed to refer to the fact that they are converts! It is up to them if they wish to identify themselves as such. They are Jews, period.
Princematt7 1 year ago
You can become a member of a tribe or nation if you meet the criteria of citizenship. And the covenant people, Klal Yisrael, remain as in the earliest days of the covenant..a nation. It hasn't changed.
Reform Judaism (of which I am a member) will consider as Jewish one whose father is a Jew IF the child was RAISED in Judaism actively and exclusively.
Princematt7 1 year ago
A Jew who converts to Hare Krishna is just as apostate, but there exists no Jews for Hare Krishna or Hare Krishna Judaism evangelical groups spending millions of dollars a year in campaigns to convert secular Jews by convincing them it is a form of Judaism
Princematt7 1 year ago
Jews are in NO way a RACE..other than as members of the human race.
When a Jew adopts a belief that is in conflict with the Jewish religion, the belief does NOT become a " Jewish belief" just because a Jew chooses to believe in it. THAT is the conflict Jews have with the Christians who call themselves Jews if they deceptively try to present their Christian belief AS Judaism.
Princematt7 1 year ago
One who has left the Jewish people for the foreign faith of another people must undergo the steps of TESHUVAH , which means repentance and return to the God of Israel. Some groups may require that the individual also requires immersion in the mikveh before being accepted back, but they do not require the formal steps of conversion should the person wish to return.
Princematt7 1 year ago
According to Jewish law they're not counted in a minyan,( the minimum number of adults required for certain prayers and other mitzvot), they can't be buried in a Jewish cemetery, they cannot be given honors to go up to read Torah at a synagogue, and they may not be allowed to speak for the Jewish people. They CAN however, return without formal conversion should they repent of their idolatrous or foreign god worship and then be embraced again as full members.
Princematt7 1 year ago
Now if one born into the covenant becomes apostate through rejection of the covenant by adoption of another belief contradictory to the covenant, they are still be considered a Jew, but for all intents and purposes, they're not given the status of a member.
Princematt7 1 year ago
. An atheist Jew may live Jewish ethics and identify with their people, but they did not take on foreign beliefs contradictory to the monotheism of Torah and become “estranged“ from the Jewish people. An atheist may not convert *to* Judaism to become a member of the tribe because an affirmation of faith in the God of Israel is required to JOIN.
Princematt7 1 year ago
One born a member of the tribal covenant nation Israel (Jewish) may not be observant or even believe in God and they’re still a full member, a Jew. They may not be a good member or an active member but they’ve not renounced membership by following something ELSE instead of Judaism. An atheist or a secular Jew is not trying to call something ELSE Judaism. That is how one may be an "atheist Jew". Not believing that there is such a thing as deity, any deity is not following a false deity.
Princematt7 1 year ago
he Jewish nation began as a group of tribes and our connection to one another is still from the perspective of a tribal nation. (example: as the Lakota nation has tribal procedure and law to determine who is a member of their tribe, who is not, who is expelled and who is adopted, so does Judaism)
Princematt7 1 year ago
and while that is how we relate to one another, other rabbis say that we should not redefine our identity based on the fact that some people confuse the definition of a nation people, with a nation state, or courtry. Further complicating this detail is the State of Israel. Israelis are citizens of Israel and may or may not be of the covenant nation people, Israel. See important definitions at the bottom.
Princematt7 1 year ago
However, one may technically be a Jew if their mother is a Jew, but apostate to the covenant of Israel and no longer considered a member of the nation if they leave it for the covenant of faith of another religion. A few rabbis have suggested that rather than identify the Jewish people as a nation, as the Torah itself calls us directly, we refer to ourselves as “family”..
Princematt7 1 year ago
The Jewish people are considered both a nation and a religion. Our connection is primarily one of faith (religion) through the covenant of Israel, yet membership is also conferred by birth, through matrilineal descent. One may also become a part of the nation Israel by adoption of the faith of Judaism and formal procedures of conversion.
One who converts to Judaism is considered as FULLY Jewish as one born Jewish and their children are Jews. This has been the case since the times of the Torah.
Princematt7 1 year ago
There are many ethnicities that are distinctly Jewish. There are the Mizrahi (from the Middle East and North Africa).The Sephardi (Spanish) and the Ashkenazi, (German, Polish, Russian and other Eastern European), the Beta Yisrael of Ethiopia, and the Cochin of India and others that are each different as to cultural practices and foods, but it is the faith and covenant that binds them all together as Klal Yisrael.
Princematt7 1 year ago
We are Klal Yisrael, the community of Israel. . *MANY* different and distinctly Jewish cultures and ethnicities have developed over the millennia in Diaspora lands. The Diaspora refers to the Jewish presence outside of Israel after the destruction of the First and Second Temple periods and the Bar Kochba revolt.
Princematt7 1 year ago
People related to one another share genetic markers. The Hebrews had no concept of genetics. Jews began as a family, then as a small group of tribes and has remained tribal in nature. However, Jews are NOT considered a race. Jews are not *an* ethnicity. There is simply no *single* Jewish ethnicity. Neither ethnicity or race define Jewish identity. I repeat, it is Jewish law that defines Jewish identity.
Princematt7 1 year ago
Jews are a nation people, Israel (tribal origin) bound by an eternal covenant of the faith (religion) of Judaism. It is the laws of Judaism, given by God to the covenant nation, Israel, in the Torah, that determine Jewish identity. It is not a matter of “blood” but of self-determination through the laws of the Jewish people. I know that sounds repetitive but I repeated that because that appears hard for some to grasp.
Princematt7 1 year ago
When you try to make peace with ignorance you get war. When you try to smile you get a frown. When you love you receive hate. When you compliment you receive insults. When you speak the truth you get lies. I understand sir that you don't like me or care for anything I say but I ask you this one question if you are so confident in your heritage why do you continue wasting your time arguing with others over your heritage. If this makes you are proud then be proud and forget what others have to say
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge " if you are so confident in your heritage why do you continue wasting your time arguing with others over your heritage"
Simple. This is a public forum. There are young impressionable minds who come to youtube and read this kind of slander about my people. Young minds that dont know any better. And this kind of slander has been used time and time again to whip people up to attack Jews, again and again. When Hitler spewed his poison, no one argued with him. THAT's why I do
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge Hateful? What and whom have I directed any hatred towards You want someone spewing hate, look in the mirror you pathetic hypocrite.
Live off the name? Do you think people give you things for being Jewish, or what? Probably never existed? LOL. You have the education and common sense of a 7 year old. There is no doubt that ancient Judea existed. There are historical records, ruins, etc. It was a part of the Roman Empire eventually. Where do you think the Bible comes from, fool?
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge Before you wanted to argue with me based on the Bible. I notice you dont have any answer to the Biblical passages I posted. So not only do you know nothing about history & archaeology, or biology & genetics, but you dont even know the Bible all that well. The idea that the Jews were chosen by God to receive the Torah, etc, is the basis of all Abrahamic religions. Islam and Christianity do not even make sense otherwise. So what exactly is your point, other than racism?
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
"The DNA crap is the same as the " world is flat" theory. "
LOL, No, DENYING the proven FACT of genetic science is PRECISELY like claiming the world is flat when we know its round, imbecile.
What does modern medical science have to with "white supremacist propaganda"? What kind of ignorant rhetorical stupidity is that? There are scientists in every nation around the world of every race and color. They ALL use the same same DNA science, and would laugh at your ignorance.
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it I love you brother believe it or not and I have nothing against your heritage. I hope that you and your people can continue to grow in faith. Oh and if you really want to talk about scriptures and see how much I know then respond to me and I will give you a party line number and we can meet in a room and discuss these thing. I know you may respond with rude and hateful commentst but I love you anyway. Take care buddy.
P.S. I graduated HS and I paid attention in my classes.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge Do you know what this video is about, fool? That's a Roman sculpture of the head of Josephus, a Jew from Judea around the time of Jesus who was a war prisoner of the Romans and became a famous historian for them. He wrote a lot of very famous books, 2000 years ago, Maybe you;ve heard of him, lol.
And notice how much he looks like a lot of modern Jews today? Funny how that works.
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@chained2it You know something I gave you what you wanted. I am not racist and I know my bible pretty well. It's funny, when I came at you respectfully with facts you criticized me by calling me a "drunken preacher". I didn't say anything mean or hateful towards you in the beginning but you were quick to prejudge me. Then when I flipped the script you were quick to say you never said anything hateful towards me and the called me a hypocrite. Wow brother. That was an experiment and it worked.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge Are you kidding me now? After the blatantly racist and hateful comments you made towards Jews? Now you claim it was all insincere? You revealed your true face, and it was filled with hatred. I did not judge you in any way before that. I called yo a drunken preacher because I was having a dispassionate discussion about historical facts, and you preaching the gospel. It was like 2 different conversations. But after your racist tirades, I think we have nothing else to discuss
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge '". I didn't say anything mean or hateful towards you in the beginning "
I did not say anything mean or hateful to you until you directed such comments towards me. Nothing. And I never said a single racist or bigoted thing about anyone. Unlike you. And now you claim it was an "experiment". How dishonest. What were you expecting? For me to off on a racist tirade like you? And now you;ve closed your account? What a fraud
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it I know the truth. I am very well skilled in ancient civilizations and history. I honestly wanted to see your reaction to bigotry and hateful comments. You were already very defensive from the start. Calm down brother it isn't that serious. One thing I can say about all humans is this: We are all born and we will all die. Jews are great people. I have some wonderful Jewish friends who so happen to be Ashkenazi. I apologize for disrespecting you but please try not to be so rude Lol.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
'honestly wanted to see your reaction to bigotry and hateful comments"
Really? How convenient. So basically, you're dishonest?
' You were already very defensive from the start"
Of course I am. Most people on this page hate Jews. And you chose to argue with me, the one Jew here, rather than anyone else. That said it all. And when I asked you why you only had words for me, you were silent. I gave you no disrespect until you disrespected me an my people
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
Is your heart pleasing in the sight of G-d? Are you giving to the poor or clothing the naked? Are you leading by example and inspiring the youth in your community? Are you loving humanity and working towards the enlightenment of all man-kind? Are you making time for the disadvantage kids who live all around this world? We all face problems and NO-ONE is greater then anyone else. My question to you and all who read this is WHERE IS YOUR HEART?? For that is what matters to God. One love.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "Are you making time for the disadvantage kids who live all around this world?"
That has nothing to do with what we are discussing, Do not presume to preach to me. We are simply debating historical facts. We're not debating what matters to God. Stick to the subject.
"NO-ONE is greater then anyone else."
And no one has claimed anyone is greater than anyone else. Jews do not believe themselves to be better than anyone. Chosen for a special obligation does not mean greater.
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "Is your heart pleasing in the sight of G-d?"
Is YOURS? Who are you to ask such a question? And why do you direct it at me and not others? Are you a missionary to the Jews?
"are you loving humanity and working towards the enlightenment of all man-kind?"
Again, are YOU?
You ask to discuss dispassionately and without emotion, and then you go off like a drunken preacher. If you cant have an objective discussion about history, thats not my problem
chained2it 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Voiceofknowledge The debate here is directed at that who wish to claim that modern Jews are not the descendants of the ancient Jews. Perhaps you should direct your argument towards them and not me. I know who my ancestors were. Its as simple as that. This is a debate about ancestry, not about God and religion. Stop interjecting your own agenda
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge Judaism is as "solid and unchanged" as any religion is. But all religions grow and evolve over so many centuries. The 1600s? You have no clue what you are talking about.
As far as DNA, please, dont make me laugh. Let me guess, you never graduated high school? Just never paid attention in biology class? LOL. You clearly have zero education about genetics. I'll defer to what science can PROVE to be true, regardless of what any primitive-minded medieval fool "believes"
chained2it 1 year ago
An example of people converting to hebraism because of the Jews is found in the book of Esther 8:17. My point is very simple, G-d isn't concerned about your bloodline or facial features but he is concerned about your heart. Abraham is blessed with descendants in many nations of the world(Genesis 26:4,Exodus 32:13). Why? Because G-d is faithful to his word. Know who you are and seek not vain arguments over genealogies. We are dust of the earth and we shall return to the earth.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge The word is Judaism not Hebraism. And of course people have converted to it over the centuries. And in doing so, they joined in with other Jews and added their own lineages to the bloodline. Anyone can convert and join the tribe. Their descendants will share the lineage of Isaac.
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
Physical features are irrelevant. But the Bible does specifically and explicitly state the Covenant is for those of specific bloodline. But that doesnt mean God's blessings are not for all. God set the Israelites apart and gave them a mission, That mission is stated in the Covenant. God's blessings are for all mankind. But the Bible states that God has a special relationship with the Israelites, and that it can be a blessing OR a curse.
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "G-d isn't concerned about your bloodline "
When it comes to the Covenant, the Bible says God is indeed concerned with lineage. It states that the Covenant was for Abraham and his descendants, but only through Isaac, not Ishmael. And from Isaac descendants, only Jacob (Israel) and not Esau. It says this explicity. That doesnt make Israelites better than anyone. It simply means those of the Covenant have unique obligations towards God that others do not, just as a priest does
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
"G-d isn't concerned about your bloodline "
This is what the Bible says on the subject of the Covenant and bloodlines
Genesis 17:7
"And I will establish my covenant between me and you and your offspring after you throughout their generations for an everlasting covenant, to be God to you and to your offspring after you"
You can argue with the Bible if you wish, but thats what it says. And it continues with more on the subject
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
Genesis 17:9-10
Then God said to Abraham, “As for you, you must keep my covenant, you and your descendants after you for the generations to come. This is my covenant with you and your descendants after you'
But the Bible also makes clear that the Covenant is not for ALL Abraham's descendants, but only through Isaac's lineage, as it states in Genesis 17:19-21, and through Isaac to Jacob
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
Genesis 17:19-21
" Then God said, “Yes, but your wife Sarah will bear you a son, and you will call him Isaac. I will establish my covenant with him as an everlasting covenant for his descendants after him. And as for Ishmael, I have heard you: I will surely bless him; I will make him fruitful and will greatly increase his numbers. He will be the father of twelve rulers, and I will make him into a great nation. But my covenant I will establish with Isaac"
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it
Genesis 17:19-21 clearly and explicitly states that the Covenant only applies to the bloodline of Isaac. That has nothing to do with being greater than anyone. Just as the High Priests of the ancient Temple of Jerusalem carried certain obligations towards God that lay people did not. The Jews are essentially God's nation of High Priests. That does not make them better or worse than anyone. Just as someone "chosen" for any obligation like military service or jury duty is not greater
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
" The Babylonian Talmud is one of the most racist and corrupted documents "
You have no idea what the Talmud is or what it really says. And the central part of the Talmud, the Mishnah, was written in the Holy Land (in the Galilee) just like the Bible was, around the 2nd century AD. The rest was compiled in Babylon 500 years later.
" typical attitude of a arrogant Jew"
typical statement of an ignorant racist
chained2it 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Voiceofknowledge
"yet most reform Jews go by it more than the torah."
LMAO! You call me arrogant while you spout ignorant stupidity like that as if its the truth. You have no idea what a Reform Jew is. Reform Judaism barely uses the Talmud at all. Many dont use it AT ALL, like Karaite Jews.
chained2it 1 year ago
Comment removed
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge Ahhh, so now the real you shines through. Speak your mind, brother. So much for your "God loves us all" rhetoric. Go ahead and reveal all your prejudices and bigotries, your ignorance and embrace of stereotypes. You cannot extract any of your nonsense from my words, yet you continue to argue against points I did not make, And now you reveal yourself to be no more than a petty hypocrite with the same loathesome views of Jews as any other ignorant racist. Sad and pathetic
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
"Jewish people are nothing more than a bunch of people who arrogantly promote themselves over every other branches of humanity in the name of a God that they stole from other cultures."
What an absolutely hateful and racist statement.
" a lot of people that cause trouble in this modern age have been European Jews."
"I would never want to be apart of a group of wicked people such as the Jews."
etc. etc.
Nothing but pure bigotry and racism. What a fraudulent hypocrite u are
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "I was trying to make peace"
You were? With whom? How?
" but you people love war and strife."
Oh, of course. Its in the Talmud. We celebrate war and strife, the sweet stuff of life. Imbecile
chained2it 1 year ago
within this gigantic family that we are all apart of God chose a tribe for himself so that all the world may know his righteous name. This group of people became known as the Israelites. Again my friend his choice had nothing to do with any external features. This group that he chose for himself was to be a a nation filled with kings and priest. They were to be a light unto the nations and through their obedience to God all the nations of this earth would be blessed(Genesis 22:18)
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
" Again my friend his choice had nothing to do with any external features."
And again I ask you for about the 5th time now, where have I said otherwise? You are arguing against a point i never made. Others have made race an issue here, not me. So why do you continue to argue with me and against a viewpoint I have not expressed? Are you talking to me, or to yourself?
chained2it 1 year ago
Abraham our forefather was not chosen by God because of his skin complexion, hair color, height, weight ect but because of his heart. That is what God looks for in all people despite your nationality or "race". Haven't you read what is written in the scripture(1 Samuel 16:7). It is written that we are all descendants of adam and eve and later Noah and his three sons. Therefore we are apart of one gigantic family and all of us are made in the image of G-d.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "Abraham our forefather was not chosen by God because of his skin complexion"
I am aware of that. And that has absolutely nothing to do with anything I have said. My argument is simply that so-called "white" Jews of today are just that - Jews, the descendants of the ancient Israelites. Of course Abraham was not chosen for physical reasons. And only a racist would say otherwise. But the Israelites were a nation, like any other nation, from a particular set of tribes
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "It is written that we are all descendants of adam and eve and later Noah and his three sons"
Yes, but that is religion, not history. And again, it has nothing to do with the topic. Even accepting the Biblical account, how is that relevant? We are not all Chinese. We are not all Bantu. We are not all Indian, Russian, Scandinavian, etc. And we are not all Israelites. Its as simple as that, and that has nothing to do with God. We're talking about a nation of people, not God
chained2it 1 year ago
Please people remember that all history belongs to mankind and that we are ONE.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
Let me show you my videos:
watch?v=zj6hnNkxKB8
watch?v=AH48MlBVDoI
watch?v=JSP8mT2kcTo
vinikorn7 1 year ago
Looks like BOB DYLAN! Heeeeeyyyyy...theeeeee tiiiimeeessss rrrrrrrrrrr aaaaaa chaaaaaaannnng'nnnnnnn.....................
AmericanFireBrand 1 year ago
sorry for this failed attempt. How do YOU know that this is an accurate depiction of Josephus??? Read his book The Wars of The Jews and find out that he documented that over 1,000,000 Hebrews fled into "Africa". Ancient Historians can give you the truth about the Hebrews......We have bas-reliefs in Assyria, Babel and paintings of us in Egypt during all our captivities.....One day soon people will know that Yahuwah has not forsaken us....this nonsense will go on for a little while longer...
yessir718 1 year ago
@yessir718 Can you give me any source of your paintings in egypt and your bas-reliefs in Assyria, Babel
Tuphut 1 year ago
@yessir718 "he documented that over 1,000,000 Hebrews fled into "Africa""
Yes, to NORTH Africa, where Jewish communities have existed for thousands of years, like on the island of Djerba.
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it Sure, according to Torah, nevim & Ketuvim the hebrews always ran south when they were in trouble, Egypt greater, lower and upper, and even ethiopia but accoring to you scholarly "desearch", ah mean research, they only and finally went north...another wiki-armchair historian and intellectual!
bansadok 1 year ago
@bansadok What does the Torah have to do with events of 70 AD, fool? It is a matter of historical record that Jews fled to North Africa, where well-known Jewish communities have lived for thousands of years, Wikipedia? LOL As if. Look it up yourself, anywhere. Obviously, you know nothing of North African or Jewish history for the last 2000 years. Yes, many fled to Egypt, until Egypt expelled them in the 1960s and they fled to Israel. They dont look much different than European Jews either
chained2it 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bansadok "he hebrews always ran south when they were in trouble"
WOW. That means a lot. Is that the eleventh commandment? Thou shalt always flee south? Funny how they did not even leave a trace of themselves, but Jews in North Africa were known for thousands of years. Go look up the Jews of Morocco, Tunisia, etc.
chained2it 1 year ago
@bansadok Jews have lived on the Tunisian island of Djerba for thousands of years. The oldest continually used synagogue in the world is there, along with a Jewish community that has existed there since biblical times. Funny how none of them are black, or ANY of the Jews of North Africa and the middle east. How about Persian Jews. who have been there since biblical times, as recounted in the Book of Esther? They arent black either
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it It really doesn't matter if they were dark skinned or very paled all that matters is the morals and values of this group of people. Genetically we are all related. Jews are all across the globe and come in many different shades and sizes. The Lemba tribe of south africa are also jewish and they have very dark skin. "There is one [non-Jewish] group, however, for whom DNA analysis has provided a direct link to the Jews of biblical times. These are the Lemba."
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Voiceofknowledge "t really doesn't matter if they were dark skinned or very paled "
Of course. But why are you arguing this point with me as opposed to others? I am arguing in the face of those who make claims of "false Jews" and deny my people's ancestry. People who claim lightskinned people cannot be descended from the Israelites, etc. Which is historically absurd. Yes, we are all genetically related, of course. That doesnt mean we all had the same historical ancestors 2000 years ago.
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "The Lemba tribe of south africa are also jewish and they have very dark skin."
Of course. The Lemba are descendants of Jews who came to Africa from Yemen, about 800 AD or so. Probably to escape Muslim persecution at the time. Probably not more than a dozen Jewish men or so, from the genetic record. They married local African women, and to this day no man is allowed to marry into the Lemba, only women. That's why they're black but have preserved their Jewish genetic lineage
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it My point is simple, the Israelites were/are a very big family whose descendants are more numerous than the stars in the sky(Genesis 26:4). So never limit a promise and blessing of God to one particular group, skin color, eye color, hair type ect. You are very knowledgeable and I'm sure that you are very familiar with this information. So in closing love all, appreciate all and bless all. Peace unto you my friend.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge
Regardless of whatever you may interpret Genesis 26:4 to mean, the fact is that the Israelites were in fact never a very numerous people. Israel was a small nation. That's why it was vulnerable to foreign conquest so often in its history. And 10 of the 12 tribes were scattered by Assyria and lost to history. The only descendants of the Israelites known to history are the Jews
chained2it 1 year ago
@chained2it Okay lets establish this before I comment any further. I am not going to argue about an ancient civilization. I will only make statements that I can back with the holy scripture. Also God is the one and only that can make all hidden things known to us. So let us reason together not based off emotion but off of truth. Let me began with basic knowledge so that this "race" situation can be squashed.
Voiceofknowledge 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge THis debate is about the Israelite people of history, not what it says in scripture. If we are talking about history, then talk about history, not religion. History and religion are 2 different subjects/ Israelites were people, like any other people, not the walking repository of all things Biblical. The Bible is the holy book that came to the rest of the world from them. I am not conversing with you out of knowledge, not emotion.
chained2it 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Voiceofknowledge
"God is the one and only that can make all hidden things known to us"
No, God gave mankind an intellect above all other creatures that enables us to discover hidden truths and facts. Our minds are gifts from God, I dont toss gifts back in the face of the God who gave them. God gave us minds and brains to use as intended. Now, can you have an objective discussion like a normal human being without sounding like a preacher? We're not talking religion here
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge "I am not going to argue about an ancient civilization."
But that is indeed what we are discussing, the people of an ancient civilization known as Israel, and later as Judea. The subject of this video is about a historical person, not a figure of the Bible. Josephus is not mentioned in the Bible. We know him from history, He was, in fact, a historian. And this is a historical debate, not a biblical one. You're inserting your own agenda here
chained2it 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Voiceofknowledge "So never limit a promise and blessing of God to one particular group, skin color, eye color, hair type ect."
Of course. All people are God's children. But according to the BIble, the Covenant applies to only one nation, the Jews. It basically means that Jews carry religious obligations towards God that are specific to Jews and Judaism under the Covenant, and they are blessed in return for honoring the Covenant. That has been the basis of Judaism for thousands of years
chained2it 1 year ago
@Voiceofknowledge And it also means that Jews face God's wrath for failing to honor the Covenant, for failing to do what Gentiles are not obliged by God to do. It is a 2-edged sword.
chained2it 1 year ago
classical like ben stiller!i see in 2 seconds if someone is jewish!like the most people see that iam greek!if you are an original of your race or folk this is the resume!its ok!big nose and ears not only jewish have it!the eyes are important some arabs have the same skull cause they are semites too!
Kerasounta 2 years ago
@Kerasounta modernJews..."They are predominantly brachycephalic, or broad-headed, while the Semites of Arabic origin are invariably dolichocephalic, or long-headed" (Jew. Enc. X (1905), 284). Semites have been long-headed, but the modern Jews were predominantly round-headed... the racial origins of the Jews, not with the Semites, whose language they adopted, but ...Hittites of Mesopotamia, whose broad skulls and curved noses they appear to have inherited" (Jew. Enc. X (1905), 284)... Shalowm.
bansadok 1 year ago
@bansadok Umm., according to DNA, which is the only legit biological scientific means of determining ancestry, European Jews are primarily of middle eastern ancestry. According to the National Academy of Science and every other institution that studied it
chained2it 1 year ago
@bansadok Gee, anthropological racist garbage from 100 years ago. How relevant.
How quaint. What's next? Nazi theories of German racial superiority? Or of black inferiority? The 1905 Jewish Encyclopdia, eh? Bullshit. See if you can find a single copy of any Jewish Encyclopedia that actually says any such thing. It says nothing about any skull measurements anywhere. You are quoting an internet fraud. You dont have a copy from 1905, liar
chained2it 1 year ago
Look at that SCHNAZ ! Chicks probably loved it
TheOriginalemoticon 2 years ago
Propaganda. I'm just suppose your word of this, because wikipedia says so. This is not proof.
42playaz 2 years ago
Propaganda my ass. This bust has been around for many centuries. Wikipedia did not invent it. Try looking it up instead of foolishly accusing people of "propaganda". This is common knowledge
chained2it 2 years ago
@chained2it the phrase "Common knowledge" is often used by arrogant people who think that because something is accepted by themselves or their little circle as a fact, that that information is undisputed and indisputable. They go so far in assuming that once its on the internet, Wikipedia, et.c then it must be true! My friend the fact that you are shouting that it's common knowledge proves that it isn't common knowledge . Peace.
bansadok 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bansadok "My friend the fact that you are shouting that it's common knowledge proves that it isn't common knowledge ."
No, it proves that some people are uncommonly ill-informed. Other than that, yout r post ins pretty meaningless and irrelevant to anything I said. I deal with facts
chained2it 1 year ago
@bansadok "They go so far in assuming that once its on the internet, Wikipedia, '
No, perhaps YOU think the internet is an actual source for info, but it only refers to OTHER sources
chained2it 1 year ago
cleary not black for all you black hebrew israelites
juanamary999 2 years ago
@juanamary999 Seems that we are listened to, we make impressions and we set a standard. Thanks for the confirmation. May YAH help us to raise our standard higher as the Yaphetim-Jews and the rest of the goyim look on. Shalowm Alaikhem.
bansadok 1 year ago