Alternate 'You Never Give Me Your Money' Beatles

[supercat1997]

am i a good children? :D

[Codename1000]

Who's the girl at 0:37 ?

[Thompsonjd3]

@Codename1000 I think it's Mary Hopkin. Paul wrote Goodbye for her.



[LovePeaceLennon22]

holy shit why cant i listen to a song without seeing a PID comment not to mention names but DCAreaguy2001

[LovePeaceLennon22]

1:17 and 3:41 holy shit two very attractive boys its a shame john didnt like those glasses because they sure do look good and ive always thought george was cute but oh my

[drummingjohn4u]

I like this rough mix. It also has a rocking ending too. Some people think it's At the Hop.  It's just a 12 bar coda, that's all!

[Matticus1231234141]

this has got to be my favorite Beatles song ever, truly, ONE SWEET DREAM

[PERROORION19]

kkloihjkmkhmmjm8hjjhifhnnutoyo­ommnpyoukhuhjhhjigjjijhnuhjnjb­hbhiughjnjnjbkjnmnnnnnnnnnkjnj­jkjkmkkjgkkmnmnbbbnnligjkhjijh­mbnjbkbklvkñkbnnkjbvmbbkbnnbmm­kknb

[pettypablo96]

people follow george harrison an take up Krishna Consciousness chant and be happy hare krishna hare krishna krishna krishna hare hare hare rama hare rama hare hare (pronounced ha ray )

[reg5381]

lennon doing a rare solo.

[SpineRipper619]

why didn't paul's vocals sound as good on this as the actual recording?

3:05-3:11 shits over the original

[princeofthemods69]

@SpineRipper619 It's in there on the album take, its just pulled back and faded out.

[DCAreaguy2001]

faul mccartney, talking about his sad life as a policeman in canada before getting the call

[gixo92]

The Beatles were and still are the greatest band in the whole world....I love this version

[DiegoRyu12]

One sweet dream... picks up the bag and get in the limousin.

MY FAV SONG OF PAUL.

[heydigabs]

after hey jude this is my fav song is so amazing... gee i love you paul you're the perfect man!!

[HoosInDaHowse]

00:43 - Paul looks like he's inhaling his cigarette! ;). ♥ YOU PAUL! :D

[1q6z]

this fookin rocks !!!!!!!!!

[Amywowow]

love it!

[chenlung1]

Paul's vocal is different too it seems.

[brigiuigi]

wow

[rangerdjim115]

its a lil different not the same with a longer ending and god its the beatles why dfoes every video have an argument when what they stood for was peace and love let it go kindly explain not argue if anything just debate no hate

[PaBasser]

A great song done by my favorite Beatle.

[jarredgamarra28]

1234567 All good children go to heaven

[caesarcerf]

reskub10 - i was your momma's thousandth customer on that street corner.

[caesarcerf]

i CAN beatlesfan6270, the long 'different' ending you refer to is just edited off. this is EXACTLY the same version of the multitrack and as such, gives you some insight into how mixing works. (i'm a professional.)

[reksub10]

yeah i heard that you stand around on street corners lol

[BeatlesFan6270]

LEGO Abbey Road - :D

[caesarcerf]

i don't think this is an alternate version i think this is just what is called the 'multitrack,' with some of the sliders on some of the (mixer) tracks pulled all the way down. What is revealed? Well, for one, how well Paul sings, that's for sure!

[BeatlesFan6270]

you can't say this is the same version as the final, the ending is completely different and very extended.

[caesarcerf]

no, george wasn't sure if it was he OR JOHN, on bass. he said so on the anthology. those who think John incapable - there's a GREAT, complicated line here on youtube on some tune or another.

[zanderness]

where can you find this version id love to have this on record

[notanomad]

I mean 2:28

[notanomad]

12:28; awsome picture!

[cr818]

I think the bass parts were done on this song and a few others on Abbey Road by George on his fender jazz.

The master tapes show the bass parts played with take one (piano/vocal) of the take.  Paul played and sang the song on piano-no bass.

[russelljdj]

The Picture of them on the steps was taken by Linda who called it the 4 strangers pix.

[idieinelevators]

5:30 Paul is REALLY tall!

[Bass69Line]

george's lead in the 2 last minutes is a pleasure. he's not dead since we hear him play! :)

[BadderThanHaley]

haha ringo, that's a hate crime.

[sonofmusic]

hey geniuses -- all the bass work on this album was done last, which Paul began doing on the Pepper sessions. This is simply the original rhythm track, no backing vocals, percussion or bass. Apparently only Paul on piano, George on guitar (sometimes with the most bassy tone), and Ringo, all of who's parts are exactly the same as in the final mix (which fades into vocals only at around 3:40).

[trev820]

I Will Eat You!

[smedly500]

nowhere near as good as the real one.

[skyprop]

No Echo on Paul's vocal as to the albums version here it is dry. No Lead Guitar either. Among other things.

[weepingforbrunnhilde]

Instrumental track sounds identical. Middle eight vocal sounds identical.

Ok, and middle eight arrangement is different too.

I like Paul's "Ohhhhhhhh" during the middle eight.

Bass seems less dominant on this version. The final version's bassline, btw, is one of my favorites. Paul at his best.

Thanks for posting this!

[sailtheseaofcheese]

ahhh

theres just a different bass line

original version way better

[jonathanlucas99]

Where is this from?

[Rooftop112]

at 1:11 John looks like Hank Marvin of The Shadows

[RobEye79]

Who is the hot broad with Paul at :31? It's not Jane or Linda. anyone know?

[makko54]

Mary Hopkin

[RobEye79]

ooooh ok thanks.

[GABY712171993]

idk but shes hot =3

[andantinowithaswager]

they should have put this version on the record. it sounds so much like the one they did except for the end.

[RonMorganMusic]

One of the greatest Beatle outtakes I've heard! Thanks!

[ghjfyfytcf]

i'm not sure it's fair to credit the song as "Paul Mccartney's 'You Never Give Me Your Money'" as parts of it were definitely written and sung by john. but thanks for uploading :D

[Tyronethe23rd]

Yeah, it's the Beatles' song, but what an amazing track!

[ghjfyfytcf]

actually, i think i might be wrong :P

sorry

but still, their songs were credited lennon/mccartney for a reason^^

[GerryMATW]

ghjfyfytcf-

The reason is quite simply that John and Paul agreed from the beginning that all their songs would be credited to Lennon & McCartney, regardless of who wrote what.

(Even "Give Peace A Chance" is credited Lennon-McCartney, despite the fact that Paul was in a different continent when John wrote it.)

"You Never Give Me Your Money" is Paul's song from start to end.

[WhoKilledCallo]

nope wrong, the songs started as being accredited to McCartney-Lennon

[manatthewindow]

WhoKilledCallo-

True enough, but the point I'm making is that they both took the writing credit together, even if one of them made little or no contribution to the composition.

[nkpatriots17]

paulllllllll

[danilobecchia]

Dopo i Beatles il DILUVIO!!!!

[doowop909]

great vocals

[maryywallace]

where's this from?

[maryywallace]

nevermind; i just realized i have this

[oompakang726]

George's guitar on this is awesome!

[forastero4ever]

pinhead at 02:52!!

[abbeyroad88]

great

[abbeyroad88]

great

[Norty840]

Awesome, awesome, awesome. This might better than the original. Thanks for posting it.

[niallvan]

cool man.

i love this song.

:)