i hate fake vid find something betta to do dont be actors wen u grow up and if you gona fake fight like i did at least fight like it 4 real my vid is shayla vs. laton
this look lame when you just look at the picture on the screen. i would have just put a picture of the fight goin on but wat ever i am goin to watch it anyway because i am bored so just lets see wat happen if it is lame i am goin to change if it is just talk
omg u slappin this girl plz girl i would punch the comb out yo big fat head girl plz u think its gonna be trouble but this girl look like she would punch the comb out yo head and slap u like wtf and also dont put this dumb crap on youtube cuz its so dumb like girl plz u would be on that good flo
and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay. :****
im not trying to rode or nothin vut this fight look real fake because y would u let somebody in tur house that u dont like and then the fight was like 4 min and if u want to make it look real do it out side because y would u do in yur house its making it look mad fake and would not do u feel and if have to say something jst say it im not scared
┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┫copy And paste ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓if this loser ┗━━┳━┳━━┛ ┃ ┃wasted your time
━━━━┃ ┃ ┗━┳┳━Of your life.. and that your much cooler than him... oh and that he should stop having sex with his mom... its bad for him, motherfucker .
What cracks me up are dumb fucking losers who don't put their pics on their profiles,look up videos of other races and calls them names.........wow lot of balls there.
u must read this. once u have started there is no turning back. a little 10 year old girl was raped and murderded in 1945. her body was not found until 1947. then a boy last week read this and did not copy and paste this message. the dead girl appeared in his room haunting him and killed him. if you do not copy and paste this onto 10 vidoes in 30 minutes the dead girl will apear in your room tonight and haunt you and kill you. well you
waz diz real..it looked real but den it looked kinda fake..it waz funni tho..kinda sorta..she waz lyk smak me smak me n she got slapped but den got madd lol
wtf i think this goes out to everybody cus ya all did it does it matter if itsrealor fake and everybody talkin bout this fake shit u bitches wasted my time like?? they didnt make u watch it and the youtube beef no disrespect but daTS cHildish as fuck k??? and the racism?? childish annywaysss look on thebright side WE ALL KNOW WE BLACK GRLS LOOK WAY BETTER THAN SOME OR MOST OF U WHITE WHORES K?? MAYBE IF U DIDNT GIVE IT UP SO FAST WE WOULDNTCALL U THAT DUMBASS AND IM SURE WE ALL AGREE
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Nigger means 'ignorant,' and that's why it was applied to black individuals in the first place; rednecks thought black people were unusually ignorant, and they may or may not have been right.
okay so why does it matter that their black? who cares...dont call them niggas or any of that shit! yeah guess what im white! and i have a ton of besties that are black and i hate it when ppl give them shit!
I don't call black people niggers. I call them by their name. The black people around here call each other nigger is like calling each other friend, buddy, partner, etc. For example: " Hey, what's up my nigga!" It all really depends on how you use the word in a sentence. A person can tell if it is racial or friendly. If a white man calls a black person a nigger out of anger he should sincerely apologize or get his ass kicked.
Yaa,,,but that nigga word influence crackpots in such a way that they think it's cool to use to it..I think it's good for all to stop using this word..is nigga the only word to use it as a greatings???
sorry to say this....but niggers calls each other nigger..n y would other non-black ppl hesitate to call blacks nigger...First stop calling ur own black fellas nigger & wait & see the change
naa its just really stupid really cause, if you know what a nigga means why would u wanna say it to yourself cause its a kuss, its just kussing ur self saying ur a white mans slave, if u do it and call each other niggaz thats u , its cool i dnt do stuff like dat, cause iam diffrent sorryx
There's a difference. It's like your family calling you a bitch or someone on the street calling you a bitch. Deep down you know your family loves you, but if a person on the street called you a bitch, how would you feel?
ok first, yes the video is stupid. but your sterotyping a whole race. that makes you stupid. there are alot of AFRICAN AMERICAN women who act like this, but not every female does. who's not to say you dont act the exact same way. it's 2008 and it sad to see that people are stuck in times where we were held down, but now it's time to get over your self. it's pathetic and ridiculous. there are black people doing positive things, but people like you choose to look at the negative... move on
who ever you are maybe it's time you evolve... instead of looking up something positive youre TRYING to find something negative about bl;ack people... but tell me this if the definition of evolving is bringing yourself to the next level... why are you stuck in the ages where it was OK to call blacks out of their name? but just like there will be videos that leave a bad impression of blacks, there will be comments left that make bad impressions on you... like this one... so think about it
wast of time
youngcute99 1 week ago
Lol "Yo hair look good but not You"
Bbbanit 2 months ago
so fake like there hair
JMiles006 2 months ago
get your hair done befor you trying to fight some one and yall cant fight
TRINITYSIDEPIPES 4 months ago
yall look so fuckin stupid this was pointless and waste of your own damn energy
SADiTYthePG 8 months ago
that shit was so lame
makayla12393 8 months ago
man that shit was so lame
makayla12393 8 months ago
Fu@king STUPID
TheA8l 10 months ago
Ohh shit , things are gunna be put in bussiness !
But, i t also seems fake becuz they stopped recording it , and its not to be contuined . (:
tokool4u935 10 months ago
fake
QueenBeaster 10 months ago
0_0 wow video you have o decied if it's fake
memegotbad 11 months ago
i hate fake vid find something betta to do dont be actors wen u grow up and if you gona fake fight like i did at least fight like it 4 real my vid is shayla vs. laton
lilshayshayla10 1 year ago 2
yall ant even fighting than wy yall dident throw puches dum asses we now it fack
katlynnicholetaylor1 1 year ago
this look lame when you just look at the picture on the screen. i would have just put a picture of the fight goin on but wat ever i am goin to watch it anyway because i am bored so just lets see wat happen if it is lame i am goin to change if it is just talk
98honesty 1 year ago
the hoes are about to get jiggy up in the hizzle...
Smperk33 1 year ago
yea right
hto1971 1 year ago
fake shit..lol
tom11zz884 1 year ago
dumazz shit if she slap me i would have stole her and wheres part that how lame this video is jones882007
siaty1 1 year ago
they need 2 stop it cause they anit making nobody laugh not one bit and all of yall can go to ciara ride iand go 2 this video of 2 gay boys
rellbaby96 1 year ago
I think I know who these girls are....o.0
TheLoveableToasty 1 year ago
so lame it didnt even last long stupid video
ZIM175 1 year ago
this was fu**ing gay. stupid ho take this video out and stop wasting peoples time.
chevy2055 1 year ago
A waste OF TIME!!! DAMN FOOLS
MEMYAI09 1 year ago
this sucked but she smacked the taste out her mouth
BaconTerd 1 year ago
lame ass bitchez smfh
MrDannyandmelinda 1 year ago
omg u slappin this girl plz girl i would punch the comb out yo big fat head girl plz u think its gonna be trouble but this girl look like she would punch the comb out yo head and slap u like wtf and also dont put this dumb crap on youtube cuz its so dumb like girl plz u would be on that good flo
bubblebeats1919 1 year ago
ur stupid retards
prox8318 1 year ago
Lame sluts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Schon05 1 year ago
BOOOOOOOOOOO YALL VIDEO CORNY
dimesr410s 2 years ago
lol, hahahahah. NOT. totally Fake. But cool.
beautifulchic90 2 years ago
The Best Girl Fight Ever
Dipset5051 2 years ago
why the fuck didnt you fuckiin finish!
superstargyrl 2 years ago
dis look so fake
mrsfashionme101 2 years ago
"yo hair look good, but not you". lol!
loblg88 2 years ago
so totally fake
cmoney97go 2 years ago
Because you all act like wild ape's in africa
terrasi11 2 years ago
ha ha ha black people are so funny to watch
terrasi11 2 years ago
wats dat supposed 2 mean
babygyrlondeck08 2 years ago
Hahaha! Guess whats also funny! Throwing white people in the pool then putting them on a scratch and sniff! Hahaha! What A Smell (:
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
im not white stupid
terrasi11 2 years ago
Color Blind?
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
whatever it was but funny as hell... she said your hair look good but NOT u! lol
JmarieG07 2 years ago
fake and gay.
inOxVidZ 2 years ago
Like Your Dad's Sex Life.
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
youre faker and gayer.
inOxVidZ 2 years ago
Child i'm Not Your Mom, So Say That To Sombody WHo Fits That Description.
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
people who talks about moms are gay... and also fake.
inOxVidZ 2 years ago
Chic, if Your Ran Outta Things To Say Just Say So instead Of Asking Your Little Brother.
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
gay is the gayest gay fagot of fakeness. kthanxbye.
inOxVidZ 2 years ago
Wow, Get Some New Jokes, Then You Can Leave.
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
i can continue this for as long as you cant. so stop being gay.
inOxVidZ 2 years ago
And Stop Having Lame Combacks, if You Can.
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay, and fake, and gay. :****
inOxVidZ 2 years ago
@inOxVidZ shut up
dajashow 2 years ago
fake
kayaira10 2 years ago
Like Your Personality! :)
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
Arn't We A Little imature Dropout?
Shall We Reverse Back To 3rd Grade?
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
hey stainsofshit.. did ur mamma give you that name? GO SIT DOWN IN THE CORNER AND SHUT THE FUCK UP!
19goodcherry84 2 years ago
Hey Good Cherry, WHo Lied To You ANd Told You, That You Were A Good Fruit? The Funny Part is When He Gets Outta The Corner, You Jump in! Hahahahaha!
Ch33ring4lif3 2 years ago
good acting :)
pulsegang 2 years ago 2
lol
RavenAndHaley 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
just two stinky ass cracked out niggers being fucking retarded what's new? I personally think we should put these apes back in the zoo.
stainsofshit 2 years ago
where's the fight..fake and lame
Splawngirl 2 years ago 3
umm that was real fake did you see the way she slaped her
iiANCE343 2 years ago 3
im not trying to rode or nothin vut this fight look real fake because y would u let somebody in tur house that u dont like and then the fight was like 4 min and if u want to make it look real do it out side because y would u do in yur house its making it look mad fake and would not do u feel and if have to say something jst say it im not scared
jiggamawd 2 years ago
lol
kingelf3 2 years ago
LMAO pinche moyas got no life lol i wonder who the lame ass that video taped this was, LOL
hunnybun600 2 years ago
lame as shit.
BObBYandsjcj 2 years ago 17
This has been flagged as spam show
┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┫copy And paste ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓if this loser ┗━━┳━┳━━┛ ┃ ┃wasted your time
━━━━┃ ┃ ┗━┳┳━Of your life.. and that your much cooler than him... oh and that he should stop having sex with his mom... its bad for him, motherfucker .
Heartless792 2 years ago
F@k3! BUt FuNnY!!!L0l
mickeysgurl95 2 years ago
why is you trying to fight people the girl in the red will mess you up better watch your step
luntmike 2 years ago
haha whaas that panneed?!
buttsnifer9 2 years ago
lol how u start shit in her house lol crack monkey
cccimone 3 years ago 3
lmao u stupid :-() crack monkeys omg hahahaha
dimondgurlable 2 years ago
What cracks me up are dumb fucking losers who don't put their pics on their profiles,look up videos of other races and calls them names.........wow lot of balls there.
hellcat4lyferules 3 years ago 2
fucking monkeys
mikecakamrc 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
srry but i'm just rly scared of ghosts
u must read this. once u have started there is no turning back. a little 10 year old girl was raped and murderded in 1945. her body was not found until 1947. then a boy last week read this and did not copy and paste this message. the dead girl appeared in his room haunting him and killed him. if you do not copy and paste this onto 10 vidoes in 30 minutes the dead girl will apear in your room tonight and haunt you and kill you. well you
IowaHawkeye23 3 years ago
get out of my house lol
maufoi8 3 years ago
Yeah, anyone can make a video and put it on youtube. There is not way to predict if the video is concocted or real.
leroyware 3 years ago
video like these you can tell if they are real or fake
brea23246 2 years ago 22
I think this was fake.
leroyware 3 years ago
U think????
Thelfreshness 3 years ago
so what was the outcome. i wanna see some fuckin puda'sos get thrown.
Fougeddaboudit16 3 years ago 2
i just want to know if they were serious or playing?
kingdomking09 3 years ago 3
There was a Lot of tention in that room
horris2 3 years ago
Mann if dat was real, I wudda killed dat bitch fa slappin me.
alexandria2OO8 3 years ago
IGNIT!
TubeBoober 3 years ago
umm Wherez part 2??
sgba17 3 years ago
that shit look FAKE
TASHANYOUNG 3 years ago
i WiSH dIs cOUlDv3 ByN LoNG3R
Babyphatgirl3 3 years ago
omg stop being racist white people can fight just as good as black people.
asq95a 3 years ago
Don't call out a racist person if you're racist yourself hat's ust plan ignorant and hypocritical.
Murgical 3 years ago
ahhh that ish sucked.
callie00067 3 years ago
waz diz real..it looked real but den it looked kinda fake..it waz funni tho..kinda sorta..she waz lyk smak me smak me n she got slapped but den got madd lol
JaSziB 3 years ago
haha shit black girls look better than white girls. you girls have nasty hair. at least we're cute :)
kkbdjc 3 years ago
I enjoy this video =) it makes me really horny!! z
POTC03 3 years ago
my tits are SO sore right now!!! :( oooouch!! s
XBOXEUROPE 3 years ago
by the way for that one person who took my comment on the end so serious it was a joke so i bet u feel real stupid dumbass
Yasmina10000 3 years ago
wtf i think this goes out to everybody cus ya all did it does it matter if itsrealor fake and everybody talkin bout this fake shit u bitches wasted my time like?? they didnt make u watch it and the youtube beef no disrespect but daTS cHildish as fuck k??? and the racism?? childish annywaysss look on thebright side WE ALL KNOW WE BLACK GRLS LOOK WAY BETTER THAN SOME OR MOST OF U WHITE WHORES K?? MAYBE IF U DIDNT GIVE IT UP SO FAST WE WOULDNTCALL U THAT DUMBASS AND IM SURE WE ALL AGREE
Yasmina10000 3 years ago 2
to people like you I'd like to say WHITE POWER
no, I'm not a racist, but you as a black person discriminating white? you deserve death just as much as some kkk member with many lifes on his ass.
piece
of
shit
Patrickrut 3 years ago
i agree and i giv u a plus =))) for a good comment
LilStew94 3 years ago
┏┫ |||┣┓ ┏┓ fuck you for
┗┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┫ wasting my time ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓ ┗━━━┳━━━┛ ┃
Londontownzy 3 years ago 3
great
Patrickrut 3 years ago
hell yeah thats my $hit
roudfde 3 years ago
that fight was so freakin' fake
angletraining 3 years ago
Dont say
''oh she faught like a white girl''
Shutup wit your racist comments,
white ones
and dark skinned ones too.
Just shut the fuck up.
Cokaxcola 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nigger means 'ignorant,' and that's why it was applied to black individuals in the first place; rednecks thought black people were unusually ignorant, and they may or may not have been right.
djkfhjkd69 3 years ago
fuck u stupid racist
LilStew94 3 years ago
┏┫ |┣┓ ┏┓ fuck you for
┗┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┫ wasting my time ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓ ┗━━━┳━━━┛ ┃ ┃
cocacoxx 3 years ago 2
okay?? that was a fight? are u serious?
steveandericalewis80 3 years ago
dis is a waste of mii tyme ok borin
mizzcutie904 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
┏┫ |┣┓ ┏┓ fuck you for
┗┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┫ wasting my time ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓ ┗━━━┳━━━┛ ┃ ┃
MoNnIeBoOt 3 years ago
boring
hollabac2 3 years ago 2
r they like serious?
luv18wm 3 years ago
┏┫ |┣┓ ┏┓ fuck you for
┗┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┫ wasting my time ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓ ┗━━━┳━━━┛ ┃ ┃
rm204bitches 3 years ago
wtf? SHE slapped YOU ibnYOUR own house. && i'm assuming that's YOUR room.
wtf? & you didn't hit her back automatically either? you handled that like a white woman.
fligrl8 3 years ago
LAMEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
zoegoon7 3 years ago
okay so why does it matter that their black? who cares...dont call them niggas or any of that shit! yeah guess what im white! and i have a ton of besties that are black and i hate it when ppl give them shit!
ditzyness2012 3 years ago 6
SO FUCKING FAKE
tarsha4u 3 years ago
why did u stop taping?
WittyRavenclawPride 3 years ago 2
cus it was fakke and if they wouldve kept goin they would look sytupid cus they had nothin else planned
legendnara 3 years ago
omg it sucks and its fake
arnotjuuuh 3 years ago 3
gay...........
sxygrneyes187 3 years ago
also, dont you love how theres that one person who makes the racial comment and all of youtube goes nuts and we all start arguing..never fails
people dont argue cause they want to, they argue because they were hurt....
i dont know... why dont you just combine both names.... like a criggerrr
lmao...yes im corny
Riixox 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't think blacks should put videos on here it just gives you white people something to say!
xXxdancegurlxXx 3 years ago
fake
rob5592000 3 years ago
I don't call black people niggers. I call them by their name. The black people around here call each other nigger is like calling each other friend, buddy, partner, etc. For example: " Hey, what's up my nigga!" It all really depends on how you use the word in a sentence. A person can tell if it is racial or friendly. If a white man calls a black person a nigger out of anger he should sincerely apologize or get his ass kicked.
asimplekindofman 3 years ago 9
Yaa,,,but that nigga word influence crackpots in such a way that they think it's cool to use to it..I think it's good for all to stop using this word..is nigga the only word to use it as a greatings???
amitpetra 3 years ago 6
I hate people when they act tough like this
KRISTENAM2 3 years ago
FUCK YOU BOTH!!!
aijiatan 3 years ago
Niggers are black.
meowphine 3 years ago
wow your an ass...would you want someone calling your mom a redneck or a cracker..just remember what goes around comes around bitch
dymemamii07 3 years ago
i think crackers a cool word n im white
lilbeatch 3 years ago
well honestly there is nothing cool about that word...
dymemamii07 3 years ago 5
yup...there is nothin cool in insulting word
amitpetra 3 years ago
fucking dumb niggers
unearth229 3 years ago
ther idiots but please can u stop using the word nigga it aint cool , we aint niggers we just black yeah
chied3a 3 years ago
sorry to say this....but niggers calls each other nigger..n y would other non-black ppl hesitate to call blacks nigger...First stop calling ur own black fellas nigger & wait & see the change
amitpetra 3 years ago
naa its just really stupid really cause, if you know what a nigga means why would u wanna say it to yourself cause its a kuss, its just kussing ur self saying ur a white mans slave, if u do it and call each other niggaz thats u , its cool i dnt do stuff like dat, cause iam diffrent sorryx
chied3a 3 years ago
There's a difference. It's like your family calling you a bitch or someone on the street calling you a bitch. Deep down you know your family loves you, but if a person on the street called you a bitch, how would you feel?
imjusthere12 3 years ago
white people gave us that name in the first place, doesnt mean u have the right to call us that tho asses!!
and we complain about white people offending us, so stop using the damn word, shut upp
like really people
Riixox 3 years ago 4
ok first, yes the video is stupid. but your sterotyping a whole race. that makes you stupid. there are alot of AFRICAN AMERICAN women who act like this, but not every female does. who's not to say you dont act the exact same way. it's 2008 and it sad to see that people are stuck in times where we were held down, but now it's time to get over your self. it's pathetic and ridiculous. there are black people doing positive things, but people like you choose to look at the negative... move on
BallaC0018 3 years ago
And I can honestly say I don't hate every black person out there..However, I do hate the majority and the Niggers.
dsendgraff07 3 years ago
plz stop nigga..
punjabiheera 3 years ago
pleez stop putting dumb ass vids on here
LILOSCAR123 3 years ago
this doesnt look real and if it is that was a weak slap.
an the racial slur all up on this vid is pathetic...
00malfunction 3 years ago
itz 2 bad that more than likely half of the white mans race went 2 hell
xXSnowMannXx313 3 years ago
well i ment that to djx2clpu4
cuz thats not rite...
i mean call uz a nigga
that gives a rite to call u a craka.
not tryna be racist or nutin
buh its true.
and if u gon hate on diz video
dont coment it keep it to ya self
cuz dey dnt need yo racist comments
so go fuk yoself.
Randumvideoz 3 years ago
rolf
leafninja05 3 years ago
were da second one i want to see da rest
ihatehim1234 3 years ago
HAHAHAAHAHAHA THATS HILLARIOUS!!!
gamer1245 3 years ago
i guess its the white mans fault they are so stupid too
chw197608 3 years ago
o wow
nickjonaswife15 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
those fucking monkeys need to evolve
dsendgraff07 3 years ago
monkeys ?
really.. explain to me why crackas always refer to black peopel as monkeys
when THEY are the ones with all the hair on ever square inch of them. furry backs, chests , stomachs n shit, lookin all kindsa nasty.
you need to shut the fuck up
mizzdarkNlovely 3 years ago
yo mamma the fucking monkey..burn in hell you bitch
dymemamii07 3 years ago
who ever you are maybe it's time you evolve... instead of looking up something positive youre TRYING to find something negative about bl;ack people... but tell me this if the definition of evolving is bringing yourself to the next level... why are you stuck in the ages where it was OK to call blacks out of their name? but just like there will be videos that leave a bad impression of blacks, there will be comments left that make bad impressions on you... like this one... so think about it
BallaC0018 3 years ago
aye I'm not the only anti-nigger conformist. Did Bush and FEMA really give a shit about Katrina?
dsendgraff07 3 years ago
i agree with ya xxxxxxx
chied3a 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dumb niggers
djx2clpu4 3 years ago
cracka.
Randumvideoz 3 years ago
umm ok. thats kinda pointless
jellybeanfreek44 3 years ago
lol
sultyan 3 years ago
these lil girls are crazy
pier8107 3 years ago
FAKE
rapparid2jsp 3 years ago 5
derrrrrr lol
shortieqz1234 3 years ago
WHERES PART 2?!?!?!?!?
tweetyishawt 3 years ago
WTF??
lovely1chic 3 years ago
Anythng 2 put der damn faces on youtube
bRyAnSgAL4lYfB5 3 years ago 3
AND THE POINT WAS
Bubbles810 4 years ago 3
Jerry! Jerry! Jerry!,, then the fake hair flies, then one turns out to be a dude..and then they have the same crack mother..
sscarzz 4 years ago
is that real
SoljiaGurl12 4 years ago
nopee
shortieqz1234 3 years ago
this was stupid as hell!
987Bb987 4 years ago 2
this is the dumbest shit ive ever seen. since i wont be abl to get my 17 secs back, now im gonna go kill myself
funeral is on friday
scunes 4 years ago