Evanescence - My Immortal (Original)

[LilySevShipper]

Whoooaaaa.... this is so fucking beautiful, and SO different from the Amy I'm used to, but I love it. Totally wish I had this instead of the Fallen version on my ipod.

[CaBaWR]

She looks like sarah at knight rider in this picture!

[TheRoflBanana]

i wish i could get the lyrics to this one :o)

[CWATalkShow]

Oh my gosh, I like all the Origin versions of these songs better than the Fallen versions. LOL

[ImFuckingInsane]

Can anyone give me the download link to THIS version!? Please!! It's the best version!

[yunnmello]

This song is the best of all the versions... This one makes me feel so different.

[KarenaTheFreak]

Just beautiful...I love this version more than the one they put on Fallen.

[Mr10Stinson]

Such a beautiful song!

[traythegrinch]

i luv this band, me n my daughter "loreen" luv this song we listened n sang it 2gevva ... sadly i lost her, i played this at her funeral, Miss u my darlin loreen rip, she was 25yrs... this is our special song <3 xxxo ,3

[LilyMoth12]

This is so beautiful. I played My Immortal at my grandfather's funeral this past summer. Everyone was upset but me. In all honesty he had been dead to me since he lost his mind. He had been the spirit linguing that wouldn't leave me alone until he was gone and I felt better and felt I could move on... I'm sorry if that depressed anyone.

[pepe48889]

Brilliant. where you find this song?

[GuitarGirl4ever]

I really love the bridge of this version, but I'm not liking the piano. It sounds too...tosco (spanish word for lack of better english word at the moment) when it needs to be more delicate.

[GuitarGirl4ever]

@demeterlol Well that's stupid. You should be who you want to be. Music is a form of expression and you dad shouldn't be telling you how you can or can't express yourself. I have a feeling you're really young, but however old you are shouldn't matter if you like Ev if not. I fell in love with Ev at age 10, here I am 8 yrs later still in love.

[demeterlol]

@GuitarGirl4ever lol when I first started to read your comment, I thought you were calling me stupid, and I was about to flip! Heh, thanks for the response. And your right, I am young. I just recently turned 15. Evanescence ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!

[iloveevanescence1795]

i love this bridge <3 <3

[XfishoutofwaterbabeX]

somehow this version always gets to me most...i guess because its so raw and 'simple'....the lyrics are different and cause im so used to the other version, it always makes me listen real hard and understand :)

[juninho0105]

melhor versao!!!!

[Alysin123]

i love this one the most....

[rahnichole]

Tão minha essa Amy.

[FeawenSelena]

Just beautiful, however I like the "Fallen" version better. Is it on "Not for your ears"?

[ABrandNewDay7]

this song wasn't only written by ben moody and with some amy's changes but by david hodges as well... i found the official reference about it and it's written by: Ben Moody, Amy Lee, David Hodges...

[edwardt3k3lo]

TE AMO AMY LEE ♥

[henj38]

I like the origin version the best. Way better than fallen or evanescence Ep.

[3sweetsugarhoney3]

As much as I love Evanescence, I don't like this version. It sounds messy and I even think she sounds a little out of tune.

[kaarankin69]

@3sweetsugarhoney3 she was like 15 or 16 in this one so of course her voice hasn't matured yet.

[XfishoutofwaterbabeX]

wow i love her outfit here!! she;s amazing

[PreciousPoision]

I bought the album with that song in it. Its the around the begenning of the record, but as a secret track its there again, and sounds the same. Anyone have the same thing? or is it diffrent yet im to deaf to hear the diffrence?

[demeterlol]

I am so ticked off! My dad said I shouldn't listen to this song so much because it's so sad! And he doesn't want me to be goth. I can't help that I am. And he admitted he liked the song too. Can we say 'hypocrite?"

[arcpianogrl]

@demeterlol of course it's a good song, but it's also depressing, so he probably just doesn't want you to be depressed.

[demeterlol]

@arcpianogrl Maybe, but its pretty much all of the Evanescence songs he's worried about. Especially My Immortal. He's under the impression all of Evanescence is depressing.

[QuerellaVlog]

@demeterlol  theres no "sad gothic" theres just gothic

[demeterlol]

@QuerellaVlog I know that. But my dad doesn't. People just automatically intertwine them.

[AnythingButAverage13]

To mi chere amour; as one may hurth a miles worth of people, others seek love, as us combined as one.

[lilygirl5099]

I like this better than the newer version.

[kur8rus]

i love this song! but its so sad (((

[GorbyMGW]

Ah, perfect for me that you describe the differebt forms of the song in your describtion :D I was searching a long time why i have different versions of this song.

What ever, every version is perfect in it's own way ;D

[MiniMe19901]

is this song from some movie or cartoon?

[AL3KZTV]

@MiniMe19901 the one on their fallen album was used for the daredevil soundtrack

[EmotionSinger]

I love the Band!!

[lukaspiojo]

UAU!!! incredible!

[AL3KZTV]

I LOVE THE BRIDGE ON THIS ONE

[GoldiRockzz]

Too me, this is the truest form of this song. Amy Lees' voice exudes emotion form deep within.

[stardarkstar]

does anyone know where i can find the music sheets to this version?

[stardarkstar]

great song

[1KU1]

This is a beautiful song, I love both versions but this is so pure and its the original version which I always love and Amy lee has a beautiful voice and I cant stop listening to her.

[wadefire23]

well for me my immortal is one of the great song i've ever heard and it fits on amy's voice so amazing

[mizushadow]

Makes me want to break down and cry, as only this song can.

[deidaraandsasorlover]

I prefer it this way

[rduquet]

I LOVE Evanescense now, I think they are one of the best Metal Bands to come along since the 80's. SO MUCH GREAT TALENT! I just got Fallen on CD a couple of weeks ago, I play it over and over!

rduquet

[Ravenlightwood]

All good things must begin some where. I think this was written in her teens and done right after Highschool. And now look at it, Its a radio, if not, global hit! I heard this song in Brazil, the US and in Germany. You cant get any bigger that that. And the fact that the fan base has actually grown in their hiatus. Congats Amy Lee and Evanescence as a whole, including all infuences, current members and past members.

[NienerWiener69]

@Ravenlightwood no... wasn't it written by ben moody about his grandfather who passed and when he left the band....she changed it a bit.

[kaarankin69]

@NienerWiener69 nah i think they changed it abit to make it shorter for the album version which is still the same now and ben was still with EV till end of october 2003

[TheYoshi010]

@Ravenlightwood dude her songs are globle right after this song thats when all her songs went globle coz of dis song



[scootachu]

@Ravenlightwood hard to get it heard in germany i bet (easier for japan and brazil i think...)

[coolpics4u]

@Ravenlightwood Actually Ben Moody wrote the original when he was 15 years old, Not Amy.

[Ravenlightwood]

@coolpics4u If you notice, If you notice, I never said who wrote it. I said congrats to her and Evanescence. past and previous members. Ben Moody was a previous member, If he wrote it and had Amy sing it, then that was his choice, but by doing that, made it an Evanescence song and further refined it to the level it is at now.

[coolpics4u]

@Ravenlightwood But you said, "I think this was written in her teens and done right after Highschool." So I assumed that you meant she wrote it.

[Ravenlightwood]

@coolpics4u Thanks for the info, but how do you honestly know that? How do you know thats true and not some made up "oh i know that...blah,blah,blah" bullpoopie that seems to float around our internet so often.

[coolpics4u]

@Ravenlightwood From a reliable website all about Evanescence. It's how I found out that there was an original version of My Immortal.

[coolpics4u]

@Ravenlightwood And also, I wasn't saying that to be a "know it all". I was simply correcting you, because I thought you meant that Amy wrote it.

[ButterflyVampire43]

Beautiful piano playing. Very pretty.

[0nooooa0]

wow

[EvanescencePure]

Wow... I think that I like this version better than the modern version...

[VideoGameGirlExpert]

Doesn't sound like Amy lee....… it sounds like a fan-made song.

[snoweatsbabies]

@VideoGameGirlExpert um...its amy not a fan made, listen carfully , its her, its from an ep they made when amy was like idk 16,17

[milla387]

I think Ben wrote it to Amy.It's so beautiful song,I can't take back my tears.

[Silvaknite]

interesting to hear originals of songs.... seems to be extra vocals in this version.... don't like the piano though.... very ploddy..... the later version is much better here....

[ttlEvanescencefreek]

OMG!!!!!

[Kafez120]

this version is good, but i think i like the other version better, it seems to fit the song better in my opinion

[reikimysoul]

just left my boo the other night, for survival. Could I have stayed I would have. The pain is thiis bad with or without him.

[BoomBTR]

i like the other version better cuz it's osfter and seems to fit the song better, but thats just my opinion ^_~

[MissMike3010]

@BoomBTR where do i find the softer version?

[BoomBTR]

@MissMike3010 type in evanescence my immortal band version

[FRIEDBREAD62]

Just beautiful :)

[hpfan7089]

I don't really like this version all that much. It just sounds a bit boring to me. It doesn't sound like she put in much effort to put emotion into the song. That's probably just me being picky, though. It really is a good song, i just don't like how she sings it.

[LeviStute]

Thats never the original !!!

[Blackbudproduction]

@LeviStute its always the original, what the hell are you talkin' bout o.e

[AlexEvansLover4L1FE]

my fav song it came out the year i was born and im a major fan along witht the rest of my fam

[hippotrot123]

Though:

"I've tried so hard to tell myself that you're gone.

But thought, you're still with me, I've been alone all alone."

Is a good bridge (used in Fallen, Origin, etc versions), I personally like the one in this version better: "I'd love to walk away and pull myself out of the rain, but I can't leave without you. I'd love to live without the constant fear and endless doubt, but I can't live without you."

[xXDaisuke]

ohhh fuck what the fu.ck ist this...wtf?????? oooommmmmgggggg....what the hell ??????????...its sooooo good !!!

[TheGeniveve]

she is so beautiful

[FeffaScemm666]

This make me cry.. too sad but to amazing :')

[XxAlexiaStarxX]

And Please,where did you got this pic of amy,it's really beautiful

[XxAlexiaStarxX]

46 people are dead :),how can't they love this beautiful song ? This is candy for ears and i especially enjoy this version...♥

[TedBundyfan83]

während ! ^^

[TedBundyfan83]

ich hab gefurzt währnde ich dieses lied hörte !

[carissahcg]

we played this song at my moms funeral

[demeterlol]

@carissahcg Oh,I'm so sorry

[sharializevanescence]

@carissahcg im sorry for your loss :(

[unknownadi]

@carissahcg really sorry :( I know how you feel T^T my dad is also...

I hope you will be oke 

[saeidsaied]

God Damnd!! i Love Amlyee!!!!

[ElectropopGoddess]

I don't think the piano is as good in this as in the other version.

[milla387]

@ElectropopGoddess I think it's better in this,like the other.=)

[viperlikescat]

i love her voice

[4wheelerDJ]

Much more raw and gloomy than the final version.

[BloodyJasi]

wow, this is very beautiful ♥ it's an awesome version

[giannisrock95]

wow I feel touched!!! its very impressive!!! I love it <3<3<3

[MeteorMan05]

I like the other with the piano, but Evanescence is awesome no matter what.

[SerenityCCat]

she sounds less falsetto here then usual.

[gothdude92]

one of the greatest songs ever written enough said

[ilovenelena16]

this is so awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ijb ogvfy ohi f utu9a g adt9d8ragiu ai guas

those random letters/#s were from me pretending i was playing the piano lol

[bunnifams26]

i lyke both verison of this song but this one is better

[KahlanUlquiorra]

is there somewhere i can download this version of the song? i found this video last year during summer when a friend of mine found it (Richard and kahlan my immortal) so i checked it out and since then iv watched/ listened to it a lot. this one really stuck with me because my ex had left me & i really cared for him & he wouldnt leave my head & i had nightmares about the whole thing that happened with him. and the part with "pull myself out of the rain" made sense becaus i love being independent.

[autogirl333]

@KahlanUlquiorra They don't have it on itunes but you can get it on limewire if you search hard enough

[priscillamemita]

it waz good but uhh it sounds diffrent then da original one???

wel to me???

[punkrockinangel]

41 people have bad taste in music!!!!

[maykayre]

the desciption is huge O_o

[SolethVonGrave]

More doomish :P sounds awesome

[MoonyMara]

schon schief



[Ta5ya148]

i agree with @NausAllien the fallen version has more emotion...you can really feel the pain in Amy Lee's voice there.

[Eduardo131451]

the original sounds better because this version is so slow the other version is faster

[juresaric1]

beautiful song but I don t like tihis version..

[NausAllien]

This song has not the emotion that the fallen or band version has, actually my favourite is the fallen version.

[lottypops102]

AWESOME!

[LMG1629]

She looks pretty in that picture( Amy Lee)

[EvanescenceVampire95]

Okay, it's obvious her voice isn't as good in this one as it is now. But HECK! It's still hecka awesome! Her voice was still probably maturing during this time. But her voice is REAL and ANGELIC none the less.

[nextJW]

pretty cool, but i don't like her voice in this one. it tends to go all over the place in pitch, probably because it is mostly unedited, and it doesn't sound like she's hitting the impact points of the song with the intensity of the full band version (guess that's why you posted the history) ....it's cool to hear this version though...cool bit of history here. thanks a lot.

[gimmycandyluver]

me-im going out mom-where me-to go 35 idiots mom-ok,just bring a jacket. me-k luv u

[mVpaokg4]

<3 I'd love to walk away and pull myself out of the rain

But I can't leave without you

I'd love to live without the constant fear and endless doubt

But I can't live without you <3

[perfectlyhis]

I laugh at all the stupid people who would rather spend forever arguing over those who dislike the song. They take up just as much space as all the negative comment and dislikes.

[klavierGavinlover]

It's so beautilful. I personally like the most popular version better, but that's just me.

[Violara1]

this isnt Amy .... ??? !!!!

cruel

[niall77777]

this isnt the original... dont say it is and mislead people

[ExdeathXInfinity]

@niall77777 original as in this was the first raw version of the song, its been modified into the album fallen.

[bellahoney82]

Emotions run through me when i hear this Song

[HOLYWOODONE]

LOVE THIS SONG



[majesiowa19]

emotions!!!!!

[KediiKat]

Ooh this is different!! :)

[jowijanssen]

i always lissen heavy metal and that shit but this is just bueatifull

[MyHappymonday]

hear voice is amaing <3 x

[syikinlala97]

34 people don't have ear

[kateybell1]

Do u have the lyrics?

[MsThat70sshow]

david star?

[Twizzellove]

32 people thought dislike was dis-i-like

[MrNick996]

I Love Her Voice

[mooey96999]

@MrNick996 ME TOO

[Justeunregard1]

Someone can send me this version please ? Thaanks.!

[cronousplayer]

@Justeunregard1 You can get it at evanescencereference.info/musi­c/

[15jallred]

Wow.. it's amazing how much Amy's voice has matured.. I mean compare this to the songs on 'Fallen' and 'The Open Door'.. she has always had a beautiful voice, but she's improved with it so much. <3

[suhailmohdashraf]

I LOVE THIS SONG...

[maleni187]

song is too strong!!! i don't listen this type of music but this song is the best!!!

[powerdead1000]

its a close between the 2

[powerdead1000]

i liek the othe rone better but no doubt this one is good to :P

[parrakeeto]

can u get a downloadable version for this song! i LOVE it!! i must have it!

[dakushigunacarly]

Prefer the band version tbh. In this one she sounds rather flat. Not her best anyway.

[NZthou]

so is this amy lee singing it dosent sound like her still really beautiful though i think every version is lovely:)

[TaterSpot]

Hm....I prefer the band version....

[drdenzil]

i love this version but is it not got any voice aids on it?

[Mussgod]

tbh this is the better version by far i fell in love this this all though the other version is imense this is what you call kick ass

[Cockholio]

Wow man. Damn. Awesome.

[mooey96999]

I love this version way more because I can't live with out you

[Phuckize]

Sorry but that piano ain´t working for me,it´s not soft enough to sound good to me.

[Jayazz79]

@Phuckize True, The Piano is too loud imo :). Tho its stil a geat, awesome, damn good song. Real music. But other version is better :).

[Phuckize]

@Jayazz79 Agreed

[pengaith30]

good song and its beautiful.......

[imadethis2watchvidz]

WTF?! How can people not like THIS?! It's beautiful!!! Some people have problems with their ears... -_-

[nichick39]

@imadethis2watchvidz I agree i sang this by my gradnmother's bedside when she was dying the song has alot of meaning. people just don;t have hearts beating in thier chests today thats all.

[x6xdevilx9x]

@imadethis2watchvidz 34 of them 2 be exact :)

[cvg1099]

@imadethis2watchvidz The decision as to whether or not they like this song is not made in their ears.

[f5superstar]

@cvg1099 i think what they ment was its impossible to not like this song, so whoever dissliked it obviously had ear issus.

[perfectlyhis]

@f5superstar or are just comfortable enough to be themselves and admit that they differ from the majority of the population.

its not a crime to dislike a song

[f5superstar]

@perfectlyhis hey i didnt say anything about whoever dissliked it, i just cleard things up for cvg1099 who was preatending to be smart

[f5superstar]

@cvg1099 "BIG WORDS" Scary why do you waste your time trying to outsmart people on youtube? doesnt sound very smart to me

[perfectlyhis]

@perfectlyhis my apologies, i was trying to click on someone next to you in the original comment list

[ilovenelena16]

@cvg1099 whatevesssssss

[Theiloveeggs]

@cvg1099 Fine; They've got bad music taste. Happy now?

[rodriguezg100]

@imadethis2watchvidz not only their ears, THEIR DAMN MIND!

[MsJasperMCullen]

cool i loke this one better

[ZeldaInuYashalover]

......................

[Hellisworthallthat]

I don't like this version...

[Fedorfan220]

I always wished this song would last much longer

[expressivechild]

Is this version available in any of their albums? EPs? 

[EvanescenceVampire95]

I wish that itunes would put this version on it too -_-