@SPkx1 i didn´t say he sang it in the album, i said that he sings it in a different way than the album version( sang by Mr Gilomur of course) he doesn´t try to sing it exactly like gilmour and he changes the music a bit.
@SPkx1 i didn´t say he sang it in the album, i said that he sings it in a different way than the album version( sang by Mr Gilomur of course) he doesn´t try to sing it exactly like gilomour and he changes the music a bit.
hahaha, roger waters sure is a genius, but you can not go to the extreme and say that the rest of the band are just his session musicians. you should listen and read more about them before you make stupid ignorant commentaries like those.
I have read about them and I am a Floydologist and I am telling you right now that Waters was Floyd and Gilmour was a very good guitarist who helped Waters at times and the other 2 were a joke.
What Roger is doing is a SOLO tour so of course he is using other musicians! I like his vocals on this one a lot. (David is very hoarse nowadays and RIck never cut it on any live appearances)
I´d rahter see Roger doing a solo tour of mixed material rather than THE WALL ( which I saw in Berlin ) and I also saw Roger solo in 2002, 2007 and 2008. Most of that stuff was live!
I think release one last album, only god knows when though....
Waters IS Pink Floyd. He left but the other 3 continued ( although Rick Wright already hade left due to his drugs... ) Gilmour admitted his own name meant nothing but the PINK FLOYD name was worth millions, Nick Mason didn´t play many notes on their MOMENTARY LAPSE album but instead that album had some 20 session players. Gilmours wife wrote the lyrics! Ha ha! FAKE FLOYD indeed! 2 studio records and 2 double live albums = smells like they need money! LOL!
I never thought I would live to see the day where Roger Waters was singing this song as a tribute to certain people now gone and included President Ronald Reagan. Waters tends to include Reagan in his hall of "tyrants" with his song Fletcher Memorial Home.
Anyway, a great version of a great song. Word is he is going to tour The Wall in the next year or so. It will be spectacular.
Roger Waters rules. Maybe the greatest songwriter of a generation.
ah...i see no good in waters,a selfish and high-nosed tonto
when he cant make own music anymore he goes on tour and plays music that isnt complete without the 3 other dudes...waters can anytime be replaced by anyone,but not david,nick or rick (RIP).
hopely waters have all his playback tapes ready fro the upcomming tour...
no sence in rehashing the same old battle. It is what it is. Time for him to leave the band when he did. Same with syd. He is like dylan. Dylan cannot sing but you have to go see him. He is a force.
sure,its for me ok he left tha band,nothing lives forever...but he could atleast do some new stuff if he do on tour...arent those fucking what god wants and other shit he made on solo heard over and over?and also he do all those PF classics in a very shitty way.if he cant go on and make new stuff...he should stop and wait for the death...and dylan???ok,he had some goodies,but no...shit also,althought better than waters,bob atleast do new material ;)
cant live without wright or mason??? ha ha ha they didnt even have wright for The Wall and they had to bring in a session drummer for some of the tracks like Mother. Its Waters band....deal with it, dummy.
To be honest, I personally loved "Pros and Cons of Hitchiking" and "Radio KAOS" - two really good albums in my opinion. I'm even a fan of David's albums, "About Face" and "On An Island".
Wish you... without Dave Gilmour its a sad joke.
booberska 1 year ago
Comment removed
josedelapuerta 1 year ago
he can sing it´s just that he always sings this song a bit different from the album version
josedelapuerta 1 year ago
@josedelapuerta He didn't sing it on the album. David Gilmour did
SPkx1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SPkx1 i didn´t say he sang it in the album, i said that he sings it in a different way than the album version( sang by Mr Gilomur of course) he doesn´t try to sing it exactly like gilmour and he changes the music a bit.
josedelapuerta 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SPkx1 i didn´t say he sang it in the album, i said that he sings it in a different way than the album version( sang by Mr Gilomur of course) he doesn´t try to sing it exactly like gilomour and he changes the music a bit.
josedelapuerta 1 year ago
That was brilliant. I want to slap the woman who was chatting through it.
DeSHi770 1 year ago
To my brother Jay I wish Icould Bring her back,but your Wife is gone,rest in peace Jess love ya
nononaynay 1 year ago
Fantastic and heartfelt performance
pjennings424 2 years ago
Roger Waters is Pink Floyd. The other clowns were basically his session musicians. If you dont get that....then you must be stupid
Bondsback2325 2 years ago
hahaha, roger waters sure is a genius, but you can not go to the extreme and say that the rest of the band are just his session musicians. you should listen and read more about them before you make stupid ignorant commentaries like those.
dpombo160 2 years ago 2
I have read about them and I am a Floydologist and I am telling you right now that Waters was Floyd and Gilmour was a very good guitarist who helped Waters at times and the other 2 were a joke.
Bondsback2325 2 years ago
@Bondsback2325 Are you retarded? Denying Gilmour's influence on Pink Floyd would be ludacris. You ignorant fuck
SPkx1 1 year ago
What Roger is doing is a SOLO tour so of course he is using other musicians! I like his vocals on this one a lot. (David is very hoarse nowadays and RIck never cut it on any live appearances)
I´d rahter see Roger doing a solo tour of mixed material rather than THE WALL ( which I saw in Berlin ) and I also saw Roger solo in 2002, 2007 and 2008. Most of that stuff was live!
I think release one last album, only god knows when though....
STAYCLEAN88 2 years ago
Waters IS Pink Floyd. He left but the other 3 continued ( although Rick Wright already hade left due to his drugs... ) Gilmour admitted his own name meant nothing but the PINK FLOYD name was worth millions, Nick Mason didn´t play many notes on their MOMENTARY LAPSE album but instead that album had some 20 session players. Gilmours wife wrote the lyrics! Ha ha! FAKE FLOYD indeed! 2 studio records and 2 double live albums = smells like they need money! LOL!
STAYCLEAN88 2 years ago
all hail Roger Waters. Who cares if he can't sing anymore. He is still the greatest song writer to ever live, and I CANNOT wait for the next tour.
iflyc77 2 years ago 4
But he CAN sing!
RaustyDK 2 years ago
This is a LOT like his version during the Pros & Cons tour. And I fucking love it!
Torenkownage 2 years ago
Waters is a genuise but I wish someone would tell him to stop singing this song. Gilmour's version compared to this is like night and day.
kegs202 2 years ago
horrible!!!
sgtsreppep 2 years ago
Fantastic Share!! Thanks so much!!
14PinkFloyd 2 years ago 3
TY!:)
ShoTgUn851112 2 years ago
I never thought I would live to see the day where Roger Waters was singing this song as a tribute to certain people now gone and included President Ronald Reagan. Waters tends to include Reagan in his hall of "tyrants" with his song Fletcher Memorial Home.
Anyway, a great version of a great song. Word is he is going to tour The Wall in the next year or so. It will be spectacular.
Roger Waters rules. Maybe the greatest songwriter of a generation.
Bondsback2325 2 years ago 3
if waters is maybe the best songwriter of generation,then your musical taste is very narrow...
but yes,he wrote a few good songs but never really made it on solo....
emerni 2 years ago
haha he is the best, you're crazy
zenarrrow 2 years ago
ah...i see no good in waters,a selfish and high-nosed tonto
when he cant make own music anymore he goes on tour and plays music that isnt complete without the 3 other dudes...waters can anytime be replaced by anyone,but not david,nick or rick (RIP).
hopely waters have all his playback tapes ready fro the upcomming tour...
emerni 2 years ago
no sence in rehashing the same old battle. It is what it is. Time for him to leave the band when he did. Same with syd. He is like dylan. Dylan cannot sing but you have to go see him. He is a force.
zenarrrow 2 years ago
sure,its for me ok he left tha band,nothing lives forever...but he could atleast do some new stuff if he do on tour...arent those fucking what god wants and other shit he made on solo heard over and over?and also he do all those PF classics in a very shitty way.if he cant go on and make new stuff...he should stop and wait for the death...and dylan???ok,he had some goodies,but no...shit also,althought better than waters,bob atleast do new material ;)
emerni 2 years ago
I have every Pink Floyd recorded concert out there any show that was recorded I have. Some were not recorded though.
zenarrrow 2 years ago
cant live without wright or mason??? ha ha ha they didnt even have wright for The Wall and they had to bring in a session drummer for some of the tracks like Mother. Its Waters band....deal with it, dummy.
Bondsback2325 2 years ago
Roger hired Wright for the The Wall Tour ...
RaustyDK 2 years ago
but I will rate your post up a helpful vote, no sence voting down because others disagree.
zenarrrow 2 years ago
To be honest, I personally loved "Pros and Cons of Hitchiking" and "Radio KAOS" - two really good albums in my opinion. I'm even a fan of David's albums, "About Face" and "On An Island".
ScottGoldbergFilms 2 years ago
thanks for posting. Hope Roger does tour The Wall next year like his manager is spreading around.
ArtPatch 2 years ago
amazing! cannot wait to see roger live again soon!! thanks for sharing! :)
shabyg76 2 years ago
Great Roger ! Thanks for sharing man ;-)
ALEClovesGENIALMUSIC 2 years ago