Added: 1 year ago
From: hayleyli2007
Views: 24,674
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (110)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I have to admit she is good but that song is not to be sung like that >:(

  • @MrNyallator agreed

  • Cher Went Through Because She's A Copy Of Cheryl!

    Rebecca & Katie Deserved Their Places!

    Keri & Katie Smith Should Have Got In Instead Of Cher And Treyc...

    My Opinion Here

  • Love this version of the song.

  • GREEN DAY :')

  • Dont mess with Green Day and not that song, it sounds good but why change the song..

  • THUMBS UP FOR GREEN DAY!

  • it's Wake Me Up When September Ends, not Wake Me Up...

  • Hope she comes back next year, although I don't know if I will be watching it. After Trayc was voted out by the judges I didn't see much of it after that.

  • Keri, Rebecca and Gamu should'v gone through and as a wild card act treyc cohen was the only right decision cheryl made however i wouldnt say that cheryl had made a mistake by taking cher through as she was somthing diffrent and unique something that x factor haven't had yet. she represented the younger generation really well! she is someone u would wait 2 c on a saturday night were as gamu, treyc and keri come under the same category!

  • @xXxbimbomomenzxXx tbh Cher wasn't all that special they had people that rapped badly on the show before.

  • @xXxbimbomomenzxXx gamu is a soul singer with a rich full tone who can sing jazz, treyc is an r&b singer who showed she could sing rock and has a great belting voice, keri is also an r&b singer but she's got a very airy soft vocal. i dont think musicly they've got anything in common apart from they can all sing :S

  • I don't get why everyone thinks she should have gone through. She already earns her living by singing!

  • cant beleive this didnt get her through. maybe its not as good as green day and nothing ever will be, but her version was soo nice!

  • Keri and Gammu should have gone through instead of Katie and Cher. The former probably reminded Cheryl of certain toilet attendants

  • Comment removed

  • kerri raquel gamu and treyc cohen shuda been the four girls omg like they were unreal !

  • how this young lady did not get through is a tradgedy, Cheryl cole woudnt know a singer if it slapped her in the face!

  • Cheryl sounded resigned to losing her with her "shes so cute" .. X Factor is turning into a bit of a joke.

  • @AndyBoy2oo7 But more pointedly Will.i.am: stated quite clearly "Shes got it"

    someone as established as him, who's also got oodles of experience behind him says something like that, but X factor doesn't take them - why on earth not? This got lost in all the noise around Gamu, but for me this was the big donger.

  • How on earth did Cheryl reject Keri and put Katie through to the live shows ? Cheryl needs to go ....

  • all the TALENT in the girls categories...and katie nabs a spot?!?!?!

    i've never rooted for anyone to fail but cheryl's decisions are ridiculous.

  • cheryl is a slag and should have her rectum thrusted

  • I Love Keri Arrindell.

    I hope she comes back next year.

  • @TheJEVANS2010 I agree, Keri should have either replaced Katie or Trayc, but preferably Katie. Shame on you Cheryl (& Simon)

  • i prefer the original, but she still rocks :)

  • She was sensational! Man, she should have gone through!

  • Brilliant song...but I prefer the original...Green Day are amazing <3

  • i want to marrie her

  • wth the date this video was added changed from 2nd of oct to the 3rd!

  • Comment removed

  • WHY DID THIS GIRL NO GET THOUGH?? is cheryle deaf?

  • She's fantastic..but the way she act she talks she seems to be a bit cold person.

    anyway she deserved to go through!

  • She was easily the best in judges houses

  • im so gutted she didnt get thru, shame chers face is on the end of this vid

  • shee should havee gotten throuu!! <3

  • Seriously, I still cant get over this audition. Cheryl ompletely f'**ked this up. I think Cher is very talented, but needs another year or two to overcome nerves, whilst Katie is a mistake. Kerri and Gamu shoulda gotten through, but I can see why Cheryl would choose Katie, just cos she's gonna be different, but honestly, her world will come crashing down so fast, itll make her head spin. U can hear the sincerity that kerri just wants to sing, whereas katie wants to do anything for fame!

  • she should be killed in a slow and painful way

  • This was a great performance by Keri, it's unfortunate that they didn't put her through. I really love her version of this song!

  • What a performance! Really surprised Katie got through instead of Keri, Gamu or Traci.

  • JOSH IT ME TREV I COMMENTED THAT YEEEEEEE SHE FUCKING TERRIBLE IF YOU WANT TO GIVE ME HATR MAIL TYHEN REPLY TO GRUNGA69

  • @jollyross i still fucking love potatoes

  • @jollyross me to

  • FAIL!!!!

  • I'm still secretly hoping she is the wildcard :)

  • People who are saying she ruins this song should grow the f**k up!! shes not re-releasing it is she?? shes simply singing a song that she likes!! she has an amazing voice and does the song proud!! she should have clearly gone through......easily the best singer there but x factor is about the people not the singers.

  • @bcfcsotv1000 shes shit and yh she is ruining the song i hope she dies

  • @jarvinator100 OOOO THAT WAS CLEVER!! SOMETHING TELLS ME UR A LITTLE SADDO SITTIN IN YA ROOM HATING EVERYTHING!!! GROW THE FUCK UP!!! 4GET WAKE ME UP WHEN SEPT ENDS.....MORE LIKE WAKE ME UP WHEN U HAVE A CLEVER COMMENT.....DICK

  • @bcfcsotv1000 core your hard aint ya. something tells me youur a pedo cunt. fuck off and die of cancer

  • Please someone tell me's done a full version of this?

    I love her voice. I love her version. I WANT HER TO DO ALL OF THIS SONG.

  • @MySweetWish TOTALLY AGREE

  • @MySweetWish I agree, but unless she comes back on the show and performs that song, then its highly unlikely you'll find a full version of this song. 

  • This is the best version of this song... I can't believe that Cheryl didn't put her and Gamu through, they were by far the best of the girls.

  • @TheUniverseOfDreams DEFINITELY agree with that. I never hear people mention her, just TreyC and Gamu but she I think Gamu and Keri should have got through.

  • @TheUniverseOfDreams no it aint the coon ruined the song

  • She ruins Wake Me Up When September Ends. That song can be sung only by green day

  • How did this girl not get through??? Cheryl has no idea what talent is.

  • She should of chose her instead of cher! but no! she want to make cher into a mini cheryl- i dont know- she made the crap decision...

  • cheryl that dumb dyke looks worried because Keri was great but cheryl already has her mind made up on katie and cher

  • was that a "shes so cute" but ive been told who to put through?

  • How the hell did any of the other girls, especially KATIE make it through over her.

    So fucking shit though, she was worried about a small insignificant vocal inconsistency in her performance, while all the while that dickhead Cheryl not even listening to the performances but judging them on how they look.

  • Keri, Rebecca and Gamu should've gone through. Their final auditions were strong and even if Gamu's was weaker compared to her performance at Boot Camp, she deserved to go through. If Cheryl's talking about judging someone through the whole process, Katie AND Cher haven't been that special and messed up right when it really counted. There were 6 other girls who fought right to the end and it's a shame she didn't choose one of them. Rebecca is the only girl who deserves her place on the live show

  • @RavenofProphecy i think it should've been either keri of cher, rebecca and gamu

  • @RavenofProphecy

    Cher deserved to get through and she did. Did you watch her first audition??

  • Keri and Treyc should be in the finals, not Katie, Cher or cry baby Rebecca!

  • rebecca, keri and gamu should have gone through !

  • @sweetbiatch18 rebecca keri gamu and treyc the real finalistes

  • she definately has talent though !!

  • It's a good cover of a fantastic song. But she shouldn't have changed so much. I love it, though :)

  • @GreenDayKitty13 No, the whole point of a cover IS to change it. You can change it as much as you like as long as it still sounds good, and it sounds fantastic here. I'm sick of people that know nothing about music thinking that covers are supposed to sound the same or similar, it's about making the song YOUR OWN.

  • @sweetbutdaring You evidently know little about music if you think this cover is any good.

  • @sweetbutdaring love how you've copied and pasted the EXACT same message to 2 different people.

    If you're just gonna trol here and do that, you are not worth my time.

    I prefer the Green Day version

    Your opinion is invalid.

  • @GreenDayKitty13 I like you :D The original is definitely better, she mixed it around way too much...I love Green Day <3

  • @Jessmo198 hence the name, mate ;)

  • She just ruined a green day song ¬.¬

  • @YellowSunniesGirl nah, she made it sound pretty :)

  • @YellowSunniesGirl No, the whole point of a cover IS to change it. You can change it as much as you like as long as it still sounds good, and it sounds fantastic here. I'm sick of people that know nothing about music thinking that covers are supposed to sound the same or similar, it's about making the song YOUR OWN.

  • The girls through to live shows should have been: Gamu Nhengu, Treyc Cohen and Keri Arrindell. End of. Cheryl is simply blinded by talent so much greater than her own. End of.

  • keri and gamu both should have gone through, by far the best singers

  • I think Cheryl made 2 BIG mistakes with her Category... She had by far the strongest 8 acts to choose from... 3 main ones better than others.... I think her Choice to put Katie through was a massive mistake... Katie is hopeless at remembering her lyrics.. she is also very out of date.... putting rebbecca through i feel was a mistake too, she is to me another leona lewis.. weve had that... i think it should of beem Gamu, Cher & Keri.....

  • Better Than The Green Day Version.

  • That really killed me a little how she sang WMUWSE.... im open to hearing people sing songs how they like but still that was just kinda annoying to me :/ and I agree @HannahN7, Green Day songs should be sang at least half way correctly.. or make it work on some level.. the small bit that they played sounded more like it was almost mixed with blues, jazz, and/or gosple

  • I prefer this version. It has a lot more emotion to it

  • I can't belive she's not in final 12 :( cheryl made 2 big mistake...she put in final cher who is really sucks and katie who is very stupid and can't remember the lyrics ( it happend to her on 1st audition and now..) i'm sorry simon didn't have these group od girls...he's not tolerant...

  • She's so hot I don't really care if she changed the song!

  • If she didn't get through and the cry babies got through ... then this show is fixed. Which is a shame. Is it a race thing? (I'm white by the way). All the good singers were the black girls, yet they need a couple of white girls in there? Good luck and best wishes Keri.

  • Comment removed

  • What the fuck? Fucking disgrace, I can't believe she was allowed to RUIN such an amazing song. X factor sucks, I think we proved that Christmas 09, it should be taken off TV.

  • @starrgirl94 omg shes aloud to sing a song in her own style, xfactor helps people to make their singing career dreams come true. she didnt ruin the song but i bet you kill it over and over again when you sing it.

  • @LittleMisslovesyou Fuck you, their 'singing career dreams' are only a way to line music fat cats pockets, Green Day and any other rock band should not be touched by this piece of shit they call a tv program.

  • @starrgirl94 She's hardly ruined the song, shes in a singing competition and was told to sing a song, and she did, very well. The whols show is fixed though. Keri Tracey Rebecca and Gamu were the best singers, cher and katie were put through because there cotroversial and will boost figures.

  • @astack21stacky Yeah, so an amazing band like Green Day, who've actually worked for their careers should not have their music ruined on this crap they call a tv program. All I can say is, Victory of Christmas 09.

  • good singer but green day songs arent supposed to get sung like that :l

  • apparently she doesn't get through :( stupid cheryl puts crap cher and katie through instead

  • She has a beautiful voice. Would love to see her go through

  • she's good but Green Day are way better

  • SHE IS THE BEST FEMALE SINGER IN THE BUNCH.

  • I didn't really know much about her on this show till this audition, and like Will.I.Am put it so rightly 'She's got it!'......but I have a bad feeling that she will not go through, and cher and katie (despite I like both of them) ill go through despite theyve choked 3 times between them.

  • I LOVEEEEEEE KERI.

  • She is really good...much better than Cher or Katie!!

    GAMU, Rebecca and TREYC/Keri should be the top 3

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more