Horowitz,s playing of this piece was for me the most memorable ever.
Very hard to surpass Horowitz,s interpretation and playing of this magnificent creation.
I wonder about Zimermans use of tempo in this piece.The relationship between the slower and faster sections of the melody does not work for me . I think he is playing the slow too slow and the fast too fast.
I have been playing this piece myself for some years & am an admirer of Zimerman but on this piece I have heard it performed better.
@WowheresJoe I agree. I have the whole Gilels-Beethoven Sonatas, except the last ones (Gilels didn´t record the last ones). I Absolutely love the poetic Gilels, especially the appassionata interpretation. But I think Zimerman is almost as sensitive as Gilels.
By the way, it´s wonderful to find you people here. I find Beethovens music as the most inspiring music in my life.
@SwordDr lol, good to be agreed. Master pieces are crying for master players. I noticed this since I started listening to Zimmerman. (And right mood, right environment, right instruments........) Too many to enjoy and to learn.
@newFranzFerencLiszt cause he paid me good performance to say so? haha And you are right, we should give ourselves the opportunities to listen to good music. Try->choose And Zimmerman and Gilels are the two survived in my iPod. I love them because they love the music they play and the music they bring to me is what I love. Have a good day.
hmm, i'd say the most beautiful melody in the universe still goes to the largo of dvorak's New World symphony, easily. the theme of this movement is great however, and zimerman presents it spectacularly, as he always does.
The most beautiful melody in the universe...and Zimerman is the best pianist in the world. What an amazing combination! So glad to see this video. Thank you for uploading!!
This has been flagged as spam show
沁みる
(Posted by Youtube Stream for iPhone (yst.me) on behalf of haaasiy at twitter)
ystme 3 weeks ago
Capturing his whole audience as ever. Simply beautiful. Dreamful.
tierzuchtZentral 3 months ago
Very nice... *lays back and closes eyes*
darthGavin 6 months ago
BEETHOVEN IS A PURE MANKIND'S GENIUS!!!
iguarni 6 months ago 3
Horowitz,s playing of this piece was for me the most memorable ever.
Very hard to surpass Horowitz,s interpretation and playing of this magnificent creation.
I wonder about Zimermans use of tempo in this piece.The relationship between the slower and faster sections of the melody does not work for me . I think he is playing the slow too slow and the fast too fast.
I have been playing this piece myself for some years & am an admirer of Zimerman but on this piece I have heard it performed better.
superwhooper69 9 months ago
@superwhooper69
Horowitz and Beethoven you must be joking!
The tempo works very well. I have played this sonata myself, too.
And it cannot be played better I assure you!
MusikPiratCH 1 week ago
The music is not really from this earth, I don´t know from where.
SwordDr 10 months ago 2
I felt darkess, serene and peace inside .
ltntem 10 months ago
Beethoven!
Uno se llena de paz con esto música.
Oscarenedg 1 year ago
infinitesimally too slow. and that! made all the difference.
woodchuckmool 1 year ago
Well, no comparison. Just a recommendation, if you like Beethoven try Emil Gilels version.
WowheresJoe 1 year ago 2
@WowheresJoe I agree. I have the whole Gilels-Beethoven Sonatas, except the last ones (Gilels didn´t record the last ones). I Absolutely love the poetic Gilels, especially the appassionata interpretation. But I think Zimerman is almost as sensitive as Gilels.
By the way, it´s wonderful to find you people here. I find Beethovens music as the most inspiring music in my life.
SwordDr 10 months ago
@SwordDr lol, good to be agreed. Master pieces are crying for master players. I noticed this since I started listening to Zimmerman. (And right mood, right environment, right instruments........) Too many to enjoy and to learn.
WowheresJoe 9 months ago
@WowheresJoe I have to admit that I found Zimmenman just lately, and he is obviously a grat master.
SwordDr 9 months ago
@WowheresJoe I have to admit that I found Zimmenman just lately, and he is obviously a great master.
SwordDr 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@WowheresJoe I have to admit that I found Zimmerman just lately, and he is obviously a great master.
SwordDr 9 months ago
@WowheresJoe Very good said :o))
tierzuchtZentral 3 months ago
@WowheresJoe There are a lot to "try"......
why don't "try" Backhaus? or schnabel? Richter! Brendel... Nikolayeva, Rubinstein, [etc]
newFranzFerencLiszt 9 months ago
@newFranzFerencLiszt cause he paid me good performance to say so? haha And you are right, we should give ourselves the opportunities to listen to good music. Try->choose And Zimmerman and Gilels are the two survived in my iPod. I love them because they love the music they play and the music they bring to me is what I love. Have a good day.
WowheresJoe 9 months ago
@WowheresJoe to you
newFranzFerencLiszt 9 months ago
Don't anyone dare to dislike this video!
QuikSapphire 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
glojet111 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@crawfordfanatic "Pathetique" means emotional, with great passion, pathos..
glojet111 1 year ago
@crawfordfanatic
"Pathetique" means emotional, with great passion, pathos..
glojet111 1 year ago
Typical musician though. Calling it "Pathetique" They never think their work is good enough.
crawfordfanatic 1 year ago
@crawfordfanatic Lol XD
pagielme4ever 1 year ago
This is the best movement of the 8th sonata.
crawfordfanatic 1 year ago
One of his most beautiful sonatas. They all are lovely but this one is my favorite.
crawfordfanatic 1 year ago
A wonderful interpretation, absolutely perfect
Kuseikos 1 year ago 11
its like full orchestra...
predoje 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I would have to agree with rang5882
RodgerRodgerson1 1 year ago
unbelievable!
littledog2008 1 year ago
hmm, i'd say the most beautiful melody in the universe still goes to the largo of dvorak's New World symphony, easily. the theme of this movement is great however, and zimerman presents it spectacularly, as he always does.
fledgehog 1 year ago
The most beautiful melody in the universe...and Zimerman is the best pianist in the world. What an amazing combination! So glad to see this video. Thank you for uploading!!
rang5882 2 years ago 31
@rang5882 Could don't agree more!
OldRabit 1 year ago
@rang5882 beethoven is the greatest composer ever..... he will forever be remembered :)
develish16 1 year ago