Christina Aguilera - Hurt (Live @ Wetten Dass...?!?)

[charlotteluvshugs]

She is lip syncing, what they do they have a seperate version meant to sound like live, Beyonce does it and so does Celine Dion. Get over it....:/

[x0amra0x]

schöne Stimme schöne Frau :)

[Cukrovypernicek]

<3



[etxhioVEVO]

3:11 FAIL HIGH NOTE <.<

[Charift]

@etxhioVEVO

you're so awesome at complaining ! let me see you make one hit like this one !

i'm a sound engineer and i can see that there are slight skinny notes ! which is normal for a human being " Aguilera " who is reaching like ... 2 octaves of Original Notes and LIke another one in Falsetto ......... GET A LIFE and STOP COMPLAINING you know nothing of Music " theory , Harmony , Diminished , Sus ....etc like she probably knows " SHUT THE Hell UP and enjoy this video ... or dont watch it !

[etxhioVEVO]

@Charift i'm just saying that she doesn't hit the note like she does in studio, because her belting range is not so high

[emmanuel24ist]

Don't like her but must admit her voice is beautiful

[JustMe7976]

My inspiration-3

[natagos76]

OMG she's has amazing great voive!!!!!!!

[lleninhadiaz]

She is amaizing!!!!!!

[OrgyAtMyPlaceNOW]

I guess this isn't a NIN/Johnny Cash cover..?

Damn.

[MissSamira59]

It's live. I listened to the studio version at the same time and it's different. Maybe it's a pre-recorded ? But I don't think so, it's live for me.

[Stallonation]

definitely not lipsyncing I know some parts different from studio version

[superdanilchik]

happy birthday Christina!!!:D

[PoofilyMarshall]

SHE'S NOT LIP SYNCING GUYS!!!!!!!!!!! SHE'S DIFFERENT IN THE RECORDING VERSION!!!!!! IN MY OPINION, SHE'S A BIT BETTER HERE!!!! THIS IS SO FUCKIN' E+P+I+C!!! GOOSEBUMPS!!!

[marysamichannel]

:Dlike if you just skipped to her singing cause you dont understand a word of what they were saying :D cuz izzz did

:D

[21JaBbAwOcKeEz21]

I'm no expert... But this is Live. lol. How i know? Cause I KNOW she doesn't have to lip sync to sing this good.

[hsg2012]

@21JaBbAwOcKeEz21 everyone lip syncs honey...

[ablackguy123456789]

i never understood why she dodged the E5. it's not even sustained. but great performance nonetheless <3 <3

[yluj0407]

Ya she is lip syncing. That’s why she is worth millions and you are worth ??? Just Kidding! You guys are cool!!!!!!! That’s why you are here asking “intellectual questions” and she is on MTV.” LOL Good Job!!! I hop I du gud in skul!

[yluj0407]

sdfasdfadsf

[yluj0407]

I find it amusing that there are so many experts, on the art of singing, here on YouTube!!! I “love” the way they express their opinions so freely, as if they were talking in person to the very people they are scorning. That’s so tuff!!! I’m sure someone or “no one” will want to respond to me, as I might have upset them in an “inadvertent” manner. You experts are so good, that’s why you’re here on YouTube posting your comments to other “professionals.” Thank You!!!

[yluj0407]

I prefer to listen to Cheap Trick!!!

[yluj0407]

I'm glad there are so many vocal experts her to comment on "YouTube." YouTube is turning into a startrek convention! This is where all the experts in "everything" go to. Very good!!!)(*&*&%^^&%$#

[rawrilovesyou1407]

you guys are all FUCKING FAGS, shes not lip syncing fucking idiots. can you hear the echo from the microphone? did you noticed she sang the lyrics wrong? did you notice that she has an OUTSTANDING voice that she wouldnt never need to lip sync anyways? hm bet you didnt cause your all ignorant little fuckers who dont notice a good singer when you hear one. so STFU AND SIT DOWN.

[hsg2012]

@rawrilovesyou1407 you're so stupid....this is not live...when she sings live her mic dynamic is so much different...and when she sings live she doesn't move her neck all crazy if she did her voice would be all over the place...she is a great singer but she is not singing live here at all...she uses this same recording in three other videos i've seen where the lyrics are messed up in the same spot as well...so why don't you STFU AND SIT DOWN DUMBASS....

[hsg2012]

@rawrilovesyou1407 she uses this same recording many times...with the wrong lyrics in the same spot and everything sounds the same but the ending....she's lip syncing...

[lokostill]

@hsg2012 Not really. When she sang it the VMA's she sounded rougher than in this one. I like this one better.

[hsg2012]

@lokostill cuz that one was sung live and this one wasn't :P

[lokostill]

@hsg2012 watch?v=3KEAD2dzDRE&list=PL203­74E8A785ED212&feature=mh_lolz

@ 2:20 She adds a growl into her lyrics... Its hard to lip sync that. You fail.

[hsg2012]

@lokostill there is no growl sweetheart so fail on your part :P

[ana34972]

christina aguilera is mix mariah carey,celine dion and whitney houston

[freeekinsane]

She's lipping. You can tell by her breathing and her neck. When she sings live she breathes long, deep breaths and her veins pop out. Not so here.

[chaipatth]

I am a big fan of her. But I agree that this is lip sync performance. Since if she did it live, she would always swing her microphone closer and farther to control volume of her voice. The best live performance of this song is in MTV music award, which is the first time she performed "HURT".

[fuckingbrill]

One of her best live performances ever. Luv her <3

Can you believe that this performance is 5 years old?!

[goldenwiz99]

What was the died saying?

[MissMariana10]

It's live.

[superbass0011]

meu deus que voz é essa perfeita lindaa demais

[hsg2012]

she's lip syncing because she has no mic dynamic...usually when she belts high notes she pulls it away and she's not in this song she's still amazing and i love her...but she's still lip syncing :)

[fuckingbrill]

@hsg2012 It's live. She's singing it like she's late with most sentences and you can hear differences between volume of voice. + She didn't sang the highest belt like in studio and she did vocalizations in low register and in falsetto that she didn't do in studio.

[hsg2012]

@fuckingbrill it's called re-recording it so it sounds like it's live because it is sang different...performers do that all the time...trust me i know my stuff on this kind of stuff.

[fuckingbrill]

@hsg2012 I know about pre recorded vocals, but it really seems live. It's not the same version like studio, so i guess she couldn't lip every note here. It's different.

[hsg2012]

@fuckingbrill it's not the studio version that's on the cd that she's lip syncing too...obviously

[fuckingbrill]

@hsg2012 okay, nevermind. i'm pretty sure it isn't edited, so it's almost live ;d

[ilovesui]

@hsg2012 its 100% live.. you know why? she sang the lyrics wrongly at 2:35.it should be "to have just one more chance" instead of "to hear your voice again". plus why would a singer who can really sing wanna lipsync? she's not ashlee simpson :x

[hsg2012]

@ilovesui you just proved my point that it is recorded and she is lip synching....she used the same recording in her Australia performance because it does the same thing...it says " to hear your voice again" at the same part where it is supposed to say "to have just one more chance" look it up :P she is lip synching...seriously

[ilovesui]

@hsg2012 are you trying to say she used the same recording as this youtube.com /watch?v=6ANXqOzIe5Y ?and yes she did sang the lyrics wrongly again. but you should listen to the link from 3:50 onwards... its totally different and you can tell its pretty obvious that she sang live! in fact,you can tell from the start the one in Australia was played from the keyboard instead of the piano both sound completely different.so it is 2 complete different playback n both sang 100% LIVE

[hsg2012]

@ilovesui no it isn't...she is using the same recording in both live performances...she could have sang the ending on them but she was lipping 95% of it...when she sings live her head doesn't move around like a crazy person if she did her voice would be all over the place and her mic dynamic is so off...at some high belting points she doesn't move the mic far away and if she was singing live she would have overdriven that mic like a motherfucker....she is lip syncing here no doubt about it.

[ilovesui]

@hsg2012 so is she lip syncing in the vmas? -----> youtube.com/watch?v=KJzQCWQF6z­E&feature=related

[hsg2012]

@ilovesui and is the video you're trying to show me the one of her in her red dress??? it won't go straight to the video for me

[ilovesui]

@hsg2012 you said that she used the same recording in both live performances? how can you explain the different sounds of keyboard and piano between both vid? how can you explain the difference from 3:50 onward in "live in australia"? seriously you should listen carefully between both videos before commenting. you cant just assume she was lip synching just by looking at her head?

[hsg2012]

@ilovesui seriously i was listening and i didn't just say it was because of her head did i smart one??? no i said she has no mic dynamics, plus you can totally tell by her throat, and the over exaggeration of her head are all implications that she's not singing live! and when you record you don't have to record with music....you just record your vocals, it's an a capella recording of her voice...think about it???

[txicmelody13]

@hsg2012 the notes aren't the same as the studio recording. so even if she's lip syncing she still sang it differently than the recording at one point.

[hsg2012]

@txicmelody13 doesn't mean she still didn't lip sync...you can still re-record a song for a live performance.... :)

[Ludmila2507]

Потрясающий голос... Обожаю её.

[shaiinuhxx]

She's so beautiful, it's unreal.

[0Kaytlin960]

what the hell? who can dislike this? its SO WONDERFUL! ♥

[wateruser77]

Hello replay button, my names rape :)

[Nawallover1]

That's Live ?

[EdwinElChulo]

@Nawallover1 amazing, right?!

[MsLmfaohaha]

her voice is AMAZING!

[quadratTube]

simply WOW

[thehorrocruxes]

powerfull voice

[scriptorium]

ehem...

watermelon

[Kaiuchka]

@scriptorium omg yes

[stcilla]

господь дал ей божественный голос,что бы души наши трепетали и становились чище.я в восторге от исполнения!!!!

[stcilla]

великолепное исполнение,талант от бога.мурашки по телу от исполнения

[Injekiplqktor]

I am really glad to see a video of Christina where the comments are actually about her voice, soul and looks... she is incredible...

[DAVIDALOVEAH]

MI DADS A ASSHOLE

[moeru94]

almost better than the recorded version - bes live singer eveeer

[KursaTime]

Chills! Her voice, soul and persona just gives chills!

[jldalex]

Awesome... I really love this song! Christina's voice gives me chills...

[TheLesperkins]

Amazing........

[ALSHEHRAY07]

(Christina Aguilera - Hurt (Studio) = Christina Aguilera - Hurt (Live

there's no different !!!

[Kocicak326]

@ALSHEHRAY07 i dont think so.... Hurt LIVE is much better! :))

[Likinism]

Nice briliant on the left hand!Yeah??O)

[3laiin32kaii10]

Note perfect!



[TwistedCA]

It doesn't get any better than that... Perfection!!

[ILoveMeXDXP]

pause at 1:42

[berecca93]

she has the voice of an angel.

[alfadalh]

The sound of perfection ... Christina Aguilera

[lolex169]

she doesn't have eyes xD

[nuckles194]

i fucking love xtina

[TheSantiPineda]

WOWOWWOw



[jubileucore]

Ela é uma cantora perfeita *-* E essa música é muito linda mesmo. Christina Diva! ♥

[globemusiclover]

She is perfect ... 5+

[laloxito1]

es increíble que cante tan bien en vivo!!

[emylxtra]

she's only need the mic and the voice... not such rubbish to look like lady gaga.... i miss her like this... bionic is epic fail... you lost me is the only track that showing off her vocal

[TheChykita28]

adoro a christina es muy muy muy muy buena !!!!!!.... mejor dixo stupenda

[SIXTIESMUSICGUY]

bravo ,bravo - encore

what a brilliant performance of this great song - christina is the best female vocalist on the planet at this moment in time :)

[211alicat]

Most AMAZING live performance i've EVER seen in my whole life! Her voice is so surreal.

[sad76009]

i really love her ! :)))

[sweetlildevil101]

Holy motherfuckin shit... her voice is too damn impressive

[KyrooBitch]

She's Diva! Amazing! ♥

[mrsnooki12]

better than beyonce

beyonce suck

[kchristian7777777]

christina aguilera gives me goosebumps.

[Zantetsuken444]

wie schön!!!!!!!

[MrBenito94]

amazing

[giggiotto90]

she is perfect!

[3finker]

What stunningly pure and charismatic vocals, isn't she a vegan?

[RideTheLightning316]

@3finker I don't know if she turned vegan but I know she's a vegetarian since she was 15 :-)

[3finker]

@RideTheLightning316 thanks for the info, I hope she is an ethical vegetarian, if so in my opinion

her amazing voice could well be a blessing for how she has chosen to live.

[SheaSheaXD]

This song is one of the best songs in the world , she is not affraid to express her true feelings in song , im not gona ask for ppl to vote up this because it doesnt matter to me , all that matters is she is the best singer in the world!

[DannyAK80]

""I won't name names, but there was a particular vocalist who I know can actually sing, and sing live, and they chose not to. It's like, 'Where did the frigging music go?'""

-- Christina Aguilera

[GreenAtmosphera48]

SO PERFECT HER VOICE<<,A DOLLFACE SHE IS GORGEUS!!! LUV IT

[kryztelly19]

she sounds great and she's only sitting down. awesome!

[xtinalove2011]

i love Christina!!!!!!!!!

[aandrebs90]

holy shit, are u kiddin me??

she really is bionic

what a voice

[sacampbell719]

I love her style here the 50's pin up style goes HARD xD

[DeathMetalRegulator]

och ich von bien en shizen

[PaolaCaracciolo]

Una delle voci piu' belle che io abbia mai sentito !

[divalicious9814]

perfect!

[TheMari6ka]

Она, кажется, (я помолилась)))) слова перепутала??? немножко?

[TyzerD3]

@HATERBYNATURE1 @stupidthingthissucks you're both retarded anyway because you put period and then put "."

[HeIsRisen17]

i would do amost anythig to see her in concert!!!

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

V O C A L P E R F E C T I O N !

[flconductor2]

@XTINASDISCIPLE Christina Aguilera is the best!!!

[Toadallstar2]

LEGENDTINA

[kelala98]

Best performance of this song EVER

[angileeca]

I LUV HER!!!! she's my all time favorite singer plus i almost sound like her!!!! just kidding haha:p

[xDbritt]

There's something wrong with this video.... I SHOULDN'T BE ABLE TO SEE THE DISLIKE BAR.

[potterrin90]

Her voice's so amazing. She's just so perfect. And I love this song....

[ValiFreakyGiirL]

@potterrin90 that's the best song in the worl :D

[alinka990]

KLASA

[ManagerGuy1]

She is the only one who can beat Whitney! Christina is the top!!!!!

[sochVTEC]

I think she has the strongest voice , (:

[geetony123]

=O !! LEGENDTINA!!!

[complotpr]

She's awsome!!! That's why she's there on that stage.

[LivLyfeAsiS]

Gotta give it to her.... Hands down the best live performance by far from any artist.

[ciannamarie164201]

She is so beautiful and a great singer! Have you seen her husband? He got lucky some how.

[QueenOfDreamsXxX]

@ciannamarie164201 Hahahahahahahaha XDDDDDD Yeah he was a really lucky man, cuz he's indeed not the prettiest x.x

But they're divorced now... So sad for her kid Maxf

[jmhlegend]

As always Christina Aguilera looking and sounding amazing. My Idol!! True Legend x

[Cath03forever]

OMG! She's amazing! How you can dislike that? :O

[TheUbralodmari]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!!!!!!!!!! her lives is the best



[reygirl92]

137 people cant sing!

[animetion1012]

she does not neeed to be auto tuned!!!

[spyderface]

vocally the best preformance she has given of 'Hurt'. and I love<3

people really don't appreciate what an amazing voice and technical ability she has.

Xtina is Legend!

[SpazChat]

@spyderface What are you talking about? I appreciate it. That synthetic sound that is so pervasive these days absolutely disgusts me. It started in the late 70s and never went away. It's just gotten worse

[kapukawai9]

i was so wowed after watching this and as i read some of these comments i got kinda mad, mainly because some people cant appreciate a good voice:( to bad for them they only pick out the flaws(barely any) she is AMAZING:) lets leave it at that shall we:D

[linamail]

NOT the best her performance. sure :-( but nice dress )

[linamail]

NOT the best her performance. sure :-(

[loveskwomen]

Gives me cold chills everytime i hear this song.

[susie22798]

137 people thought it was DIS I LIKE

[mikeshinodalove]

Da quanto canta bene sembra in playback. Bravissima come sempre!

[cillangie]

@mikeshinodalove Bravissimooo! Chri sei fantastica! <3

[ILmanipolatoreOscuro]

:D

[13Icegirl]

....... and she did that sitting down?... Omg i will never be able to sing like that standing up!

[liljayfludd]

FUCK NO! SHE IS NOT THE QUEEN OF "LIVE PERFORMANCES"!! AT ALL!!!!! I WILL HAVE TO GIVE THAT TO BEYONCE!! Xtina is one of the best singers in the world, but "live" she struggles alot.

[yaymusica]

@3:30 flawless how she switched so smoothly to the falsetto! BAM! god she's amazing =D

[leCoCoCarousel]

gah.. her voice is a bit overwhelmingly whiny in this performance.

[Mramcdon]

@leCoCoCarousel  dick!!

[2sissylalas]

oh my god!!! she is so freaking amazing live!!! wow!!! oh my flippen gosh!!!! wow!!

[arachnoo]

I wonder how her recordings must look like...

*sings the new song for the first time*

"okay Christina, we got this... you can go home :)

[TheVagapov]

she`s singning WONDERFUL!!!

[tutplz]

She is so amazing:)

She is like the best at singing live

[ilyniners]

She sounds just like WOW!

[Teletubbie657]

ilovechristinasomuch!!:$

[Cbrookins1990]

136 people were hurt and didn't understand~

[DoriaAdmiral]

Xtina Spears 10-0

[co384264]

I got teary. And this song has NOTHING to do with my life (other then my grandpa, but he's still alive!) and I STILL got teary eyed. :') Go Christina!!

[Aquita17]

She looks gorgeous with that bright red lipstick.

[vfbulder]

My god she's even better live than on audio...

[mirlindism]

This woman is sooo TALENTED and BEAUTIFUL :)

[MrDembar]

просто ахринетительно!!!в живую спеть также как и с студийной аранжировкой.это замечательно... ...this a wonderfully...

[tutplz]

She is awesome this is the first time i've seen her and she is amazing... I can't think of words that decribe her she is so good

[ang4ful]

She is the only one, who can really sing. I love this song

[MakeMeFamous2011]

Wow......136 people that can't stand the fact that she is better at them!!! Fail, they should go die in a hole while trying to sing with their sucky voice!!! Christina is my role model and in my opinion she is one of the best female singers in the world!!! ;)

[katielee11331]

Does anyone see lady gaga ANYWHERE in this video?! Its x-tina bitches, Lets give credit to christina and just leave gaga out of it cuz she is nothing compared to christina :)

[Marissab93]

goosebumps everytime

[JimmyChoosLoverx]

Wow, stop hating and face the facts , she is absolutley amazing, probably the best live singer not some artist who edits all their work then shows it, she can sing!!!! she is AMAZING.

[tonyAJ420]

Dumb bitch actually didnt forget the words this time

[lalaland135able]

@tonyAJ420 listen im just saying just cuz she ACCIDENTALLY messed up on the national anthem doesnt mean shes a dumb bitch ok?? i mean for realz thts a hateful thing to say shes a beautiful singer and everyone fukks up so dont hate cuz u aint great

- laterz

@tonyAJ420 She has performed countless times with