k oh so its on the xbox taht is is playing now so thameans its not on pc becae you pay on pc its like playing wow i wood rhater play wow than this online
You know this and part 2 inspired me to buy PSU, i maxed my level a long time ago, and quit after maxing a 2nd. it was a good run! i still play extra mode from time to time! I always just seem to come back to this video. XD.
@luksdes no you can buy it in player shops or just run innocent girl at the grm shop, the lady at the entrance has the mission, and the wings are called whittil wing
EVERYONE:: PASTE EVERY VIDEO BRING BACK PSO PSO IS NOT DEAD ITS JUST BEEGING THE UPGRADES TO STOP GC PSO FTW EVERYONE THAT AGREES STAND TALL AND POST THIS EXACT MESSEGE ON EVERY SINGLE VIDEO
@xFlareStrikex GRM shop I think, uber expensive, like 550k meseta I think. I've got them too. :P Ragnarok, or something like that, idk, haven't played the game in forever.
How many people still play this game, the last time i played i only meet 6 in one of the lobbys, and thats all i could find. Did you know newmen are not spell casters they ment to be melee users and humans are ment to be spell casters.
sadly enough, psu wasnt even half as good as pso, if they made a remake os pso with the new graphix but kept all drop rates, enemy stats, mags and so in i would so buy it
And weapons clothes CAST parts. Returning classic bosses (few new ones SEGA aint creative). AND THE BEST PART, $10 a month. >.> But hey if you get it for 360, look for xSTx Venom
Thanks! ^_^ I have the demo..But my Birthdays in 7 dayz so..Ill get the Regular game and start PLAYIN WIF YAZ >:O
Ill let you know once I get it...We can meet at a specific place or something. Anyways, Thanks! ^_- (My voice over live sounds a bit girly like though. o_O)
(Yeah xbox does that! My wingman on gears is like dude youre not black. And i tell him to call me and hes all, "Holy hell dude! You sound so damn black WTF!")
The game is on PS2, PC, and Xbox 360, Your best off with the Xbox, the PS2/PC online servers for PSU and it's expansion are shutting down on March 31st, sadly.
lol i know u didnt do this lol u have japineese ritin on your fin vid and how 2 u know completely fine english lol ur just a wanna be douche bag onles inomose eglavanedos
Just reach level 100 and go to your room and click game achievements and then go to rewards.. You should have a title and the reward will be the wings :)
There is also one more way to get the wings.. On the last mission where you fight Helga her 2 helpers (the robot dudes) sometimes will drop these wings..
wings are only available in japan atm 4 the illuminos online, but u soon wen the next even comes out its gnna b light event so this tym we will be getting thos wings, xSTx death note <<
I caught it offline. In the offline mode the item is better. In oof it's an S rank armor,. in on it's an A rank item.
I caught it in the Hive, the last mission of the offline mode. There is a room that as no way out, and in 1 of the monster will drop you that. It's so easy (at least was to me) that I have 3! XD
Is this game any good...I remember someone telling me to buy it...and I was wondering if it is any of the versions are any different...besides graphics?
sorry if its a noobish question, but whatever i do i cant seem to get my skills/spells that iv'e got/bought to my pallete or use them in any way, if anyone could, please answear! what options widnows and so on i should use...
Dark Meta it not horr it whore man spell it right. LoL dumb man whore go EAT A AMERICAN COCK DUMB IRAQ ASSHOLE SHIT EATER.By the way Dark meta is a very VERy gay homo player dont friends him lmao.
IF ANYONE KNOW This nigga TalonTsi96 he is a f***ing cunt coward ass pussy talk shit and then chicken out. But wont make his own video to prove himself. He aka know as Dark Metal the scammer in PSO. And his youtube acc is TalonTsi96 and he a iraq asshole ^^
@bboyyen06 first off thats a very racist comment. second whats wrong with iraq? 3rd this is COMPLETELY irelevant to the video and lastly LEARN SOME FREAKING ENGLISH!
Now how did you get the wing looking things on your back? its so cool. Like I have Phantasy Star Universe for PS2 but i do not pay for the online thing cause its like 10 bucks a month which is rediculous cause Sony said there online gaming would be free and all but anyways is there a way i can get that for PS2 offline versionN?
is this game japanese only? or is there an english version too? and.. what's it like compared to Phantasy Star for the gamecube, it looks cool though. is there subscription fees too?
woot! rising strike=my fav photon so far. how much pp does rising strike use with the last hit? (I've gotten the last hit but haven\t figured out how much the last hit uses)
tornado break and the average twin daggers photon art are pretty cool but are only usefule when in close quarters and surrounded.When its a boos fight i use the skills i get from s rank missions.Oh yeah i was dissapointed to find out that knuckles spec is the same forever...
how to get that wing???i look very cool,why he do not use code breaker to get better costume than his clothes?noble long coat and bottom set is suitable for that wing....in the hive cave do not drop this rare item...bored...
what kind of game is phantasy star universe? is it a mmorpg? i kno that its online but is it like mmorpg thousands of people in 1 server or its jus online like 4,6 people in a group on own private world?
For those who are wondering what the song is, it is called TimeScars by FFmusic Dj. You can find it at OverClocked ReMix. It is a site of a bunch of remixed video game music done by fans.
How to get a MAG???
71GA 6 days ago
k oh so its on the xbox taht is is playing now so thameans its not on pc becae you pay on pc its like playing wow i wood rhater play wow than this online
hulahurahup 1 month ago
how you get the wings? oh and is this offline?
ufuckedmymum 3 months ago
@ufuckedmymum if you are on xbox you get the wing from innocent girl quest. keep doing it until they give you wings, its a unit.
Dance1713 3 months ago
If you would tell me the flaming sword melee action that would be great and tell me where you bought it? Or was it bought just like that?
Andreww3m0 5 months ago
HOW DO GET ThIS ON PC?!!?!? AND DO U HAVE TO PAY FOR ONLINE ON THE PC?!
DjLuk3 5 months ago
HOW DO GET TIS ONPC?!!?!? AND DO U HAVE TO PAY FOR ONLINE ON THE PC?!
DjLuk3 5 months ago
You know this and part 2 inspired me to buy PSU, i maxed my level a long time ago, and quit after maxing a 2nd. it was a good run! i still play extra mode from time to time! I always just seem to come back to this video. XD.
PureDarkAngelSkillz 7 months ago
i love the background music, whats the name of it??
doguss1 8 months ago
do i hear the crono cross theme hear? awesome
crazycapell1441 8 months ago
i need help i wanna do more than use ethans moves on the extra mode help meh???
benkingdomheartsfan 9 months ago
im new hehe getting this game sometime next week spent months looking for it lol games getting rare now
xUnR3ALxKHAoSsx 11 months ago
Are the wings only for the JPPSU? If not, how can i get them?
"This video features all level 30 skills for melee weapons that are store bought" ← That's in the description
luksdes 1 year ago
@luksdes no you can buy it in player shops or just run innocent girl at the grm shop, the lady at the entrance has the mission, and the wings are called whittil wing
565765746867665 1 year ago
Are the wings only for the JPPSU? If not, how can i get them?
luksdes 1 year ago
how do you get the robot
AngryManDidon 1 year ago
how long does this game take to beat?
omgwsx 1 year ago
Too much money every month!
AQRenokiller2 1 year ago
EVERYONE:: PASTE EVERY VIDEO BRING BACK PSO PSO IS NOT DEAD ITS JUST BEEGING THE UPGRADES TO STOP GC PSO FTW EVERYONE THAT AGREES STAND TALL AND POST THIS EXACT MESSEGE ON EVERY SINGLE VIDEO
MrHinesward12 1 year ago
Yawn
simmsoriginal 1 year ago
i have thos fist there really good
evanrickyshow 1 year ago
That last claw tech look kinda of sick with the wings
youngchaosdragon 1 year ago
hit me up on the full game im ORSS
tammy89422 1 year ago
Ok just for having the remix you win.
jbizilbe2 1 year ago
1:05 Dude where/how can i get those Epic Flaming Swords?!
xFlareStrikex 1 year ago
@xFlareStrikex GRM shop I think, uber expensive, like 550k meseta I think. I've got them too. :P Ragnarok, or something like that, idk, haven't played the game in forever.
TheFallenChaos 9 months ago
how did u make the effects of the weapon last longer
brycemclean2494 1 year ago
i luv this game but 4 sum reason when i play it 4 like 10 minutes i get sleepy
Raitatsumaki 1 year ago
me to weird lolz im serious i get sleepy when i play any PSO game
Konataluver 1 year ago
How do you get those skills ? Also do you need the full game for it ?
Please Help / Ty =D
xXxWEEwooxXx1 1 year ago
How many people still play this game, the last time i played i only meet 6 in one of the lobbys, and thats all i could find. Did you know newmen are not spell casters they ment to be melee users and humans are ment to be spell casters.
TheAzulupus 2 years ago
Is this game for free?
LiangHuBBB 2 years ago
sadly enough, psu wasnt even half as good as pso, if they made a remake os pso with the new graphix but kept all drop rates, enemy stats, mags and so in i would so buy it
tzukaza 1 year ago
@tzukaza word pso pwned
CmoreBuhts 1 year ago 2
the hanzo looks really cool with gra photons :)
PSOperro 2 years ago
Where u get the wings from?
pivotdude37 2 years ago
level 30 beast
jerrywalmer 2 years ago
i bet he got them from drinking red bull
tommolloydman 2 years ago
redbull gives u wings :D
pivotdude37 2 years ago
howed u get tose wings nd who was dat lil guy doin nothen pm
dmxdog123456 2 years ago
is this psu or psu aoi
skyguy0815 2 years ago
So This is Lke Phantasy Star Online Ep 1 and 2 But on 360 and Better Graphics? AWESOMESAUCE..NESS! :3
doomedtodead64 2 years ago
And weapons clothes CAST parts. Returning classic bosses (few new ones SEGA aint creative). AND THE BEST PART, $10 a month. >.> But hey if you get it for 360, look for xSTx Venom
THAT BE ME!
^_- ill help ya start good!
Most High lvl xSTx's will actually
1beefstick 2 years ago
Thanks! ^_^ I have the demo..But my Birthdays in 7 dayz so..Ill get the Regular game and start PLAYIN WIF YAZ >:O
Ill let you know once I get it...We can meet at a specific place or something. Anyways, Thanks! ^_- (My voice over live sounds a bit girly like though. o_O)
doomedtodead64 2 years ago
Alright man!
(Yeah xbox does that! My wingman on gears is like dude youre not black. And i tell him to call me and hes all, "Holy hell dude! You sound so damn black WTF!")
-_-' One of many flaws among xbox live
1beefstick 2 years ago
Cool, im getting this game soon, hope you could help me start up : D
skinny3600 2 years ago
u need a level 30 beast and level 20 beast can go to beast mode i heard its kinda boring but im tring to get to it
jerrywalmer 2 years ago
@skinny3600
I know ur coment is 3 months old.. but could u help me?
What console are you getting this game for?
Or is it for PC?
lokohehehe 2 years ago
The game is on PS2, PC, and Xbox 360, Your best off with the Xbox, the PS2/PC online servers for PSU and it's expansion are shutting down on March 31st, sadly.
therealhyperwire 1 year ago
ill let ya know wen a get the game, i tried phantasy star online ep i and ii aaaages ago so i thought i wud try this new 1
tommolloydman 2 years ago
how u get wings
DriftKingFeter 2 years ago
Bah its all about the Humans, Underdogs FTW!!
jayvash22 2 years ago
newman own
carsonchambliss 2 years ago
how much damage do you do
SilentSniperRofl 2 years ago
lol i know u didnt do this lol u have japineese ritin on your fin vid and how 2 u know completely fine english lol ur just a wanna be douche bag onles inomose eglavanedos
Mase188 2 years ago
Lv 3 Hp restore and +4 end. i think
ROFLchef 2 years ago
do the wings help you at all
deadshot145 2 years ago
I dont think so.They just make you look cool
WiseStrife25 2 years ago
i got mine from shred the darkness
Blakdragun7 2 years ago
Well. if this was the 360 we only have the Dark wings and you get them by turning in Zonspheres for an event O.O
XxPhantomLegacyxX 2 years ago
were did you get da wings?
ultimatezeldaplayer 2 years ago
They are whitll wings (something like that) You get them at level 100.. :)
Kanji234 2 years ago
ok any sertain way how to get them.
ultimatezeldaplayer 2 years ago
Just reach level 100 and go to your room and click game achievements and then go to rewards.. You should have a title and the reward will be the wings :)
There is also one more way to get the wings.. On the last mission where you fight Helga her 2 helpers (the robot dudes) sometimes will drop these wings..
Kanji234 2 years ago
wings are only available in japan atm 4 the illuminos online, but u soon wen the next even comes out its gnna b light event so this tym we will be getting thos wings, xSTx death note <<
shardz1990 2 years ago
OMG wut wings are those??!??! I am getting dark are those light?
Cool10yearold 2 years ago
i dont get why we pay 4 xbox live and u have to pay for PSU aswell
AZZA280 2 years ago
You can play PSU without XBL gold.
AngelsRequiem 2 years ago
i didnt know that thx man can you get pre paid codes for it anywhere?
protoncode 2 years ago
I don't think there are any cards made specifically for PSU, but I think that those prepaid debit cards work.
Not exactly sure though
AngelsRequiem 2 years ago
Whats with the cool wing effect?
Inuyasha10200 2 years ago
They're called Whitill Wings you can get them offline from the level 60 mission "The HIVE" pretty rare though
haddii2324 2 years ago
whitill huh? like the section Id in the past pso eps
SilverDifenNHE 2 years ago
Ah yes so they are haha i just remembered them
haddii2324 2 years ago
like extra mode on the 360 offline
skyguy0815 2 years ago
2 headed ragnus
booger341134 2 years ago
what r those like fire swords
ruphus182 2 years ago
Oh, Nvm lol (Didn't read the Description.)
IAvinI 2 years ago
Nice ass vid.
Dude what song is that? It's kick ass.
IAvinI 2 years ago
That's an Item. The name is whitill wing
jessicaFmonteiro 2 years ago
And where can you get that item?
Ailishmage 2 years ago
Comment removed
jessicaFmonteiro 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I caught it offline. In the offline mode the item is better. In oof it's an S rank armor,. in on it's an A rank item.
I caught it in the Hive, the last mission of the offline mode. There is a room that as no way out, and in 1 of the monster will drop you that. It's so easy (at least was to me) that I have 3! XD
jessicaFmonteiro 2 years ago
chapter 12 story
online buy from people
blastercore 2 years ago
Thanks :)
Ailishmage 2 years ago
holy crap this vid makes me want to buy the full game
Kin20x6 2 years ago
I was wondering about the wings too. =p
And, perverts are everywhere Dx Look amoungst your selves.. @.@
StylesEste 2 years ago
where u get the wings
joedaclown 2 years ago
I don't have PSU because you have to pay monthly I just play PSOBB
cate200103 3 years ago
huh? i have the game but i dnt play monthly ( ooooo is it cos u got on pc cos mine on 360 )
harryajosh 2 years ago
you dont pay monthly?
it might be charging ur credit card without u knowing
V2cowboysfanV2 2 years ago
how do u get those wings?
iloveanimeftw 3 years ago
Is this game any good...I remember someone telling me to buy it...and I was wondering if it is any of the versions are any different...besides graphics?
LyeWong 3 years ago
It alldepends on what system you have. I like Phantasy Star Online Episode 1 & 2 for Gamecube more than Phantasy Star Universe for Xbox 360
Arsageo 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this game looks gay as shit. perverts play this on live
AnEliteSpartan 2 years ago
I have a question
i have the 360 version and im wondering if PHU:ambition of illuminis(or whatever)is a different disc or just an expansion
if its an expansion then how do i download it?
and what does the other version do?
Queerdragon11 3 years ago
u can download the expansion off of xbox live for like 800ms points or summink like that
Ozunalive 3 years ago
1600ms and u have 2 have xbox live
BlindProductions20 3 years ago
marketplace 800 ms
jaik0wn 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
vote for obama
gamerglitcher 3 years ago
sorry if its a noobish question, but whatever i do i cant seem to get my skills/spells that iv'e got/bought to my pallete or use them in any way, if anyone could, please answear! what options widnows and so on i should use...
Maund001 3 years ago
u have to learn them first. look them up in ur inventory and choose learn
DarkJosh14 3 years ago
i think in hioves i found it there and i died befor i could leave though
wowowotang 3 years ago
Whats the max Lv. of Photon Skills? I thought it was 30 but i was able to reach 31 and at 31 i get a pink glow while swingin that weapon(Slicer).
Avian07 3 years ago
ummmm its a japanese version the one hes showin in the vedio
darkmanbors 3 years ago
whats on his back?
KenjiHatazo 3 years ago
whithill wings
sasukeuchiha17x 3 years ago
WHERE DO U GET THEM FROM...?
debtzero 3 years ago
there only on the japanese and offline versions i think
sasukeuchiha17x 3 years ago
But where do get em exactly? XD
Avian07 3 years ago
no idea...
sasukeuchiha17x 3 years ago
u get them from a drop in the HIVE mission(offline)
captainhero02148 3 years ago
If i buy this game do i have to pay to play online on the 360
OhSoNasti 3 years ago
you have to pay 9.99$ everymonth to play online.
001122334111 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dark Meta it not horr it whore man spell it right. LoL dumb man whore go EAT A AMERICAN COCK DUMB IRAQ ASSHOLE SHIT EATER.By the way Dark meta is a very VERy gay homo player dont friends him lmao.
IF ANYONE KNOW This nigga TalonTsi96 he is a f***ing cunt coward ass pussy talk shit and then chicken out. But wont make his own video to prove himself. He aka know as Dark Metal the scammer in PSO. And his youtube acc is TalonTsi96 and he a iraq asshole ^^
bboyyen06 3 years ago
@bboyyen06 first off thats a very racist comment. second whats wrong with iraq? 3rd this is COMPLETELY irelevant to the video and lastly LEARN SOME FREAKING ENGLISH!
Neoomegasonic 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how did this video get added on september 26, 2008 if the game wasnt out till october 2006
Pein155 3 years ago
uhh cuz 2008 is AFTER 2006
Gokaru 3 years ago 4
u could see that he/she made a mistake in dates and also this is japanese or chinese w/e version its not american if u can see
baseballdjplaya 3 years ago
ROFL!!
gohthecrow666 3 years ago
Pein your a retard and it says Added: September 29, 2006
BlindProductions20 3 years ago 3
@Pein155 BECUZ IN HUMAN WORLD TIME GOS FORWARD XD
BOBBYOWNZPSU 3 weeks ago
how did u get magashis swords?
dragonhunter159 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
EVERYONE WHO STILL PLAY PSO 1&2 PLZ SEND ME ANSWER!
Im gonna start play soon 4 the second time :)
SuperKidEmo 3 years ago
very cool
poopdeloop11 3 years ago
any1 hir know how to complete the mission shadow conspiracy? the part wer u will save 6 survivors in 15 mins.
baldomeroh 3 years ago
how do i get the light wings please help i need somebody help¡
AnkokuDragon 3 years ago
I can't compare to PSO (never played it) but this is a great one for consoles.
neilp4453 3 years ago
this is in extra mode...
K1LL10NARE 3 years ago
it says hes lvl 100... but what do i know ... ive never played this game! xD
doncavalli 3 years ago
how do you use our skills?
sasusakufann 3 years ago
Now how did you get the wing looking things on your back? its so cool. Like I have Phantasy Star Universe for PS2 but i do not pay for the online thing cause its like 10 bucks a month which is rediculous cause Sony said there online gaming would be free and all but anyways is there a way i can get that for PS2 offline versionN?
Unit775 3 years ago
how many people play this game?
jkin90 3 years ago
awesome!!
kerupt123 3 years ago
you don't have all skills level 30 n00b
UnweariedSaucer 3 years ago
Im definitely gettin this now, i play the demo, and I thought that was close to the full game but its not even half!
PyscoAnimeFan 3 years ago
last one was the best
BOWSERDOWSER 3 years ago
i think to get the wings u need to have the best armor and then go on the hive mission (last one) and a monster drops them
BBOYIKNOWU 3 years ago
How is the double saber skill called?
and how did you get those wings?
o0NJ0o 3 years ago
is this game japanese only? or is there an english version too? and.. what's it like compared to Phantasy Star for the gamecube, it looks cool though. is there subscription fees too?
rifler27 3 years ago
its not as good/addictive as pso. trust me. however, i havent played this game in over a year and i heard they released an expansion
jaab3z 3 years ago
how many stars are those wings? probably like 13, right? CAN you get them online?
parrothead1992 4 years ago
teh wep at 2:03 looks like a salad fork..but attack like an egg beater
ECSit 4 years ago
how do u make ur eyes glow
mybaIIs 4 years ago
how do you get those wings???
BigHorsexx 4 years ago
you get them doing the mission the hive
sillypiggy2 4 years ago
not online
Halo3ManiacXxX 4 years ago
no you dont need to be online for it
sillypiggy2 4 years ago
can u make ur own character in single player mode?
ishidabow 4 years ago
you need to go to extra mode
sillypiggy2 4 years ago
oh ok
ishidabow 4 years ago
woot! rising strike=my fav photon so far. how much pp does rising strike use with the last hit? (I've gotten the last hit but haven\t figured out how much the last hit uses)
SmoshRules55 4 years ago
tornado break and the average twin daggers photon art are pretty cool but are only usefule when in close quarters and surrounded.When its a boos fight i use the skills i get from s rank missions.Oh yeah i was dissapointed to find out that knuckles spec is the same forever...
fartonbrain 4 years ago
This is PC not ps2 so codebreaker = fail, cheat engine ftw!
Jelloman18 4 years ago
how to get that wing???i look very cool,why he do not use code breaker to get better costume than his clothes?noble long coat and bottom set is suitable for that wing....in the hive cave do not drop this rare item...bored...
FIREANONYMOUS 4 years ago
Yo Umes! We know each other. Lol! From online.
AmauryGarcia 4 years ago
Song name and artist? Please put the full name and full artist's name. ^_^
AmauryGarcia 4 years ago
All i know is its, Chrono Cross Time Scars Remix
Jelloman18 4 years ago
i only got the twin sword in lv23 and it me a long time! anyway how do you get the wings
cambodianATM 4 years ago
wings drop in HIVE stage offline extra mode...
Jelloman18 4 years ago
can u get it on storymode?
khfan106 4 years ago
the wings are the "whitill wings" but i dont think they're avaible online yet.
but hey, how did u capture the vid so nice??
Bluefull 4 years ago
Fraps
Jelloman18 4 years ago
hey wuts the wings are the a slot piece or a sheild i woould like that
Masterheart 4 years ago
its an Srank slot unit that drops in HIVE offline extra mode...
Jelloman18 4 years ago
WHat is the song used in this video? It is a remix of a chrono cross song.
Blasingame0 4 years ago
Time Scars remix
Jelloman18 4 years ago
The cities on the different planets have a lot of people in them, but when it comes to batttle, you take a group of people with you, like in PSO.
kevinjfox 4 years ago
what kind of game is phantasy star universe? is it a mmorpg? i kno that its online but is it like mmorpg thousands of people in 1 server or its jus online like 4,6 people in a group on own private world?
windtunnel 4 years ago
the claws fit a beast character nicely lol
masterslayer256 4 years ago
nice music, whats the name?
sithci2 4 years ago
For those who are wondering what the song is, it is called TimeScars by FFmusic Dj. You can find it at OverClocked ReMix. It is a site of a bunch of remixed video game music done by fans.
EzkaTheKingOfBeasts 4 years ago
Thanks man, was just about to ask ;)
Smartguy1992 4 years ago
hey yo this is only for extra mode right?i was wondering where do i get these skills? i gotta be 30+ lv to get em?
Kohaku1 4 years ago
You have to level up those skills to level 30.
Darkaeonix 4 years ago
The skill actually only has to be level 21 for you to use the full combo.
Darkaeonix 4 years ago
OMIGOSH! GIB WINGS! O.O
shinji969 4 years ago
nice AoEs and nice gear too bt how did you get wings?
hmongxboi 4 years ago
I want this game sooooo bad!Your character kicks ass!Could some 1 be kind enough to send me a copy of the game?!Although I don't own a PS2 or a 360:(
sanrok2 4 years ago
OMG I LOVE PHANTASY STAR UNIVERSE! Pity you must buy the CD to play it anyway...
lf2net 4 years ago
do we need to pay per month
nirv4n4 4 years ago
yep, in PC\PS2 u can do 9.99 monthly on 44 for about 180 days.
recondelta0195 4 years ago
and whats the name of this song, its sick.
youtuba211 4 years ago
its from chrono cross, not sure what the name is,though.
kikujiroBuru 4 years ago