Extremely surprised that so many of you watch this video in such an simplistic way. Can’t you see that Eason is already *IN* the water when the video starts? If he ends up dying by suffocation it is because he is already living in the water when the whole narrative starts. The rope is only an agent which REMINDS the protagonist of the fact that he is always surrounded by water, i.e. the rope highlights the ILLUSIONARY peaceful environment around him.
This song has such bad melody... sounds the same like all his other songs. Seems like in Hong Kong, song writers write the lyrics first before they have the music... It's like someone trying to sing out a story he reads somewhere, so the melody has no movement, no up and down, no rhythm....no rhymes... It's just someone humming in an essay while taking a shower with random flat notes.
@mylastread You said "same like all his other songs" - first of all, try 一絲不掛 for the up and down melody.
Besides, the melody need to match with the message and them of the song. This song actually has a melody that is bittersweet, and at the chorus, every sentence, the melody starts from up to down, so it feels like falling into this 無人之境
Every song has a different style - if you don't like this style, go listen to some other songs.
@KalvinC8 U said, "the melody has to match the song"... Usually, talented musicians creates a good melody with great notes first, then the talented song writers find words to fit in the melody to rhyme with it. For this guy's song, it sounds like someone wrote an essay first, then hums it out not caring about the "musical notes and the harmony of the notes"......I just found 緣份 from my dead father's old CD. Was told to toss his CDs away, but 好唔捨得 after listening. Now, this is a "song"
以前以為無人之境係講搞GAY==
ivan52908723 5 days ago
呢首歌2年啦......光陰似箭......
071408aog 1 week ago
月亮總不肯照亮情慾深處那道背影 ...
dominiclok 1 week ago
co1203 2 weeks ago 3
我想你知道,我是多麼的想在人群裡跟你牽一下手,多麼的想在節日裡和你一起分享喜悅,多麼想跟父母說我找到了喜歡的人,然而事實諷刺的告訴我:你沒有這種命。
也許這就是第三者的命。
wkchan27 2 weeks ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
絕症 = 椰菜花? 我笑了 = ="
loyu2007 2 weeks ago
'無人之境'比我感覺中心係:無視其他人,只理會自己感受既一首自私既歌, 我反而覺得係講緊鐘意左一個有夫之婦,未必自己有另一半因為我聽呢首野個時鐘意左個女仔但係佢同佢男朋友拍左2年拖, 個feel係match到過份,離晒譜 我知我有罪,不過,唉...係我抵死
bbgdtop 2 weeks ago in playlist eason 3
@bbgdtop 你同一模一樣...
mklong135 3 days ago
61個人因為係女朋友面前播 "無人之境 "之後比人以為偷食
ivan52908723 3 weeks ago 5
浪漫到一起惹絕症<生aids?
ben1120720867317 3 weeks ago in playlist HEI's Song
黃偉文昨日接受電台訪問,爆出當年為陳奕迅(Eason)填詞的《無人之境》以婚外情為題,原先是Eason和謝安琪(Kay)分別唱出男女版本,據聞Kay已錄起,但因當時兩人的緋聞太敏感,最終Kay版本未出街已「銷毀」。
viviennelam 3 weeks ago 8
@viviennelam sosad
philip233096 2 weeks ago
係咪講緊佢同KAY ^_^
amykawasuberi 3 weeks ago
明明就無個種經歷 個種感覺
但係好中意首歌:)
s100160 3 weeks ago 4
不是...
這首歌是在講有家庭的男人到外面偷情
明知最後下場會很慘卻硬要去做
最後越陷越深無法自拔,陷入無盡的深淵之中
"浪漫到一起惹絕症"就是愛到無藥可救的意思
adolfodin 3 weeks ago 9
浪漫到一起惹絕症
絕症 = 椰菜花?
tmstaffleslie 3 weeks ago 11
2:42-3:27 閉了45秒氣
a25885200 4 weeks ago
我剛才聽到伊斯頓春。這是他的歌曲,我聽到的第一個。我是如此sppechless,即使我不明白他在說什麼。什麼的人才和語音。
HanseTInsane 1 month ago
我一路睇個MV一路閉氣...
fanofhouston 1 month ago 37
@fanofhouston 咁希望你可以以eason黎做目標 慢慢閉氣閉夠4分鐘,....
poopoo2313 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我好想潛落水底唱這首歌等她明白我有多辛苦
fenglouis 1 month ago
Comment removed
fenglouis 1 month ago
Nicely expressed by Eason....Well written lyrics as well. Really like this song.....One of my favorites.
jeancheng11 2 months ago
聽這首歌會哭.....想起跟你一起的日子
曾經是你和我一起用過的聆聲
在你車常常播的歌
至今已經一年...你已經又跟別人在一起
但我還很想你....維維
hahabubi 2 months ago 9
想當年,首歌很玩野!全世界都以為E神玩人妻!突然有這首有意之作.
現在回想,痴線!
tak820 2 months ago 11
@tak820 當年出呢首歌時,因為eason正同kay傳緋聞,所以咪比d傳媒借呢首歌炒作囉,
其實都係一首歌黎姐..而家諗番冇必要同緋聞扯上關係....
071408aog 2 months ago 7
首歌係09年,話禁快2年了....
071408aog 2 months ago 16
@071408aog 時間的確過得好快
Ronaldscl 3 weeks ago
0:55(!@,@!)
adrianbb123 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2011年11月6日(星期日) 區議會選舉 投票日
早上七時三十分至晚上十時三十分一齊投票
香港七百萬人一齊支持 社民連 人民力量
大家記住投比 社民連 人民力量 公民黨的區議員
一人一票踢走民建聯 新民黨 自由黨 工聯會
大家一定要投以下候選人
代號 E05 選區名稱 富榮
大家請投 候選人編號 1 候選人姓名 楊繼昌
bigedisonchan 3 months ago
Can someone tell me roughly what does the lyric mean? Much appreciated :)
MissyyMe 3 months ago
@MissyyMe Justifying himself having an affair
wukuanlin 2 months ago
@wukuanlin Owww alright. Thanks!
MissyyMe 2 months ago
首歌唔一定系講緊男偷食,女都會呢
samuelhkleung 3 months ago in playlist samuelhkleung's favorites 12
好似快左D嚄,慢D好
kinglhk 3 months ago in playlist 中文金曲
係咪真係系水入面拍??????
tommy200401 3 months ago
@tommy200401 佢拍呢個MV一定拍得好辛苦
rachelmanman 2 months ago
好歌
YFHuan 3 months ago
黃偉文D詞愈黎愈好~~~~比起以前真係進步左好多
chy3167 3 months ago 5
月亮總不肯照亮情慾深處那道背影
dominiclok 4 months ago
2:11-2:26 one take+singing...I'll be 窒息 hahah good job Eason
2:42-3:29 HOLY!!!窒息
debrabra 4 months ago 2
Comment removed
debrabra 4 months ago
千萬唔好響女朋友或老婆面前好認真唱呢首歌.............
ABARHAMFONG 4 months ago 360
之前去唱k,跟著有個人好大聲話無人之囧- -''
MattewMa1996 5 months ago
呢個mv係叫人做愛要帶condom
否則浪漫到一起惹絕症
suipanw 5 months ago 3
@suipanw
可能講鐘意了一位妓女,因為太浪漫了做愛時明知危險都唔用套,搞到賴左野個種心情
ipspacific1 4 months ago 118
@ipspacific1
利害. 咁都比你估到. 中....
georgeckf 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ipspacific1
利害. 咁都比你估到. 中....
georgeckf 4 months ago
@ipspacific1 sosad
IvanIFW 1 month ago
@ipspacific1 笑了..
aHin12345 1 month ago
Comment removed
chyin520xd 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
只是想留一個msg.
樂
我還愛您,我很想您
婷
SSSUKI0305 5 months ago
又一首好歌!!
9759carls 5 months ago
有50人聽吾到....
ptshing 6 months ago 4
好想佢post 製作過程><
joanneyoyo 6 months ago 3
和玉蝴蝶一樣??
kaki1129flourish 6 months ago 2
傻子多
yaoer187 6 months ago
= =佢忍到咁耐嘅...
m0nchitung 6 months ago 13
千萬不要因一時的快樂而去背叛自己的愛人
因為到時候一定一定會後悔
我失去了最愛的人...現在我後悔了...
kacy1209 6 months ago 17
我正經歷這種..完全感受到這種痛苦
聽Eason的演繹,不禁哭了
roy061172 6 months ago 12
我聽e首歌會喊-.-
Orz1205 7 months ago 4
第一次睇..唔錯
kAiO0xD 7 months ago
如若早三五年相見 何來內心交戰
真心體會到了..
kcikctwwy 7 months ago 10
@kcikctwwy
這句話也讓我很深的感觸體會~
wang2zerozero 6 months ago
1:45 subliminal message of converse shoes
litomonkie15 7 months ago 9
@litomonkie15
Wow u got fast eyes.
chochunkit 6 months ago
这个世界最坏罪名 叫最易动情~
但我喜欢这罪名~~赞!!
teyboonqin 8 months ago 8
其實個Mv點拍咖?_?
wanlok0519 8 months ago
@wanlok0519 好似真係喺d水入面拍
rmanchan95 8 months ago in playlist music
@wanlok0519 真的在水中拍的
sugarbrosis 7 months ago 5
wong wei man's lyrics are always awesome like this
hazzaurora 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
謝安琪加陳奕迅
真係天作之合
我指唱歌
唉 有時真係要講Time
waiwai6b 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
謝安琪加陳奕迅
真係天作之合
我指唱歌
唉 有時真係要講Time
waiwai6b 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我想你知道,我是多麼的想在人群裡跟你牽一下手,多麼的想在節日裡和你一起分享喜悅,多麼想跟父母說我找到了喜歡的人,然而事實諷刺的告訴我:你沒有這種命。
wkchan27 8 months ago
Extremely surprised that so many of you watch this video in such an simplistic way. Can’t you see that Eason is already *IN* the water when the video starts? If he ends up dying by suffocation it is because he is already living in the water when the whole narrative starts. The rope is only an agent which REMINDS the protagonist of the fact that he is always surrounded by water, i.e. the rope highlights the ILLUSIONARY peaceful environment around him.
FabulousCatgirl 8 months ago 2
絕症-憂鬱症
teddy3do 8 months ago
這歌所說的是地下情吧...
eason 唱得好有感情^^
希望佢無經歷過啦.....
kongkong1023 9 months ago 3
@kongkong1023 我相信他沒有!!!!
s777991a 8 months ago
拿影帝
mr0tw 9 months ago
Comment removed
TANK000228 9 months ago
看似進入無人境,其實只是一個更大的牢獄
PhantomRian 9 months ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
謝安琪
CharmlessMan7 9 months ago
每一種愛情~
都可能陷入無人之境
u220206535 9 months ago 10
我很懷疑什麼時候我跟你才會承認這一切,到底要騙全世界到什麼時候...
katrinaccc 9 months ago
在水裡要怎麼唱歌啊?
706815903 9 months ago
@706815903 對嘴而已
YKYmonster 9 months ago 2
eason在水唱歌很好笑...哈哈
infernoman11 10 months ago
歌播完對她的愛未完
fenglouis 10 months ago 31
情不自禁地愛上他的歌.....
a8920467 10 months ago 6
熱與冰的交集,直至今日我才知道這首歌到底唱的是什麼。
musicboy123451 10 months ago 7
不要過份放大愛情帶來的傷感,不要過份放大愛情帶來的憧憬.
ahd0n 11 months ago 29
唔係講笑...我第一次留言係Eason呢度....真係好歌..唱的人好.唱的好聽.一個字:good
a71595939 11 months ago 6
突然想聽反呢首歌...可惜點解呢個mv要賣廣告呢....
jacky2367 11 months ago 4
我的心,都停了
wsad8866 11 months ago 5
多情的人,結局永遠都是獨自一個享受如窒息般的苦楚
nkfswan 11 months ago 57
睇埋個mv會覺得好驚
gbavbaxd 1 year ago 2
為何 不想說明只想反應..
beytang3 1 year ago
@beytang3
講出尼,會比天下人鄙視
lwy1314 11 months ago
@beytang3
成首歌就係唔明依句~
alexs1219 8 months ago
@beytang3 對錯講唔清,不如向自己的感覺/囡囡有所反應
lomanchun 8 months ago
係一段不被世間所接納既愛情...可唔可以係同性戀???
lastkiss321 1 year ago
@lastkiss321
我覺得唔太得
lwy1314 11 months ago
佢應該係有條輸氣管係佢d衫到黎呼吸 我之前睇解開魔法陣佢都係用輸氣管係水中呼吸1,2個鐘(唔係好記得水中呼吸幾奈,仲之好奈) 佢哩個係MV 拍哩d野更加easy,but,哩個MV拍得好好=]
iamlysbabyxd 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
fenglouis 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@iamlysbabyxd
= = 比你知道點拍又點 呢個mv係比我地欣賞,比d身同感受ga人聆聽 吾係比你研究點拍 ok??吾好牛頭不塔馬嘴
fenglouis 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@iamlysbabyxd
比你知道點拍又點 呢個mv係比我地欣賞,比d身同感受ga人聆聽 吾係比你研究點拍 ok??吾好牛頭不塔馬嘴
fenglouis 11 months ago
唔知點解睇住呢個MV好難透氣:(
avahsu 1 year ago 15
the more u listen, the more emotion u put in
ragnurak 1 year ago 4
第一次只留意表面,
第二次再聽我哭了
ZaKu573 1 year ago 10
個mv點拍嫁.....
chapmanccm 1 year ago 6
不自覺地閉氣了.~
kamkamkam2006 1 year ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
謝安琪
Walker9527 1 year ago 4
波兒???
conlubaaron 1 year ago 8
如果以3D拍攝,睇個陣真係要自備氧氣筒
jeffery13355 1 year ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
This song has such bad melody... sounds the same like all his other songs. Seems like in Hong Kong, song writers write the lyrics first before they have the music... It's like someone trying to sing out a story he reads somewhere, so the melody has no movement, no up and down, no rhythm....no rhymes... It's just someone humming in an essay while taking a shower with random flat notes.
mylastread 1 year ago
@mylastread You said "same like all his other songs" - first of all, try 一絲不掛 for the up and down melody.
Besides, the melody need to match with the message and them of the song. This song actually has a melody that is bittersweet, and at the chorus, every sentence, the melody starts from up to down, so it feels like falling into this 無人之境
Every song has a different style - if you don't like this style, go listen to some other songs.
KalvinC8 1 year ago
@KalvinC8 U said, "the melody has to match the song"... Usually, talented musicians creates a good melody with great notes first, then the talented song writers find words to fit in the melody to rhyme with it. For this guy's song, it sounds like someone wrote an essay first, then hums it out not caring about the "musical notes and the harmony of the notes"......I just found 緣份 from my dead father's old CD. Was told to toss his CDs away, but 好唔捨得 after listening. Now, this is a "song"
mylastread 1 year ago
我好想知佢點拍呢個MV
raylichun 1 year ago 9
3首最中意就係呢首~可惜view count最少就係呢首
primadonna717 1 year ago 11
i wonder how much it cost to make his MVs
lung1019 1 year ago
淒美.....
iammimamami 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
好聽咩- -
gloria1649 1 year ago
@gloria1649 唔好聽咩???
tommak1997 9 months ago
我心動.....我心痛....
iammimamami 1 year ago 3
可惜的是,我們相遇恨晚~ 為什麼 為什麼總是這樣....道德與情感的決擇....若有一個無人之境給我們 多幸福.
YIPLUIKEN 1 year ago 5
0:05 - 0:58 沿着繩索到無人之境、亨受着自由自在
0:59 - 1:15 愈來愈不安、不自在、開始害怕‧‧‧
1:16 - 1:39 想回頭的時候發現、繩索已經斷掉
1:40 - 3:30 驚慌、恐懼、尋找出路、後悔‧‧‧最後永遠陷入這【無人之境】
不要因一時的快樂而去愉情,泥足深陷的時間便不能回頭!
rtnwp21 1 year ago 1318
@rtnwp21 講得好
king19940621 6 months ago
@king19940621
多謝 ;)
但其實我評得不夠深入,只怪當時少不更事.
現在評得太深入,又沒有多少人明白我的意思.
罷了,淺淺的描寫在可以的了.
rtnwp21 6 months ago 2
@rtnwp21 再都能打錯是能有多深
BlakeYu 5 months ago
@rtnwp21 你唔講我都唔知,氬係右真係wo
samsonpau 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rtnwp21 你唔講我都唔知,但右係真係wo
samsonpau 5 months ago
@rtnwp21 how many votes!!!
amanogawamakoto 4 months ago
Comment removed
jayfong513 3 months ago
@jayfong513 你捉摸不著他的意思?嘗試深究了解歌詞意思。
lose1000 3 months ago 3
@lose1000 有個男人偷食以為好易就甩到身點知一去冇回頭???
jayfong513 3 months ago
這愛情無人証,這愛情無人性..
loveuwai916 1 year ago
越聽越耐聽!依家反而鍾意呢首多過陀飛輪、一絲不掛!
tim122 1 year ago 15
This has been flagged as spam show
請加入facebook群組 [[ 罷看2010年十大勁歌金曲頒獎典禮,支持四大唱片公司,反無綫壟斷,反英皇任何壟斷行為!!!! ]]
請支持公平音樂競爭!!!
pu1878 1 year ago 2
我看着MV裏面的Eason 看了好久好久 只是覺得這樣在水裏漂浮的感覺很夢幻
到整個MV完了之後 才突然驚覺 這樣美好的夢幻 原來背後有這麽沉重的窒息感
這個 也是這首歌的message之一吧
HildaPossible 1 year ago 470
好痛.....麻木了
stupidbear220 1 year ago
醉生夢死的想像 卻換來心遊無人之境
YikShun1 1 year ago 10
多麼想跟你散步橋上把臂看著風景
月亮總不肯照亮情慾深處那道背影
《斷章》卞之琳
你站在橋上看風景
看風景人在樓上看你
明月裝飾了你的窗子
你裝飾了別人的夢
siuyu1992 1 year ago 27
為什麼會有38個人不喜歡這首歌??這38個人是低能兒嗎??沒有眼光, 可憐的38個人...
stevenD114 1 year ago 6
@stevenD114 不用攻擊別人吧
kevin10600 1 year ago
Comment removed
stevenD114 1 year ago
男人幸福就會身痕
ivaaaaaan 1 year ago 14
@ivaaaaaan 唔止男人 女人都會
tiffanybaby1124 7 months ago 5
Comment removed
ivaaaaaan 1 year ago
好想說謊 不眨眼睛 似進入無人境
happynga103 1 year ago
這不是無人境 因為有你在
你就是世界
是我靈魂的牽引者 是我身心的詮釋
若夢不老,若傷不痛
那你便,
化光化幻,成為世界
無處,不在。
k8ongj 1 year ago 11
真的很感動!
daniel2937 1 year ago
Comment removed
daniel2937 1 year ago
like! less than 3
TheHeatstroker 1 year ago
like!
TheHeatstroker 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1,002,584
觀看次數 又一100萬既eason歌
1001997 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
1001997 1 year ago
聽日上黎一定過 1 Million!!
HKasian 1 year ago
還差6000!!!!
harry1995915 1 year ago
100萬點擊!!!!!
harry1995915 1 year ago
被兩种情感撕裂
一邊是決定白頭的人 一邊是控制感官情緒的人
矛盾地兩個都想要 兩個都想保護
殊不知 忘了保護自己
玩火的可是自己啊
他和她 我和他 他和我
我們還是我們 他們還是他們
不在意了 他是否真的愛過
也許 真的 出現得太晚了吧
otakupear 1 year ago 9
控制感官情緒的人,為什麼不能是決定白頭的人?
誰規定這個?
人最重要不是對別人負責,而是對自己負責. 後才能對別人負則
tungcheuk000 8 months ago 4
我想你知道,我是多麼的想在人群裡跟你牽一下手,多麼的想在節日裡和你一起分享喜悅,多麼想跟父母說我找到了喜歡的人,然而事實諷刺的告訴我:你沒有這種命。
wkchan27 1 year ago 8
陳奕迅不只道出了歌聲,更唱出了靈魂。
Akonsky 1 year ago 10
Good work by Eric Kwok!
discovery2168 1 year ago
SAD SONG
fuckpretty 1 year ago
good song
kellyktman 1 year ago
真係落水拍GA? EASON唔好凍親!
mg1228 1 year ago
@mg1228
係903聽過佢個訪問...應該真係落水拍
bedonken 1 year ago
Eason好似戴左假發咁XD
hoiching031 1 year ago
人是犯賤的,失去時想擁有,擁有時想更好,更好時想再好,結果惡性循環,最後一事無成
jeffery13355 1 year ago 4
佢係巨肺E神
bigham166 1 year ago 4
隻鞋有咩意思...... @@
siuching97 1 year ago
Comment removed
siuping1 1 year ago
@siuching97
哈哈~賣廣告
點解水裹會着鞋@@
siuping1 1 year ago
這種愛含蓄但美麗,誰試過便會了解。
wkchan27 1 year ago 12
唱個時記住抖氣要自然
wenjilu 1 year ago
2:42 -