American Idol gives back 2008 - Idols sing Seasons of Love

[jbwrestling232]

i mean the times she died, and i meant or not on

[jbwrestling232]

david arhculeta was the worst because he messed his part up. its in bridges he burned on the way that she died, not in bridges she burned and the times that she cried

[bnorem09]

this sucks. david fucked it up.

[kutlessRULES4life]

good performance. i loverent. just the girl who ang the first part of the solo......neede to raise her voice some. its a higher note when the stars from Rent sing. the woman in Rent sings with higher pitches and notes. she put feeling into it. still a good performance. just saying it couldve been better, i thought Cook wouldve sang the guy solo. lol.

[emilyloo13]

i love david archuleta he should have won

[2pimpsinaboxx]

LUV U ARCHULETTA

[billlangley0090]

ha ha, this sucked...

[FunWordsOrganization]

Love the song but this composition sucks...Plus they took out the part at the end with the REALLY high note...Would have loved to see one of them hit that note...

[Keianna94]

David Archuleta got the words wrong on his solo. Wow thats embarrasing!!!

[saysakwee]

how can u measure ur love to God?

[2yng2livAlie]

lets not bring religion inta this, mk?

[SirLirin]

It's not "Seasons of Love" unless you hit THAT NOTE. >:(

[ExquiZiteBeauty15]

I know!!!!! UGH! :-(

[2008dude12]

they should have followed the original cast from rent. they would have done better if they did.

[alysheba1994]

I wonder if they ever heard the Original Broadway Cast!?

[bwaybaby333]

they probably never even heard of rent

[heylookatthat1]

David A. and Syesha were the best.

[DavidArchuleta94]

Wow this wasn't that good. I think the best part was David Archuleta's.

[dxsalah]

david a. got the words to his solo wrong

[Khellspawn]

I'm agreeing with everyone below: there's no real passion in their voice... no spirit. I'm not getting any vibe from them, and the solos are weak. They don't have what the original singers had... it's sad they feel they have to ruin a good song like this. Disappointing.

[archuletaa1]

yeah. this is a bad version.

except for david archuleta's part...that was the best(:

[brilutes]

katy did awful on her first solo!!

[maximumride2453]

wow i thought they did really good. The rent version i good too.

[LEmusic103]

ughh they soo just ruined that song. especially the solos. (david was good!!)

[rdwngsfan92]

some of them should not sing this song.

[MeLoveDavidArchuleta]

David Archuleta was the best

[ayooxxxjordan]

omggg compared to rent this is HORRENDOUS.

[looneylove55]

lol YES i agree

[BabyKat008]

definetly!

[hollalauren]

probably one of the worst versions,

no offence to them.

[caitlinvalerie]

exactly^^^

[joshuabernstein]

Kristy Lee - OFF KEY