Its Nedra singing lead on the verses I asked Ronnie Spector in 1995 she comfirmed these were auditions for Phil Spector who wanted to hear each Ronette sing solo ,all three Ronettes sing the chourus listen and you can hear Ronnie very clear.
Ronnie did all the lead vocals on the other three songs "Mash Potato" "The Twist" and "Hot pasturi".
I liked this Spector treatment of the song but I got to say while I like it It was not the best vehicle for the Ronettes and I like the Orlons better this was right up the Philly Cameo-Parkway alley so to speak but thanks for posting it it's always interesting to hear a different treatment of an early teenage classic. It always impresses me that so many can pick out who's singing what I could tell very often as a kid but I knew the sounds not the names
There is no way this is Ronnie, but I couldn't say for certain who it is exactly. I haven't heard Nedra or Estelle doing their solo work, so it could be either one of those from my perspective.
Great pic of the luscious Nedra, too. I never knew that the Ronettes covered this one until seeing the comment at the Orlons' song posting! And Nedra singing lead is a new one on me, too.
Another point about the voice here is that Ronnie's range is really big and the singer on this track can't quite get the top note. So it is more likely Nedra here but Mash is a Ronnie sound.
Really? That's Nedra?? I have listened many times and, though the sound is recorded hard, the voice has the tonality and verbrato of Ronnie. Ronnie sings with accent to the "a" letters in words which I haven't found with Nedra!! Interesting if it is her. Pretty rare stuff if thats the case.
I really can´t remember but I think I read it somewhere. Also I have later records with Nedra singing live (yes se did Be my baby live at least twice) and you can tell it´s her. Estelle sounded very much as Ronnie on her own recordings from the late 60s. I hear 100% Ronnie on mashed potato time.
Ronnie changed her vocal style near the end of her affiliation with Colpix records... If you listen to other early Ronettes' singles, you will note a major difference between Ronnie's voice then (59 - 62) and the later "Frankie Lyman" inspired voice that she auditioned for Phil Spector in mid-1963. Ronnie openly admits taking the voice and style from Lyman ("Why Do Fools Fall in Love" and other late 50's hits).
If they were taking turns, which song does Estelle sing lead on?
jennifersenn 1 month ago
Its Nedra
soulfultony 1 month ago
Thats Nedra singing lead.This track appeared on The Crystals Sing the Greatest Hits LP.
soulfultony 2 months ago
Its Nedra singing lead on the verses I asked Ronnie Spector in 1995 she comfirmed these were auditions for Phil Spector who wanted to hear each Ronette sing solo ,all three Ronettes sing the chourus listen and you can hear Ronnie very clear.
Ronnie did all the lead vocals on the other three songs "Mash Potato" "The Twist" and "Hot pasturi".
DLfanatic01 4 months ago in playlist The Ronettes #2
Nice one, Nedra!
promerops 6 months ago 2
Exudes a lot of happy innocence, alas, not heard anymore. Thanks for the post.
nitenday12 8 months ago
The only song of their's where a man's vocals is actually heard.
OVtigerstripe 9 months ago
Yes, ScriptWorker, this is Nedra Talley singing lead. She sang lead on one or two songs I believe.
OVtigerstripe 9 months ago
I like this version :)
helenlloydmusicuk 11 months ago 3
Comment removed
wayydowneast 11 months ago
I liked this Spector treatment of the song but I got to say while I like it It was not the best vehicle for the Ronettes and I like the Orlons better this was right up the Philly Cameo-Parkway alley so to speak but thanks for posting it it's always interesting to hear a different treatment of an early teenage classic. It always impresses me that so many can pick out who's singing what I could tell very often as a kid but I knew the sounds not the names
elamite66 1 year ago
This is Nedra signing lead on this.
yandrsupreme 1 year ago 2
Must be Nedra...............Love her!!.
desert3347 1 year ago 3
I think this is Estelle singing........simular vocal genetics to Ronnie!
desert3347 1 year ago
Sounds cute. Ronnie was the voice of the group however its nice to hear Nedra or Estelle sing lead.
Vincent50 1 year ago 2
Sounds like mud. Sorry, Phil.
excelsior544 1 year ago
Its not as good as the original arangement
mgc2125 1 year ago
@mgc2125 For sure!!!!
excelsior544 1 year ago
Darlene Love?
axcrewe 1 year ago
There is no way this is Ronnie, but I couldn't say for certain who it is exactly. I haven't heard Nedra or Estelle doing their solo work, so it could be either one of those from my perspective.
TreblaYevrah 1 year ago
yes the beautifull nedra
arnyarny77 1 year ago 3
is nedra the one that died in 2009 in englewood, nj?
they were all so beautiful. fun times.
macdelight 1 year ago
No, it was Estelle that passed away.
ronetteloverz 1 year ago
I have never heard this version either. As good as The Orlons. Cute pic of the Ronettes too. Thanks for sharing.
SandySummers 2 years ago
Great pic of the luscious Nedra, too. I never knew that the Ronettes covered this one until seeing the comment at the Orlons' song posting! And Nedra singing lead is a new one on me, too.
LesbianVampireLover 2 years ago 2
Another point about the voice here is that Ronnie's range is really big and the singer on this track can't quite get the top note. So it is more likely Nedra here but Mash is a Ronnie sound.
ScriptWorker 2 years ago 4
Nedra also sang lead on Mashed Potato Time issued on the same "Crystals Sing the Greatest Hits" issued in 1963
soulfultony 2 years ago 2
Really? That's Nedra?? I have listened many times and, though the sound is recorded hard, the voice has the tonality and verbrato of Ronnie. Ronnie sings with accent to the "a" letters in words which I haven't found with Nedra!! Interesting if it is her. Pretty rare stuff if thats the case.
ScriptWorker 2 years ago
I really can´t remember but I think I read it somewhere. Also I have later records with Nedra singing live (yes se did Be my baby live at least twice) and you can tell it´s her. Estelle sounded very much as Ronnie on her own recordings from the late 60s. I hear 100% Ronnie on mashed potato time.
peterandreasen 2 years ago 2
Yar I reckon its Ronnie.
ScriptWorker 2 years ago
You have records with Nedra singing?! Which ones? I wish I had them...
Sadakogirl 2 years ago
I like this version way better than the Orlons recording of it. Much cleaner and crisp.
ronetteloverz 2 years ago 14
@ronetteloverz the unmistakeable touch of PS
don56texas 3 months ago
Three cute kids singing a cute song. I have to admit it's kind of infectious! Makes me smile.
ostrich67 2 years ago 2
Too bad they didn't use her lead more often.
ronetteloverz 2 years ago 4
It´s Nedra on lead - the only song she ever got to record as a lead with The Ronettes
peterandreasen 2 years ago 3
Hi Peter
I can tell the vocals are different than the Ronnie sound, but could you let me know out of interest how you can know its Nedra. Very interesting.
ScriptWorker 2 years ago 2
Ronnie changed her vocal style near the end of her affiliation with Colpix records... If you listen to other early Ronettes' singles, you will note a major difference between Ronnie's voice then (59 - 62) and the later "Frankie Lyman" inspired voice that she auditioned for Phil Spector in mid-1963. Ronnie openly admits taking the voice and style from Lyman ("Why Do Fools Fall in Love" and other late 50's hits).
PaulDePace 2 years ago
Who's singing lead on this? Estelle? It doesn't sound like Ronnie to me.
poconoboy61 2 years ago
i agree with ya the voice doesnt sound like ronnies normal voice
johnreynolds71 2 years ago
@johnreynolds71 .....it is Nedra on the lead. Paul / Texas
PaulDePace 1 year ago
@poconoboy61
Actually...the lead was Nedra (Talley) confirmed.
PaulDePace 1 year ago
@poconoboy61 It's Nedra. Check out the YouTube postings for Nedra's "Full Circle" album and you can hear
her voice alone, as it is here. There are about seven postings of songs from that album.
ronetteloverz 1 year ago 2
@poconoboy61 ....."Wah Wahtusi"....that is actually Nedra on the lead. Confirmed. ...Paul / Texas
PaulDePace 10 months ago
@poconoboy61 It's Nedra.
MissyMagical 8 months ago